r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Mar 22 '20
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/EmotionalDog1945 • Dec 21 '22
Season 3 This season is giving low budget
No offense but the sets, make up and costumes are giving Dr Who or that crappy Dune adaptation that also starred James McAvoy. Cheap cheap cheap. Lord Asriel's fortress was supposed to be spectacular and massive, it looks like a refugee camp. All the budget clearly went to the CGI daemons.
I will forever be mad that New Line re-edited The Golden Compass causing it to be a bad film and flop, killing the chance for a mega budget film franchise the way it deserved to be.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Polstead • Feb 22 '20
Do you think there could be a connection between Dust and the Force?
I’m watching again the Star Wars episodes and I’m just starting to think about this.
George Lucas says he “wanted to ‘awaken a certain kind of spirituality’ in young audiences, suggesting a belief in God without endorsing any specific religion.”
And the cinematographer Roman Kroitor says "Many people feel that in the contemplation of nature and in communication with other living things, they become aware of some kind of force, or something, behind this apparent mask which we see in front of us, and they call it God".
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Keystone_Devil • Feb 08 '23
Season 3 Underwhelming Ending
Now I haven’t read the books, but I’ve absolutely loved the show. The philosophy and the world building, the complex characters, and the visuals are all breath taking. But the ending was just pretty cliche and tacked on it felt.
Will and Lyra are good friends through out the show, and in the last episode they suddenly have this extreme Romeo and Juliet love. Which didn’t feel deserved, and certainly didn’t give me time to feel attached to their romance, before the last minute explanation that all portals need to be closed so they can’t be together.
Not to mention the promise that they have to wait for each other and, and can’t love anyone else. Which granted, is the type of thing a teenager would say. But for them to stick to that over the rest of their lives is a bit crazy and almost toxic. And with a story otherwise written so well it feels jarring.
The whole love story felt like a tacked on YA ending. HDM didn’t need a love plot. The weird love of Lyra and her parents. And the love between Lyra and Pan was enough. And the overall the message and ideas of free will, theism, and power all made for a good story. But the last 20 minutes really undercut what was otherwise a good finale.
I’m not knocking Pullman or HBO or anyone. Like I said, His Dark Materials is still one of my favorite shows, and I’ve loved it since it first aired. But still, the ending needed some work.
Edit: We’ll you guys have certainly proved me wrong. Which I can say happily. I wasn’t trying to have a “gotcha”. I’m glad to be proven wrong in this case. You’ve made me see the ending differently, so thank you. Even if some of you were less thank kind about it lol. I know how I must seem to other people about comics now.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Interesting-Cancel13 • Nov 16 '24
All Lyra and her period
We know that daemons settling is the marker of puberty in the HDM world, but does that normally happen before or after a girl gets her first period? In TAS, Lyra's period was never mentioned so we can assume that she didn't get it. It is not like periods do not exist in her world either - Lyra does get one in TSC although I don't remember very well, so please refresh my memory.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Oct 18 '23
TAS I gave an AI the description of a Mulefa and these are the results that looked somewhat interesting
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Mundane-Relative-267 • Nov 26 '24
All Starting to wonder about Philip Pullman *Trigger Warning*
Before I start, let me emphasize that the HDM series has been my favorite for over 15 years. I felt like the first book broke me - I’d never experienced such a rush before, and I remember struggling against tears and a wave of goosebumps as I read the last sentence. I will forever cherish that book in particular, and it will remain a defining piece in my early life.
I consider Pullman a brilliant, masterful storyteller and world builder.
However, certain details revolving around a certain theme have cropped up too many times in relation to Pullman and his works. It’s made me start wondering about him.
TRIGGER WARNING and SPOILERS
Suggestions of pedophilia or perversion towards children were present in HDM.
the scene with Lord Boreal in the car, where he notices Lyra’s bare legs and forces her to crawl over his lap
the priest in the Amber Spyglass who clearly wanted to get Will drunk and molest or rape him
Okay. I get it. It’s part of his world-building. Pullman rightfully wanted to include sexual abuse committed by the Catholic Church against children. Boreal was a multi-dimensional icky character, and the uneasy feeling he gave Lyra added to that.
If this troublesome pattern I’ve noticed in Pullman had ended there, I would have believed that’s all there is to it.
But it didn’t.
In La Belle Sauvage, we have the rape scene of Alice, a fifteen year old girl with a yet unsettled daemon. Many, including myself, have denounced this scene as unnecessary to the story, demeaning and casual.
We also have some weird insinuation that Malcom will be used as “bait” for an older priest, although this is never followed up on.
The latter could still be argued as a consistent detail in Pullman’s world-building: the Church is teeming with pedophiles and perverted older men.
I have a lot less leniency towards the former, though. It’s where I started to question Pullman.
Moving on to The Secret Commonwealth:
I REALLY started to question Pullman in this book.
Malcom comes off as a stand-in for Pullman himself. It’s just a suspicion. He thoughts feel, as they did in LBS, like those of a much older, worn-down man. The fact that he is so mild-mannered and unassuming and yet infinitely capable strikes one rather as a Mary Sue, which authors typically use as a means of writing out their personal fantasies.
Malcom is in love with Lyra. He’s obviously known her since she was an infant. He is 31 and she is 20, and he’s in love with her.
The age gap is questionable but not necessarily…perverted. BUT. Pullman writes in length about how Malcom’s feelings for Lyra began when she was fifteen or sixteen. Pullman describes Malcom noticing the scent of her hair. When she was sixteen. He specifies that is wasn’t shampoo Malcom smelled, but specifically “young girl”. Starting to feel really weird now.
These feelings from Malcom are quite clearly acceptable in the story world. Seen in a positive light. Other characters (like Alice) even encourage them.
Then, there’s the constant mentions of Lyra’s appearance and the effect she has on older men. For example talking to the older Gyptian man on the boat, he tells her if it comes down to her looks, she could easily pull off being a witch (who are unearthly beautiful). Okay…
You know what I’m going to say here. The rape scene of Lyra. Many have said it was necessary, to show she finally “found out” for “fucking around”.
I guess? Why didn’t she have to “find out” by literally getting VIOLENTLY GANG-RAPED in the original series? Why wasn’t that necessary to illustrate the dangers she was much more cavalierly putting herself in in that series? Or like…in most series ever written?
The detail of the scene was again gratuitous. If Pullman had to include this scene, I don’t think he had to describe her panties getting pulled to the side and fingers getting shoved inside her. I really don’t.
At this point I had rather lost my patience and trust of Pullman. I know others saw this subtle description in a positive light, like “yay, finally someone mentions menstruation in a non-dramatic way in a book”. But for me, when I got to the part about Pullman describing Lyra sensing her period was coming, I felt icky. Like he decided he had the right to go there and talk about this intrinsically feminine phenomenon, just like he had the right to have his young female protagonist violently assaulted.
This isn’t all. A memory came back, from when I was obsessed with these books and Pullman and in my internet digging I came across his favorite short story: “The Beauties” by Anton Chekhov.
https://amp.theguardian.com/books/2011/dec/11/writers-pick-favourite-short-stories
http://www.online-literature.com/anton_chekhov/1251/#google_vignette
I encourage you to read it yourself. Beautiful writing, and on its own I wouldn’t necessarily question it, but with everything else from Pullman, I now view it in a different light. It describes (sometimes much older) men being taken by the beauty of sixteen and seventeen year-old girls, and staring at them and feeling they’re in love with them. Interesting.
Recently I saw that Pullman once refused to visit schools in the UK because he’d be required to register to a non-pedophile list. He was outraged by this. I don’t understand what’s to be outraged about wanting to protect children from predators.
Interesting.
Finally, I haven’t read them, but others have said the Sally Lockhart series, meant for children/young adults, also contains themes of sexual abuse. Not sure about that but would be interested in others’ perspective on that series.
All in all, sad to say, but I’ve begun to view Pullman in a scrutinizing light. It’s even made me question his descriptions of Lyra experiencing her sexual awakening in TAS.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Anxious-Actuator3713 • Feb 09 '24
2007 Film I’ve dressed movie Pantalaimon (Pan) in costumes! I’ll do more or maybe HBO TV Series Pantalaimon in the future, but what do you think so far? Spoiler
Yeah, that includes the dinosaur costume too, which I sent earlier last year.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Dec 16 '19
Season 1 How overwhelmingly disappointing …
I don't think I have a lot to say. But I don't know anyone around me who watches HDM so I have to vent here instead. 😁
I'm so disappointed in the wasted potential in the TV show. It's not even bad per se. The CGI is good (though embarrassingly often avoided), the actors are good, the music is awesome! But the storylines and the dialogues are so packed with clichés and stereotypes! Also, I don't think Dafne Keen is well-chosen for playing Lyra, which is not the actress's fault though. Mrs Coulter is as mad as I imagined her – but they don't really manage to make her believable. It seems so forced! The same with Lee btw. He's just cringy. And Will's storyline is unnecessary imo. It's just a dragged-out version of what happens in one chapter of the book. I don't really see any character development for Will or his mother. Not even a proper introduction. We don't really know anything about them besides that they care a lot for each other. But for a whole season, that's pretty little …
Anyway, this is of course just my personal opinion. I can understand how people love the show, because I do enjoy it myself. But I really have to force myself to not compare it to the books and to see it as a stand-alone basic fantasy TV show. 🤷🏼♂️
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/ItsEternity01 • Dec 13 '24
Meta Tell me your daemon and I will say what it means
For example, mine is a red squirrel named Rinouka (normally, the daemon is the opposite sex to the owner, but same-sex daemons do exist). My daemon is female, and I am a male.
Having a red squirrel as my daemon indicates a blend of energy and playfulness, adaptability and resourcefulness. It signifies a curious, resilient, and adventurous person who can face challenges confidently and positively while maintaining a strategic approach to life.
So let me know your daemon's gender and name.
I will reply to your comments in a few days.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/11114444Elmo • Jan 30 '23
Season 3 Asriel/James McEvoy are exhausting
His whole schtick is just...yelling. Hello, I'm Asriel, and I will proceed to spend every scene raging against everyone and everything, or else smirking and cackling. I don't know is it because Mrs Coulter was so nuanced and interesting, next to his Freedom Fighter tantrum-throwing. The fight against The Authority was never that big a thing in the book - I think it was a literal deus-ex-machina, that in the show they really tried to make A Thing of, and it was just daft? I started just swearing at the TV with his final fight with the Regeant. He's going to punch an angel and win...right.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • May 15 '25
TSC people freaking out about the age gap thing have internet brain rot and are afraid of real life
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/dilroopgill • Dec 27 '22
Season 3 Everyone seems worse off at the end Spoiler
I don't get where they suceeded in the end. So now people turn to dust when they die and they no longer have eternal souls and conciousness? Anfels still exist and control and manipulate dust (literally the world's magic) and now humans can't at all? It feels like everyone was better off with metatron, lyras mom could've became an angel and not died.
The only downside was lyra dying but now she turns to dust in a 100 years which is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Is the afterlife still eternal so it is a choice to erase yourself like the good place? Never was a fan of erasing your own existence being the whole goal of life. I thought azriels goal was to get rid of metatrons control not get rid of an afterlife, didn't he want heaven to exist and for people to be able to go there.
Everyone seems worse off, lyra and will can't be together, they are now stuck to their worlds, wills stuck in our boring earth after experiencing other realities. That one lady communicated with another sentient species to never interact with them or dust again, all of her research may as well have been fictional.
Overall I just can't see not existing as a good end goal.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Sep 04 '23
TSK Mistake in the subtle knife?
In the beginning of the book Lyra discovers an old skull in a museum:
These skulls were unimaginably old; the cards in the case said simply BRONZE AGE, but the alethiometer, which never lied, said that the man whose skull it was had lived 33,254 years before the present day, and that he had been a sorcerer, and that the hole had been made to let the gods into his head.
This skull would be from the Paleolithic era if it really was that old, did Pullmann want to reference a mistake the scientists made, or did he just not bother to check, when the bronze age was?
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/antibendystraw • Oct 29 '22
Season 2 Am I the only one that doesn’t like the casting for Will?
On my first read through of the series (no amber spyglass spoilers please). Absolutely love the novels!
Watching the TV show now before reading the third and waiting for the third season.
We saw some Will in season 1, but after watching s2e01, I’m really confused on the direction they went for Will in the show. Not sure if it’s the actor or just the direction. He just seems so limp and weak to me in the series. Will in the novel is a fighter.
Example: in the novel, upon meeting Lyra they get into a physical fight. (Doesn’t he even punch her in the face?) vs In the show, Lyra catches him by surprise and pins him down? What a horrible direction they went with. Novel Will would never. He just seems whiney and weak. And Lyra is fawning over him but he hasn’t commanded any respect.
In the novel, he takes charge, he directs Lyra, and she is a little bit of a brat but he doesn’t just take her shit. He puts her in her place because he has a lot on his plate, and the safety of his mother and himself and finding his dad are of the utmost importance. In the series Lyra takes his bed and he just bitches under his breath but doesn’t do anything about it.
Anyways, I’ll finish watching of course, maybe he wins me over but just curious on how others received the changes made in the show around this character..
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/MachineLoud9484 • Jun 07 '26
All Chapter 6 of the fanfic novel is now posted
archiveofourown.orgWell it's another Sunday, and another day for me to post the next chapter of my trilogy. Enjoy the read :)
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/dootmouse • Jan 31 '20
All I am so completely disappointed, I cannot even watch.
I have to start by saying the books are my absolute favorite series of all time, so my expectations were very high. I also have a pretty soft spot in my heart for The Golden Compass movie, if it were only longer and told the whole story I think it could have been incredible. I just finally got HBO Now just to watch His Dark Materials and I am borderline disgusted. The casting is so wrong I am just utterly confused, Lyra’s acting is awful and her character isn’t likeable. At all. She has no charm and no spirit. Iorek’s voice is so ridiculous I seriously started laughing when I heard it. He sounds like Winnie the Poo doing a Bane impression. It is absolutely insane. And WHAT THE FUCK did they do to Lee Scoresby? He’s like a completely different person? Even if he wasn’t supposed to be Lee Scoresby, I just don’t like him as a character. I am appalled. I feel like they completely destroyed the essence of the series. Am I alone in this?
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Dec 13 '20
Not a good episode Spoiler
In terms of structure I'm not sure why they went for this.
The murderous kids chasing Lyra and Will through the city and onto the roof is suspenseful in the books, and a great way to end an episode. Here it was a quick opening scene at the beginning, with a cringe witch appearance to tell us not to take it seriously.
I would understand it if they had other ideas, but instead they spent 45 minutes doing nothing (in the penultimate episode...). Even Mrs Coulter had to sit down for a few wines as there wasn't a whole lot happening.
To top it off they then made the kids nice and innocent. Sure it was a decent scene, but you're supposed to build tension not tell us how un-threatening everything is.
How do the Spectres build any tension when they're now controllable and couldn't even finish off a witch they'd swamped?
Greatly enjoyed the series as a whole, but this one was weak.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Cyclonedx • Dec 21 '20
Season 2 Are the books as bad as the show? [S2 Spoilers] Spoiler
Just finished Season 2 and I'm so disappointed. What started off as a mysterious and enthralling story turned into a boring, cliched ending. Here are some of my gripes:
The last few episodes have been literally every character just traveling, with some ominous/cryptic prophecy lines thrown around here and there. It was frustrating to hear the same bits of the prophecy being mentioned all the time. It felt like the Lyra is Eve line was supposed to mean something but came off pretty nonchalant.
The show conveniently uses the witches' power whenever it's needed. Somehow, they are capable of defeating multiple armed people and airships, but then lose 1v1 to Mrs. Coulter. They also seem to have enhanced senses in some scenes, but can't hear Mrs. Coulter/Spectors approaching them in their sleep.
Lee's death was really sad but felt like very lazy writing. If he and Grumman destroyed the airships last episode, where did the army of soldiers come from? Why did he wait till he was about to die to summon Serafina?
How does Mrs. Coulter catch up to the gang in just one scene when she was all the way back in the city? The past few episodes have been dedicated to all the characters' travels but she conveniently reaches them so quickly.
Grumman's death was probably the worst of them all. Love how just one random soldier appears to take him out, but not before he's conveniently killed before Grumman dies in Will's arms and is safe once again.
I'm pretty sure the books are written much better than the show, but just want to hear from you guys. Was planning on watching S3 before reading the books but now I'm reconsidering. Probably going to get a lot of hate for this but I sincerely hope this show is not renewed for a third season with how poorly the second season turned out to be.
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Moist_Purple_1646 • Feb 25 '25
All The Ending Spoiler
Why the fuck cant it have a happy end they got ripped apart so all they did to come closer and safed the multiverse was for nothing?!?! This autor and I got a big peoblem
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/Daregmaze • Jul 22 '26
NL/TGC Iofur Raknison and Species Dysphoria
When I first read the books not only did I think that being otherkin, therian, etc. isn't valid, but I also knew very little about alterhumanity and non-humanity. Now that I know theses identities are valid AND know more about them, I can see that Iofur Raknison is alterhuman-coded
Its totally obvious that he had severe species dysphoria. His experience is similar to that of therians, but instead of being a human who is a bear therian, he is a bear who is a human therian (I know most therians arent human at all, I just don't have a better way to explain what Im trying to say). Its not clear if he identifies as a human or as a bear, the fact that he was pretending to have a human daemon implies he still consider himself to be a bear, but it could also not being the case
The one thing I dislike is how his species dysphoria and species envy is depicted as a bad thing. Don't get me wrong, I am not trying to excuse his actions, no matter how dysphoric he was it wasn't right of him to force the other bears to act like humans and to make them suffer and that made him a bad person, but his feelings of not being contempt with his soul and attributes were 100% valid. His desire to be a human/like humans was 100% valid
I understand that Pullman's message was that you can't choose your nature, but Iofur Raknison's nature was that of a bear with a neurodivergent brain that worked more like that of the average Homo sapiens/a human in a bear's body/something alongst thoses lines.
He was an interesting character and I do wish we had seen more of him, even thought it wouldn't make sense storyline wise
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/ellivibrutp • Jan 04 '21
HDM has Serafina Pekkala. Harry Potter has Seraphina Picquery. HDM has Ruta Skadi. Harry Potter has Rita Skeeter. All four are witches. HDM came first. Coincidence?
Sure, almost everyone in HP is a witch, but not in HDM. One close match seems unlikely. Two stinks of plagiarism (or less cynically, a tribute).
Thoughts?
r/hisdarkmaterials • u/[deleted] • Nov 18 '19
All Am I supposed to know anything about the book before I start The Golden Compass
I just started it and it acts like I'm supposed to know what's going on. It starts with" Lyra and her Daemon" like I'm supposed to know what that even means