r/homeworld • u/raverrn • May 20 '24
Homeworld HW3 is irredeemable. Sorry you had to find out this way.
Going beyond the (absolutely atrocious) story, there's zero gameplay here. Homeworld 3 feels like a mobile game, designed to let the player move his blob of units into the other player's blob of units and watch a pretty light show. The speed of units has been compressed severely, with fighters moving glacially and the Mothership a racecar. Every ship has an insanely controlling AI that seems to override all player commands and maneuver and act on it's own - completely negating the directional damage claims and horrendously ruining several ships with restricted firing arcs. Unit abilities are almost all completely brainless, yet require player input to make you feel like you're accomplishing anything. Skirmish maps are tiny, the majority of cloaking has been stripped away as was hyperspacing, deception tactics, probe placement, subsystem choice. Anything that's not an attack order has been broken or obscured to near uselessness. This includes mine frigates with their staggeringly worthless dispersal patterns - What fucking texture is the game gaining from a sphere of mines vs a cube of mines? - and turrets, with a UI so useless I thought it was a joke at first. You're telling me I have to select and place them one at a time, with individual selections and place orders, AND they rearrange themselves in the group status box so I'm sometimes moving the same turret about the space? It's laughable. I want to unlock the Wargames turret fleet just to see how absurdly useless it is, but I can't stomach playing Wargames for that long.
If Homeworld 1 was a micro-intensive RTS with diverse build paths and HW2 was a space-control contest defined and breaking over subsystem choice and loss, this?
This is jingling keys in front of an infant. There is nothing in HW3 worth saving.