r/honesttransgender • • Mar 18 '21

tw: contentious themes some transbians make WLW spaces feel uncomfortable

1.9k Upvotes

So I’ve just recently joined reddit, when I did I joined multiple WLW subs because I’m a bisexual trans woman (questioning if I’m a lesbian). In the short time I’ve been on here I’m starting to notice something that bothers me, pushy transbians in these spaces who don’t really understand boundaries, I’m not saying this is ALL of them but from what I can see in comment sections it’s certainly a vocal majority.

Here is what I’ve noticed, on ANY post regarding vaginas/periods/nsfw jokes you’ll find a trans woman in the comments talking about how the meme made her dysphoric or how she wishes she had a uterus (me too but I keep it to myself out of respect). To me if you can’t relate to the meme maybe keep scrolling instead of trying to make others feel bad for you? The other day a member posted a tiktok about men trying to force lesbians to like dick and there were trans women in the comments trying to tell her that girldick was different, which came off as pushy to me if a lesbian says she doesn’t like dick she doesn’t why are you trying to convince her otherwise? I don’t understand interjecting into conversations where you don’t really belong.

Most of the trans positivity I see on these subs are all about girldick, one or two posts are fine but it starts feeling like I’m being fetishized when I see it everyday. I’m just a woman who so happens to have a dick why do I need a constant reminder?

Not bashing anime but I see this from a lot of trans users, they often post unrealistic anime girls to these subs? All of these pictures have a male gaze type of feel to them they were obviously not made for women.. it just feels really weird and fetishy I don’t want to see hentai on WLW subs I want to see actual women.

I remember early in transition I felt like I needed validation from cis women, but some of the trans women in these spaces need to realize that this space is not for that, it makes me feel embarrassed when I see the daily “am I valid uwu 🥺” posts like yes you know you are it’s in the rules and description of the sub. AL is starting to feel like MTF 2.0 from how many trans related posts are posted.

Rant over. Us trans women belong in these spaces, but we need to be respectful and mindful of what we’re doing and saying. This is probably an unpopular opinion but I needed to get this off my chest.


r/honesttransgender • • Jun 07 '21

tw: contentious themes In the nicest way possible a lot of you need to go outside

1.2k Upvotes

"Are nonbinarys literally killing true transsexuals by existing in their general area" "how can I call this afab a silly girl who can't make her own decisions with adult male guidance without actually saying silly girl who can't make her own decisions without adult male guidance" my GOD Kim people are dying

Its that there's kids on trans subs every day in genuinely horrific situations and the rest of you who had mummy and daddy pay for all ya surgeries and hormones sitting around wanking each other off about how you're the only real transsexuals because you hate yourselves or whatever

Get a hobby or something to dedicate yourselves to because fuck this ain't it. Make your life about something other than spreading negativity.

The privilege is sickening honestly!

Edit: thanks for all the awards! I'm glad a lot of you resonated with this post and had interesting discussions in the comments! I'm a bit tired of the discussion now, like I said I'm not interested in the transier than thou debate so I'm gonna leave you to it. Enjoy!


r/honesttransgender • • Apr 09 '21

opinion Don't Say "Trans Community" If You're Just Talking About Trans Women

1.2k Upvotes

I don't even know why this needs to be said, but I got downvoted for this opinion because apparently it's controversial.

Don't use the label "trans community" if all you're going to talk about is (primarily binary) trans women. Just don't. That's NOT the trans community, that is a part of the community. Don't write me your "Dating While Trans!" article and only describe the experiences of trans women. Don't try and tell me about "trans people" in X history period and ONLY mention trans women. Don't write a spiel on the trans military ban or anti-trans legislation and only feature trans women. Don't talk about trans people in politics and ignore the trans men and non binary reps and candidates. Don't put together surgery and medical resource wikis for the "trans community" and only include procedures for trans women. Don't make your hour and a half long video essay on Transphobia In Pop Culture and only focus on trans women, and then tweet about how a trans woman told you transphobia towards trans men only manifests as ignorance and invisibility, and THAT'S why you decided to ignore trans men (lookin at you Lindsay Ellis, maybe one day you'll get your foot out of your mouth).

The trans community is more than trans women. If you want to just talk about trans women, that is 100% fine! Write your "Dating As A Trans Woman" article. Write about trans women in X history period. Write about how such legislation has affected trans women. Write about medical resources for trans women. Just say this stuff is for and aimed at trans women.

It's fucking disingenuous otherwise and I'm tired of having to defend that point. "Well the author only writes about trans women," you say, and that's absolutely fine - just tell that author to NOT label their works and resources as for the trans community.

All this shit does is reinforce that the only kind of trans person out there is trans women, which is very objectively Not True, and makes it incredibly difficult for people who aren't binary trans women to access resources or materials related to them.

And before someone cries transmisogyny - I've plainly said that these resources are fine to exist, just label them as for trans women. It's in no way transmisogynyist to acknowledge that the whole trans community is not trans women and shouldn't be labeled as such.


r/honesttransgender • • Jul 25 '23 This

MtF Trans women don't get periods.

1.1k Upvotes

I don't know when this extreme of a stance got pushed to the degree where disagreeing with it means you're a TERF or transphobic.

But like, scientifically nothing about the hormone cycle that cis women experience is equitable to how Trans women experience hormone fluctuations.

Ovaries fluctuate between follicular and luteal phases. Trans women injest estrogen and metabolize it out.

Having a period isn't just feeling hormonal. Neither is PMS.

I've heard people say that "cis men have periods too" but that's just inaccurate.

Period cramps are also not influenced by estrogen or progesterone. They're influenced by prostaglandins, which are released regardless of estrogen or progesterone levels in your blood stream.

Hormones "mimicking symptoms of a period" are side effects. Swaths of Trans women can be on estrogen and progesterone for decades and never experience symptoms where as the overwhelming percentage of AFABs do.

It's just not only scientifically inaccurate, but just a gross appropriation in my opinion of something that trans women truly don't have the biology to experience.

Like, do you not understand how delusional it makes Trans women sound? I know we're not, but it's truly insane the way Trans women are attributing symptoms to a biological process that is not in any way happening to them.

Periods are horrible for AFABs especially Trans men, and it just feels insensitive to me to upplay your indigestion and boob soreness as a period. It takes away from the pain people actually experience.

People are taking validation for something that simply isn't true.


r/honesttransgender • • Oct 25 '21

rant If you’re a detrans adult, there’s nobody to blame

917 Upvotes

Grown adults cannot be groomed. People did not “convince” you you’re trans. You wanted to be told you were trans and went to spaces that do that. Do I find r/egg_irl cringe ? Yea. But nobody just innocently wanders over there and gets trapped in the clutches of the evil trannies. It’s a sub full of 19 year olds posting memes. Not a underground organized crime ring.

The whole reason detrans people blame trans people on the internet more than actual doctors is because most of them did informed consent. So they can’t play the “I didn’t know” card without admitting they ignored warnings. Most (but not all) can’t deal with admitting a shred of self responsibility so trans people become the target.

If you make “am I trans posts ?” about how you have dysphoria and hate your body and want to be a man/woman and provide no other context, then yeah. Random people are gonna say in their opinion you’re probably transgender. Nobody has a magic ball to know all the information you left out.

If you’re a kid who thought they were trans. Fine. Young people don’t have a fully formed ability to make good decisions and try out different identities. But if you’re a grown person, you are 100% responsible for the choices you make. You don’t get to cop out and infantilize yourself and claim other adults “lured” you into making a shitty decision.

EDIT: Shout out to all the deeply offended people streaming in to comment on a fucking 6 day old post. I find it hilarious that r/detrans is covered day in and day out with posts calling trans people deluded and predatory and how we “tricked” them but make a single post acknowledging their own responsibility and they literally cannot handle it.


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 16 '21

opinion Stop treating "born in the wrong body" as a wrong thing to say

903 Upvotes

You want to stop using it as a blanket statement for all trans people? Perfectly fine.

In turn I ask you to do not use the "not born in the wrong body" for all trans people too.

I'm sorry but me being trans is all about my body being wrong. I don't care about gender roles, if it didn't get me misgendered I wouldn't mind wearing dresses and I would like to wear more make-up. I cry easily, I like cute things and I guess my personality is "feminine". However I am a man. Why? Because my afab body never felt like home. I just wanted a body that produces t naturally, has penis and balls and no boobs. And I have the exact opposite, so yes, in my conception I was born in the wrong body and I am making steps to fix it.

Or trying to fix it, I got top surgery, im on t and should be able to get hysto next year, but, considering my country I will likely never have bottom surgery so I guess I have to live with something akin to missing limb. Nice...

If you think your body is fine the way it is or you have another approach to gender that's fine, just don't push the narrative that my view of my own body is wrong.


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 17 '22

trans critical themes I really wish young trans people would stop pretending like wanting to pass is transphobic

877 Upvotes

I've seen it a lot of tiktok and even on r/trans and r/ftm. people saying that wanting to pass is transphobic or were trying to "please the cis" when that's such a small part of why i do it.

sure, there is a part of me that doesn't express femininity (ftm) because I'm worried I'll be hatecrimed or misgendered but that's like 10% of it. I bind and pack and grow out my facial hair and this and that for ME. dysphoria is hell. my body is a fucking prison. I don't do that shit for anyone but me. I don't see how you can see trans men breaking their ribs from binding and think "ah yes this is for the cis. bad tran" like you can't be that fucking dense bro.

it's always the non dysphorics with some fucking shit to say about binary trans people. if you are okay with looking female and saying ur ftm, be my guest. idgaf. but don't shit on ME, someone who has nearly always had dysphoria, because I want to be comfortable in a way you don't get.

I'm just so fed up with people saying that. or telling me dysphoria is in my head and I need to just accept myself. that's literally just terf logic repackaged.


r/honesttransgender • • Jan 06 '21

tw: transphobia We are aware you don't have to have sex with us.

845 Upvotes

Posting this here because the ftm sub removed it.

I am seriously getting tired of the people who feel the need to make "It's not transphobic to not be sexually attracted to a trans person!" posts on lgbtq subs. For numerous reasons, the main one being:

We fucking know. We know that you don't have to have sex with us, and implying that we don't is borderline transphobic. This is eerily similar to the whole "omg my crazy sjw trans friend literally stabbed me fifteen times because i accidentally got their pronouns wrong! this totally happened and all of them are like this! aita for crying?" attitude people had (and, hell, still have) about misgendering people. There isn't a Trans Mafia out to shame and force the poor cis people into having sex with us and cancelling anyone who doesn't bow to our demented standards. Trans people complaining about how difficult dating can be aren't trying to force or guilt people into have sex with them either. The most I've seen called transphobic when it comes to dating is when a straight woman turns down a trans man claiming she's "only attracted to real men" or when a person refuses to date someone they're attracted to solely on the basis of their transness, and even those call-outs are heavily soaked with "you don't have to date him even if you did respect his identity".

Some of the worse versions of these posts tend to be "I'm not transphobic or anything, but ew! Trans bodies! I know what they all look like, and I wouldn't touch em. And that's okay!", and in places where trans people frequent for emotional support or just to escape hateful reality, to boot. Why? Who is that helping to announce you're not sexually attracted to, or even repulsed, by a group of people who didn't even ask??? I don't go to support subs for people to tell me how unfuckable I am while implying that I'm a sexual predator.

The silliest part about this is their belief that we'd be interested in having sex with folks who have no attraction for us in the first place. But apparently we're also too trans to have basic empathy like that, huh?

Just stop this.


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 21 '21

vent It's ok to assume your kids are cis unless they indicate otherwise. It really is.

840 Upvotes

I'm so sick of this strawman. Nobody (ok, nobody aside from a few internet loonies) is saying you're going to scar your kids by giving them gendered names or failing to bend over backwards to raise them in as gender neutral an environment as possible. Just don't be a dick about it if they want to explore their gender identity. (And don't push gender roles on them, obviously, but that's not healthy for cis kids either).

I'm openly nonbinary and my parents were never supportive. If I ever have kids, all I'm going to do is make sure they are exposed to positive examples of gender nonconforming adults and talk to them about society/gender related issues to whatever extent is appropriate. I'm not secretly tut-tutting under my breath at people who don't try to raise their kids in a gender neutral bubble. The people I've met who do are invariably the helicopter parent types, which is an unhealthy thing in and of itself.

We don't live in a new age post- gender society and trying to shelter your kids from that reality is only going to teach them that you're the type to try and put out a five alarm fire with a water pistol.


r/honesttransgender • • Jul 31 '21

tw: phobic themes Chris-Chan is exactly why we need to have actual standards for calling people trans

738 Upvotes

Okay getting it out of the way first: I'm not going to go out of my way to misgender Chris-chan, as I literally couldn't care less and it's easy enough and it's absurd the amount of stalking that has gone into making Chris-chan a common name online. Also, nobody deserves the sheer amount of information the internet has compiled from her, even if she is a mentally unhinged person people find "worth studying."

BUT I do find people claiming her as trans incredibly ridiculous as well, it is abundantly clear that she has no actual experiences desiring to live an authentically female life as a woman, rather using it as an excuse to supposedly expand her dating pool. Typically this would sound like a dogwhistle, but in her case there is an abundance of evidence that she isn't even remotely trans nor does she have any interest in being so, and combined with her very fucking clear crappy relationship with femininity, she is a fantastic example of what TERFs and conservatives think Trans people (and especially trans women) actually are--I don't know about you all but I don't want to be associated with that because people on Reddit and Twitter go into every thread and demand people use she/her pronouns for her and demand people acknowledge she's trans. It makes all of us look bad and plays into stereotypes, and for what? A person who is mentally unstable to the point that she only sees gender as a way to sleep with women and is in the news for raping her mother.

This isn't what we need in the media. I have seen people defending it as something you should just do because by allowing people to misgender a cis person you open the floodgates for cis people to misgender trans people whenever they do something wrong or morally questionable, but that seems logically questionable and not something I, at the very least, think does anything other than put a band-aid on the real issue: having people see us as the identities we so clearly embody. We need to push the idea that trans people are the gender that they are because of more than self identification.* Trans men are men because they are observable and socially men, trans women the same (enbies are a bit harder to identify without ID I suppose), and when someone like Chris-chan is pushed as trans exclusively because she calls herself such rather than her actually being or even believing that she is a woman. I despise the idea of a cis person going after other cis people on threads regarding the recent controversy because people don't believe she's genuine in her identity. What I see as actually harmful is pushing such a clear example of a mentally disturbed, very unstable person as some kind of fucked up trans celebrity (on top of that, think about how few trans people we have in the common knowledge. Do we REALLY need to push chris-chan as one of our famous few?).

*to be clear here, self ID is useful (and I think it should be the standard) for medication, as proving one's transness to a doctor is a pretty flawed metric, but when a person so clearly isn't a trans person, we don't need to go through absurd mental gymnastics to argue for their transness simply because they "identify" that way. It degrades actual trans experience as nothing more than an identity, rather than a life one lives.

We need to move past validity politics and into advocating for our existence not as a breakdown of social constructs, but as something proven time and time again to exist by historians, the medical establishment, et cetera. We need to work for the image others are going to see us as and we don't need to accept people who are so obviously not trans, and with so few trans celebrities in the world, Chris-chan is not one we need to push for, not one we need to discuss as a trans person. We don't need to defend someone like Chris-chan's supposed gender identity when we have enough struggles getting decent recognition as is. Don't go out of your way to misgender these people, but we don't need to defend their supposed transness and we can't fight the battle against their identity for them if we are to be taken seriously by anyone as trans people are still murdered, beaten, denied medical care, etc. because the cis culture thinks we're all our own mini mentally disturbed Chris-chans or attention seeking Demi Lovatos.

Stop defending Chris-chan's transness. To be a valid community and to ask for understanding and compassion does not mean being uncritical of everyone and anyone's identities. We need to be ethical to others, but perhaps even moreso to ourselves and to our community.

TL;DR: Defending Chris-chan's very obviously faulty self-ID as a trans woman does more harm to trans people than cis people misgendering her, and it, in my opinion, shows even more that "trans" as a label is something we need to be able to define better for the sake of actual trans women, men, and enbies. Sorry for the long rambly post.


r/honesttransgender • • Jun 10 '21

hormones Stop encouraging people to play around with/experiment with hormones.

734 Upvotes

Tired of seeing comments about microdosing and starting hormones then stopping them after a short period od time for a few desired effects. This is primarily about testosterone. It's dangerous and irresponsible to encourage people to "experiment" with a strong hormone that has irreversible effects.

Additionally, changes happen at different rates for different people, and you can't control which changes DO happen. I've seen people talking about microdosing testosterone for a deeper voice, which is just...plain uneducated. This is how the detrans rate rises, when people start hormones without knowing what they're getting into, and suddenly wonder why they're being seen as a man, or why they have less "cool" side effects (increased sweating, acne, receding hairline, etc ).

I'm tired of the irresponsibility and misinformation.


r/honesttransgender • • Jun 15 '23

FtM Stop lumping trans men and nonbinary trans masc people together.

721 Upvotes

Trans men are not masculine nonbinary people. I'm tired of correcting people who make a point to call me "they" when they know I am a man and have only ever used he/him since knowing me. I'm also seeing more and more people use trans men and masc interchangeably. They're not interchangeable btw.


r/honesttransgender • • Apr 03 '23

MtF Why do transbians think its okay to post about dick in lesbian communities?!

718 Upvotes

Look, I'm a trans woman, I am (unfortunately) attracted to other trans women (I tried my best to make it work with cis guys). Don't we think transbians could just......stick to our own spaces and stop doing this?! If you want to be seen as a cis lesbian woman, then at least don't bring up your dick every waking second! If you're going to constantly mention having male anatomy, stick to trans centric spaces and stay out of cis lesbian spaces. Please.

I do not want to be part of a community that behaves this way.


r/honesttransgender • • Jan 26 '24

vent Trans women are obsessed with the lesbian community.

710 Upvotes

Lately I have seen so much trans content on lesbian subs and it's frankly annoying and overwhelming. I'm way past the stage where being trans is my whole identity. It seems like there are so many new trans women that are attaching themselves to the lesbian communities because it's one of the few ones that are accepting to trans women and validate them.

The issue is it's starting to be to much where it just feels like it's being forced down people's throats so they HAVE to accept trans women or you're transphobic. Like no you've been on hormones for two months and still have a dick not all lesbians are gonna be into you. It's annoying. It's going to start pushing people away from wanting to be associated with us and it's hurting the community by making all of us seem insufferable and have a lack of boundaries.

Yes trans women are women most people understand that. Stop being annoying. I want to go to lesbian subs for lesbian stuff not to see trans people constantly seeking validation.


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 31 '22

tw: dysphoria I'm so tired of being talked over by nondysphoric, nontransitioning people

703 Upvotes

I'm tired. They out number me by a dozen. I just want to pass. I just want to get medically treated. I want to feel masculine and blend in. I want to be a man, not some boy derivative. What impowers you does nothing for me, and I'm tired of sharing the same space. I don't understand why it's so controversial to say that dysphoric people who want to transition deserve their own space and deserve to be represented and heard. But I guess I'm a minority within a minority. Sue me, fight me, dogpile away.


r/honesttransgender • • Jul 08 '25

psychological health themes The honest truth of "Sexual Re-assignment Surgery" after almost a year into healing.. this might be offensive

637 Upvotes

I don't mean to upset anyone with this post but I feel the truth needs to be told before anyone else makes the same mistake I did. The political correctness around this subject needs to stop and the mollycoddling to "protect" peoples feelings is not worth it if it leads to others making the same horrible decision I did.


Like many people getting caught up in the transing and the genders I thought it was ok to keep putting off my SRS. I thought 'I can always do it later i mean who knows if it will actually work.. and what if she comes out.. imperfect 😱 then it would be even worse, right? Right?' Yea no. It's fucking amazing. bro..I have a vagina. Like fr I have a. fucking. vagina. It's so incredibly awesome amazeballs. is she perfect? No. But she is soo much better. You would think that eventually I would get tired of looking in the mirror and seeing that I have a vagina but no. There she is. My vagine. And every time I see her I smile the biggest smile I've never had before and never even expected to. I genuinely can not describe how absolutely right the decision was..

The Honest Truth about SRS and completing transition that they don't say because it's "not PC to push people": That it's worth it and you should get it as soon as you can. It makes all the difference in the world for people afflicted with Gender Dysphoria. 100% the biggest relief out of all the transition steps. I wish I didn't make the horrible mistake of waiting and I hope you don't either.


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 28 '23

opinion Some trans people should just read the room and stop focusing on the misgendering of the trans Nashville shooter

615 Upvotes

Seriously, read the room. You are all making us look bad and the situation is bad as it is. Like how we are focused more on the gendering of the killer than the actual dead kids. There is a time and place for misgendering discussions and the time is not now.

EDIT: No one here is arguing here whether misgendering is right or wrong. Of course it is not. The issue is whether discussing that is effective. Just because it is a right thing to do, it does not necessarily mean that it is effective in addressing this current issue. We need to work on the real broader talking points such as gun control and mental health. Arguing about pronouns gets you nowhere


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 06 '21

tw: contentious themes The people currently turning r/TwoXChromosomes into r/transtimelines are cringe af

613 Upvotes

I finally decided to see for myself what the all the fuss has been about over there, and what I saw was more jarring than I was prepared for. There are women talking about losing pregnancies, dealing with abuse, and other very sensitive topics and all of this is being drowned out by a barrage of MTF before-and-after selfie posts.


r/honesttransgender • • Jul 13 '21

rant Define "trans" however you want, but we need to be able to distinguish between people who actually experience gender dysphoria and people who change their pronouns and nothing else

605 Upvotes

I feel like 90% of trans discourse happens because people don't distinguish between these groups. Dysphoric people have way different needs and desires from the pronoun-changers, and so much infighting happens because these pronoun-changers talk about "trans" issues when really they should clarify that they're only talking about their narrow subset of "trans" people. This would also keep pronoun-changers from talking over dysphorics when it comes to things like getting medical care, which many pronoun-changers now seem to be against. This causes a ton of confusion with cis ppl and closeted trans people because they keep hearing two completely different sets of perspectives and issues from people who all call themselves "trans". That makes it harder for cis people to understand the experiences dysphorics and pronoun-changers as different, and makes it harder for closeted trans people to figure out their transition.

If we don't make this distinction, pronoun-changers will continue to flood into trans spaces and talk over dysphorics about what actual newly-out trans people should do. They will discourage actual dysphorics from medical transition, push them out of trans spaces, and people will die as a result. We need to create some kind of distinction here so people can actually understand what the difference is and can have actual discussions instead of talking past each other.


r/honesttransgender • • Jun 03 '22

legal No, your republican "friends" will not stop with banning healthcare for trans youth, they're coming after your healthcare too.

579 Upvotes

This was always the plan, but you self loathing collaborators felt like your friends wouldn't come after you if you just argued against trans youth having access to care.

https://www.axios.com/local/tampa-bay/2022/06/02/florida-could-end-medicaid-coverage-transgender-care

Wake up.


r/honesttransgender • • Jan 24 '21

life/social/society Sick of woke academic types referring to people as "bodies"

568 Upvotes

"How do trans bodies navigate this space"

Well I'll be navigating mine directly to the nearest vacant toilet 'cause I gotta puke


r/honesttransgender • • Apr 10 '23

opinion I think if menstrual product companies wanted to be trans inclusive they should use trans men to advertise, not trans women.

567 Upvotes

Trans men experience the bleeding that comes with periods. Hence, they actually need the products. Trans women don’t bleed. And I personally don’t know if they even do experience periods. Some people say they do and some people say they don’t, so I won’t comment on that, but they don’t bleed. So why are they being asked to endorse the brands and not… I don’t know.. The people that actually do? I don’t know if any trans women have actually accepted the offer because i’m sure a lot of them feel the same way but why aren’t brands reaching out to trans men? I feel like a lot of “trans inclusivity” is just “trans women inclusivity.” And it could cause dysphoria for some trans men but if they actually normalized it then maybe it would be so uncomfortable?


r/honesttransgender • • Mar 03 '21

rant Pronoun Circles Can Go Burn

563 Upvotes

I want to say that “going around and telling people your pronouns uwu” is cis people trying their best, and maybe they are I don’t know. That being said I HATE these things. As someone super early on in my transition and doesn’t pass well, pronoun circles give me two choices: out myself to this entire group or lie to myself and everyone around me. I just wish they didn’t seem mandatory to do, if the people organizing these things just said something like “if you would like” at the end of their instructions I’d feel way less pressure with these things.


r/honesttransgender • • Aug 29 '21

FtM I am not a trans masc, I’m a trans MAN

558 Upvotes

This vent was written out of anger and frustration. This is in no way in any hate towards people who use the term trans mascs.

I’m may I deleted tiktok. Around that time I saw the terms trans masc and trans femme getting used more, which really didn’t bother me. There are plenty of afab trans people who are masculine, but not trans men.

I recently just got it back, and now nobody says trans man or trans woman anymore.

“Safe space for trans mascs!”

“Non trans mascs don’t interact”

“Trans mascs have my whole heart”

It hurts. It hurts so much that my gender is just being reduced to ‘masculine’. I’m not even that masculine, I like to be feminine sometimes too. Not to mention that term really just reminds me of the fact I was born a girl.

I am a man, more specifically a trans man. Stop watering it down.


r/honesttransgender • • Aug 08 '21

vent Being a black trans woman sucks

535 Upvotes

Every space intended for trans people I've gone to, both online and in real life, I either was or had fair suspicions that I was the only person of color there. Every trans sub on Reddit I see, it's just white people left and right. And all the subs about black trans people are just porn subs.
I can't make any cis-straight black friends because homophobia/transphobia, unfortunately, runs very deep in black culture. Nearly all of my extended family had disowned me after I came out.
It seems like every other day, I'm reading a news article about another black trans woman being killed, further inhibiting my desire to present the way I want in public.

And the worst part is I have a hard time telling anyone about this because black voices, women's voices, and trans voices are always being put down, and I have to deal with all of those simultaneously.