r/heedthecall • • Oct 07 '25

Genuinely bummed about the show

40 Upvotes

Yes, I know there is so much negativity on this sub yada yada yada. But reddit is a forumn for thoughts and discussions, and thus, I have some.

I felt like the week 5 recap was arguably the worst show ever. It felt like Dan completely phoned it in, and just is bummed about the Yankees and Jets. Marc continues to be great, but Dan is either off the rails with every bit, interruptting everyone, or just doesn't give a shit about the football. And what happened to the music? I get it, it cost money and time to produce a show, but there is a reason why you put that investment in. Because it makes the product significantly better.

Like a lot of you, ATN meant a lot more to me than is probably healthy for an NFL podcast, and I understand why it came to an end. I genuinely respect the guys for branching out and trying thing, but the "f*ck the audience if they have issues with how we do the show" attitude never lasts forever.

Hopeful they can turn it around, but the trend is concerning.


r/heedthecall • • Jun 02 '26

The Rams glaze is out of control

2 Upvotes

Going to drop a disclaimer first: I am a Seahawks fan and I loathe the rams. I can admit though that they are a well run organization and McVay is a damn fine coach.

BUT.

Here are their past five seasons:

  • 2025 (12-5): Finished tied for the NFC West lead. Loss in the NFC Championship Game vs a division rival.

  • 2024 (10-7): Divisional round exit.

  • 2023 (10-7): Wild Card round exit.

  • 2022 (5-12): McVay's worst season.

  • 2021 (12-5): Won Super Bowl.

With the amount of glaze they seem to be getting, you would think they are the 2001-2004 Pats. Yet three out of the past five seasons are mediocre.

The common thread in all their glaze is this - it is assumed that every one of their bets is going to work out. Whereas every other team's bets are analyzed with more skepticism, as it should be. Hedging this much on Stafford's back staying healthy is a huge fucking gamble. Paying this much for a single player is a strategy, but it is a damn high risk move. If Garrett has a season ending injury, you sold the farm for the next three years for basically nothing.


r/heedthecall • • Mar 18 '26

Aren't they all just American?

8 Upvotes

I've never noticed it as much as this year, but what's with Americans referring to themselves as Irish? This is the 3rd podcast I've listened to this week where the hosts are all of a sudden everyone seems to be claiming Irish citizenship.

Were you born there? No? Well then you're not Irish.


r/heedthecall • • Sep 27 '24

The flagship show is better without the radio highlights

0 Upvotes

I was initially a little let down when they didn't have the radio highlights on the Sunday show, It was a great feature of the ATN pod.

But I think I prefer it this way.

The prewritten intros are fantastic. I'm all about that mirth, and any chance to hear some surrealist Sesslerian prose is a pleasure. Conor's a great writer too. Justin not being a great writer is a developing bit. I'm all for it.

I suppose radio highlight followed by prewritten bits would be the ideal scenario.


r/heedthecall • • Nov 26 '25

Anyone else a little underwhelmed with the merch?

2 Upvotes

I feel like it misses the "Myark" on what they could've been offering


r/heedthecall • • Sep 16 '24

HTC dropped the ball with the Seahawks game

33 Upvotes

It is frustrating to watch this podcast as a Seahawks fan. First of all, the Seahawks/Patriots game was probably the best game of the day and no one watched it. Ok, you didn't watch the game, then move on and don't try to comment on details. But then, Gravy embarrasses himself by saying "Geno didn't have a great game. He had a few offtarget throws". Really? I saw Geno throwing dimes all game and DK/JSN having a few bad drops. 33/44, 327 yd and 1TD is a bad game??? I'm used to the casual disrespect from Dan, but Gravy too? I'm sorry that Geno is no Will Levis, but he tries his best.

Edit: To be clear, I didn't intend to make this a hatefest for HTC. I do like the like the pod and I want it to be successful. I'm just pushing for more content of my favorite team. And my criticism of Gravy's opinion is just my opinion. All opinions are subjective and to be taken with a grain of salt.


r/heedthecall • • Sep 28 '26

"If Myles Garrett was in this game it would have been ovahhh" - Conor Orr

2 Upvotes

Bit of a wet fart of a recap from the boys on this one. At times I genuinely found myself wondering, “Who actually won this game?” because you’d hardly know from the post-mortem.

The Heroes sounded borderline offended by the result. Yes, the refereeing decision was a mess, but it didn’t force a Rams team dripping in offseason glaze to completely shit the bed and cough up 30 second-half points.

Blaming the officials is the easy bit. Talking honestly about a hyped team folding when the game was there to be won apparently requires a little more effort.

Maybe that’s harsh, but it’s disappointing hearing my favourite “independent football podcast” start sounding like another branch of the big-market PR department.


r/heedthecall • • Oct 31 '24

Free Talk! I sincerely don’t think I’ve ever been more offended on this show

0 Upvotes

MSD’s take on Pulp Fiction and Tarantino is one of those things that makes you never look at a person the same way again.

I get it, subjectivity blah blah, but damn… that one was rough


r/heedthecall • • 25d ago

The revised Pod Schedule

0 Upvotes

This probably wont apply to most but as an overseas fan (UK based) I really dont enjoy the new pod schedule.

I like listening to the pods during work but because of the lack of individual MNF recap and it being combined into the power rankings, the earliest opportunity I can listen is Wednesday.

This clashes with the other pods I listen to which preview the weeks games (I like to have listened to them all before TNF) and the pods breaking down stuff about my own team.

Im finding the power rankings pod has been creeping to a later and later release time also.

Im scrambling to find time to go back and listen to it later in the week but didnt used to have this issue.

I get the LA time difference, im finishing my working day and its not even 10am for the guys but just felt like a moan.


r/heedthecall • • Jun 25 '26

Free Talk! Triple G is on vacation from NFL Daily this week as well; a coincidence or are Tugboat and the Rainmaker at some sort of peace summit arranging for a guest spot on one pod or the other 🤔

7 Upvotes

I know it's only coincidence, and I've been happy to listen to both Pods since the troubles, but I liked ATN more, and would really enjoy listening to Gregg as a guest on Heed


r/heedthecall • • Aug 21 '24

Create new drops instead in rerecording old drops.

0 Upvotes

It's taken a long time to mske this post because it's hard to let her go, but she gone and she ain't never coming back. Let her go bro, it's time to move on, it can't be the same but that doesn't mean it can't be great. Like pet cemetery it can be resurrected, but it's different somehow. Just make new drops in real time that are inclusive of this show. This show is great on its own, it doesnt need to drag its luggage from a past relationship.


r/heedthecall • • May 22 '26

When did Conor Orr become so weaselly?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been a frequent listener of this pod since the ATN days, but maybe I’ve just been asleep at the wheel when it comes to Conor.

I was pretty bothered by him refusing to concede that he lost that Jags/ 49ers bet with Justin in relation to the wedding gift. Real sore loser type shit imo. And now this whining about him getting pushback online over his bad Cam Ward take is beyond annoying.

For the record I’m a Falcons fan and we definitely have our own QB issues, but to rank Ward below Dart and Shough, is just dumb. The Titans are fully expecting Ward to turn out to be a franchise QB, and he’s done nothing in his first season to derail that notion. Putting him in a 50/50 tier after 1 year where he actually played well, is absurd.

But the final straw was on this latest episode where Conor really goes hard at Justin over this in a way that comes off as insanely cringe. Everyone is just smiling and awkwardly laughing while Conor is comparing titans fans to insects and saying Justin is going to have to go talk to 12 year olds to find the next QB? Ok bro.

Sorry if I’m overreacting here, but this didn’t feel like friendly banter. It felt like Conor was throwing a temper tantrum.

Quick edit here just playing it back. Conor starts impersonating Justin too lol like chill out. Way too over the top.


r/heedthecall • • Jan 13 '25

Hey Dan…

10 Upvotes

… eagles won.

GO BIRDS 🦅


r/heedthecall • • Mar 28 '25

Jourdan Rodrigue is subpar on her best day

0 Upvotes

Just listened to the latest pod and heard how worried she is about peeking this sub. She should be. Usually a lot of love but I think we all know she is some weird mix of Colleen and Gregg.

Ok, that should cover what is visible on the thumbnail/ headline. Jourdan if you made it this far you are a great addition. I am impressed with all the co-hosts/guests on HTC. Conor is wild, MSD brings a fresh take on most topics also has those fancy shades, Zumi is great and brings the possibility of many cameos.

I think this show is really finding the stride and keeping everything interesting.


r/heedthecall • • Jul 28 '25

Stop changing the logo colors

9 Upvotes

The yellow and black was fine


r/heedthecall • • Feb 09 '25

Doughy media chuckleheads are making me root for Sirianni

5 Upvotes

Sirianni is a jabroni but the pendulum has swung too far where every podcast bozoTM (used lovingly, and not just the Ol Zeuser) are getting their shots in and making it seem like he can't even tie his shoes, all while the man is in the same number of Super Bowls as Shanahan/McVay/Carroll/Tomlin. Discourse has gotten to the point where I'm hoping the Eagles win and nick does the big balls celebration on the sidelines as time expires.


r/heedthecall • • Oct 23 '24

Dan, Daddy Chill

0 Upvotes

I have been surprised so far by how much of a heel Dan has turned into. In the ATN days he brought fun and levity to the program, but now he’s honestly just been weird and rude to Gravedigger.

You don’t need to talk about his fiancée, make him do weird sexual drops (the water one), talk over him during his analysis, and rip him in every podcast. I have been a loyal listener for years, and it’s just coming off as childish and makes me uncomfortable.

He left his job to join you when you got fired from the NFL, don’t be a dick.

Big Daddy Rich, chill.


r/heedthecall • • Sep 01 '25

Not to beat a dead horse but...

0 Upvotes

Conor saying these coaches (referring to the "safe" coaches in the hot butt ranking) are the creme de la creme, which INCLUDES Siriani is bonkers. Saying he's at, above or below the Dalton line is one thing. But to say he's in the same class as the likes of Reid, Harbaugh and Shanahan is wild. There are better options for the Dalton line HC, in my opinion, but are people (Conor included) seriously lumping Siriani in with true difference making HCs?? Come on now.


r/heedthecall • • Sep 26 '25

Dan and Carlie Irsay-Gordon

10 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I don’t think being infatuated with a person from afar as a media personality is a bad thing inherently AND Dan/Marc have commented on ALL people, not just women. That being said…

I felt this preview ep had a strange portion where Dan just waxed poetic on how attractive Carlie Irsay-Gordon is? To the point of commenting on her facial structure and suggesting that she gets him going. If people feel I’m wrong, happy to be so, but it felt very odd to me that Dan would talk ad nausea about how much he’s into her - he wouldn’t do that with virtually any other owner. On top of that, he couldn’t get her name right TWICE. Just disrespectful and somewhat gross to me for someone who is just (seemingly) trying to be a good, responsible owner of a football team


r/heedthecall • • Jan 12 '25

We need to talk about Pat (we don't, but I do)

13 Upvotes

First off, I'm English and live in England. You need to know that bit for the next bit. I tuned into Pat McAfee's show when it first started on ESPN out of curiosity because I didn't know who he was and the zoo format interested me. I watched for about 6 weeks on and off.

Now, I found myself watching last week for the first time in a long time and heard Mr. McAfee go on a 60 second rant ragging on England and how much of a bad place it was blah blah blah.

Now, if anyone watches regularly can you fill me in to where his anti-England sentiment has come from? I know he has Irish heritage, so that might play into it. But it seemed like something more.

My first thought was: Mate, why don't you sort out the trash in your own backyard before you start ragging on other countries? To be fair, Mr. McAfee did say that English people were ok, it was just England that was problematic. Can anyone solve the mystery? It really bloody irritated me.

As you were.


r/heedthecall • • May 16 '25

Dan please please stop saying "play the guitar" I think it's gotten lodged in your brain because it's being repeated 5 times an episode, easy. C'mon man!

0 Upvotes

r/heedthecall • • Jan 06 '25

No Flagship Show?

1 Upvotes

Did I miss an announcement or something, at the end of the week 18 preview show they said they'd see us Sunday night.


r/heedthecall • • Sep 16 '24

MARC WIDDA C !

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/heedthecall • • Oct 14 '25

The "Justin is the only one that gives good analysis" stance- huh?

0 Upvotes

I generally have very long commutes to and from work which means I listen to a lot of different football podcasts and as a result I am genuinely dumbfounded by the assertion that the commentary offered on HTC is somehow vapid and lacking with the exception of that offered by Justin.

Justin gives serviceable, unremarkable commentary. It's fine.

That's not a dis to Justin, I highly doubt he thinks of himself as some kind of a football savant. Robert Mayes or Mina Kimes he is not.

In contrast, I find the perspectives of Dan, Marc and Connor to be unique and remarkable; unlike almost all the other available football commentary out there.

It's refreshing to not be beaten over the head with DVOA from all comers. Nothing wrong with the advanced metrics, they are cool, but not the only way to view the sport.

I've also started to piece together that a majority of the Justin "defenders" ( what should they be called? If Lamar has the Lamarmy, what are the Justinites to be christened? ) are also the Dan haters, and also seem to highly populate the cry baby posts about how awful HTC has become.

Justin is his own man and I don't think he probably feels "defended" by the condescending presumption that he is a helpless and a hapless soul. He seems to do just fine standing up for himself on the show.