r/heidegger • u/tattvaamasi • Sep 18 '25
Deep sleep in heidegger
In deep sleep point of view doesn't it show the radical indviduality of dasein along with dependency on on some external agent to trigger waking state ?
r/heidegger • u/tattvaamasi • Sep 18 '25
In deep sleep point of view doesn't it show the radical indviduality of dasein along with dependency on on some external agent to trigger waking state ?
r/heidegger • u/UniqueBrick8723 • Mar 24 '26
r/heidegger • u/DroggellordAlt • May 20 '26
Warum wird auf dem Sub nicht auf Deutsch geschrieben? Martin Heidegger hätte es bestimmt nicht gewollt, dass man seine Werke auf Englisch diskutiert – und wahrscheinlich auch nicht liest. Wenigstens könnte man es auf Französisch versuchen, der zweitschlechtesten Sprache für die Lektüre von Heidegger. Aber Englisch ist mit Sicherheit die schlechteste.
Englischsprachige Nutzer können Reddits KI-Tool verwenden, um Texte zu übersetzen, und umgekehrt.
Dieser Post ist kein Trolling und keine Provokation, sondern ernst gemeint.
r/heidegger • u/Maximum-Builder3044 • Oct 14 '25
On the surface, the works of Marcuse and others seem to bridge the gap between Marx and Heidegger. The Nazism of the latter aside. But what I think ultimately makes that bridge insurmountable is that Marx is interpreting Dasein's historicality inauthentically.
Marcuse, roughly, tries to incorporate Marx's class theories into Heidegger's conception of historicality. This fails in my opinion because Marx's theories concern primarily the economic status of Dasein. But that economic status is, as Heidegger points out in SZ, concerned with "one's work". But one's work is important proximally and for the most part in average everydayness. That is to say, Dasein, in inauthenticity, understands itself through its work: its equipment, its world, and its social status among "the they". This is exactly what Marx does. Marx essentially reduces us to these forces of social production, where Dasein is an economic tool used in the machine of capitalism.
But this is an inauthentic understanding of Dasein. Dasein isn't primordially defined by its relation to equipment or its economic status, it is defined by its existentiality (or ek-sistence, in later Heidegger). Marx's charicterization of Dasein is an inauthentic one that reduces Dasein to an economic agent that is used by capitalism.
So whilst it's true that Dasein is thrown into an economic or social role, these are not its primordial historicality. Marx's project interprets Dasein in its inauthentic everydayness, as united with its world and understood only in relation to its work. Heidegger's project is wholly antithetical to this.
Let me know if you think my critique stands.
r/heidegger • u/[deleted] • Jun 02 '21
This is possibly the most clever, masterful, mischievous, and graceful literary device ever crafted.
All the more potent and fitting if, like me, you consider this book to be Heidegger's Magnum Opus and more central a work than Being and Time! (An unpopular opinion?)
So, we have: Only the Greatest work ever created by the Greatest thinker the earth has yet produced! (Or at least on par with Plato's Republic and Nietcscha's Zarathustra).
And what is it's title?
"Contributions to Philosophy".
So, this title is not just inappropriate as a name for the work- it is SO glaringly inappropriate that it can ONLY be taken as a "ruse"... As a decoy. A trick. A trap!
I fucking guarantee- Heidegger was not without a sense of humor, and this was a monumentally creative PRANK. If you think "Contributions" was a sincere sentiment and if you think the words of this work were a sincere offering to "Philosophy" then you have been TROLLED.
You have been TROLLED erudites of academia.
The proof of my thesis, for those who care, is in the esoteric message of the "subtitle": "From Enowning".
This madlad, Heidegger, was so bold- so BRAVE- so uniquely ethically KNIGHTED and CHRISTNED-...
That he dared to write and publish his greatest work under the guise of a Ruseman's Trap, and present it to the world as if it had a humble and bland title- "Contributions to Philosophy" while all along, all the while, the most megalomaniacle hubris was swollen and cresting for presentation as the TRUE title of the work: "Enowning".
Yet Heiddegger was NOT mad as Nietcscha was or became- his sobriety is precisely what distinguishes him from Nietcscha.
And so, in sanity and in wisdom, Heiddegger wrote a Sacred Text.
Called "Enowning".
Which is, he says [and I will quote!!] CANNOT be written yet.
So the book known as
"Contributions"
is an excerpt...
From a book....
Which. ..
Does not
Yet
Exist.
r/heidegger • u/thegreatfloofmiester • Mar 05 '22
Prove you have read being and time
r/heidegger • u/ether6000 • Feb 16 '22
r/heidegger • u/NecessaryReindeer593 • Nov 30 '25
First of all, this is by no means a judgment. I'm actually interested in seeing if there are people who agree or disagree and if this makes sense.
It seems to me that either they're generally less interested in continental philosophy and more inclined toward analytic philosophy, or that reading Heidegger and Merleau-Ponty in English is just poorly translated.
I feel the same thing about psychoanalysis. And since Lacan is linguistically ambiguous by purpose it seems to me that could be the same problem.
As a Portuguese native speaker, I can normally read German-translated philosophy without getting lexically confused. French translations on the other hand can be very strange. Derrida, Merleau-Ponty…
r/heidegger • u/tattvaamasi • Sep 30 '25
One of the ontological and exisitenzial features of dasein is understanding, even though we cannot say it directly as Cartesian subject but it can be a form of uniqueness which I call "subject" in recording or understanding the unique contents or projections!
If understanding is a seperate ontological function it would be a sort of pure subject, if it is not seprate from its unique projection material it becomes a subject of uniqueness! Or an essent of uniqueness!
Any thoughts !?
r/heidegger • u/lucius-verus-fan • May 14 '22
Paper: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4077540
Abstract: A Map of the Universe explores the fundamental laws of the Universe, the mechanisms which allow a subject to perceive the Universe, and the features of post-perception existence. The Map is constructed from a set of axioms that optimally capture knowledge of the Universe with respect to the constraints of perception. This project is situated inside a historical continuum of metaphysical exploration and draws on findings from the fields of logic, semiotics, mathematics, metaphysics, philosophy, and literature. Out of the Map falls theories of perception, consciousness, determinism, self, the role of language, and the nature of the Universe as a whole.
r/heidegger • u/Schizo_Thinker • Sep 22 '24
Heidegger states that Dasein are Beings that questions Being. However, will Dasien apply to Artificial Intelligence once it questions its own existence?
r/heidegger • u/jakeskoans • Mar 11 '26
I’ve read most of Heidegger’s works, and in the evenings I’ve started journaling a private daseinanalysis. I’ll take some of my favorite themes and semiotics from his works and apply them through various mathematical models. It keeps me in check. Was curious to see if anyone else was interested in doing this with me. Happy Heideggering everyone.
r/heidegger • u/ParadeSauvage • Feb 13 '25
The criticisms of Being and Time (Heidegger, 1927, almost one hundred years ago) can be grouped into three categories:
the first approach consists, not in criticizing the content of the book, but in criticizing the person of its author. This is what is called an "ad hominem" attack. As Paul Valery said, "when one fails to attack a line of reasoning, one attacks the reasoner". If I had to transpose this approach to physics, I would reject the uncertainty principle because Heisenberg was a Nazi.
the second approach consists in taking a word from the text of Being and Time, giving it a completely different meaning from the one it has in the text, leaving aside all the rest of the text and constructing a delirium (which no longer has anything to do with Being and Time) from this word. Again, if I had to transpose this approach to physics, I would consider Newtonian mechanics as a form of Nazism ("About the introduction of Nazism in physics") given its use of the notions of Force, Power and Work.
the third approach consists of not reading the book but reporting what others have said about it. This is a very fashionable approach in journalism, which is to no longer report facts but statements. In this way, we no longer have to ensure that the facts are true but only that the statements were indeed made. It is a form of argument from authority, the authority of philosophers on TV sets, of media animals. Reading the text is then advantageously replaced by listening to a France Inter podcast, which is much less tiring and more accessible.
r/heidegger • u/Democman • Dec 13 '24
The idea that person needs another person to achieve self-recognition comes purely out of the needs of a person with NPD, who needs external validation to regulate himself emotionally.
In a healthy person recognition is acquired from the self, not from others, and therein the entire Hegelian system collapses. In the case of the bondsman, he is also self-alienated and needs to work for the “master” in order to recognize himself.
Both are mentally ill, needing external validation to satisfy their existential dread, rather than simply being in the world.
r/heidegger • u/[deleted] • Aug 20 '24
Is phenomenalism the basis or core of phenomenology ? I argue yes, and that this is the reason why phenomenology is also ontology (and why ontology is only possible as phenomenology.) Here's an excerpt:

These claims are justified/unfolded in various informal essays available here. I'm happy to debate, discuss these points. And I'd be glad to look into the essays of others who researching something related.
r/heidegger • u/InviteCompetitive137 • Jan 04 '26
My understanding of Heidegger is he tried to generalize everyday lived experiences and provided a reasonably accurate description of phenomena. I was wondering if his thought can be extended to abstract ideas which include the notion of concept and/or memory.
Any body think this is reasonable question to ask? TIA
r/heidegger • u/reddit_user_1984 • Jun 22 '25
I like listening to Muchael Sugrue and in one of his lectures he quotes Heidegger. "We did not not ask for this. We did not ask to be thrown into this world and have things events happen in our lives".
At one of those corners again and being a victim of Cioran's anxiety. I am wondering , do I even know what I want to ask for? Let's say I did not ask for this anxiety, but whatever I do ask for creates its own problems and anxieties. There is really nothing which will not end in being pain for me. Or anxiety ridden event.
I am left with more doubts than I had questions.
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • Sep 27 '26
r/heidegger • u/_schlUmpff_ • Aug 05 '25
I read from the Ted Sadler translation of On The Essence Of Truth. Page 59.
r/heidegger • u/tattvaamasi • Sep 09 '25
When we understand the concept of being in heidegger and his desperate attempt to not explain how being "gifts" clearing to beings, therby opening it to a perceptions of beings ! But whatever the perception is, it must include a confession that being of beings should always be the being of difference and therfore, a being of transcendence, or else how can a being grant plurality? And since it is independent it is free of metaphysical speculation only in this way !
r/heidegger • u/glowing-fishSCL • Oct 05 '24
I deleted my last post because I had poor word choice---I used the word "disciple", which wasn't quite what I meant to say.
(I also should have remembered to copy my original post)
But the question still stands: who here studies Heidegger, thinks he is an important and influential philosopher, but basically sees him as one voice among many, with his own flaws? Heidegger has helped me think about many things, but there are some things I dislike about him.
r/heidegger • u/ComprehensiveFront18 • Oct 11 '25
Hey there! I'm reaching out to share a unique play called Martin and Hannah: A Das Sein Ghost Story, which explores deep philosophical themes through the lives of influential thinkers. Every donation makes a real difference in bringing this important project to life, so I’d really appreciate it if you could take a moment to click the link below to donate or share it with others who might be interested. Thank you! https://gofund.me/9bf9b1457
r/heidegger • u/TraditionalDepth6924 • Feb 15 '26
Is it not naïve to assume that an authentic mode of life automatically/magically happens when one confronts their mortality/finitude?
How about valuing the process/progress in the middle between birth and death, where one gradually finds their authentic calling as she hones her own course of techne?