Okay getting it out of the way first: I'm not going to go out of my way to misgender Chris-chan, as I literally couldn't care less and it's easy enough and it's absurd the amount of stalking that has gone into making Chris-chan a common name online. Also, nobody deserves the sheer amount of information the internet has compiled from her, even if she is a mentally unhinged person people find "worth studying."
BUT I do find people claiming her as trans incredibly ridiculous as well, it is abundantly clear that she has no actual experiences desiring to live an authentically female life as a woman, rather using it as an excuse to supposedly expand her dating pool. Typically this would sound like a dogwhistle, but in her case there is an abundance of evidence that she isn't even remotely trans nor does she have any interest in being so, and combined with her very fucking clear crappy relationship with femininity, she is a fantastic example of what TERFs and conservatives think Trans people (and especially trans women) actually are--I don't know about you all but I don't want to be associated with that because people on Reddit and Twitter go into every thread and demand people use she/her pronouns for her and demand people acknowledge she's trans. It makes all of us look bad and plays into stereotypes, and for what? A person who is mentally unstable to the point that she only sees gender as a way to sleep with women and is in the news for raping her mother.
This isn't what we need in the media. I have seen people defending it as something you should just do because by allowing people to misgender a cis person you open the floodgates for cis people to misgender trans people whenever they do something wrong or morally questionable, but that seems logically questionable and not something I, at the very least, think does anything other than put a band-aid on the real issue: having people see us as the identities we so clearly embody. We need to push the idea that trans people are the gender that they are because of more than self identification.* Trans men are men because they are observable and socially men, trans women the same (enbies are a bit harder to identify without ID I suppose), and when someone like Chris-chan is pushed as trans exclusively because she calls herself such rather than her actually being or even believing that she is a woman. I despise the idea of a cis person going after other cis people on threads regarding the recent controversy because people don't believe she's genuine in her identity. What I see as actually harmful is pushing such a clear example of a mentally disturbed, very unstable person as some kind of fucked up trans celebrity (on top of that, think about how few trans people we have in the common knowledge. Do we REALLY need to push chris-chan as one of our famous few?).
*to be clear here, self ID is useful (and I think it should be the standard) for medication, as proving one's transness to a doctor is a pretty flawed metric, but when a person so clearly isn't a trans person, we don't need to go through absurd mental gymnastics to argue for their transness simply because they "identify" that way. It degrades actual trans experience as nothing more than an identity, rather than a life one lives.
We need to move past validity politics and into advocating for our existence not as a breakdown of social constructs, but as something proven time and time again to exist by historians, the medical establishment, et cetera. We need to work for the image others are going to see us as and we don't need to accept people who are so obviously not trans, and with so few trans celebrities in the world, Chris-chan is not one we need to push for, not one we need to discuss as a trans person. We don't need to defend someone like Chris-chan's supposed gender identity when we have enough struggles getting decent recognition as is. Don't go out of your way to misgender these people, but we don't need to defend their supposed transness and we can't fight the battle against their identity for them if we are to be taken seriously by anyone as trans people are still murdered, beaten, denied medical care, etc. because the cis culture thinks we're all our own mini mentally disturbed Chris-chans or attention seeking Demi Lovatos.
Stop defending Chris-chan's transness. To be a valid community and to ask for understanding and compassion does not mean being uncritical of everyone and anyone's identities. We need to be ethical to others, but perhaps even moreso to ourselves and to our community.
TL;DR: Defending Chris-chan's very obviously faulty self-ID as a trans woman does more harm to trans people than cis people misgendering her, and it, in my opinion, shows even more that "trans" as a label is something we need to be able to define better for the sake of actual trans women, men, and enbies. Sorry for the long rambly post.