Like the rest of you, I am distressed by how Tony Carver is treating his daughter. I'm sure, furthermore, that he is meant to be unsympathetic, at least at this point, and we're supposed to feel stressed and unhappy.
But people are calling him abusive and the worst dad and demanding an intervention from Jimmy Jims. While I am very much looking forward to that, we haven't actually seen Tony be all that awful.
Here's a list of the things Tony has done to his daughter that are bad:
Not seeing her for years cuz he was in space or whatever
Embarrassing her in class, not warning her he was going to show up, and making her remove her makeup
Make her repeat 9th year
Make her give up Renard
Be pretty strict and harsh and not like give her hugs or anything
Three of these things: making her remove her makeup and embarrassing her, making her give up Renard, and not seeing her for years, are actually pretty normal and reasonable dad things. Lots of dads don't like their teenage daughters wearing makeup and try to control what they wear. Being embarrassed by your dad in front of your peers is pretty much a part of growing up, and if a dad does it on purpose, well that's worse but not the end of the world so long as it's not a pattern. Lots of dads have important jobs that require them to be away from home for extended periods of time. And lots of dads would be disturbed by the idea of their daughter hanging around with a body-stealing demon who killed a guy while trying to woo her mother. That's super creepy from an outside perspective, and it's perfectly understandable he would want to take Renard from her. As for making her repeat ninth year, while super harsh and probably the wrong decision, from the perspective of someone who is worried what kind of habits his daughter has formed in her absence and the peer group she built, and especially from a teacher who takes learning super seriously, it's not totally unreasonable. We live in a world where parents are sometimes allowed to make probably bad decisions for their children like this. It's not right, but it's not as unreasonable as it first appears either.
Less defensible are the lack of warning he gives her and the lack of affection he shows her. But even then, it wasn't that uncommon all that long ago for dads to be unaffectionate. I know my grandfather was never very affectionate to my father. Not that he didn't love him and didn't support him, but simply that hugs and "I love you" and so on didn't happen. My dad turned out okay and doesn't seem too bothered by it. And not warning her, while totally a dick move, seems pretty much like a Tony thing to do. I bet Jimmy Jims, Anja, and, uh, whatever Kat's dad's name is, I forgot, didn't get much advance notice either.
Tony is a bad dad, and he definitely deserves a kick to the dick. But he isn't the worst dad or even abusive from what we've seen so far. If the controlling behavior continues and the lack of affection is ever more than Tony being Tony, well....