Claire talks about “music production” from 26:30 onwards and has absolutely no idea what she is talking about. It seems that the interviewer (a mathematician) knows more about music production than her. It feels that he is subtly roasting her at the same time.
————————
Transcription:
Grimes: 00:26:30 For a neuroscience class, yeah, just generate tones and various things or whatever. And so I went home and just made an EP. Because I was just like, "Wow. This is so fun." Also free software, yes. And then I basically just had-
Sean Carroll: 00:26:43 You were good at it.
Grimes: 00:26:44 It's so funny because people were like, "Oh ..." Not that it was easy, but people ... Basically my first music kind of went viral, so it was just ... I definitely didn't work for it my whole life. I just definitely randomly got super lucky.
Sean Carroll: 00:26:54 Yep. So yeah, sometimes, well-
Grimes: 00:26:56 With no musical ... And then I had to very quickly learn music very fast in front of a lot of people, which was very intense.
Sean Carroll: 00:27:03 So what does that mean, learning music? Did you learn to play instruments and things?
Grimes: 00:27:05 Yeah.
Sean Carroll: 00:27:06 Music theory, all that stuff?
Grimes: 00:27:07 I didn't learn music theory. I-
Sean Carroll: 00:27:08 The circle of fifths?
Grimes: 00:27:10 I don't know the circle of fifths. Just to play live and stuff, you just have to be good at doing stuff. Oh my God, I'd better learn-
Sean Carroll: 00:27:17 So really the practice, the practical-
Grimes: 00:27:19 And production. My first stuff was very low fidelity. I had to very quickly learn about how to be a good producer and make things sound ... engineering I guess, because yeah.
Sean Carroll: 00:27:29 So for most of your songs you had written the music, you've played the instruments to whatever extent that is, wrote the lyrics, did the singing and did the producing.
Grimes: 00:27:39 Yes.
Sean Carroll: 00:27:39 That's a lot of work it sounds like.
Grimes: 00:27:40 It's fun. It's fun though.
Sean Carroll: 00:27:42 Which is the most fun part?
Grimes: 00:27:43 Which is the most fun part. I mean, probably the producing cause it's like weird world-building. You make some weird-
Sean Carroll: 00:27:50 So for those who are again not experts, what does it mean to be producing music in the digital age? Is it like just modifying sounds, mixing tracks together, deciding what to include and not?
Grimes: 00:28:01 Yeah, basically. It's like cyber composing. You're just ... You've got a weird paint graph in front of you that is the song and you just sort of fiddle it together and put compressors and EQs and effects on things and kind of make it fall together.
Sean Carroll: 00:28:17 But you clearly need to know what the words like compressor and EQ mean.
Grimes: 00:28:20 You can ... I kind of just figured it out.
Sean Carroll: 00:28:22 You figured it out, yeah.
Grimes: 00:28:23 I was just like, "I'll just press these buttons to get it," kind of thing. And then you eventually just fall into it. It's like, I don't know.
Sean Carroll: 00:28:31 And I'm sure people would be different levels of skill at it, but it does sound ... I mean, your story is a good one in the sense that there might be other people out there who, if they were exposed to these tools, could really make music other people liked.
Grimes: 00:28:43 I mean, the one nice thing about production is, I mean, you do need to know things but you don't really need to know ... I mean, it's like the piano. If you sit down at a piano and you press a key, it kind of sounds just nice. There's sort of this inherent niceness to it and you can kind of deduce how to make it nice. You just-
Sean Carroll: 00:29:00 I mean hundreds of years of practice to make pianos that sound nice, right?
Grimes: 00:29:02 Okay, I mean ... yeah, yeah, so it's-
Sean Carroll: 00:29:03 Yes. We're blessed with that.
Grimes: 00:29:05 The tool set, there's a wonderful tool set available, so. And so you just need to figure out how to drive the tool set. And yeah, I think ... yeah.
Sean Carroll: 00:29:16 When you're performing live, are there people playing instruments or is it you at a keyboard like a-
Grimes: 00:29:20 It's kind of both. We're running certain things off Ableton, and then I'm triggering things off of Ableton and blah blah blah. And I'm also-
Sean Carroll: 00:29:26 So there's a little dynamic back and forth where things are happening by your choice in real time.
Grimes: 00:29:30 It's a mix of being, actually doing things and certain things running off of Ableton. But I used to actually do everything, like live loop and ... But that's when you're playing front of 50,000 people and you're trying to live loop something and you fuck something up or one weird sound. You just don't want to do that. I've definitely learned the hard way not to do that.