r/guygavrielkay • • May 30 '25

Written on the Dark Part 3 Spoilers (ALL SPOILERS) Was Written on the Dark... Spoiler

1 Upvotes

just bad? He seems to be going down hill with his last few books and lost the magic of his previous works. Especially with the Joan of arc character the book just went downhill in the later parts. Did I miss something?


r/guygavrielkay • • Jan 14 '25

Question Why do people dislike his writing stile?

0 Upvotes

Seems ok to me.


r/guygavrielkay • • Jul 21 '26

Discussion Simon Vance’s narration of Under Heaven sounds like he’s in a hurry to get it overwith.

0 Upvotes

I don’t know why his narration isn’t working for this one, usually his readings are near flawless.

He sounds like he’s got half his body out of the office door and his keys in the ignition.

What a dry and blah reading. Anyone else think this one is oddly boring and dispassionate?


r/guygavrielkay • • Aug 06 '26

Discussion The World of Two Moons is actually Mars billions of years ago… fan theory.

3 Upvotes

Mars is the only planet in our solar system with two moons, and the only one that may have once harbored life.

Now, I’m only a person who likes watching space documentaries and listening to astronomy lectures, but am by no means an expert.

There’s a ton I don’t know.

But, I often think about Kay’s worlds, and I think it would be cool if his world was actually Mars billions of years in the past.

The idea of panspermia comes to mind as an explaination to how humans emerged on earth billions of years later. Perhaps the world of two moons is a genetically ancestral home of ours with its own history we know nothing about.

All of it is a huge maybe.. very unlikely. But fun to think about.


r/guygavrielkay • • Aug 04 '25

Question tigana - why was devin at the hunting lodge?

1 Upvotes

Just started chapter 5 of the book and im confused about why Devin decided to go to the hunting lodge last chapter? Did he just decide to go there after hiding in the closet with Catriana and overhearing Tomasso? Maybe I‘ve accidentaly skipped a page while reading but i dont remember when and why he decided to do it


r/guygavrielkay • • Dec 11 '25

Discussion I pretend that Song for Arbonne, Tigana, Under Heaven and Lions of Al-Rassan are in the same world, because I think that’s really how it should be.

19 Upvotes

Some of you have seen me express mild irritation at the unnecessary amount of different worlds Kay’s stories take place in.

I’m reading Under Heaven again this week (total masterpiece) and I just cannot understand why this story couldn’t have even set in the same “World of Two Moons” that Lions, Brightness, Last Light, Children, Seas, Sarantine Mosaic, etc are all set in.

Why not just set the continent on a different region of the planet? It would make so much sense, it wouldn’t disrupt a thing. In fact it would make the world far richer.

Same with Tigana, and Arbonne…

Simply making these brilliant stories part of the same world as Lions and the rest would be absolutely brilliant, and far easier to manage.

I look at Kay’s work as a collection of epic stories set in different continents/eras of the same world, because why not?

I think Kay’s work is near flawless, and this is the only thing about his work that bugs me… what a missed opportunity for world expansion/building.

So instead of a single, manageable world, we have like 5 different planets in Kay’s universe and three of them only have one story in it.

Why do this?

The stories are great, but if you’re going to write entirely in secondary worlds, why create several that only have one story?

Make it part of your larger canon.

Making two entirely separate planets that just happen to have two moons of identical characteristics is absolutely poor planning and just silly.

The most silly thing I’ve ever encountered in fiction.


r/guygavrielkay • • Sep 05 '25

Question Is Kay’s World of Two Moons called Sarantine?

5 Upvotes

I was watching a video on how to properly approach Kay’s books according to setting, and which books are set in the same world as others and which ones are not.

This is a subject that Kay himself has never given due attention publicly. Hence the need for guidance videos.

In this video, the host laid out each book and organized the according to the world they belong to. Then gave a recommended reading order.

Lions of Al-Rassan, A Brightness Long Ago and Written on the Dark are all set in the, as he put it, “Sarantine” world.

Is this the correct way to put it?

I’ve always seen it called World of Two Moons.

——

On a side note, this is something I find mildly irritating about Kay’s otherwise flawless bibliography. He doesn’t give the reader a clear idea of which books are and aren’t set in the same world, and part of that issue is this insistence to never give the world a definitive name that’s clear and memorable to readers.

He never addresses this in interviews as far as I can tell.

And yes, I know that these are standalone and don’t need to be read in any sort of order, but chronology isn’t the issue, it’s a clear idea of setting, history and place.

This is something I think Kay could give more attention to. And publishers could also do a better job in their marketing.


r/guygavrielkay • • May 30 '26

Discussion I read The Lions of Al-Rassan and I don't know what I feel (spoilers) Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Hey.

Let me say right away that I don't think The Lions of Al-Rassan is a bad book. I still rate it positively, but I just... I have my issues with this novel.

As for my favorite character, I think it's the inexperienced Alvar. I thought I'd love Rodrigo and/or Ammar, but even though their characters had a lot of "aura farming," I didn't grow attached to them. Besides, I wasn't convinced by the "triangle," which had an obvious ending – Rodrigo had a wife and he wasn't a cheating husband.

This also influenced the final duel between Rodrigo and Ammar. It was obvious that Rodrigo - husband and father - would die, and Ammar would get his happy ending with Jehane. Although I admit, the author tried to confuse the issue in the epilogue by suggesting that Alvar might have married Jehane.

Overall, Jehane was just okay, but I didn't care for her.

King Badir, his chancellor Masur, and Zabira are also strong characters. Zabira is simply my weakness for the femme fatale/seductive woman trope, when it's not done superficially. It's unknown what ultimately happened to her, but in my headcanon, King Badir somehow ensured her and her children's safety, if only because of his chancellor's sacrifice.

Overall, I feel this book is the most cruel in terms of punishments against people and the lack of respect for corpses. I know it was realistic, and such punishments probably existed in the historical period the author was inspired by, but I simply felt anger at cruel punishments that made sense to characters from specific cultures. It's as if cruelty make sense. It simply doesn't.

Of the GGK books I've read so far, this one is the most religious, and I simply don't accept the notions that religion makes some people superior and others inferior and "infidels," and that "infidels" can be killed, tortured, or their corpses desecrated. The author isn't saying these views are right or disapprove of them, but I simply felt anger at such views because I don't accept them.

Overall, it's not a bad book. I had a good time reading it. I just feel like the historical period that inspired the author for this novel doesn't resonate with me at all. I also have a problem with Asian settings when they're too focused on honor and obedience to parents, who sometimes simply don't deserve obedience.

In any case, despite the still high quality, this is probably my least favorite GGK book I've read so far. Perhaps it will take some time for my opinion to soften.

Ranking:

  1. A Brightness Long Ago

  2. A Song for Arbonne

  3. Children of Earth and Sky

  4. Tigana

  5. The Lions of Al-Rassan


r/guygavrielkay • • May 15 '25

Image My tier list

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/guygavrielkay • • Nov 21 '24

Question Query from potential reader: are the sex scenes in the books easily skippable?

4 Upvotes

I've been really interested in GGK's books for a while now (...the writing style especially sounds like exactly my thing, and let's just say the Silmarillion is my favourite book so there's another) element of recommendation... but the things I have heard about the handling of romance and related subjects so far have worried me.

In short, I do not read erotica or books with erotica-adjacent elements and I do not wish to have any contact with explicit sex scenes. Are they of the variety where you can tell it's coming a mile away, or rare enough that one can say "skip chapters [7] and [13] and you're good", or is impossible to avoid them?


r/guygavrielkay • • Sep 04 '26

Discussion Lions of Al Rassan discussion [spoiler] Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Cards on the table this is my first GGK book and I enjoyed it. Solid 7 out of 10.

However, I liked the main characters and thought there were some great ideas, but I constantly felt like there was far more story being set up than actually told.

My biggest issue is that so many interesting arcs and plot threads are underdeveloped or skipped over.Alvar's transformation, Diego's family visions, the Muwardis and the kings brother who's hand gets chopped off, a number of political players all felt like they were introduced with significance and then abandoned. The final chapter and epilogue alone contain enough major life events to fill another novel, yet they're covered in a handful of paragraphs.

I think it was aiming for the melancholy of two great men being forced to kill each other, but for me the melancholy came from feeling like I was reading the outline of a great story rather than the story itself. The book kept moving past the parts I was most interested in.

I suppose the thing id be interested in others opinions on is that I think the novel would have been stronger to be expanded on into a second book that explored these storylines and themes. Alvar for example goes from religious warrior to a religious convert doctor and much of that change happens off page.

I think that by the end I was left wanting more of the story from the build up.


r/guygavrielkay • • Jun 13 '25

Discussion GGK Novel Tierlist from a Fionavar-hater

Post image
12 Upvotes

I'm sorry GGK, please forgive me, but Fionavar was straight CHEEKS!!


r/guygavrielkay • • Aug 31 '26

Question Questions about Lions of Al-Rassan Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I’ve just finished reading Lions of Al Rassan and I loved it. It was my first book by GGV and it’s definitely got me excited to read some more of his work.

I do have some questions though about the book, particularly one chapter when they’re in Ragosa. First:

Ammar gives a poem to the King which causes a bit of confusion amongst the King and the Chancellor. It says:

“For the Bright Lord of Ragosa, long tenured on his dais, much loved, and deservedly, may there always be in times to come cool water from the moonlit pool and wine in the drinking glass”

Badir needs it explaining, and frankly so do I. Later it says Ammar meant it as a well wishing than a homage, save for the moonlit water line. I took it as Ammar noting that the King will be successful should Mazur stay by his side and advise him as that is the source of Badir’s power. But is there more to it than that?

Also in the same chapter Mazur sleeps with Zabira and she whispers something to him that she says “Ammar is troubled by something beyond divided loyalty…If I am right, it would be amusing in truth”. Something that Mazur would never have contemplated and causes him to rethink the poem. What would this have been?

Thanks!


r/guygavrielkay • • May 17 '22

Why does Ren Daiyan join the bandits at the beginning of River of Stars?

1 Upvotes

In the beginning of River of Stars, fifteen year old Ren Daiyan is conscripted as an impromptu bodyguard for a government official and kills seven bandits on his first escort mission. Daiyan then walks into the forest and joins the bandits. Years later, Ren is recruited by the government's military to fight against a barbarian invasion. What was Daiyan's motivation for joining the bandits, and what changed to make him willing to return to government service?


r/guygavrielkay • • May 29 '26

Discussion Song for Arbonne or Sarantine Mosaic?

7 Upvotes

I’m looking for my next GGK read and these two stand out the most to me! So far, I’ve only read Lions of Al-Rassan and overall loved it. The writing, setting, and characters were all beautifully done. I greatly appreciated the real-world parallels with the religious and political factions and found the narrative really compelling. I will say my one issue was with all the gratuitous sex scenes - they just felt unnecessary and didn’t contribute to the story. In particular, a major female character sleeping with a boy to “cure” his desire for her seemed a bit silly. Otherwise, great book!

Any further recommendations, especially between these two options? Thanks so much!


r/guygavrielkay • • Aug 31 '26

Question Sarantine Mosaic

8 Upvotes

Where is Ispahani? It is in the east I know that but I don’t see it in the map provided. Is it India?


r/guygavrielkay • • May 24 '26

Question Just finished and adored the Sarantine Mosaic, but… [SPOILERS] Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/guygavrielkay • • Dec 21 '25

Discussion A Brightness Long Ago: Remembering The Past That Once Was Spoiler

Thumbnail
sites.google.com
11 Upvotes

r/guygavrielkay • • Mar 11 '24

Should I read "The Lions of Al-Rassan" after not finishing "Tigana"?

11 Upvotes

A few years ago I tried reading "Tigana" and unfortunately I had to put it down because I was extremely confused about everything that was going on. I'm not sure if it was the writing or the actual story structure.

Someone recently recommended me "The Lions of Al-Rassan" and from the sinopsis it seems like something I could enjoy, but I'm afraid I'll end up not being able to finish it like Tigana.

So, could anyone very familiar with these works could tell me if "The Lions of Al-Rassan" is easier to read than "Tigana" or if it's about the same?


r/guygavrielkay • • Oct 02 '25

Question Anyone know where we can find the two Drabbles (100 word short stories) we wrote for Pixel Project?

3 Upvotes

Just curious. Cant seem to find them or even a place to donate from the original charity thing.

Here's a post about it

https://brightweavings.com/journal/2014/05/02/against-violence-against-women/

Thanks


r/guygavrielkay • • Sep 03 '26

Image What Crispin's work could be

Thumbnail en.wikipedia.org
14 Upvotes

r/guygavrielkay • • Sep 08 '25

Question Just finished Written on the Dark and question

4 Upvotes

Am I crazy or did GGK just literally put himself in the book


r/guygavrielkay • • Jan 02 '26

Question Is Neal Stephenson a GGK fan?

4 Upvotes

In NS's fantastic 2007 novel Anathem, the oldest, wisest and most powerful character--as in, able to move between, and manipulate, alternate realities to change the future--is named Jad. ("Fra Jad," a sort of wizard of Knowledge. It's complicated.)

Always wondered if he borrowed the name from GGK.


r/guygavrielkay • • Dec 07 '24

Question Newbie question on the lions of al rassan

4 Upvotes

70 pages in. Like it very much. So beautiful. Some of the words are new to me. Whats a Wadji?


r/guygavrielkay • • Jun 22 '25

Question Hello, I'm New. Help pls, I heard

4 Upvotes

That guy garviel kay in his books writes short descriptions when characters part, about how that meeting changed their lives in a brief description. Can someone please inform me of some excerpts like that? I haven't read any of the books yet.