I have a 2009 Honda Pilot Touring AWD with approximately 195,000 miles. I’ve owned it for a while and really love the vehicle, but I’m now trying to decide whether it’s worth putting more money into it or cutting my losses.
Here’s what’s going on:
• Excessive oil consumption: Burning approximately 1 quart every 1,000 miles.
• Misfires: Check engine light with a P0301 code (cylinder 1 misfire), along with intermittent misfires involving cylinders 1–3.
• Oil-fouled spark plug: My mechanic found the #1 spark plug fouled with oil and replaced it.
• Warning lights: Both the check engine and VTM-4 lights have come on.
• Possible piston ring issue: My mechanic referenced Honda TSB 13-082, which addresses oil consumption and misfires related to piston ring problems on certain Honda V6 engines.
So far, I’ve spent $185 to replace the fouled spark plug, but no compression or leak-down testing has been documented, and I don’t have a definitive diagnosis of internal engine damage.
I’m concerned that replacing spark plugs is just treating the symptoms rather than addressing the underlying problem.
The Pilot otherwise meets my needs really well. I use it for long road trips, hauling kayaks and mountain bikes, and occasionally towing a 16-foot aluminum boat. Unfortunately, I’m increasingly concerned about its reliability, especially on longer trips.
I’m also still carrying approximately $3,900 on the vehicle, which complicates the decision.
I’d appreciate advice from other Pilot owners, especially anyone who’s dealt with similar oil consumption and misfire issues:
Has anyone experienced these symptoms on a 2009–2015 Pilot, and was the problem ultimately traced to piston rings?
Is there anything else I should have checked before assuming the engine needs major work? Compression test, leak-down test, valve adjustments, PCV system, etc.?
Has anyone successfully addressed this issue without an expensive piston ring replacement or engine rebuild?
At nearly 200K miles, would you invest in repairing this Pilot or put that money toward a newer vehicle?
If you’ve continued driving with similar oil consumption, how much longer did your engine last?
I know these Pilots can go well beyond 200K miles when properly maintained, which makes this a tough decision.
I’d really appreciate hearing what others have experienced and what you’d recommend.
Thanks!