We bought a townhouse two years ago, that came with an Irving oil boiler, which I believe is around 26 years old. It heats the hydronic baseboards and previously provided our domestic hot water. Its one of those that always has to stay on no matter what (Although i keep it off in the summer).
Since we moved in, we installed mini-splits and switched to an electric hot water tank. The oil boiler is now strictly a secondary heating source, mainly used as a backup during extremely cold weather.
The boiler is getting pretty old and it will need replacing, along with the outdoor oil tank (I think it has 2 years left per maintenance guy). I currently try to keep the tank full just in case, but I’m starting to question whether it’s worth maintaining an oil heating system that I barely use. I am also spending money keeping it full even though it barely gets used. I also have to pay someone to come and clean it every year.
I have considered a few options:
Electric baseboards: I would have to remove the existing hydronic baseboards and replace them with electric baseboards for backup heating. I would also need to upgrade my amp to 200.
Electric boiler: Keep the existing hydronic system but i hear these type of boilers increase the power bill tremendously. Would still need to upgrade amp to 200.
Propane boiler: Convert the existing system to propane, although I’m not sure this makes financial sense for something that’s only used occasionally.
Replace Oil furnace : There are apparently new oil furnaces that have cold start that don't stay on all the time. Would still need to replace the tank outside.
Has anyone made a similar switch? I believe a lot of people are in the same boat in NS given that high number houses still use of oil. For people that switched, what option did you choose and how much did it cost, and are you happy with your decision?