r/heinlein • • Aug 31 '18

About halfway through The Cat Who Walks Through Walls and the uberlibertarian heroes are doing their best impersonations of idiot assholes demonstrating the ills of libertarianism.

0 Upvotes

Fun to see the uber libertarians on one page complain about, and then two pages later complain about:

Page 1Page 2
border inspections of food, plants and animalsrats in luna city
regulationsbeing ripped off by the air merchant
regulationsbeing ripped off by the hotel merchant
regulationsbeing ripped off by the hotel merchant again

I can't figure out if Heinlein is poking fun at libertarians or was growing senile.


r/heinlein • • Oct 01 '24

Question Can someone make “The Moon is Harsh Mistress” fanart?

6 Upvotes

just finished the novel for an english class, absolutely love it. Unfortunately, it’s not popular enough for there to be widely available fanart. Someone should really make some fanart, specifically homoerotic fan art between Mike and Mannie. I always felt that there was sexual tension between them, and when Mike stopped talking at the end of the book I was heartbroken.


r/heinlein • • May 01 '23

Dubois V. Declaration Of Independence

0 Upvotes

It saddens me when American fans take Col. Dubois' propaganda in Starship Troopers on face value. For example, here's a literal deconstruction of Dubois' argument against the American declaration of independence.

Unalienable

Unalienable per the dictionary, not Dubois, describes rights that cannot be given to you or taken away from you by your government, and you cannot give away either. With this understanding clarified you can easily refute Dubois's "doublethink" – the word Orwell invented to mean "the acceptance of contrary opinions or beliefs at the same time, especially as a result of political indoctrination."

Life

Life? What `right' to life has a man who is drowning in the Pacific? The ocean will not hearken to his cries.

It is not the ocean that the declaration supposes must respond to a man, but his system of government. As opposed to tyrannies that arbitrarily kill people after using propaganda and mind control to demonize them as "bugs" or "skinnies" or other forms of subhuman or non-citizen ... which is to say aliens in the sense of unalienable.

What right' to life has a man who must die if he is to save his children? If he chooses to save his own life, does he do so as a matter of right'?

The right to expect that his government doesn't get to make that life and death choice for him – which is why the American declaration represents that right as unalienable.

If two men are starving and cannibalism is the only alternative to death, which man's right is unalienable'? And is it right'?

If we treat both their rights to life as unalienable, the government doesn't get to decide who will die, eugenically speaking, for the "lebensraum" or "pro-life" of the other. In this way we see pro-choice baked right into the declaration of independence – as unalienable.

Liberty

As to liberty, the heroes who signed that great document pledged themselves to buy liberty with their lives.

Just so, Col. Dubois, gold star for you.

Liberty is never unalienable; it must be redeemed regularly with the blood of patriots or it always vanishes.

Now go to the back of the class, Col. Dubois. Why? Because Dubois just implied that unalienable means gratis, no cost. Unalienable does not mean free. It means, as Jefferson and Heinlein were equally well aware, what the dictionary always said it means. RAH intends the reader to discover Dubois' doublethink for themself, providing this textbook example so that others cannot hoodwink us this way. When Liberty cannot be legitimately given or taken by a monarch or oligarch, it belongs to the natural sovereign - defined by Rousseau, whose Republic the founders took to heart - as the people united under a system of laws of their own choosing.

The right to liberty is unalienable in the Declaration of Independence because otherwise the state has the right to imprison people arbitrarily - for their beliefs, their race, their associations, their poverty, or any other reason.

Of all the so-called `natural human rights' that have ever been invented, liberty is least likely to be cheap and is never free of cost.

Dubois knows we agree with the latter clause but uses our agreement to propagandistically persuade us to agree with the former – that liberty is not natural, but invented. If it is not natural, we may be legitimately deprived of it by the Federation as aliens ourselves - as subhumans, non-persons, subversives, enemies of the state, etc.

Pursuit of Happiness

The third right'? -- the pursuit of happiness'? It is indeed unalienable but it is not a right; it is simply a universal condition which tyrants cannot take away nor patriots restore. Cast me into a dungeon, burn me at the stake, crown me king of kings, I can `pursue happiness' as long as my brain lives -- but neither gods nor saints, wise men nor subtle drugs, can insure that I will catch it.

Like any parlor magician, Dubois' magic relies on getting us to look away from the trick. Now he trots out the dictionary definition of an unalienable right and calls it something other than a right. While we may wrestle with that conceit, the real trick words are on his other hand.

As explained in detail at https://news.emory.edu/stories/2014/06/er_pursuit_of_happiness/campus.html , "Pursuit" in the Declaration's time did not mean attempting to catch a thing, but the actual practice of that thing. Likewise "happiness" did not refer to individual happiness - which is of course fleeting - but the mutual benefits of happy interaction in a free society.

Only you and I together may happily trade, associate, converse, marry, and so on. Those are the pursuits of happiness the declaration tells us the "older and wiser heads" of Dubois' Federation's anonymous politburo may not alienate.

Why did Heinlein write this?

Directly opposing RAH's passionate patriotism per his "Heirs of Patrick Henry", Dubois serves as the embodiment, in Heinlein's words, of "the dead certainty of communist enslavement". Unlike Harshaw and De La Paz, Dubois does not represent the author's voice, nor a crusty libertarian teacher or American compatriot. He's a propagandist and bureaucrat pouring communist doctrine into the impressionable minds of children attending a compulsory mind-control class, a trope that, these days, we call an unreliable narrator.

Because Starship Troopers is a satire. Not a Mel Brooks belly-laugh satire. Nor a Verhoeven gore-and-titties satire. But a bone-dry political satire in the mode of Swift's infamous Modest Proposal. You may be sympathetic to the book's politics, yourself, but you must understand that Heinlein wrote it as a cautionary tale, not as a statement of his beliefs. If you're looking for that statement, you should look here instead.

The political system of Troopers' Federation is neither a democracy nor a republic. It is identical with the system of the Soviet Union of Heinlein's time, a single party state in which only veterans of public service in the Komsomol gained the right to vote as members of the Communist party. The book is the story of a Komsomol recruit fighting in a war of invasion against neighboring Eastern Bloc countries - only dressed up in American rhetoric and military tropes to lead the reader into questioning those tropes when they appear in real world mind-control media.

Like those that enslave Americans today.


r/heinlein • • Nov 13 '22

What are some valid criticisms of Starship Troopers?

0 Upvotes

I am wondering whether I should buy that book, but I heard a lot of bad stuff about it. Like the backstory of his society is partially about how the old order collapsed because people stopped spanking? Yet when I criticize the book for stuff I get shouted down by fans...so whats valid Heinlein criticism then? Do you agree with this article at least - https://www.blackgate.com/2021/07/31/my-robert-a-heinlein-problem/


r/heinlein • • Jun 07 '25

Heinlein: Perv or not a perv?

9 Upvotes

I was first exposed (pun) to RAH in my early teens. A fellow student had a paperback copy of Friday. This particular paperback had the cover with Friday purportedly on some space vehicle where she was wearing her famous overalls not just showing cleavage, but practically her entire right tit exposed. Seemed like a good endorsement to me! Being a pervert myself at that age, I didn't seem to notice anything wrong with the over sexualized content of RAH novels. Strange, yes. Particularly the incest themes. But as RAH tried to rationalize these themes, I decided I could suspend disbelief to read on. I certainly did that for many forms of entertainment, so why not SF?

Over the years I made my way through his catalog not seeing much disturbing. But recently I started revisiting some of his works. In particular, The Door Into Summer. Once again, there's an incest theme. This subject, his "niece", though not by blood. However his niece turns out to be eleven years old! RAH gets around this seemingly pedo situation by having his protagonist get engaged with the eleven year old old, then using suspended animation (the cold sleep) while the eleven year old ages to 21 whereas she cold sleeps until he "uncle" wakes her up. They (and his cold sleep cat) live happily ever after. I swear to god I needed a shower after finishing this.

Thoughts?


r/heinlein • • Jul 02 '14

Review: "Starship Troopers" (Robert A. Heinlein) and "Starship Troopers" (Paul Verhoeven)

1 Upvotes

Podcast review of the book and movie


r/heinlein • • Apr 05 '25

Question Is Cast Away’s ‘character’ named Wilson a homage to The Red Planet’s Willis?

2 Upvotes

Grok says: There’s no definitive evidence that the volleyball named Wilson in the movie Cast Away (2000) is a direct homage to Willis, the Martian “bouncer” from Robert A. Heinlein’s Red Planet (1949). The two characters share some superficial similarities—both are spherical, non-human companions with a significant emotional bond to the protagonist—but the connection appears coincidental rather than intentional. In Red Planet, Willis is a sentient, volleyball-sized Martian creature with a furry exterior, capable of mimicking sounds and playing a key role in the story. In Cast Away, Wilson is an inanimate Wilson Sporting Goods volleyball that Tom Hanks’ character, Chuck Noland, anthropomorphizes by painting a face on it with his blood, turning it into a symbolic companion during his isolation. The name “Wilson” in the film comes from the brand of the volleyball, not from any narrative allusion to Heinlein’s work. The origin of Wilson in Cast Away stems from screenwriter William Broyles Jr.’s research into survival scenarios. Broyles spent time on an island to simulate Chuck’s experience and found himself talking to objects, like a volleyball that washed ashore, inspiring the character. The choice of a Wilson-brand volleyball was a practical one—Wilson Sporting Goods provided around 150 volleyballs for the production, gaining significant product placement in return. There’s no indication from Broyles, director Robert Zemeckis, or Tom Hanks that Heinlein’s Willis influenced this decision. Heinlein’s Red Planet was a notable sci-fi juvenile novel, and Willis was a memorable character, but its cultural footprint by 2000 was more niche, overshadowed by Heinlein’s later works like Stranger in a Strange Land. While it’s possible someone involved in Cast Away could have been a Heinlein fan, no behind-the-scenes commentary—such as interviews, DVD extras, or production notes—links the two. The timing and context also differ: Red Planet is a 1940s sci-fi adventure about Mars, while Cast Away is a 2000s survival drama grounded in realism. That said, the idea of a spherical companion providing emotional support is a fun parallel to ponder. Both Willis and Wilson serve as unconventional “friends” in isolating environments—Mars for Jim Marlowe, a deserted island for Chuck Noland. But without concrete evidence from the filmmakers, it’s more likely a case of convergent storytelling tropes than a deliberate homage. What do you think—do you see other similarities that might suggest a nod?


r/heinlein • • Jan 09 '23

Small Screen adaptions

2 Upvotes

Hey y'all! I can't believe it took me nearly 4 years to find this sub. There are several new media companies that are growing very fast. Any chance we could see 'The Long Watch' produced by Timcast, or The Daily Wire?


r/heinlein • • Jan 30 '25

Discussion I'm half way through The Moon is a Harsh Mistress and I think I hate it

16 Upvotes

Am I missing something? I'm fairly sure this is an unpopular opinion. Anything that might change my opinion on it? People who like it, what do you like about it?

I've read Stranger in a Strange Land, Time Enough for Love, Methuselah's Children, Space Cadets, Between Planets, and several short stories and really enjoyed them all.

edit to add: I've also read Starship Troopers

I want to like it and I'm very disappointed that I don't.


r/heinlein • • Aug 27 '23

Discussion Anyone feel that massive quake?

0 Upvotes

I just watched Starship Troopers III. OMFG. At least they finally have mecha


r/heinlein • • Nov 15 '23

Words of Wisdom Mice vote to bell the cat...

1 Upvotes

Does history record any case in which the majority was right?

~Robert A. Heinlein


r/heinlein • • Mar 11 '23

Was he or not?

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen some stuff around the internet that Heinlein may or may or my not have been a fascist. Especially with his work Starship Troopers. I love the movie as a kid but as an adult I have heard some Mixed opinions. And other fasciy people read and loved him. (Not that reading the other side has stopped me before. I just want to know.) so if anyone could please explain I’d appreciate it.


r/heinlein • • Jul 24 '16

A little off topic, but who are we Heinleinites voting for?

3 Upvotes

r/heinlein • • Nov 24 '23

New rule: no politics

33 Upvotes

This is not the place for discussion of current political topics. Nobody ever changes anyone's mind online and arguments get ratcheted up to incredible levels of emotion. Please keep this in mind when posting: we're not here for provocative gotcha posts. This kind of post/comment will be removed.

Politics can be discussed in so many other places. Please leave it there.


r/heinlein • • Jan 30 '22

Video on Starship Troopers

2 Upvotes

Let me know what you think about my video on how Paul Verhoeven adapted Starship Troopers without reading it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpAt7yaCnqM&t=261s&ab_channel=FellPurpose


r/heinlein • • Jan 17 '22

TCWWTW -- geeze

0 Upvotes

So, I decided to give TCWWTW a reread after 30 years.....

It's almost physically painful. The virtual absence of any descriptive text is maddening, and confusing. Also, I just want to smack both the main characters.

I think authors are just better now.


r/heinlein • • Nov 06 '24

Heinlein Prophecy Are we in the Nehemiah Scudder administration?

48 Upvotes

From the Wikipedia entry for "If This Goes On--"

"The story is set in a future theocratic American society, ruled by the latest in a series of fundamentalist Christian "Prophets." The First Prophet was Nehemiah Scudder, a backwoods preacher turned President (elected in 2012), then dictator (no elections were held in 2016 or later)."


r/heinlein • • Jan 19 '25

Question Can We Help /r/AskReddit ...

1 Upvotes

with this? Was it Heinlein?


r/heinlein • • 2d ago

Discussion Star Ship Troopers Criticism

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Your probably tired of this line of reasoning, but how would you respond to this criticism of Starship Troopers?

Please already read this: https://substack.com/home/post/p-169497684


r/heinlein • • Feb 24 '14

First 224 issues of Starlog - free download!

Thumbnail
cinearchive.org
0 Upvotes

r/heinlein • • Nov 06 '24

Heinlein Prophecy Re: The 'are we in the nehemiah scudder administration' post being locked for the 'current politics' rule.

50 Upvotes

Respectfully, I think the decision to lock the post was misguided as Heinlein was very articulate regarding Scudder's leadership and misdeeds. To draw parallels between the incoming president and Scudder is fundamentally pertinent and not inherently divisive.

Will people get their feelings hurt? Probably, but only if their emotional ties to their political ideologies are based in ignoring what Heinlein wrote/predicted ~80 years ago. A fan of Heinlein should have the mental fortitude to prioritize the exceptional ideas and text brought to the political consciousness of his fans over a need to ignore self-reflection.

This appeal has nothing to do with claiming a political ideology and is in no way a criticism of the mods doing what they felt is best, though I disagree for the reasons above. In sum, please re-open the conversation.


r/heinlein • • Nov 14 '22

Discussion Please comment on this Heinlein excerpt

0 Upvotes

Can anyone explain to me the appeal of this passage?? Because as much as I try to appreciate Heinlein this just sounds absolut bonkers to me. No offense.

"Law-abiding people," Dubois had told us, "hardly dared go into a public park at night. To do so was to risk attack by wolf packs of children, armed with chains, knives, homemade guns, bludgeons... to be hurt at least, robbed most certainly, injured for life probably — or even killed.

Murder, drug addiction, larceny, assault, and vandalism were commonplace. Nor were parks the only places — these things happened also on the streets in daylight, on school grounds, even inside school buildings. But parks were so notoriously unsafe that honest people stayed clear of them after dark."

I had tried to imagine such things happening in our schools. I simply couldn’t. Nor in our parks. A park was a place for fun, not for getting hurt. As for getting killed in one — "Mr. Dubois, didn’t they have police? Or courts?"

"They had many more police than we have. And more courts. All overworked."

"I guess I don’t get it." If a boy in our city had done anything half that bad... well, he and his father would have been flogged side by side. But such things just didn’t happen.

‘Juvenile delinquent’ is a contradiction in terms, one which gives a clue to their problem and their failure to solve it.

Have you ever raised a puppy?"

"Yes, sir."

"Did you housebreak him?"

"Err... yes, sir. Eventually."

You scold him so that he knows he’s in trouble, you rub his nose in it so that he will know what trouble you mean, you paddle him so that he darn well won’t do it again — and you have to do it right away! It doesn’t do a bit of good to punish him later; you’ll just confuse him. Even so, he won’t learn from one lesson, so you watch and catch him again and paddle him still harder. Pretty soon he learns. But it’s a waste of breath just to scold him."

Let us never forget that puppy. These children were often caught; police arrested batches each day. Were they scolded? Yes, often scathingly. Were their noses rubbed in it?

Rarely. News organs and officials usually kept their names secret — in many places the law so required for criminals under eighteen. Were they spanked? Indeed not! Many had never been spanked even as small children; there was a widespread belief that spanking, or any punishment involving pain, did a child permanent psychic damage."

"Corporal punishment in schools was forbidden by law," he had gone on. "Flogging was lawful as a sentence of court only in one small province, Delaware, and there only for a few crimes and was rarely invoked; it was regarded as ‘cruel and unusual punishment.’ " Dubois had mused aloud, "I do not understand objections to ‘cruel and unusual’ punishment. While a judge should be benevolent in purpose, his awards should cause the criminal to suffer, else there is no punishment — and pain is the basic mechanism built into us by millions of years of evolution which safeguards us by warning when something threatens our survival. Why should society refuse to use such a highly perfected survival mechanism?

However, that period was loaded with pre-scientific pseudo-psychological nonsense.

Back to these young criminals — They probably were not spanked as babies; they certainly were not flogged for their crimes. The usual sequence was: for a first offense, a warning — a scolding, often without trial. After several offenses a sentence of confinement but with sentence suspended and the youngster placed on probation. A boy might be arrested many times and convicted several times before he was punished — and then it would be merely confinement, with others like him from whom he learned still more criminal habits. If he kept out of major trouble while confined, he could usually evade most even that mild punishment, be given probation — ‘paroled’ in the jargon of the times.

"This incredible sequence could go on for years while his crimes increased in frequency and viciousness, with no punishment whatever save rare dull-but-comfortable confinements. Then suddenly, usually by his eighteenth birthday, this so-called ‘juvenile delinquent’ becomes an adult criminal — and sometimes wound up in only weeks or months in a death cell awaiting execution for murder."

"Suppose you merely scolded your puppy, never punished him, let him go making messes in the house... and occasionally locked him up in an outbuilding but soon let him back into the house with a warning not to do it again. Then one day you notice that he is now a grown dog and still not housebroken — whereupon you whip out a gun and shoot him dead. Comment, please?"

"Why... that’s the craziest way to raise a dog I ever heard of!"

"I agree. Or a child. Whose fault would it be?"

"Uh... why, mine, I guess."

"Again I agree. But I’m not guessing."

"But — good heavens!" the girl answered. "I didn’t like being spanked any more than any kid does, but when I needed it, my mama delivered. The only time I ever got a switching in school I got another one when I got home and that was years and years ago. I don’t ever expect to be hauled up in front of judge and sentenced to a flogging; you behave yourself and such things don’t happen. I don’t see anything wrong with our system; it’s a lot better than not being able to walk outdoors for fear of your life — why, that’shorrible!"

"I agree. Young lady, the tragic wrongness of what those well-meaning people did, contrasted with what they thought they were doing, goes very deep. They had no scientific theory of morals. They did have theory of morals and they tried to live by it (I should not have sneered at their motives) but their theory was wrong — half of it fuzzy-headed wishful thinking, half of it rationalized charlatanry. The more earnest they were, the farther it led them astray. You see, they assumed that Man has a moral instinct."

"Sir? But I thought — But he does!I have."

"No, my dear, you have a cultivated conscience, a most carefully trained one. Man has no moral instinct . He is not born with moral sense. You were not born with it, I was not — and a puppy has none. We acquire moral sense, when we do, through training, experience, and hard sweat of the mind.

These unfortunate juvenile criminals were born with none, even as you and I, and they had no chance to acquire any; their experiences did not permit it. What is ‘moral sense’? It is an elaboration of the instinct to survive. The instinct to survive is human nature itself, and every aspect of our personalities derives from it. Anything that conflicts with the survival instinct acts sooner or later to eliminate the individual and thereby fails to show up in future generations. This truth is mathematically demonstrable, everywhere verifiable; it is the single eternal imperative controlling everything we do."

"But the instinct to survive," he had gone on, "can be cultivated into motivations more subtle and much more complex than the blind, brute urge of the individual to stay alive. Young lady, what you miscalled your ‘moral instinct’ was the instilling in you by your elders of the truth that survival can have stronger imperatives than that of your own personal survival. Survival of your family, for example. Of your children, when you have them. Of your nation, if you struggle that high up the scale. And so on up.

scientifically verifiable theory of morals must be rooted in the individual’s instinct to survive —annowhere else! — and must correctly describe the hierarchy of survival, note the motivations at each level, and resolve all conflicts."

"These juvenile criminals hit a low level. Born with only the instinct for survival, the highest morality they achieved was a shaky loyalty to a peer group, a street gang. But the do-gooders attempted to ‘appeal to their better natures,’ to ‘reach them,’ to ‘spark their moral sense.’Tosh! They had no ‘better natures’; experience taught them that what they were doing was the way to survive. The puppy never got his spanking; therefore what he did with pleasure and success must be ‘moral.’

"The basis of all morality is duty, a concept with the same relation to group that self-interest has to individual. Nobody preached duty to these kids in a way they could understand — that is, with spanking. But the society they were in told them endlessly about their ‘rights.’ "

"The results should have been predictable, since a human being has no natural rights of any nature."


r/heinlein • • Apr 18 '26

Heinlein Prophecy A video I did to honor Heinlein and his amazing vision

13 Upvotes

Hi folks, not sure if this is ok, but I recently did a video honoring Heinlein's vision of the future. It's an AI video, which I thought was appropriate given his work. Here it is, hope other Heinlein fans like it. https://youtu.be/Bph1ATeDUw4?si=xsdaRhxGJfL7U_ou


r/heinlein • • Jun 15 '22

Farnham's Freehold - a lot to digest ;-)

13 Upvotes

Recently read this. And I have to say I am impressed. So many interesting concepts to think about.

Before this I read Time Enough For Love - enjoyed the pioneering parts. Not so much the relationship drama stuff. But it's me.

Number of the Beast was even more boring for me - a lot of relationship related stuff and leadership "lessons" and just shout outs to other authors. Cute but not very entertaining....for me.

FF has a bit of that burden of leadership struggle but it does not on go on for the whole book.

Neat prepper ideas - I bet a lot of full time preppers did not even consider some of them.

Feudalism and slavery taken to it's logical extreme - eugenics, cultural stagnation, cannibalism etc.

Comparing different cultural outlooks. Christianity for all it's faults, is very much antithetical to ideas of slavery and even feudalism....compared to Islam, Judaism, some African religions and even the Hindu caste system. It makes sense if so called Northern cultural space was wiped out, something akin to Ottoman style would dominate.

Very interesting was the observation how would society structure if patriarchal was not the main lineage i.e. Great Uncle narrative. In Judaism and so called primitive tribal cultures Mother Earth is worshiped or matrimonial lineage is preferred. It is a must in harem culture - too many bastards.


r/heinlein • • May 17 '26

Discussion My last name is Heinlein, ask me anything?

11 Upvotes