r/homeschooldiscussion • • Oct 15 '23

Shared experiences have value. Homeschooling takes that away from people.

65 Upvotes

I homeschooled my daughter when very young because of some developmental issues, but I always, always, always wanted to get her to a place where she could go into public school.

She got to start middle school with the kids her age and continued through high school. She experienced dances, sports, clubs, band, honor societies, field trips, a Disney trip, senior skip day, and even getting into a little social, love-triangle drama.

Having those shared experiences is so important in life! You have to be able to relate to people and share your life stories. Similar stories builds rapport, and is the foundation to friendships.

In business and life, it's not about what you know, it's about who you know and ultimately who likes you!

I've met adults who homeschooled all the way through and they can't join in the professional, workplace water-cooler talk. They continue to be outsiders. There's too much the don't understand.

If you're thinking of homeschooling, it's easy to get excited about the positive things you'll be giving your child, but also consider what you're taking away.

They can NEVER get back those school experiences, and you'll be the reason they're gone.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jul 22 '25

You all succeeded

55 Upvotes

Hi Reddit,

I just wanted to let you know that you have successfully converted me. I was on the fence about homeschooling my son this year and I was looking for curriculum. I found r/HomeschoolRecovery 's discussion of PACES in my research and went down the rabbit hole. Reading your collective experiences made me realize that homeschooling has served its purpose for us and now that we are past some of my child's major medical issues and diagnostic hurdles, I re-enrolled him in public school today. Thank you for being vulnerable. I just wanted to let you know you made an actual difference.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • May 07 '23

Why do you think homeschool parents get more credence than homeschooled people?

52 Upvotes

Whenever someone has questions about homeschooling who do they ask? They go to the mommy groups, the main homeschooling subs, asks people they know who are homeschooling their kids, but almost never the people who have been homeschooled.

While I'm not under the delusion that no ex-homeschooler enjoyed their experience, the vast majority I have talked to a know in real life where traumatized or at the very where left unequipped for life in one way or another. Look at r/homeschool, It's 90% parents. If someone asks a question, or shows a hint of doubt the pro-homeschool brigade jumps down their throats to try to convince them homeschooling is the perfect solution and can't harm a child because mommy knows best.

For homeschool parents, when you're in your spaces and you read someone who has much more radical beliefs than you, what do you think? "my 14 yo still can't read" is met with "everyone moves at their own pace." People talking about vaccines causing autism. People raging about 5G, or only teaching their children out of the bible. You know that these are the same people telling the person with doubts that homeschooling is a perfect option for their family, correct? You would be disgusted by these people's treatment of their children if you saw it in real life, but you'll happily take their advice on curriculum, or what amount of socialization is enough.

When a an ex-homeschooler comes out and says that twice a week art classes, or the homeschool days at the art museum wasn't enough socialization we aren't believed. When we say that one person isn't capable of teaching a child everything they need to learn, you don't listen.

How many times do you think I've heard "but I'll be different," "I'll be better," "we're not religious nuts," or "but my child is well socialized and learned from real curriculum?" Now how many times do you think I heard that from my own mother?

So when you trust other parents, but ignore people who have experienced cruelty at the hands of homeschooling what is your thought process?


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Apr 24 '23

Advice from an ex homeschool student, now entering public education

31 Upvotes

Hey y'all, This is mainly for any parents currently considering/unsure about homeschooling their kids. Mainly because, as someone who works/is currently studying in k-12 teaching, I think I may have a slightly different outlook than most other ex homeschool students here, at least to an extent.

And to disclose any biases beforehand, I was homeschooled 4th-9th grade, and was left with clinical depression, lifelong social issues, etc., as a result of it. So it's not really a surprise how I feel about it.

So obviously I can only give my take, but as an educator I think there's some things to be said. Mainly that, unless you are in a very, very specific set of conditions, where your child will be able to have daily (not just weekly or biweekly, but consistent, daily) social interaction with the same group of kids their age, and will receive classroom instruction on par with kids in public school, as someone who has worked with homeschool kids, it will harm your child. There's not really any two ways about it.

And even outside of my own trauma, I've witnessed the difference first hand between the kids coming from the best, most dedicated and well meaning homeschool families, and those who have been through even extremely difficult public school districts, and it legitimately is night and day.

Because from a psychological and development level, your child's needs will not be met, and there's a reason that in the modern world, a teacher needs at least a four year degree to step foot in a classroom. And I have personally seen the damage done by homeschooling, and at least in my experience, I have never, not once, seen a child come out of it who wasn't scarred or developmentally harmed in some way.

So just, unless you're the 0.0001% who can provide an environment perfectly analogous to a regular school for child, as an educator, and someone who has been through it myself, I would thoroughly recommend that you reconsider.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Feb 19 '24

Could your parents have done anything to make homeschool a positive experience?

27 Upvotes

For example, would you have enjoyed it if:

A.) One parent was an actual licensed teacher who also brought in experts (tutors, Outschool classes, etc.) in areas that were more technical/outside of their area of expertise

B.) You attended a drop-off program 2-3 days/week and had a structured social activity each day (martial arts, group music class, co-op field trip, science lab, etc.)

C.) You happened to live in an area with a lot of secular homeschoolers, so it’s not social taboo and you have lots of opportunities to get together

AND

D.) It started out because you ASKED to be homeschooled and you are allowed to go to public school at any point.

Context: My oldest went to private preschool but it didn’t work out and she was sad about it, so to try to make it up to her I did a semi-official “homeschool preschool” time with her a few evenings a week until public preschool became an option. She did public preschool the next year and liked it, but asked me if we could do homeschool again for Kindergarten. My husband and I had already decided that I was going to step away from my teaching job for a few years and because her epileptic seizures were not quite managed at that point, we agreed and are now a little over halfway through Kindergarten with the set-up described above. It is working really well for us and she is thriving, so we’ve kind of decided to leave school choice up to the kids unless something drastic changes.

But, I read through the homeschool recovery subreddit often to stay self-aware and, especially after the recent post about what they’d tell parents considering homeschool, I’m starting to wonder if we should encourage/push her to try public school again next year.

I would so greatly appreciate your thoughts on this! With our extracurriculars and drop-off program and the fact that I’m an experienced teacher I thought we were avoiding all of the negative parts of homeschool, but now I’m not so sure.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Oct 14 '22

I worked for a public school and that's why I want to homeschool

24 Upvotes

Hello all,

First I want to say that I'm very glad I found the homeschool recovery sub, because it's given me a lot to consider and, I hope, will make me a better homeschool parent.

I'm pregnant with my first baby and I'm planning to homeschool. I'm already planning to turn a small extra room in our apartment into a circle time room (with a rug, children's books, weather chart, and other manipulatives that would be used in pre-k/kindergarten story time).

I just want to share why I'm planning to homeschool despite knowing its challenges. Because I would actually prefer to send my child to school. I had great experiences with school as a kid. I loved playing with my friends at recess, I had lots of freinds and good teachers, and I sang in the school chorus. Middle school was slightly more challenging, but I greatly enjoyed elementary school.

The thing is, school has changed since the 90s and is no longer the fun and exciting place that it was when I was little. At least it isn't where I live (and we can not move due to the very specialized niche my husband works in).

I worked in my city's public school system until 3 years ago (I quit because I was fed up with how the school was handling the pandemic-those kids did no learning virtually). I was not a classroom teacher, I was an instructional aide, so I had limited influence. I worked in a number of schools, since I started out as a day substitute. I worked across many grade levels and with every group of children, from gen-ed classrooms to the behavioral classroom to the special education classroom.

I'm gonna list out some of the issues i saw.

-Substituting as an aide in various kindergarten classrooms, I was horrified by how long those poor little guys have to sit quietly and do worksheets. They would do circle time in the morning, one "special"-like art or gym once a day, one recess of 20 minutes, and lunch of 30 minutes. The rest of the day was worksheets. 4 and 5 year olds should not be sitting for hours at a time doing worksheets. It isn't developmentally appropriate and it's just sad! When I was a kid, I did half day kindergarten. I was at the school for about 3 hours and most of that time was doing "centers" with tactile stuff or listening to stories. I only remember doing 1 or 2 worksheets a day when I was in kindergarten. Those kids are being set up to hate school and learning.

-No training in special education classrooms. So, eventually I became a designated aide in a special ed classroom. I worked with kids with autism. These were a "level two" in my district. Moderate disabilities. Without warning, for the summer program, they threw me into the level one program. these were kids with severe disabilities. I'm talking non-verbal, many non-mobile, not able to feed or toilet themselves. I wouldn't mind working with this population, but the lack of training and supervision they gave me just wasn't safe for the kids! There were dedicated nurses in the classroom to change them and help with feeding, but there weren't enough of them, so us aides were often expected to help with that stuff. On my second day, i was sitting on a mat with a wheelchair bound kid (he had a myriad of disabilities that were never completely explained to me). He was non-verbal but liked to be taken out of his chair a couple times a day to rollabout on this mat. i guess it gave him some freedom and let him exercise the few muscles he had some control over. It was only me and one nurse in the classroom at the time. everyone else had gone outside for recess and the classroom teacher asked me to stay behind and help keep an eye on the two kids who couldn't go outside (for medical reasons). The nurse was feeding another kid at a table nearby. As this kid was rolling about on the mat, the feeding tube in his stomach popped out. I alerted the nurse who just said, "Oh, you can pop it back in." I stared at her dumbfounded. I am not a nurse. I have no experience with feeding tubes. I had a bachelor's degree in creative writing and it was my second day working with this population. I told her I wasn't comfortable doing that. She was very annoyed that I didn't want to touch his feeding tube. I just didn't want to hurt him! Nobody had ever shown me how to do it and I'd never been told stuff like that would be in my job description.

Another situation involved a kid who was also non-verbal and partially mobile. He could stand for a little bit each day, as long as there was something for him to hold onto (it was a muscle-control issue-he had poor balance and moved very jerkily). He would often grunt and kick as a way to ask to be let out of his chair. So, we would take him out and either walk slowly around the room holding his hands, or set him up in front of a table, which he would hold onto and someone would sit nearby. One day i was in the room alone with another aide (an aide who had worked with level one kids for years and it was my second week at this point). It was me, her, and this partially-mobile kid. He was very cooperate and friendly and able to move somewhat on his own, so it usually only required one person to get him back in his chair. I was cleaning up and this other aide was putting him into his chair. I looked over as she was saying, "I'll be back, I'm bringing him out to the bus." I looked over and said okay and, as she pushed the chair forward, I saw that his foot had gone under the wheel and she was running it over as she pushed him forward. His ankle was twisted at a horrible angle and looked painful. I jumped up and yelled that his foot was under the wheel. She stopped and we both got his foot out from under it. We situated his feet back on the footrests and she went to move him again. His foot flopped down out of the footrest again and I was able to catch her attention before she ran it over again. We put his feet back and again he flopped his feet out. We were both puzzled for a moment. We tried to figure out how to get his feet to remain in the rests without him flopping them out and getting run over. I saw that there were these little velcro loops at the bottom of the footrests. I asked her, "Do you think these are here to keep his feet in place?" She said, "Oh, they must be." So, we secured his feet with the velcro straps and she was able to bring him out to the bus without hurting his feet again. Well, that was on a Friday, come Monday I'm getting pulled into the office and questioned. The parents were livid, saying that restraints were used on their child. I felt so horrified and guilty. I just didn't want the kid's feet to get hurt. When I looked over the first time, the other aide had his entire foot under the wheel. She had thrown me under the bus completely and said that I was the one who did it and acted like she wasn't involved at all. They ended up watching the cameras and realizing that I was just trying to not let the kid get hurt and truly thought those velcro pieces were a safety thing. But like....why was i thrown in with this vulnerable population with no training? I pointed that out when this incident happened and still didn't get any training. If I ever asked questions, people were annoyed at me for bothering them. I was expected to feed kids with no training, to help perform lifts. Apparently, this is a job that you're just supposed to "learn as you go." I didn't sign up to be a nurse or deal with physical needs. I never knew I'd be expected to. But if I wanted to keep my job, I had to jump in and try. People jumping in and trying with such vulnerable children should not be acceptable. I'm glad no children were ever seriously injured on my watch.

-Next, violence in school not taken seriously. We had a very troubled little boy in the middle school where i worked the longest. He was a level two moderate disabilities in the autism program. This little boy happened to find a lead pipe outside while they were out for an impromptu recess on a warm day. He proceeded to charge and swing at several teachers and managed to hit one male teacher pretty hard. This teacher had to physically restrain the kid. I'm sure this was very traumatizing for the other kids to see. He was allowed to come back to school a few days later.

On another occasion, this same child threatened to steal his uncle's gun, bring it to school, and shoot specific people. It was well-known that the kid's uncle (who he lived with) was also a bit of a nut, and yes, he did have guns. Kid was allowed to come back to school two days later with an apology. THAT was one of the times I argued and told my higher ups they were dead wrong. I said, "This is the red flag that other school shooting victims wish they'd had. Don't ignore it." They ignored it. I doubt the other parents with children in that special ed program knew that other adults had decided their child should remain in the classroom with someone who had threatened gun violence. this same child and his uncle also came to my weekend job at one point and followed me around. I never told them where I worked. Administration decided this was my fault for being "too friendly" to this child. No conversation was had with the child or his uncle.

Not as serious as the previous example, but another child with autism often threw books and heavy objects at other children. There was one child-only partially verbal-who was terrified of this kid and would cry and cower every time he came into the room. Not sure how much learning that kid did while actively experiencing trauma.

-They would dump kids who couldn't speak English into the autism program. Yes, you read that right. Only half the students in these classes actually had autism. They straight up told me (the BCBA coach and department head) that they would write down autism and fake the paperwork if administration asked them to, so that they could get the "disruptive students" away from "the kids who will actually do well on the tests." They robbed these children of an appropriate education, in order to keep federal test scores up. Because special ed test scores are not weighed as heavily, and often these kids don't have to take the same tests.

-Class time wasted on nonsense. The head teacher of the special ed room I worked in had to fill out constant reports on the kids. So much time was spent getting the kids to fill out worksheets for these files. One day she made me sit with a kid and just TELL HER exactly what to write on each line, because we didn't have time to have the kid not do the worksheet correctly. This was a child who could not read at age 14. She often showed some promise of having the ability to become literate. She wanted to learn to read and after a couple days of one-on-one help, learned a handful of sight words. But then we never had time to continue with that. We had to fill out fake worksheets that the kid didn't even do herself. We spent so much time on that and other baloney and the kid went off to high school still not knowing how to read. The curriculum is so structured that kids aren't getting what they actually need.

-Kids being expected to sit in silence and not socialize at all. When I would cover gen-ed classes at the middle school, I would usually tell kids they could talk as long as they did their work. I mean, it's so unnatural to have them move from one 40 minute block where they sit in silence and do work to the next 40 minute block where they sit in silence and do work, ALL DAY. But I had to stop letting the kids talk in class. The other teachers complained. One even barged into the room to lecture me in front of them. It's not right to expect them to sit in silence and work all day. Even adults don't have to work that way. Adults chat while they work. The way kids are treated in school is unnatural. It's like prison. (But like...aren't even prisoners often allowed to talk while they work?) Yes, SOME quiet time is good for concentration, especially for kids that have trouble focusing. But the bulk of the day was working in silence.

-Teachers are often inappropriate. The classroom teacher that I worked most often with loved AOC and started showing videos of AOC to the kids, even saying things like, "Isn't it great that she's so young and is doing so much!" The teacher upstairs, another teacher in the special ed program, got wind of this, got annoyed, and started doing the same thing, but with Trump. Special needs middle schoolers don't go to public school to get any political views foisted on them: progressive or conservative, and these kids had BOTH foisted on them, sometimes back to back, as they often went from AOC lady's class right to Trump lady's class.

That's all I can think of at the moment. But overall, I felt nothing but sadness for those kids everyday. The public school system in my city is failing them.

If I start homeschooling my kids and they ask to go to public school, I'll respect their wishes. I just can't stomach the thought of sending a 5 year old to school to do worksheets for 5 hours in silence. I'll be a hundred times more anxious if I give birth to a special needs child, knowing that untrained people could be thrown into the classroom or a child who has threatened gun violence could be allowed to come back to school and sit in the same classroom as my child, all without me ever being notified.

I do want my kid to have friends and a great social life, so I'm planning to try enrolling them in many of the activities I did for fun as a kid. As a kid, I did dance classes several times a week and I was in a book club at my library. I also went to camp as a kid and always loved it. If they don't like those things and want to try different activities, then we'll do that.

I guess I just wanted to share my reasoning for not wanting to public school and hear what you guys think. Are my reasons good? Am I being silly?

I never considered homeschooling as an option for future children, until I worked in a public school.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Nov 28 '23

Those who are against homeschooling: What do you think about the posts in r/Teachers about how terrible schools have gotten?

23 Upvotes

I grew up homeschooled, so I have no real idea of what public/private school is like. My parents told me it was horrible, bullying is rampant, kids go haywire, and no learning gets done.

As an adult, I realize how terrible my own education was and that a good portion of the world my parents created for me was a lie: Creationism, politics, 9/11 conspiracies, anti-lgbt propaganda, etc. So I've come to doubt everything they've said about public school as well. I've also come to be very pro public school in principle because I think it's good for society.

The problem is, I have two sisters who ended up going to public school for several years, and they experienced horrible bullying, drug use, sexual assault, etc. This was in St. Louis which is not known for having quality schools.

Then I've read a lot on r/Teachers where rowdiness and poor educational results are being described. They say kids are being passed on from grade to grade without reading comprehension, terrible behavior, and bullying.

So for those who are against homeschooling, do you honestly think public schools are better? Especially for a family who doesn't live in a wealthy school district?


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Apr 25 '22

A Warning on Homeschooling - Harvard Gazette Article

22 Upvotes

I was reading this article referenced in r/HomeschoolRecovery and I agree with it wholeheartedly. I am not opposed to homeschool regulation at all. There needs to be checks and balances in place so that kids do not become neglected and abused. I'm also not opposed to periodic testing to make sure each child is meeting their grade-level benchmarks assuming that they have no learning/cognitive disorders or other health impairments.

I like what Bartholet said here specifically.

BARTHOLET: "I’d like to see a radical transformation of the homeschooling regime. I would not ban all homeschooling but would require that parents demonstrate that they have a legitimate reason to homeschool — maybe their child is a super athlete, maybe the schools in their area are terrible. They should also demonstrate that they’re qualified to provide an adequate education and that they would provide an education comparable in scope to what is required in public schools. And for parents granted permission to homeschool, I would still require that their kids participate in at least some school courses and extracurricular activities so they get exposure to a set of alternative values and experiences".


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Apr 06 '26

After reading about multiple nightmare "homeschooling" experiences, are any other parents now extremely skeptical when you see parents talking about their "happy homeschooling" families?

20 Upvotes

* ETA: sorry for the long title, I couldn't post without user flair--none of which fit, so I had to redo the title and I rushed it.

I homeschooled my oldest to 6th grade because his ADHD just made it so hard for him (and his teachers). I homeschooled his brother only to kindergarten, and put them both in public school because I'm just not energetic enough to get them around other kids--other than neighbor kids and soccer.

But as I watch a few videos here and there, read about horror stories like the "homeschooling" family in California (I forget their names), Stella McCormick etc, when I see people talking about how wonderful homeschooling has been for their family I feel pure suspicion.

I also want to share the Stella McCormick information with anyone who had a traumatic and abusive homeschooling experience, because she got herself out and managed to get herself through college.

***If you're homeschooling your kids in a healthy way--with love, open mindedness, actual teaching, and socialization, this is certainly not about you, so please don't take it as such. 💜


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jul 26 '23

Anyone else really confused by the posts on the other homeschool sub?

20 Upvotes

I thought one of the main benefits of homeschool was tailoring a curriculum to your kids, but most of the posts at the moment seem to be about finding an online one.

Maybe I find it odd coming from the UK, where we have a published national curriculum, so you don't really need to search one out. But lots of these parents seem to want a full school just without the building. They'd let their child stare at a screen all day on a curriculum thing, but don't want them going to school? Maybe I'm missing something.

I was really considering homeschool as a great alternative, but the posts on there seem incredibly off-putting. Maybe I had a warped idea in my mind of what it's like, however those posts just seem like people struggling with things easily fixed by in-person school, but clinging to the brand of homeschool.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jun 01 '26

My daughter wants to be homeschooled

19 Upvotes

I have three kids. They are all in a dual immersion school and like it for the most part. My oldest (3rd grader) has been begging me to homeschool her for the past year. She HATES going to school. It’s an everyday issue. She tells me she really wants to try homeschooling and I’m torn. She is asking to be homeschooled for 4th grade. I told her we would “homeschool” for the summer so that she can get a taste of what it’s like.

I have a background in education and have a very good grasp on curriculum and so forth.

I am just not sure if it’s a good idea. I keep hearing horror stories of others being homeschooled and I’m afraid of failing my kid. Thoughts?


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Apr 18 '22

Black Ex-Homeschoolers? Asking as a Black Parent - LONG READ All welcomed to Chime In

19 Upvotes

I am a Black parent that is seriously considering homeschooling my daughter who has recently turned 15. She has ADHD and cognitively is a little slower than her peers. Due to her lack of impulse control even with medication.

The bullying she has endured at school reached a fever pitch recently when she went to a faculty member about being threatened by bullies at school. The girls bullying her decided to go to the faculty and drudge up every piece of dirt they could about my daughter including a lot of things she was doing that I had no prior knowledge of.

I won't go into detail, but I will say that 98% of these activities were happening during school hours or when she was supposed to be at an afterschool activity. What adds insult to injury I have been in communication with all of her teachers and principals throughout the school year and only one teacher was concerned about the students my daughter was socializing with enough to contact me.

I warned my daughter about her friends, a couple of them have probation officers, a couple of them are pregnant, and all of them are always in and out of trouble at school, but that's who my daughter chooses to hang around.

Bullying has always been bad at public schools, but it is on a whole other level with this generation and social media.

For Black kids especially, society is not as forgiving when they mess up. I know so many kids who made grave mistakes as teens and have JUST gotten out of prison within the last 10 years, so the risks are very real.

I am by no means a religious parent. Anti-religious would be more accurate. My reasons for wanting to homeschool have NOTHING to do with religion and it may not even be permanent. My daughter has an IEP, but it is on her to ask for help when she needs it in the classroom. However, I think that the potential embarrassment of needing help keeps her from asking for it. Plus, she has told me that there have been times when teachers have been dismissive when she's asked for it. There have been a few occasions where teachers have done this and I have had to get her principal involved. We had her transferred to a different class this semester because one teacher she had was just a jerk to put it nicely.

Not only that, but I want my daughter to fall in love with learning. When I help her with assignments at home she gets it! She's engaged! With her ADHD she has to have simplified instruction and bigger tasks broken up into smaller parts. Her teachers do not have the bandwidth to do this with her and with them having 20-30 other students in their classroom, I'm not sure it is realistic to expect them to be able to.

I also want her to learn History in a way that is not so biased. Public school history is taught from a perspective that leaves out A LOT. I want her to learn the roles Black and other people of color have played in our history. For example, Black people have fought in EVERY war this country has had, but if you were to read most public school History books you would NEVER know it! I've seen a couple of homeschool curriculums that are more inclusive that I'm excited about using, plus I have several books I have read that I would like to supplement with.

I am going to stop here because I could go on and on, but that's why I am seriously considering homeschooling. However, I always like to research both sides of the argument so that I can make a well-informed decision. All and I do mean all of the views I have read about people opposing homeschooling are from kids that come from White, conservative, religious parents, but I have yet to find a Black ex-homeschooler that hated it.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Dec 18 '23

Homeschooling because public schools failed your kids?

17 Upvotes

I chose to homeschool my son when the public schools failed him time and time again. He is on the higher end of the autism spectrum. He had difficulty reading, and the school refused to honor the 504 plan. It got to where he was having meltdowns and panic attacks about attending school. The teachers were bullying him, and the admin refused to do anything. He was not learning. We had to deschool for a couple of weeks but gradually got him into a routine. I worked with him using phonics cards, and he was reading above grade level within three months. I kept him drilled in language arts and math but did allow him a great deal of autonomy in other subjects. He was more of a hands-on learner than a book learner. A great deal of his schooling included building and creating things. He thrived and eventually learned to think, problem-solve, and reason for himself. I have taught in public schools and will complete my master's in education in the spring. Sadly, many still operate on the obsolete learning model of preparing workers for the factory line. It is a one-size-fits-all approach unless you qualify for special education. Homeschooling worked very well for us.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Nov 29 '23

To ex-homeschoolers: Besides "unschooling" and socialization, what other factors made your experience negative?

17 Upvotes

I have browsed through the HomeschoolRecovery reddit long before I had or was pregnant with my 15 month old daughter. I was in public school my whole life, but I was severely socially isolated so I can relate to a lot of the feelings and resentment towards my parents over the way I was raised. Most of the posts I see there resemble the "unschooling" method I've seen, but taken to lengths of, in my opinion, neglect.

I am working on an AA degree as I plan to open a family-home learning center (play-based), we also really want to homeschool our children. I am very passionate about education and learning, and also about my children's future social lives.My goal in homeschooling would be for my children to either do Running Start or get their GED depending on what paths they may choose. If they came to me asking to go to public school, I'd allow it. I don't want to deny them experiences.

I feel that I could provide a better education than what my kids might receive in public school, it's not about politics or religion for me (I'm not involved in either), there's so much else wrong with our school systems - our national reading and math competencies have been dropping over the last 10 years. Less people are attending college, imo, partly because of how soul draining the US public school experience can be.

I'm just interested in finding out how I can give them an experience they will grow up appreciating. I just want the best for them, TIA for any responses.

  • A worried mom


r/homeschooldiscussion • • May 02 '22

Warning: Abeka Homeschool Curriculum

17 Upvotes

And this is why I will be avoiding religion-based curriculum...

https://twitter.com/BMenHomeschool/status/1514829118034087942


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jul 10 '22

Covid homeschooler mom sending kids back to school in August - need a reminder that I'm doing the right thing?

15 Upvotes

Hello! I wanted some thoughts, especially from those who were homeschooled and wished they hadn't been. I am a mom of 3 kids, ages 7, 9, and 11. Until March of 2020, my girls were in public school and my youngest was attending private kindergarten at the time. They all loved school! When schools closed, we finished out the school year of 2020 with e-learning, then decided to just pull them and homeschool that fall when the instability of pandemic schooling seemed like too much for them. We were also very Covid cautious, and it felt like the right thing for us.

We intended to send them back for 2021/2022 school year, but then Delta was circulating when my state decided that it was illegal for schools to require masks. We felt it was unsafe and decided to homeschool again at least until the kids could be vaccinated (I know, that's another controversial topic).

Long story short, here we are and we are sending the kids back to school in August after 2 years of homeschooling. I have honestly LOVED homeschooling them, but I never planned on doing it long term. Homeschooling can be a wonderful thing for some families, and we bad a great 2 years, but I think it will be good for them mentally, socially, and just make our home life be HOME LIFE again...maybe they'll even fight a bit less if they're not constantly with each other.

The cons? The kids aren't excited about it. They say would stay homeschooled if they could. It's little things they mention like not wanting to get up early, public school is too long, etc. I think going back gives them a little anxiety? Especially for my oldest, since she'll be starting middle school. I will also miss them terribly, of course. And I do struggle with anxiety and I worry about school shootings, etc, but have told myself that can happen literally anywhere, sadly.

Basically, I'd love to be reminded of why this is the right decision. Does that make any sense? I am a mom who LOVES my kids. I want them to be healthy - physically, emotionally, and mentally, and of course I want them to have a good education. But when the kids aren't really excited to go back, and there's craziness everywhere I turn in this world, it's easy to second guess myself.

Thanks to anyone who read this whole novel.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • May 27 '26

Question for those who were homeschooled

14 Upvotes

I saw a group for homeschool recovery while looking for homeschooling advice groups - I would love to hear the perspective specifically of those who were homeschooled themselves, especially if you had a negative experience.

My kids have always been in public school, and keep asking me to let them be homeschooled. We are a blended family and the other set of parents is also on board. I’m willing to give it a try if it is what’s best for them, but all I see is posts from homeschooling parents and not from the kids who actually experienced it. I want to make sure we are making a well-rounded and informed decision either way.

My son is neurodivergent and daughter is highly anxious. They are not thriving in traditional school despite the myriad of supports in place. There is a level of depth to their academic, emotional, and developmental growth that I feel is not being met there.

I have a background in education and am being very thorough on curriculum research so I’m not overly worried about that aspect. We would ensure social opportunities as much as possible (and as much as the kids would tolerate) through friends, co-op, sports, activities, and mental health social/emotional skills group. There would be no religious aspect.

What is it specifically about homeschooling that you are recovering from? Was it a situational issue that can be avoided, or something foundational? What advice do you have for me - things we can do to make it a positive experience for our kids, or just don’t touch it with a ten foot pole?

Thank you for your input!


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Feb 09 '26

Question from a Concerned Father

13 Upvotes

Hi there! I just found out about this sub as I've been doing a bit of research on homeschooling. I have a 5 year old daughter who I adore and want the absolute best for her.

I personally really lean toward public School However, my wife is pretty "set" on homeschooling. I have a full time job and my wife is a stay at home mother - she is an amazing mother and genuinely goes the extra mile in everything for our kids. This past year she homeschooled our 5 year old for Kindergarten. We both agreed that we'd "try it out" for this first year.

Now its getting close to 1st grade and I'm really wanting to enroll my daughter into public school. Although my wife does great efforts - I am worried that as our daughter gets older the toll of homeschooling will begin to be felt and it could hinder my daughters education.

However, wife still feels pretty strongly on homeschooling. We have aligned on a potential "Hybrid" program with a public school. It seems like a charter school program that does Independent Study/Homeschool/Parent Led Learning.

For those that have been homeschooled or know more about this. What are your thoughts on a hybrid style program like this? Please feel free to be blunt and honest.

Thank you all truly.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jan 25 '25

What your homeschooled kids are actually doing on Chess.com...

13 Upvotes

r/homeschooldiscussion • • May 04 '23

Homeschool regulation (question for current/ex homeschooled people)

12 Upvotes

I have been wondering if you all are familiar with the Coalition for Responsible Home Education and what you think of their proposals.

If you're not familiar, this is an organization formed by people like those of you who were homeschooled and had some very bad experiences. They advocate for the rights of the child in homeschooling situations, unlike HSLDA, which is all about the rights of the parent. They have a set of proposals on their website for a set of regulations to replace the current ones, especially in states where there is little or no oversight of homeschooling.

A lot of parents would consider me a traitor for this, but I believe that the child's rights to safety, security, and an education outweigh the parents' right to avoid government interference. It seems like no contest to me, because the potential harm done to the child if those fundamental rights aren't honored is so much worse than any harm that can come to the parent by having some government oversight.

I've browsed their site many times over the years. It feels to me like their approach is very rational, and despite the fact that they have lots of personal reasons to be furious with homeschooling, they seem quite approachable to me as a parent.

The specific policy proposals are here. There is one proposal that I'd like to see removed or addressed in a different area of law, making it not specific to homeschoolers. And there are a couple of things that I'd like to ask them to expand upon because I don't know exactly what they mean. Otherwise, it sounds fair. It wouldn't address everything that some of you have experienced, but it feels like a decent start. (Of course, I'm already in a highly regulated state and have nothing to lose. lol)

Any thoughts?


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Mar 23 '23

Question for homeschooled students from a prospective homeschool parent

12 Upvotes

Hello,

I apologize in advanced if this question is inappropriate for this sub, I think this is where I should ask it though.

I have one child, still preschool age.

The school district around me is pretty awful, covered up sexual assault and abuse by both students and teachers along with guns, bullying, etc. The other school district child to go to is just as bad. One of the teachers actually arrested for sexually abusing students has been found on school grounds twice.

The option for private school uses Abel’s curriculum and costs an exorbitant amount of money.

All of that to explain why I am considering homeschooling.

Now onto the questions.

If I used a completely secular, science based curriculum, had free play with friends her own age several times a week (2-3 days for several hours), went on field trips, and put her in extracurriculars such as dance, martial arts, etc. would that be a better option in your opinions? Is there anything else you would want as well? Any issues I’m not considering?

Thank you in advance.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Apr 12 '22

Transition to the Real World

12 Upvotes

This is my first post on Reddit. I forget how I found the homeschool recovery forum, but I have been lurking there for a while, searching for insight. We know a lot of homeschool graduates who have done well, and I had not heard many negative perspectives before.

I am a Christian mom of 8, ages toddler to 21, and I’ve homeschooled since our oldest was in K.

Academically, my kids have done well. I’m in a no regulation state, but we do testing to make sure we’re on track. In high school, the kids have taken a mix of community college and co-op classes. The older ones scored in the top 5-10% on the SAT, and my current 9th grader tested into college level courses (including math) on the CC entrance exam. My current senior is headed to a big state school on a full scholarship with plans to eventually become a doctor.

Socially, my older kids have kept busy with sports and activities. They have friends to hang out with in their free time. The older they get, the less they help around the house. We encourage them to get their driver’s license, jobs, etc., and basically develop their own lives. Our kids are vocal about their likes and dislikes, and seem happy. We live in an area with an active homeschool community where there are football games, prom, etc. Our current high schoolers weren’t interested in public school.

Nothing is ever perfect, but from my perspective, homeschooling seemed to go well, so it caught me off guard when our oldest came home after an unsuccessful first year in college to work thru some issues. Since then, I’ve spent a lot of time looking back at our experiences, wondering what could have been done differently or better. I have even pondered whether or not homeschooling was a mistake.

I’ve asked our oldest about it. He said that while there are things he would change, overall homeschooling was a good experience and he is thankful. He said maybe he should have seriously considered going to high school. He said socially and academically homeschooling was fine, but going to high school would have helped him learn how life worked and how people really are.

Just wondering if any homeschool graduates can relate to that sentiment (not knowing how life works and how people really are) and have thoughts on what that is like and what could make that transition easier.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Dec 27 '23

Just asking for some advice, I guess

11 Upvotes

First, I'm sorry if this is not an appropriate topic, but I'm not quite sure where to post this on reddit.

Kinda, sorta long time reader, first time poster. I (32M going on 33) was homeschooled through high school. Went to college and got a master's degree. Though I can't help but wonder if I "missed out" on life in some ways. For instance:

1.) I feel like maybe I should have had certain milestones accomplished by now. This might be silly, but I've never been in a fist fight. I guess I bring this up because--again, maybe a silly thought--it makes me feel less like a man. Plus, due to my social awkwardness in freshman year, I was picked on regularly by a few people in the dorm. One guy was a total jerk: regularly called me [insert slur for gay people here] and seemed convinced I was autistic. Admittedly, I was afraid of the guy.

2.) My dating life is practically nonexistent lol. I had one girlfriend in college, who I'm pretty sure I drove away because I wasn't that affectionate toward her. Reason being, I was afraid it would lead to other things and I'd get her pregnant. Actually, I'm still kinda afraid of approaching women. I'm not sure, but would have going to a public high school have stopped this?

That's it for now. Thanks for reading. Again, if this topic breaks the rules, sorry.


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Jun 08 '23

Received push back for my intention of homeschooling and I just want to do right by my kids. Input needed.

11 Upvotes

I recently commented on a thread in another sub where someone was asking about homeschooling. Immediately this person was flooded with naysayers so I chimed in and said I plan to, some reasons why, some tips for when the time comes and a suggestion for now. I was immediately met with downvotes and someone just kinda being rude about my stance. Please feel free to go to my comment history and look at what I had to say.

The jist of it though is that with rising secular/non-religious homeschooling rates and curriculum, access to activities and groups outside the home, and most importantly in our eyes, the lack of safety within school systems due to the absence of certain types of laws, homeschooling is a good option for my family. I didn’t clarify this there, but if my kids ever wanted traditional schooling, they’d have that choice once being informed of the pros and cons.

I don’t want to cause my children trauma if I can be educated about it. I went to public schools and hated my time there (my home life definitely wouldn’t have led to a good homeschool experience admittedly). If you had the homeschool experience I’m describing or even if your parents thought that’s what they were giving you and your perception was different… Is this a lost cause? Or is there hope of a positive homeschool experience for my kids?


r/homeschooldiscussion • • Oct 23 '22

Looking for experiences from very specific ex-homeschooled people

11 Upvotes

Hello,

I am a mom to a young toddler who is considering homeschooling for various reasons and I’m doing my research now specifically on the experience of formerly homeschooled students to look at how to avoid the negative outcomes typically associated with homeschooling.

I’ve noticed a trend in the negative stories who all have very similar backgrounds and family dynamics and I rarely see feedback, good or bad, from students who were homeschooled how my husband and I plan to do it. I’m seeking any stories at all and input from those who went through homeschooling with all or most of the following conditions:

  • secular home and curriculum

  • focus on outdoors (forest school/1000 hours outside)

  • parents who are leftist/socialist but not militant about it

  • parents with post secondary education

  • non-rural/suburban location

  • lots of extracurriculars/sports/swim lessons/community library events etc

  • friendships allowed and encouraged

  • believe in vaccination/modern medicine while also focusing on preventative health and nutrition

Basically want to hear from anyone who had somewhat crunchy but sane leftist parents who let them have social lives just thought the local school and curriculum was shitty/inadequate? Im in Alberta and it’s an absolute mess here, kids getting stabbed on school grounds is becoming a semi regular occurrence and the shit I hear from my teen/tween nieces in public school horrifies me.