r/hamiltonmusical • • Jan 03 '23

I’ve just started a new school and theirs a kid here literally with the first name of Aaron and middle name Burr. Respect to his parents

18 Upvotes

Sadly, his parents based it off respect to the senator rather than simply a character from the musical. I’ve asked him, and apparently he doesn’t like Hamilton the musical (shame) and has never watched more than the first 5 minutes.

What’s some witty lines I can say to this guy? I’ve got friends that are huge Hamilton fans so it’ll be nice to start some nice inside jokes. (Not bullying the guy though).

So far, on a day he was away from school I said to some friends something like “Ironic. Aaron Burr didn’t want to be in the room where it happens”. It was cringy, but I can’t waste an opportunity like this so I need your help on suggestions ;)


r/hamiltonmusical • • Feb 17 '24

A lot of people on this sub don’t understand the show

0 Upvotes

I feel like every other post I see on here is someone describing this “big revelation” they just had about the show, and it’s literally just a story beat. Nothing profound was realized, it was literally just what happened. Discerning that Hamilton’s downfall was his pride is not a huge discovery, it’s one of the main lessons of the story. Rant over.


r/hamiltonmusical • • Jul 29 '26

Hamilton lied to Eliza even before he cheated - new lyric realization Spoiler

33 Upvotes

I've now seen Hamilton live 4 times after listening to to the soundtrack hundreds of times and I had a realization for the first time:

In Stay Alive, Hamilton says:

I have never seen the General so despondent I have taken over writing all his correspondence

Then in That Would Be Enough:

Hamilton: How long have you known? Eliza: a month or so Hamilton: Eliza, you should have told me Eliza: I wrote to the General a month ago Hamilton: No Eliza: I begged him to send you home Hamilton: You should have told me

But based on what he says in Stay Alive, he would have seen Eliza's letter and he chose to ignore it to stay in the war and claim glory from that. It wasn't until Washington kicked him out that he went home. So this can be seen as the first time he lied to Eliza, even before cheating on her!!!


r/hamiltonmusical • • Jan 27 '22

Did you know

0 Upvotes

After Hamilton was shot he kept laughing and didn’t fall over and whatever like pass out or somthing


r/hamiltonmusical • • Apr 18 '22

Why I don't like Say No To This

16 Upvotes

So this song have really good music and overall rhythm but the words are so bad I really can hear it too much

  1. Hamilton "excuses" and looking innocent

Especially the start: "I hadn't slept in a week" "I was weak" "You've never seen a bastard orphan more in need of a break" those lines are coming right after take a break. All of this start is Hamilton trying to make excuses for himself, but also Lin Manuel Miranda trying to keep his hero sympathetic. He is cheating on his wife, I love the forgiveness afterwards, but in the song itself? Just excuses.

2. Using women as a means to an end

"Whatever you want, if you pay / You can stay" This one is a little better in my opinion, because it's more about history than the song itself, but still, it doesn't make listing to the song better.

3. Making Hamilton look like a hero

Lines like: "So I offered her a loan, I offered to walk her home" and "I gave her thirty bucks that I had socked away" and Maria just describing being abused by her husband. All of that trying to make Hamilton look like a hero or a man with good heart instead of focusing on the actual thing that is happening.

I think I owe this song a little so I'll say I really love how Maria is using the phrase"I'm helpless" over and over, trying to convince him by trying to be his wife like the song helpless.

What do you think?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Sep 09 '26

Is it bad that I love Hamilton songs, but not the musical?

1 Upvotes

I could actually listen to Hamilton songs all day, but i never could watch it. I tried almost four times now, but i still can't get into it. I love musical and play songs but don't like the actual performances. Is that a bad thing??


r/hamiltonmusical • • Jun 17 '23

Women in the sequel?

1 Upvotes

I’m sorry but this is a tough question to google. When in the Schuyler sisters she sings “all men are created equal, and when I meet Thomas Jefferson, Imma compel him to include women in the sequel (work!)”, what is that referring to? What document has men and women as equal from that era?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Feb 12 '25

What's y'alls opinions on the ships that exist?

7 Upvotes

Basically I've been looking through some fanfics recently cause I got bored and saw a LOT of different ships- I only really knew of lams before

Now ships I've found are

Hamilton X Laurens

Hamilton X Lafayette

Hamilton X Burr

Hamilton X Jefferson

Hamilton X Washington

Lafayette X Mulligan

Lafayette X Washington

Jefferson X Madison

Madison X Burr

Madison X Laurens

Laurens X Peggy

Phillip X Theodosia (Jr)

Phillip X Eacker

Phillip X Georges Washington de Lafayette

Whatever Character X Spouse

Eliza X Maria (Reynolds)

Jefferson X Laurens

John Adams X Jefferson

Lafayette X Jefferson

Correct me if I'm missing any (and I defenetely am missing a lot), but what's y'alls opinion on them?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Dec 21 '23

Unpopular opinion: I kinda dislike Eliza Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just can't get over the fact that Hamilton was a HORRIBLE husband to her and did her wrong so many times, from leaving her in "Non-Stop", not taking a break and going away in the summer to spend quality time with his wife (which he said was for "work" reasons, but we all know that's not what he did), and my breaking point was the scene in "Say No To This".

Right now this sounds like hate against Alexander Hamilton, but the fact that Eliza sang "Burn" (which i was so excited she was finally speaking her mind and letting that horrible man go), but then GOT BACK WITH HIM LIKE FOUR SONGS LATER.... right after he was literally one of the main factors of her son's death (her son was trying to defend HIS honor, and Alexander enabled it by giving him his guns and saying "go make me proud").

THEN he lied about having a "work trip" when he was going to his duel against Burr.

I understand that divorce and leaving your husband wasn't a common or realistic thing to do back then due to financial and social status reasons, but GOSH that man screwed you over so many times for you to STILL decided to stay with him. You could've done so many things that didn't involve staying with Hamilton and still be safe, raise your kids in a good life, and not be broke. She could've asked Angelica for help, because she had her wealthy husband, or she could've just got a side man and distanced herself from Hamilton. I just can't respect Eliza for getting back with him... idk what do y'all think.

EDIT: I think it’s safe to say i dislike Eliza the MUSICAL character. Eliza as an actual person to me is separate from how she was portrayed in the musical.

ANOTHER EDIT: Y'all make some good points, but I'm sorry I just don't think Eliza should've forgiven Hamilton. She should've had more love and respect for herself... Read my comments for more of my insight and reply if you have something that I should take into consideration.

LAST EDIT: Maybe I'm just way too young to understand y'alls reasonings, I really just can't get past what I see from my point of view. Hopefully I find a different perspective when I grow older and rewatch Hamilton.


r/hamiltonmusical • • Feb 01 '25

washington was a slave owner. end of.

0 Upvotes

So many americans try to defend washington for literally OWNING SLAVES??!!! it doesn’t matter if he ‘felt uncomfortable’ owning them, or freed them in his will, he never spoke publicly about it, as the mf president he never ended slavery he had slaves till he died and the amount of americans who defend him are brain dead. it’s okay to admit that americas most loved historical figure was a slave owner it makes a lot of sense really.


r/hamiltonmusical • • Nov 09 '18

I’m taking my 8 yr old to see the play this month on Broadway and he is obsessed with the music, but I’m worried about the “sex” stuff bc he is still very innocent and is like to keep it that way. My question: are the only innuendos in “Say No To This?” Can we step out of the theater for that song?

15 Upvotes

r/hamiltonmusical • • Apr 26 '19

So... I found our man on Facebook and got carried away until I was blocked...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/hamiltonmusical • • Mar 09 '25

Can Hamilton even be adapted to live action ?

0 Upvotes

Movie adaptation of Wicked is successful and this got me thinking is movie adaptation of Hamilton is even possible ?

First things first, it won't be one movie because musical is 2hr 22 mins long and movie is bound to have some extra scenes to maintain consistency. So, maybe they can release two parts after gap of 4 months or just release part 1 and release part 2 based on reception.

My main expectation from the movie adaptation would be:

  1. Some new songs preferably.

  2. Enhancement in production quality of existing songs. I do like the existing production quality but, it is intentionally not too complex which can't be replicated by real time orchestra in real time so, an enhancement in production quality will be welcomed.

  3. Something to pad out the time jumps. In a broadway musical, time jumps work but, something needs to be done to pad the time jumps in movie.

  4. Something to explain scenario of that time period better. Although LMM did a fantastic job at explaining many things, Act 2 went completely over my head. I didn't understand why Room where it happens is a big deal and why position of capital is such a big emotional deal. And why do southerners want to work closer to home. Only after understanding American Revolution and American Civil war (thanks to Oversimplified) I was able to understand everything.

Personally for me I am only interested in 2nd point because (it might be controversial) I liked production quality of songs in Wicked Movie and I liked it over the original musical although, I still miss Idina Menzel's strong voice.

What are your thoughts on this ? Is this even possible ?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Nov 12 '22

The Reynolds Pamphlet is the manliest, most ENTJ document ever written by a founding father.

4 Upvotes

r/hamiltonmusical • • Jul 21 '23

Is it just me, or does something sound unnatural/uncanny with the Disney+ version?

3 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel like the audio mixing/engineering sounds off on the Disney+ version? I feel like the orchestra is way too loud for some songs, and even LMM's voice sounds airy and overpowered by the background chorus.

Maybe that's not even it... but for some reason I don't enjoy the Disney+ version anywhere near as much as I do just listening to the soundtrack. I tried watching the Disney+ version when it originally came out, but I was pretty underwhelmed by it. Then, I saw it on Broadway and I did a complete 180. It's my favorite musical, now! But even going back to the Disney+ version after loving it in-person it still sounds underwhelming for some reason. What is it!?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Jan 02 '24

I dislike Angelica Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Ok, give me your thoughts on this but me personally, I dislike her due to the fact she still had an affair with Hamilton(?) despite her saying " I will choose her happiness over mine every time"

I don't understand why she would send letters to Hamilton and she couldn't say she didn't want to be with him anymore despite saying she'd choose Eliza's happiness over hers. Wouldn't it of caused Eliza more pain knowing her sister and her husband were secretly sending letters to each other and having an affair?


r/hamiltonmusical • • Oct 28 '23

Hamilton should of came back to bed on the night of his death

0 Upvotes

Listen if he came back to bed just like Eliza said he would be alive for an few more years


r/hamiltonmusical • • May 04 '24

What are y’all’s favourite Hamilton ships?

7 Upvotes

My person favourites are Jeffmads, Lams, and George/George squared


r/hamiltonmusical • • Dec 16 '22

Gender bend of Hamilton Laurens and Lafayette

2 Upvotes

The last Title I had for this might have been offensive. That was never the intention and I am sorry is it was.


r/hamiltonmusical • • Dec 03 '22

Finally made the pilgrimage to Princeton to get Hamilton’s revenge

Post image
321 Upvotes

r/hamiltonmusical • • Apr 05 '24

I don't like Aaron Burr

0 Upvotes

I understand the need to feel important especially when a huge decision is taking place and I love "The room where it happens" but the entire song felt as if a child was having a tantrum cuz he wasn't allowed ice cream. Burr wasn't able to join the others and discuss about where they put the new US capital because he wasn't needed. Like all the other posts said, Burr spent all his time standing around and waiting for it that in the end he waited to long and missed it. If he was just a little more sure, a little more firm when it comes to decision making then maybe he would have been included. He's just a spoiled little brat that wants everything handed to him rather than working for it


r/hamiltonmusical • • Nov 11 '24

Explanation for the “my dearest, Angelica” line

0 Upvotes

Without the comma it says “my dearest Angelica” which means that Angelica is close to Hamilton but not the closest.

With the comma it says “my dearest, Angelica” which implies that Angelica is the closest person to Hamilton in his life.


r/hamiltonmusical • • Sep 02 '25

Hamilton Inspired Rant

0 Upvotes

So, I’m writing a novel/screenplay and there’s this character (a super cool principal named Luis Ramos referred to as Principal Ramos) that wasn’t at first inspired by Lin, but started becoming him the more I’ve written him. So much so, if it does become a screenplay, Lin is the first choice to play the character.

And, while this part wouldn’t be in any of the novel or movie because it’s an internal monologue from Principal Ramos and Ramos is not the main character… I wrote this part out just to get inside the characters brain and I had a bit too much fun with it.

Figured I’d share because it’s really funny and I want more people to see it instead of just me.

So here it is

Context: Ramos is burnt out because the main character (Aiden Davenport) keeps getting in fights with this bully (Blake Winters), and he has to deal with the fallout. Homeboy is crashing out hard and this is the inner monologue he has.

The Monologue:

I swear to fuck, I’ve had it.

Just once. Just ONE time. I want someone to tell me: “Hey. You’re trying.” Or even: “Hey. You’re doing great sweetie.”

Because that? That would be fucking enough.

But no. God forbid I get that luxury.

I don’t get to “Take A Break.” Fuck you, Hamilton. If he’s not taking that break, I sure as hell will. I’ll go. I’ll go right now. You think I won’t?

Fucking try me.

“Say No To This?” More like “Say yes to this and would you like fries and early retirement with that?”

Please Schuyler sisters. Please for the love of everything holy. Take me on your vacation upstate. Because if Hamilton won’t? I promise, I will.

And no, Burr. I will not wait for it. No, Angelica, I won’t be an ocean away.

I’ll be there in the Bahamas sipping margaritas with my wife under a goddamn palm tree faster than Lafayette can rap out “Guns and Ships”.

I’m taking this horse by the reins all the way to the beach and no, I won’t be back. You’ll see.

While we’re at it? Fuck Washington too.

I want to sit under my own vine and fig tree. Lord knows I’ve earned it.

Unfortunately that’s not my life. No. My life is being the broke-ass version of Alexander Hamilton in Non-Stop. Difference is? He at least wanted to write his 51 essays. In fact? He lived for it.

Awesome. Wow. Good for you, Alex. You deserve a medal. Have fun with the burnout. That sure got you somewhere, didn’t it? Cheating on your wife in 4K then dead in Weehawken before you hit your fifties. How inspired.

And that, dear friends, is about to be me. Except instead of cheating on my wife, I’m going to have a damn ulcer and die under a stack of incident reports covered in my blood, sweat, tears and my crushed soul that I’m certain died weeks ago when I didn’t expel those kids after fight one.

If I have to write one sentence about how Aiden “I’m Not Throwing Away My Shot And I Have Something To Prove” Davenport punched Blake “Charles Lee: Teenage Bully Edition” Winters, because Blake quote “destroyed Aiden’s honor”? I will burn the school down so fast, Eliza would rise from the dead to give me a goddamn standing ovation.

I swear to God. At this point? I’m just reenacting Christopher Jackson’s role in Meet Me Inside. Playing the general who has to pry Hamilton away from Lee before Hamilton loses his shit.

Except I don’t get to scream in G minor about my problems while an ensemble backs me up. Instead I get angry emails screaming at me as if I threw those two chucklefucks into the boxing ring myself and shouted “TO THE DEATH”.

Yeah fucking right.

Here’s the truth. I’ve done just about everything at this point short of sacrificing my cat’s soul to the devil. I’m running out of ideas.

And let me tell you something.

I’m not satisfied. I’m not even helpless. I’m FUCKING DONE.

If Schuyler was defeated, then I’m dead.

Deader than Philip in “Stay Alive Reprise.” Deader than Hamilton in “The World Was Wide Enough.”

And let me tell you this history. I’m one, and I mean ONE, more incident away from handing in my resignation with an angsty rendition of “One Last Time” in full King George energy.

I’m one incident away from belting a sonnet so raw and powerful Lin-Manuel Miranda himself would weep and drag me onstage to declare me “King of Broadway”.

Maybe I’m being dramatic. Maybe I’m overreacting.

But I don’t care. At all.

If I have to write anything, I want to write out my resignation in full Adam’s Administration energy.

And no, not the simple “Sit down John, you fat motherfucker.”

I’m talking cut rap version. Full “An open letter to the fat arrogant anti-charismatic national embarrassment-” roast style version. Entitled the Ramos Pamphlet.

I will go full “Dear sir, I hope this letter finds you in bad health and in an unprosperous enough position to put wealth in the-”

You get my point.

And history? Listen when I tell you.

I will fucking do it.

  • End -

Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed! 💕


r/hamiltonmusical • • Jan 07 '24

Soooo..

0 Upvotes

I saw this comment that I thought as kinda confusing

It was and I’m Not directly quoting that “Hamilton Was anti -i immigrant's”

Which makes no sense because Alexander Hamilton was a imigrint from Charlestown Nevis

And it’s in the first song you don’t have to pick up a book and read about him and how he migrates to New York Or to the “Mainland“

Just you wait!
(In New York, you can be a new man) Just you wait!
In New York, you can be a new man
In New York! (New York)
Just you wait!

The ship is in the harbor now
See if you can spot him (just you wait)
Another immigrant
Comin' up from the bottom (just you wait)
His enemies destroyed his rep
America forgot him

Another thing I saw that made no sense was that Eliza was also against immigrants which also is stupid because she married a immigrant Alexander Hamilton which is why she is referred to as Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton

on that note is was claimed that Eliza (just calling her that because its easier to type out) would not allow immigrants into her orphanage the the New York Orphan Asylum Society or the Graham Windham orphanage which goes against the point of the association

if you find any sources that go with the claims let me know