r/homeworld • • May 20 '24

Homeworld HW3 is irredeemable. Sorry you had to find out this way.

1 Upvotes

Going beyond the (absolutely atrocious) story, there's zero gameplay here. Homeworld 3 feels like a mobile game, designed to let the player move his blob of units into the other player's blob of units and watch a pretty light show. The speed of units has been compressed severely, with fighters moving glacially and the Mothership a racecar. Every ship has an insanely controlling AI that seems to override all player commands and maneuver and act on it's own - completely negating the directional damage claims and horrendously ruining several ships with restricted firing arcs. Unit abilities are almost all completely brainless, yet require player input to make you feel like you're accomplishing anything. Skirmish maps are tiny, the majority of cloaking has been stripped away as was hyperspacing, deception tactics, probe placement, subsystem choice. Anything that's not an attack order has been broken or obscured to near uselessness. This includes mine frigates with their staggeringly worthless dispersal patterns - What fucking texture is the game gaining from a sphere of mines vs a cube of mines? - and turrets, with a UI so useless I thought it was a joke at first. You're telling me I have to select and place them one at a time, with individual selections and place orders, AND they rearrange themselves in the group status box so I'm sometimes moving the same turret about the space? It's laughable. I want to unlock the Wargames turret fleet just to see how absurdly useless it is, but I can't stomach playing Wargames for that long.

If Homeworld 1 was a micro-intensive RTS with diverse build paths and HW2 was a space-control contest defined and breaking over subsystem choice and loss, this?

This is jingling keys in front of an infant. There is nothing in HW3 worth saving.


r/homeworld • • Feb 29 '24

Homeworld 3 Why I'm still buying HW 3 at full price

1 Upvotes

First disclaimer: I probably liked what we saw so far more than most people here (or at least more than a very vocal group).

Second disclaimer: I won't blame for killing the franchise you if you're not buying the game.

Basically, I don't want the franchise to die. We had so far four games, two of them are great and the others are very good IMO. If this game underperforms financially, this will possibly be the last HW game we'll ever get. If the game turns out to be profitable, it's possible that in the next game, BBI will acknowledge their blunders and will fix them.

I believe that the best example is the X Series from Egosoftware: X3 was probably the pinnacle of the franchise, X:Rebirth was pretty bad, but X4 was a vast improvement, even if it wasn't as good as X3. But would they be able to release another game if X:Rebirth was a completely failure? I don't think so.

Now, if everyone buys the game, then we'll have a problem, as they will believe that they did a great job, but this is a very remote possibility, I believe. A marginaly profitable game, with some backlash and feedback is probably the best thing we can do to make HW great again.

I hereby urge you all to buy the game if possible. And please, do not under any circumstances pirate it.


r/homeworld • • Jun 07 '24

Homeworld 3 Whats the hate for homeworld 3?

9 Upvotes

Howdy, id like to preface that I am brand new to the Homeworld franchise. This is the first time ive even heard of it.

A week ago I saw it on my steam page and, being the sci-fi nerd I am, checked it out. I saw really bad reviews at nearly 50% approval rate which threw me a major red flag.

I decided to take the risk and get the game anyways despite the reviews. Im on my 4th campaign playthrough and I loved every bit of it.

The story was engaging and interesting, the visuals were phenomenal, the controls were intuitive and it was overall incredible! My one and only gripe is that theres no large scale stellaris type gamemode where you hop worlds and build large fleets (partially fixed by installing mods).

So I guess I just need some context, where is the hate coming from for this game? Why such a negative reception?


r/homeworld • • Jun 28 '24

If Homeworld 2 came out today

0 Upvotes

Ya'll would cry over shitty story and auto difficulty scaling and cancel the game into oblivion


r/homeworld • • May 29 '24

Homeworld 3's story is actually competent and not nearly as bad as people are saying.

0 Upvotes

I write games for a living and I've been playing Homeworld since 1999. For the past few weeks I didn't buy Homeworld 3 because all of the story backlash this game has been getting on this sub. The idea that they squandered HW3's story broke my heart and I didn't want to tarnish my view of the series.

But turns out, they didn't screw anything up. The story is competently done. It respects the original games, takes you to many great missions and has a nice dose of unexpected team ups. The villain is mostly two dimensional, but she was given an interesting ending that was way more interesting than anything the villain of HW2 ever got.

The fact that we got this game at all is a miracle, and the hate HW3's story is getting is totally out of proportion. I totally understand the premise that "Homeworld should be a story about a people, not individual characters", but that stopped being the case since Homeworld 2. That was all about 2 characters.

But to be fair, If I had written it, I would personally have focused on the people angle - but they decided to pick up Homeworld 2's baton and to focus on something else. And while it may not be everyone's cup of tea, it was competently done, not the trainwreck that many people are implying.

The story is good, way better than your average game. And the game is good too. If you are a fan, you won't want to miss on any of it.


r/homeworld • • May 15 '24

Homeworld 3 Hot Take: Are people just review-bombing the game because their standards are too high?

65 Upvotes

I won't say that HW3 is flawless. It definitely has its faults, but I'm honestly not finding it bad. And sure, modding may be needed to get the most out of the game, but I'm still satisfied with what we got.

I get it: people think it doesn't stack up to HW1 or to Cataclysm. But those two set a very high bar that I was never expecting HW3 to surpass. You can't beat a classic, after all.

This isn't the only place I've seen people doing review-bombs because a game doesn't live up to their expectations. These days, it feels like people are setting impossible standards that you can't reasonably expect a game to live up to, and then they get mad because the game doesn't match their definition of "perfect". They seem to think that the devs are supposed to please everyone when that is simply impossible, and then they bash them for trying to draw blood from a stone?

So, instead of going "it's flawed so it sucks", I'm going to go with "it's a good effort" in describing the game so far. And I hope that more players will cut the developers a little slack.


r/homeworld • • Jun 02 '24

Homeworld 3 detractors dont seem like very nice people. Yet they are the ones claiming about politics ruining video games. How ironic.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/homeworld • • May 15 '24

Are we getting lost in nostalgia?

19 Upvotes

I've been thinking about some of the major criticisms, especially when comparing it to the first game.

It seems to me that people may be misremembering certain aspects of the older games, especially because these criticisms were often true of those games as well.

The storylines of the original games weren't particularly subtle or well-written, the playtime was short, and the gameplay was innovative but often boiled down to basic resource management. As an example, contemporary reviews praised the game but had mixed responses to the plot.

I'm not dismissing anyone's right to critique the game or feel disappointed; especially because there are legitimate issues to discuss. However, it's worth considering whether the game isn't delivering the sense of nostalgia you were expecting.


r/homeworld • • May 23 '24

Homeworld 3 Is there a Homeworld subreddit for people who like the game?

62 Upvotes

My Reddit feed is constantly filled with people shitting on the new game. They are entitled to their opinion, but I guess I'm just sick of constantly seeing how much everyone hates a game I genuinely enjoy.

I know this is subjective, but I love the Homeworld franchise and love the new game: graphics, gameplay, and story. It's a perfect addition to my favorite childhood videogame franchise, and being in this subreddit kinda robs some of the joy of the game for me.


r/homeworld • • Dec 05 '24

Homeworld 4?

0 Upvotes

What do you guys think the chances are for Homeworld 4? I hope there is still is a future for the IP,


r/homeworld • • Jun 27 '24

Meta I’m Going to Buy Homeworld 3 to Specifically Make All of You Angry

0 Upvotes

Seeing the reaction HW3 has gotten from y’all and the HW fandom writ large has been… interesting, let’s call it. Here we have a pretty decent capstone for the franchise in terms of gameplay, the critical (eg Polygon, IGN, etc) reception is warm (not STELLAR by any means, but still relatively positive), the story looks and feels like a natural evolution of the themes from the previous games…

And all of you hate it. Why? What did this game do to you, dear HW fan, to deserve this vitriol? Did it personally kill your beloved childhood puppy? Did it piss in your cereal? Did it knock over the urn containing your grandma’s ashes? Did it suddenly start unironically quoting “Mein Kampf” during Thanksgiving dinner? What did this game do to you that made you so angry with it?

It’s fine! It’s not perfect, not by a long shot if the critical reception is to be believed, but it certainly looks ok! It does its job! It tells its story! It’s fine!

But apparently that’s a grievous, heinous sin. How dare this game be merely decent instead of excellent! How dare this game go in a different direction story-wise than simply rehashing HW1! How dare the mechanics of this game not be the exact same as HW1! How dare this game exist while not being a 1:1 recreation of the first game!

Jesus Willy H. Tap-Dancing Motherfucking Christ on a damn pogo stick y’all need to chill! I’m not sitting here trying to defend the actions of a developer/publisher over creative/business decisions that none of us have control over, nor am I suggesting that this game is the best ever, but holy shit all of you need to go touch grass or something. This isn’t healthy. This isn’t helping. This is absolutely ludicrous. You’re making the Fandom Menace, the fucking worst fandom in the history of nerd-dom, look like the goddamn Boy Scouts! For fuck’s sake, when you make r/saltierthancrait and/or 4chan’s /v/ look like unabashed utopias, that’s when you need to step back and reevaluate your priorities.

To quote the Somtaaw warship Kuun-Lan: “You’re worse than the Beast! At least the Beast doesn’t pretend to be righteous!”

And to paraphrase Hellsing Ultimate Abridged: “No one ‘ruined’ Homeworld for you! The Homeworld you like is still available on GOG and Steam in its remastered form!”

So, with that outta the way, you’re probably wondering why I titled this post the way I did. In some ways, it’s to garner attention; need to make sure that people actually see and read this, after all. Basic, yes, but the needs must in this day and age of algorithms.

But to cut to the heart of the matter, it’s titled that way because I want to threaten you, the person reading this. I want you to feel rage over me enjoying my purchase. I want you furious about me having FUN. I want you to scream, thrash, and throw your hands up in impotent anger at me playing a game that I bought with my own money. I want to bask in the glory of your salt as you realize that you cannot stop me from deriving pleasure from this game.

This threat, the threat of me buying HW3 and being happy about it, won’t be followed up on immediately, no. That would be too easy. Too simple. I’m going to wait for the perfect moment to buy this. I’m going to watch for a sale, a big one, and then…POW! The game will be in my library, I’ll be playing it, and you won’t be able to do a damn thing to stop me. Hell, I’ll even leave a positive review of the game that references this post, just to further twist the knife.

You will seethe, you will wail, but you won’t stop me. I’m going to have fun… and I want that thought to keep you up at odd hours of the night, keeping you awake in your anger as you realize that me enjoying this game is your worst nightmare made manifest.

Sweet dreams.

TL;DR: What the post says on the tin.


r/homeworld • • Aug 06 '24

Do you think HW:3 can be saved at this point?

0 Upvotes

I am wondering does the fan base (well this subreddit's contingent) think HW3 can be saved at this point?

Wishful thinking, but I wonder if they can release like something akin to a directors cut (a polite way to save face and edit out Geabox's clear interference) and try to retool the game.

I mean, I think I'd be content with them not apologising or going out guns blazing and doubling down on the mess they did release; as long as they were like well here is something more akin to our initial vision of the project.

But I have the sneaking suspicion after the community's campaign against certain writing staff, that they'd be accused of giving in to hate speech or whatever other buzz word Gearboxes PR and twitterverse fan base might use.

Just thought i'd ask.

Edit:
Just to clarify, when I mention a "hate campaign" I very well mean that there would be cries from certain people in Gearbox saying that BBI/Gearbox gave into a "hate campaign".

It's happened with almost every game/property that has a bad story/design because it fell into the hands of someone with zero experience with the IP they're working on/or their own take. I.E. the woman at Gearbox.


r/homeworld • • May 19 '24

Any chance for HW3 to be remake?

0 Upvotes

Cause the storyline is really really bad…


r/homeworld • • May 20 '24

Homeworld 3 I, for one, enjoyed the campaign.

16 Upvotes

I thought that the Incarnate Queen was very compelling, even though she was somewhat underdeveloped. It’s obvious that some stuff was cut that would’ve allowed for more character building, but by and large, it was pretty good, it wasn’t GREAT as a metric, but I enjoyed the campaign enough that I would recommend the game for it. Really, the one gripe I had related to Imogen, specifically how she was animated in the CG cutscenes. This isn’t a complaint about the CG cutscenes generally, more one specific aspect of them. They animated her in this weird middle ground of being both asleep and awake in the core, and it leans too far into the uncanny valley for what I think they were going for. Aside from that, I felt the CG cutscenes were decent, even though I miss the hand-painted cutscenes, too.


r/homeworld • • May 15 '24

HW3 is our Dawn of War 3

5 Upvotes

From the hype and hopes of what the game could achieve. To the flopped execution, removed mechanics and tonal changes.

Sad really. Hopefully mods can improve the game over time. Thanks gearbox for nothing.


r/homeworld • • May 30 '24

In the light of Homeworld Mobile shutting down and HW3 is going the same path

0 Upvotes

It's no use to push community feedback and feature request if BBI/gearbox is not listening. I enjoy HW3 but with so much I love about HW2 and, heck, even DoK, is missing in HW3. I had, somehow, a better feeling with the range and position of railguns in DoK than in HW3 with torpedos and ion frigates.

They have every opportunity to check out HW2 + mods to take away what made that great and introduce that again what people loved.

And for the love of god, don't split the playerbase with DLC. Innovate, do something crazy, improve and go beyond what we expected from you. You played it too safe.


r/homeworld • • Jun 05 '24

Homeworld 3's campaign pisses on the grave of the long dead Titans of the RTS genre.

16 Upvotes

I always knew it wouldn't live up to Homeworld 1 (or even Cataclysm) from the moment I saw the design direction, hell from the second I saw Imogen's photogenic girlboss face with her full head of hair and skintight body suit on full display...

But god. God how is it this bad. I have nothing really meaningful to add to this beyond my wailing cries of agony at seeing yet another disaster for the ailing genre and its misbegotten progeny.


r/homeworld • • May 14 '24

This game is bad. Stop accepting mediocrity. You don't owe the developers anything. You should demand more from them in terms of quality.

22 Upvotes

First off; let me say that I am a fan of Homeworld and the Remastered Collection. I play mods on both versions even to this day. Classic is still playable despite it's age and I still get a kick out of from time to time.

When they announced Homeworld 3; I was excited like most fans. I loved Homeworld 2 despite the flaws fans had with it in terms of gameplay and campaign. However; as the months progressed while following Homeworld 3; I began to notice a trend. Blackbird was being extremely coy of what the progress was like when the game was in development. You would think that they would be active in terms of giving updates every 3-4 months or wanting to show off what they were working on to generate hype for this game.

Blackbird barely gave consistent updates about this game even after it was delayed the first time. There would be months of radio silence before they actually posted on what they were working. I began to see several red flags about what they were demonstrating in terms of gameplay but kept them to myself. After all; game development changes unexpectedly and not everything makes it for that reason in the finale game release.

I was optimistic but guarded despite this game being delayed again and again. People kept saying "The longer it takes for them to make a good game; I'd be okay if they pushed it back. Give them time to cook to make a Homeworld we all wanted"

Okay. I could understand that. I was one of the few that actually voiced dismay that this game was going to be delayed but after awhile; I could see reason. I was still skeptical that they could turn it around after the game was so close to release when they announced the delayed to May 2024. I did not think much could be done within 3 months of game development; if anything; production would have wrapped up at the most with everything pretty much completed. It's not like they could redo something major in terms of gameplay mechanics.

However; when the game was finally released and with people showing off in YouTube; I couldn't help myself. I wanted to like what I saw and initially I did. I have an impulse to buy something that if I feel like it could be really good in actual gameplay content in the long run. I was worried about the whole focus on War games that Blackbird kept mentioning but felt I could get into it within reason and time. I like PVE content if it's only PVE and not solely PVEVP.

So I brought Homeworld 3 as soon as I could. I waited eagerly for it install while watching gameplay videos. The gameplay had me hooked and I loved what was shown with gigantic climatic battle in space. The campaign was secondary but I didn't pay more concern to it at the time.

This is where I began to dislike what I brought. The game; while beautiful; lacks actual soul of what it's trying to be. Something felt off. I tried doing a few Skirmish matches against the AI. I found it to be underwhelming due to how the AI reacts; is over aggressive without actually researching; gathering resources; and building a fleet to attack you in the game. That was the basis in previous Homeworld games where it was it's "you built a base in terms of ships while gathering resources". It just rushes you for no apparent reason. I've been told this a bug on easy but have seen it on standard as well.

The other issue that I had was that it lacked build tree depth and upgrades to every ship. In Homeworld 2; you could research hull defense and firepower with different levels in terms of upgrades. Where is that in 3? You could upgrade what type of ships you build within a carrier or on the mother ship. Each category had it's own set of upgrades per ship type. In 3; it's too simplified. For example; the fighter class you could only research the ability for it to boast firepower for a temporary set of time in exchange of a negative. Where is the upgrades to make it faster or increase durability? Where is any type of actual research for ship classes within 3?

I'm not even going to go over the actual campaign as it's been discussed to death and the negative issues with it is shared by almost the majority of the fanbase. I will say that the overall gameplay features within Homeworld 3 is severely dumbed down. The ship designs are lacking in terms of actual creative design but that's just my opinion. Some people like it while others obviously do not.

I wanted to like this game. I brought it at full price and had high expectations like everyone else. It's been too long since we actually got a Homeworld sequel. I'm disappointed with how this game was released. They should have done more on features that the fans wanted before actually releasing it. It feels lifeless and generic at best.

And I know people will down vote me without actual replying because that's how they are on Reddit. I ask you to actually understand the legitimate issues that this game has. This game has issues; that is a fact.

I just don't get why certain users need a reassurance boast of self confidence by posting a topic saying "Let's give praise to the developers of this game and no negativity!!" You do not know the developers at all. They do not know you. They are not your friends. They were paid to make and develop a game that clearly wasn't fleshed out and released it in this dismal state of backlash.


r/homeworld • • Jun 29 '24

Will Homeworld 3 ever be available on Apple Silicon?

0 Upvotes

With the rise or ARM on both Windows and MacOS, this was the first game I was actually surprised to see not available on Mac.

Will it ever be?


r/homeworld • • Jul 09 '24

Homeworld First DLC - Some intel ?

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

Now that most of the detractors have left for new horizons, do we have any news about the first DLC expected this month?

I've been poking around steamdb and I've seen that several updates from recent depots are announcing changes, but I'd love to have some information on what's in store for us.


r/homeworld • • Feb 06 '24

Homeworld 3 Pre order cancelled. My heart is broken

32 Upvotes

We have waited decades for this, and this is what they show us a month before release to convince us to buy it?!

The original games were a big part of my childhood gaming. The style and direction of those games feels barely present in this demo. The 'history of homeworld' was completely different from the original art style of the cut scenes. The narration also felt completely forced.

The gameplay itself is abysmal.

Camera controls are dizzyingly bad, with eventually finding yourself further and further away from anything until you refocus.

Ship movement and AI is laughably bad, spending most of their time floating about missing their targets or not engaging enemies at all. Projectiles move too slowly and too uniformly to feel fired at all, and more like a sprite following a line from the firing ship and it's target.

I like the ship design, and some of the UI styling, and that's basically about it.

All in all this feels like a game that needs another 6 months to a year in development. To the people saying this is an old build and the release version will be more polished, I have only this demo as reference. I will not buy it to see how it is based on some spurious idea that it might be better than this demo.

I have been shown a product, and that product is weak and unfinished, why would I spend money on it?!

I hope the Devs see these posts and realise that they are not a personal attack against them, but please take on board what we have said as a community.


r/homeworld • • 23h ago

Question, is Lin Joyce responsible for the terrible story of HMW3?

9 Upvotes

I've been looking into why Homeworld 3 sucked so much, the short missions, the stupid story line, and I keep coming across a name, Lin Joyce?


r/homeworld • • May 05 '25

Homeworld 2 Homeworld 2 End mission: What. The. F*ck?!?! How Stupid. Seriously. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hey friends. Replaying Homeworld 2 in the remastered collection. First/last time I played it was probably when the collection first came out. So I don’t really remember anything.

Let me explain my situation. Got to the final mission of HW:2. Only had like one battle cruiser, one destroyer, and the dreadnought + Sajuuk.

Immediately realized I looked upon like 5 battle cruisers and even more destroyers. So I loaded back to the last mission.

Before killing the flagship I maxed out my ship count. 3 battle cruisers, max destroyers and carriers, plus a bunch of bombers, interceptors, and corvettes.

Ok cool. So I brought the hammer onto the siege fleet right?

Nope.

Let me explain how my final mission goes.

Have my 3 cruisers split into 3 formations. The middle having the dreadnought and Sajuuk.

Send each to its respects side, send resource collectors to save the battlecruisers, engage, and all is good and fun.

But then here comes the stupid fucking planet killers.

My fighters/corvettes are too slow to intervene. And no matter how many Sajuuk takes out I simply cannot kill enough of the missiles.

So this is my question/point.

Normally most games will be difficult, but if you’re good enough you can win on your first save.

But this final mission is fucking horse shit. So I’m supposed to know to send my interceptors or corvettes to each corner of the side of the map?

Micromanage them to target the missiles and not help the dying fucking home fleet.

Which is what pisses me off the most. I’m sorry, but you put this entire home fleet, give them the voice lines of them valiantly holding the line, and I’m just supposed to abandon them for missiles I wouldn’t know are coming?

This mission just pisses me off. I love the Homeworld series. But seriously? It’s like you must have intimate knowledge of the mission, the AI, the trajectory of the missiles, and more to even have a chance.

How stupid. So how the fuck do I win this mission? I have max everything.

Max cruisers, destroyers, fighters/bombers, corvettes, and more.

Yet still these stupid fucking missiles that are faster than my gunships will just bomb the planet and BOOM I lose?!

wtf?!

What a shitty final mission to an amazing sequel.

Apparently you must have in-depth knowledge of the final mission, what will happen, how to respond, where to place units, to ignore your dying fleet, and more to even have a chance.

Are you kidding me?! Horrible design. Horrible final mission.

Leaves such a bad taste in my mouth after having such an incredible time playing Homeworld 1 and 2 (except the final mission for 2 obviously).

Oh and WHO THE FUCK EXPLAINS that Sajuuk can use hyperspace?! I’ve never seen that once in the game. But apparently we must already know that so we can hyperspace close to the planet killers.

Like seriously?! Maybe I’m old school but why the fuck should I have to scavenge through forums in order to find a strategy or game gimmick to exploit to actually beat a mission. Shouldn’t you… idk… EXPLAIN IT?!?! Or at least fucking show us Sajuuk hyperspace traveling?

Just seems like such a SHITTY finish to such a great game.


r/homeworld • • May 16 '23

Hey, Blackbird Interactive...get up off your lazy butts and make a Deserts of Kharak-themed clone of 'World of Warships'. I said what I said.

4 Upvotes

MAKE IT HAPPEN


r/homeworld • • May 16 '24

This games story is worse that halo 5 and The Room put together

0 Upvotes

change my mind