r/guncontrol • • Oct 12 '21

Meta The harmful effects of guns and why we support gun control

266 Upvotes

The goal of this post will serve as a compilation of research explaining our primary arguments against guns and in favor of gun control. It is, by no means, comprehensive, and a lot of research and many smaller arguments are being left out, but it is an excellent starting point.

The effect of guns on suicide

The majority of gun deaths are suicide, nearly 60% in fact. However, because these deaths are self-inflicted, people often have a tendency to dismiss them with the argument that guns aren't responsible for these deaths because suicides would happen anyway. This could not be further from the truth. As it turns out, guns have a significant impact on suicide rates. The Harvard injury control center has a good page on the topic. This GMU study, this study on the link between access to firearms and suicide, and a study on handgun ownership and suicide in California all find a significant correlation between the prevalence of guns and suicide rates. The main reason why this is the case is because guns make suicide much easier. They provide a quick and painless death. In fact, suicides by gun have the highest completion rate, at 89.6%. As a result, those who commit suicide by gun simply don't find other methods to be acceptable. From Cook and Goss's 2020 book (The gun debate: what everyone needs to know):

Teen suicide is particularly impulsive, and if a firearm is readily available, the impulse is likely to result in death. It is no surprise, then, that households that keep firearms on hand have an elevated rate of suicide for all concerned—the owner, spouse, and teenaged children. While there are other highly lethal means, such as hanging and jumping off a tall building, suicidal people who are inclined to use a gun are unlikely to find such a substitute acceptable. Studies comparing the 50 states have found gun suicide rates (but not suicide with other types of weapons) are closely related to the prevalence of gun ownership. It is really a matter of common sense that in suicide, the means matter. For families and counselors, a high priority for intervening with someone who appears acutely suicidal is to reduce his or her access to firearms, as well as other lethal means.

The link between making it easier to commit suicide and elevated suicide rates doesn't just apply to guns. Its been noticed long before, pertaining to carbon monoxide gas in Britain:

Between 1963 and 1975 the annual number of suicides in England and Wales showed a sudden, unexpected decline from 5,714 to 3,693 at a time when suicide continued to increase in most other European countries. This appears to be the result of the progressive removal of carbon monoxide from the public gas supply. Accounting for more than 40 percent of suicides in 1963, suicide by domestic gas was all but eliminated by 1975. Few of those prevented from using gas appear to have found some other way of killing themselves.

Removing easy methods of committing suicide drastically decreases suicide rates. This Harvard article goes over the issue in more depth.

All that said, some argue that this is a good thing, because people should have the right to end their own life, but what they're missing is that the vast majority of the people who commit suicide by gun don't actually want to kill themselves. Such violent suicides often happen during a depressive episode, within hours or even minutes of the thought of suicide occurring and 90% of people who attempt suicide do NOT go on to die by suicide later on. The majority of people who attempt suicide regret it shortly after. The reality is that firearms are a huge risk factor for suicide.

Guns and Homicide

The next largest group of gun deaths come from homicide. Here too, gun advocates often claim that the removal of guns will not significantly impact homicide rates, yet research shows this to be untrue. Most criminologists and social scientists tend to agree with the fact that guns are linked to increased violence and death. While guns don't necessarily increase crime rates, they do greatly intensify crime. Crimes involving guns often much more violent and lead to far more injuries and deaths. The association is clear, more guns lead to more homicides.

According to a book by Cook and Goss 2020:

Finally, it is worth emphasizing that the conclusion is not “more guns, more crime.” Research findings have been quite consistent in demonstrating that gun prevalence has little if any systematic relationship to the overall rates of assault and robbery. The strong finding that emerges from this research is that gun use intensifies violence, making it more likely that the victim of an assault or robbery will die. The positive effect is on the murder rate, not on the overall violent-crime rate. In other words: more guns, more deaths.

On top of the research cited by the book, there have been many studies establishing the link between prevalence of guns and homicide, such as Hemenway and Miller 2000, Killias 1993, a literature review by Hemenway and Hepburn. HICRC has a page on this as well.

That said, we should keep in mind that there is less research on this topic than there would've been as a result of NRA's lobbying that resulted in a ban on using federal funds for research on gun violence.

Guns and Self-defense

The main argument in favor of guns is that guns are important to society because they're primarily used as a method of self-defense, to protect yourself and your property, and that a law-abiding citizen with a gun is the best solution to a criminal with a gun. However, this argument doesn't really hold under scrutiny because research shows that guns are far more often used to threaten, intimidate, or escalate situations than in self-defense:

Using data from surveys of detainees in six jails from around the nation, we worked with a prison physician to determine whether criminals seek hospital medical care when they are shot. Criminals almost always go to the hospital when they are shot.  To believe fully the claims of millions of self-defense gun uses each year would mean believing that decent law-abiding citizens shot hundreds of thousands of criminals. But the data from emergency departments belie this claim, unless hundreds of thousands of wounded criminals are afraid to seek medical care.  But virtually all criminals who have been shot went to the hospital, and can describe in detail what happened there.

Victims use guns in less than 1% of contact crimes, and women never use guns to protect themselves against sexual assault (in more than 300 cases).  Victims using a gun were no less likely to be injured after taking protective action than victims using other forms of protective action.  Compared to other protective actions, the National Crime Victimization Surveys provide little evidence that self-defense gun use is uniquely beneficial in reducing the likelihood of injury or property loss.

We found that one in four of these detainees had been wounded, in events that appear unrelated to their incarceration.  Most were shot when they were victims of robberies, assaults and crossfires. Virtually none report being wounded by a “law-abiding citizen.”

Self-defense gun uses are rather rare, and aren't effective at preventing injury. Additionally, there is a very good chance that most reported self defense gun uses aren't legal to begin with. This study took advantage of stand-your-ground laws to assess the resulting increase in death and they find that unlawful homicide make up most of the increases. Also see this study, where most judges report that the majority of self defense gun uses were probably illegal.

While the argument that guns enable weaker people to defend themselves makes sense at first, it doesn't hold up to further scrutiny, because more vulnerable groups like women rarely, if at all, use guns in self-defense.

Accidents and Gun Safety

Of course, it is rather obvious that more guns result in more unintentional firearm deaths, but it is a noteworthy point, because not everyone properly stores guns, even after training. There research indicates that even with proper training, many people still do not properly store guns. These two studies found that firearm training either had no effect or actually increased the storage of guns in an unsafe manner. However, it should be noted that there also research that finds otherwise, so it may be helpful to mandate gun safety and training as a requirement for purchasing a gun.

All that said, it is clear that not everyone receives training, because unintentional deaths continue to happen.

Economic Cost of Guns

Gun violence is expensive, not just because of the cost of more deaths to the economy, but also the impact of dealing with those deaths and the violence itself. One report finds that gun violence costed America around $280 billion in 2018:

Ted Miller, a health economist and researcher at the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation who worked on the report, pointed to work and quality-of-life costs as the largest. Work losses refer to lost income because of firearm-related death or disability, while quality-of-life costs are more indirect losses from gun violence -- pain, suffering, a loss of well-being for victims and families -- that researchers quantified using jury awards and victim settlements as guides.

This doesn't sound like much, until you consider opportunity cost. i.e what this $280 billion could be used for. Without guns, not only would we have a better average quality of life from the get go, but $280 billion per year would be enough to accomplish a variety of policy objectives. In fact, it alone is enough to pay for a large portion of the $3.5 trillion spending bill proposed by the Democratic party. It would be enough to pass public option health insurance, double the child tax credits and make them permanent thereby ending child poverty as a whole, help low income people pay college tuition, and many more policy proposals that can dramatically improve the overall quality of life in the USA.

Proper gun control policy can help mitigate this issue:

Gun policy also may contribute to state gun violence costs, the report found. In Louisiana, among the states with the highest levels of gun deaths, the cost to residents averages out to $1,793 per person each year. In Massachusetts, which has strict gun laws and the lowest rate of gun deaths in the country, the average per-person annual cost is $261.

There are other reports that reach slightly different conclusions, such as this report which finds a $229 billion price tag and some others which find similar numbers.

Effects on other countries

Yes, the effects of lax gun control in America aren't limited to America itself. The flow of guns from the USA to Latin America gets ignored, but it is a huge issue:

Research shows that a majority of guns in Mexico can be traced to the U.S. A report from the U.S Government Accountability Office showed that 70 percent of guns seized in Mexico by Mexican authorities and submitted for tracing have a U.S. origin. This percentage remains consistent, said Bradley Engelbert, a spokesperson for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.

A report from the Center of American Progress found that the United States was the primary source of weapons used in crime in Mexico and Canada. Other countries in Central America can also trace a large proportion of guns seized in crimes to the United States. For example, the report found that from 2014 to 2016, 49 percent of crime guns seized in El Salvador were originally purchased in the U.S. In Honduras, 45 percent of guns recovered in crime scenes were traced to the United States as well.

Lax gun regulation in America exacerbates violent crime across the border, and may even be the cause of some of the refugees showing up to the border, considering that escaping violence and poverty is the primary reason for their entry to the USA.

Additionally, WaPo has an article documenting how sniper rifles bought in Houston is being used by drug cartels to murder both American and Mexican policemen.

Effective Gun control policy

Now, we reach the point where we ask the question, "what should we do about all this"? Well there is plenty of research indicating that many gun control policies can help mitigate the effects of guns on American (and global) society:

  1. Stronger, universal background checks that use federal, state, and local data. This study finds that more background checks are associated with lower homicide rates. This study finds that universal background checks were associated with a 14.9% reduction in overall homicide rates. And this study finds a 40% reduction in Connecticut. This article outlines how repealing licensing law in Missouri led to a significant increase in murders.

  2. Removing stand-your-ground laws. Stand-your-ground laws are seen as important for encouraging self-defense, but their overall impact is really just making encounters more dangerous. This study finds that self defense laws increase deaths by 8%. This study found that stand your ground laws increased the homicide rate.

  3. Wait times. Waiting periods are shown to effectively reduce homicide rates. This study finds that wait times reduced homicide rates by 17% in DC. A Rand article finds that waiting periods decrease homicides and suicides. Waiting periods are usually ineffective if the purchaser already has a gun, but it is very effective if someone who doesn't have a gun tries to purchase a gun for nefarious use.

  4. Mandatory Gun Safety training. It isn't always effective, but it can help.

  5. Safe storage and Child Access Prevention laws. There's been a decent amount of evidence indicating that gun storage and safety laws significantly reduce injuries and death by guns. This study finds that unintentional firearm deaths among young people fell by 23% in 12 states where safe storage laws had been in effect for at least one year. This study found that states requiring gun locks experienced a 68% lower suicide rate compared with states that had no similar requirement. This meta-analysis (and this) of 18 different gun policies by the RAND Corporation found that CAP laws have reduced both firearm suicides and accidental shootings among young people. For further reading, see: this, this, and this.

This is by no means a comprehensive list, but the general point is that a society without guns is safer, healthier, and even richer due to the economic cost of guns. Pursuing strong federal gun control reform is more than worth it, though the ideal is a society without guns at all.


r/guncontrol • • May 29 '22

Article Today's edition of the NYT has a brilliant, horrifying cover

Post image
217 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Nov 11 '22

Meme/Image How about that...

Post image
156 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Oct 13 '21

Peer-Reviewed Study Gun Control Measures we Know are Effective at Reducing Death

133 Upvotes

I wanted to update this post with some updated studies and facts.

Here's what we know to be true, so far, based on peer-reviewed, published studies that have stood up to replication.

Waiting periods reduce death:

Vars, Robinson, Edwards, and Nesson

Luca, Malhotra, and Poliquin

Eliminating Stand Your Ground laws reduce death:

Cheng and Hoekstra

Webster, Crifasi, and Vernick

Humphreys, Gasparrini, and Wiebe

Child Access Prevention Laws are effective at reducing death:

Schnitzer, Dykstra, Trigylidas, and Lichenstein

Webster et al.

Gun Accidents can be prevented with gun control:

Webster and Starnes

RAND Analysis

Stronger Concealed Carry Standards are Linked to Lower Gun Homicide Rates:

Donohue, et al.

Xuan, et al.

Background checks that use federal, state, local, and military data are effective:

Sen and Panjamapirom

Siegel et al.

Rudolph, Stuart, Vernick, and Webster

Suicide rates are decreased by risk-based firearm seizure laws:

Kivisto et al.

Mandated training programs are effective:

Crifasi, Pollack, and Webster

Rudolph et al.


r/guncontrol • • Mar 26 '21

Meme/Image I'm from a small town in Eastern KY. This is an actual fundraiser they are running for a local Little League...

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Jul 16 '18

Article NRA Illegally Used Shell Company to Coordinate With GOP

Thumbnail
lawandcrime.com
121 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Feb 19 '18

Meme/Image What Does Your Decency Cost

Post image
115 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • May 26 '22

Meme/Image It’s almost as though laws affect society?

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Jun 19 '22

Meme/Image Republicans strategy.

Post image
105 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Apr 20 '25

Peer-Reviewed Study Gun Control Measures we Know are Effective at Reducing Death

104 Upvotes

This is an updated list of research on the topic, developing off of previous posts by others on the sub. Here's what we know to be true, so far, based on peer-reviewed, published pieces of research that have stood up to replication and scientific scrutiny.

Gun free zones reduce death:

Reeping, et. al

Waiting periods reduce death:

Vars, Robinson, Edwards, and Nesson

Luca, Malhotra, and Poliquin

Eliminating Stand Your Ground laws reduce death:

Cheng and Hoekstra

Webster, Crifasi, and Vernick

Humphreys, Gasparrini, and Wiebe

Child Access Prevention Laws are effective at reducing death:

Schnitzer, Dykstra, Trigylidas, and Lichenstein

Webster et al.

The SAFE Act reduced death:

Karaye et. al

Gun Accidents can be prevented with gun control:

Webster and Starnes

RAND Analysis

Stronger Concealed Carry Standards are Linked to Lower Gun Homicide Rates:

Donohue, et al.

Xuan, et al.

Background checks that use federal, state, local, and military data are effective:

Sen and Panjamapirom

Siegel et al.

Rudolph, Stuart, Vernick, and Webster

Suicide rates are decreased by risk-based firearm seizure laws:

Kivisto et al.

Mandated training programs are effective:

Crifasi, Pollack, and Webster

Rudolph et al.

More gun control in general saves lives:

Hurka and Knill

Jehan et. al

Decreasing gun ownership overall reduces death:

Sharkey et. al


r/guncontrol • • Feb 17 '18

Article Couple who owned gun store that sold AR-15 to school shooter Nikolas Cruz shutter their business for good and vow to support gun control legislation in wake of Valentine's Day massacre

Thumbnail
dailymail.co.uk
103 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Jan 21 '25

Discussion White House office of gun violence is now gone

91 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Mar 10 '18

Meme/Image The US and the rest of the world

Thumbnail
imgur.com
87 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Sep 10 '25

Meme/Image Kirk was making a racist argument to minimize gun violence when he was shot

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Nov 21 '22

BRIGADED "But the AR 15 is for home defense!"

Post image
80 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • May 19 '18

Meme/Image Police have identified the accomplices in today's school shooting

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Apr 01 '23

Meme/Image Where is the lie here? Why does it vary so much!

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Jul 02 '22

Article New York passes new, more restrictive gun laws following SCOTUS decision

72 Upvotes

The new law requires applicants display “good moral character,” pass a firearm safety course and provide data from their social media accounts as part of strengthened background checks. Licensing agents will review each applicant, and individuals who are denied will be given a chance to appeal. Applicants must participate in a firearm safety course, undergo “enhanced screening” with in-person interviews and submit to reviews of their social media. Additionally, the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services will review permit holders’ records monthly for criminal convictions, criminal indictments and protection orders.

Purchasing ammunition would also trigger a background check by DCJS, and the bill further restricts the types of body armor that can be sold. Hochul will tear up a deal struck under her predecessor Andrew Cuomo that stalled the implementation of an ammo sales database.

It also defines “sensitive locations” — such as schools, polling places and certain public gathering areas — where weapons are off-limits for most permit holders. The law also designates “sensitive places” where illegally possessing a firearm constitutes a class E felony. Such locations include government buildings; any location providing health, behavioral health or chemical dependence care or services; any place of worship or religious observation; libraries; public playgrounds; public parks; zoos; the location of any state funded or licensed programs; educational institutions both in elementary and higher education; any vehicle used for public transportation; all public transit including airports and bus terminals; bars and restaurants; entertainment, gaming and sporting events and venues; polling places; any public sidewalk or public area restricted for a special event; and protests or rallies. The law also prohibits firearms on private property, unless the property owner allows it. Business owners can display a sign on their property to allow concealed carry weapons on the premises. If there is no sign, concealed carry permit owners should assume firearms are off-limits.

Several groups are exempt, including current and retired law enforcement, peace officers, security guards who have a special armed registration card, and active-duty military. The law also allows hunting and hunting education, with the proper licensing.

Once Hochul signs it, the law will go into effect on Sept. 1 and the DCJS will implement a background check database and gun training courses by April.

You can read more in this NYT article and this piece from Politico.


r/guncontrol • • Mar 16 '18

Meme/Image Back in my day...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
70 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Oct 03 '17

Article Australia confiscated 650,000 guns. Murders and suicides plummeted.

Thumbnail
vox.com
70 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Dec 27 '20

Meme/Image Gun-related deaths are a major problem in the US compared to other countries, despite high comparative wealth

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Jun 01 '18

Article The NRA warned Dick’s Sporting Goods sales would plummet after banning guns. The opposite happened.

Thumbnail
thinkprogress.org
67 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • May 02 '24

Discussion People should have the right to own atomic bombs.

63 Upvotes

Atomic bombs don't kill people. The people who would set them off would make us responsible atomic bomb owners look bad but that shouldn't tarnish our constitutional rights and prevent us from owning atomic bombs. I would only use my atomic bombs for defence purposes (e.g. if someone from a different continent wanted to launch their atomic bomb at me I could retaliate or bomb them before they bomb me). Moreover, if every individual has atomic bombs nobody will actually use them because they would be too scared so they will 100% just prevent an atomic apocalypse. I am simply an atomic bomb enthusiast and don't actually plan to set one off. The current communist government is preventing mass manufacturing and sales of atomic bombs to individuals because they hate this country and the economy. Imagine how much better our economy would be with millions of atomic bomb sales to atomic bomb enthusiasts like myself annually.


r/guncontrol • • Jun 07 '18

Article 'Swatting' David Hogg wasn't a 'prank,' it was attempted murder

Thumbnail
latimes.com
63 Upvotes

r/guncontrol • • Sep 10 '24

Meme/Image Thoughts and prayers everyone

Post image
62 Upvotes