Abridged Chat with Basro, Creator of Haxball
[In response to his latest Update posting in the News page, in which he alluded to things to come: "I’m working on implementing more admin tools (player kicking, promoting to admin, etc) but since it will take a while I decided to release these smaller changes now."]
doubl: checkin the change log - i think the ability to kick players will definitely be a great change -- I was wondering if it'd be worth considering making it a vote-based kicking? hosts can sometimes be a bit dictatorial lol
basro: vote kick would not make much sense, the hosts own the room and it only moves if the host makes it move
doubl: this might be a crazy, impossible, and even stupid idea, but have you considered getting the Facebook API and implementing this game into that? --effectively letting them host it and whatnot. I don't know if it's possible, or something like it.
basro: I haven't looked into facebook yet, I have no idea if it's possible. If you're talking about using that to get dedicated servers, then it's downright impossible. The server is run on flash, and the hosts are the servers. Haxball is the only flash game to use this p2p technology so far.
doubl: Next, it'd be nice to know a few things when you join a room: who the host is, what the game is going to, and what the time limit is.
basro: I'll do all of those things someday :) when I get to it. My problem is the damn GUI, it's tricky to make :(
doubl: yeah cause whenever I make a room, I try and give all that info in the room name--within the limited space for a room name: "doubl's room - 3min 1v1 to 3!" Just out of courtesy for the player, cause when people join a room and see two people 1v1ing, for example, knowing it's to three makes people much more likely to stick around to play some games.
basro: yes, that will definitely be added once I figure out a nice way to put it in place. But next I'm making the player list + kicking and stuff.
doubl: so one thing I've noticed, as I host a lot of games: whenever I am hosting, and I'm just speccing for example--letting other ppl play while I sit out, and I switch tabs in chrome for example: THAT by itself causes an extreme amount of lag.
basro: yes, that is because flash will switch to 2fps when you do that.
doubl: ok, and once I figured that out, I make it a point to keep telling people this, cause it's obvious when it's the case in rooms where other people are hosting--they're in another tab for a sec. so I guess it'd be nice if people were aware of that
basro: indeed. I plan to detect an fps drop in the future and tell others about it, so you'd know when the room is slow because the host switched tabs.
doubl: we know you're working on the kick feature and others you mentioned in the recent change long - think it'll be days or weeks?
basro: not sure, I'm having some gui problems for it. I decided I want to make a player list gui, but it's hard work ;D
basro: the idea is this: there will be a "Players" button under the "Menu" button. It will toggle the visibility of a player list for each room. The player list will be kind of like an IRC list of people in a room--inspired by that. From this list a host would be able to kick people out of a room.
doubl: so one thing I enjoy about FIFA and other soccer games are the game-end stats like "shots on goal," in addition to who scored which goals, man of the match (mvp). stuff like that could be fun to view after a game.
basro: it's a bit trickier to determine that in haxball though.
doubl: yeah, I figured it would be.
basro: since a bounce shot is also a shot on goal if done properly (banking off of the wall, or bouncing it off of someone else) so it is hard to determine "who" made a goal sometimes for statistical purposes like that.
doubl: yeah, I guess it could be as simple as who touched the ball last - making it a goal you scored or an Own Goal you inadvertently caused
basro: sometimes you try to deflect a ball but dont manage to do it enough, that should not count as an own goal maybe
doubl: right
basro: I haven't found any good solutions to this problem though.
doubl: another thing I like about other soccer games is the longer you hold kick, the stronger or harder you can kick the ball. it requires you to be in control of the ball for longer, meaning you can't do it all the time, and requires skill and tact whenenver you do.
basro: there is a haxball equivalent to that, sort of: you can first push and then kick to make a stronger shot.
doubl: I guess it could be a slippery slope - harming the simplicity of the game...it's a careful line that must be tread.
basro: yes. it kinda sucks that now that the game's so popular, I'm a bit more reluctant to change things like that.
doubl: rightt, well it's sorta like facebook - people will allllways bitch and moan about changing things they're used to, even if they're truly and rationally good, better changes. tis what gamers need to do anyways, adapt to stay at the top of the game - say if there's a new call of duty or halo game.
doubl: so it's not like you can't change some things I guess is my point, but they HAVE to ultimately make sense, and not be arbitrary.
doubl: that introduces another possibility - game modes, or settings the host can control.
basro: yes, if I make gameplay changes, I'll probably make them optional. In the match settings, you'd be able to select to play classic haxball.
doubl: the last thing I was wondering about is name registration - lately now I've seen people spoof my name and entering my room and being a dick, and then leaving and coming back and doing the same to others in my room, annoying me and people with whom I'm friends now -_- lol
doubl: related question - I know you're not done with the player list/kicking stuff, but do you have an idea for how the banning will theoretically work? if we don't have player regs, is it IP based so they can't simply change their name and re-enter and screw up the game again?
basro: there will never be nick registration, but I'll make it so that anyone who joins a room that already has that nick will get a (#number) attached to their nick
doubl: interesting - no nick registaration eh? is there a general policy or philosophy behind that? it's something regular players I know seem to be clamoring for.
basro: the reason is that I'm used to games like quake and cod, in such games you can pick any nickname. I'd rather be nicknamed basro than basro123123.
doubl: well for now, I imagine if we are allowed to make accounts or usernames, we'd not have much trouble getting our preferred handles. that could also lead to win/loss ratio stats, ratings for your hosting history maybe?
basro: an idea that comes to mind right now is that maybe I can get a nickname priority system, so that multiple people can claim a nick, but those who claimed it first have a priority. So if you join a room and someone is using your nick, then that other person would get a (2).
doubl: that seems effective
basro: but it seems like a lot of trouble to make ;P
doubl: if I donate $10 or so to you, how would it be spent? red bull?
basro: no idea :P I don't drink energy drinks.
doubl: well that was a joke lol
basro: I know ;O
doubl: well like you've implemented ads in a small for a purpose
doubl: is it for game development stuff or simple profit?
doubl: (are the ads doing well?)
basro: yes, ads are my main income right now. life is cheap in arg though ;)
doubl: well that's cool
basro: so yes, I'm dedicating myself to working on haxball now
doubl: xD great news
basro: kind of as a job, but I don't like to call it that
doubl: yeah, as opposed to a time balancing ratio...haxball was surely a side project or hobby creation for you, correct? what did you do before haxball?
basro: I worked fro an iPhone game development company. But I quit 2 or more months ago :P
doubl: what was the genesis of this game? what made you think of it conceptually in the first place? Sumo volleyball?
basro: that one is a funny story, kind of :D I wanted to make a sumo game, I got to the point where the discs were synched up and each player would control one and be able to collide with each other. One day while playing around with it, we started trying to get one of the idle discs to the other side. There was
no kicking then, of course, but it was quite fun.
doubl: oh I see, haha.
basro: So then I hardcoded the posts and a ball as a joke, and it was really un, so I added kicking and etc, etc.
doubl: rofl, awesome.
basro: yeah, I plan to make the sumo game someday anyway--the idea is you have to stay inside an arena an push others out of it. probably a deathmach thing.
[Not in conversation: THIS reminds me of a Fusion Frenzy mini-game...anyone remember this?? Fun game!]
doubl: oh nice, that'd be fun!
doubl: well, the development has been amazing, the changes you've made in the past few weeks very good
basro: I had no faith in the game when I first released it. Thought it'd be a failure and was thinking on what to do next.
doubl: if I wanted to regurgitate some of this convo for others to read - would you have a prob with that? There's prob a lot of interest in some of the things you've said today. Basically if you don't want any of these grand plans released, I have no problem keeping it to myself.
basro: this info / irc chat is public, so yes, no problem :)
doubl: well cool, thanks a lot - great job again, keep up the great work, and I'll be back in due time ;)