How would you rank the couples in the series in terms of how monogamous they might be? Here's mine (and there's potentially at least one hot take incoming):
Shane/Ilya: As seen in the books, these two will crash out if anyone else even looks at their husband, let alone flirt, let alone opening their relationship (as evidenced by Shane not talking to Ilya for 3 days when he suggested non-monogamy and Ilya shooting the puck at the reporter who was flirting with Shane). They are not opening their relationship up in a bajillion years, not until the Heat Death of the Universe. They took so much time to get together, they are not letting an outsider cut into their precious time together.
(Massive, massive gap the size of the Böotes void, because I feel like all these other couples could potentially maybe at least think about having a threesome)
2. Ryan/Fabian: I just don't see Ryan being a threesome guy? Maybe Fabian suggests it, but Ryan would 100% go into an anxious spiral thinking about how he can't keep Fabian happy anymore, and then Fabian scraps the plan and comforts him.
3. Troy/Harris: I'm gonna have a headcanon that Troy has had at least one threesome when he was with Adrian De La Cruz. Based on that alone, I think he and Harris would maybe potentially explore the idea of having one, but it wouldn't be on a regular basis.
4. Scott/Kip: Admittedly this is my bias that the NY couples are the least interesting out of the main five, but after reading Game Changer, I didn't even think Scott and Kip would last, let alone be non-monogamous (the writing of Game Changer, the worst book in the series, doesn't help). But, yeah, they get married in CG, which put a wrench in my theory that they don't last, but I still think both of them would want to spice up things a bit pretty frequently and would invite guys back into their home.
5. Eric/Kyle: I mean, yeah. Self-explanatory.