r/grandorder • • Jan 21 '25

Discussion Discussion to block X.com links

0 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing this topic on other subreddits and feel that the discussion deserves to be had here too.

Given the recent behavior of X/Twitter’s owner, I personally can’t stomach the thought of giving him another click.

That said, X/Twitter has been one of FGO’s main avenues for releasing announcements, and has relied on engagement there to fund certain campaigns within the game.

Personally, no amount of quartz would ever allow me to engage on such a platform with a clear conscience, but I’m curious what others think.

I’m hoping the mods also weigh in with their thoughts.


Addendum


There have been a lot of comments on this within the past three hours, and I wanted to make some additions to the post to both clarify a few things and address some of the responses received:

  1. This post was never a call to ban Twitter posts - only to open the floor to discussion. Given the state of other subreddits, it’s been a hot topic of debate over the course of the day, and, given how this sub’s subject matter is more reliant on Twitter (from official artists, to fan artists, to news, and to milestone campaigns) I felt that at least having the discussion was warranted.

I gave my personal (emphasis on Personal) two cents on the matter and opened the floor to discussion.

2) There is a clear majority of users who feel that a ban is unwarranted - for a variety of reasons that I feel are valid (such as the effect it would have on fan artists as well as Lasengle’s and associates of Lasengle’s own reliance on using X/Twitter) to - I feel - not so valid (“virtue signaling”, “sir this is a gacha game sub”, etc).

3) To those of you who gave valid criticisms and oppositions to the idea; thank you. I appreciate the insight and your civility.


r/grandorder • • Jun 28 '20

NA Discussion I hate that way Mash is endlessly inflicted on the story.

0 Upvotes

Mash gets way too much screentime its getting really annoying and affecting my enjoyment of the game.

When I first started FGO over a year ago I was indifferent to her but disliked her in the servant interludes where she appears for no reason and takes focus from the servant that should have the focus.

After the events at Solomon I actually liked her but that lasted only until the end of Agartha. Shimousa was great because she wasn't around but then Salem hits and she forces her way to be with the team of servants despite having zero combat ability at the time on the feeble excuse that she memorised all the lines in the play. Then she does literally nothing but take screentime from the rest of the servants and doesn't contribute to the action.
Yet the MC praises her to no end despite being useless. His interactions with her are always "I like you Mash A" or "I like you Mash B", he never critisizes her even though there are such options with other servants.

Nothing has changed in the Lostbelts, she is still clingy and annoying, she loves to speak in the most long winded way possible which annoys me and always points out the obvious and declares her next action out loud. Sigurd even pointed out to her how she blatanlty told him how her power works because she can't shut up. What happened to servants keeping their powers secret? Must she say 10 sorrys and 10 thank yous in one conversation? Obviously and exaggeration but you get my point.

I am currently in section 3 of Götterdämmerung and usually I can tolerate Mash because there are other characters around but now that its just her and the mc with no communication with the shadowborder so no cool banter from Da Vinci or Holmes, its become a chore to get through this part.

Mash is basically her own character but also the mouthpiece of the mc and the self-appointed narrator of the story. Kadoc pointed out how she used to be all quite but now she is too talkative and man do I wish she stayed that way.

Since FGO cover has Artoria, Jeanne and Mash couldn't they have given us the option to choose our main servant? I would have been fine with just the option between her and Galahad but that is too good to be true so at least give her a bit less screentime and let the MC narrate himself and have more dialouge...

How do you guys feel about this?


r/grandorder • • Aug 15 '18

Moderator A proposal for JP Releases

25 Upvotes

If you are looking for the Help Thread, click here

Hello, fellow Masters. With JP’s Summer Festival part 2 gacha coming up soon, we want to try out a new system for submitting posts on the subreddit after releases of new Servants and content to help organize everything and prevent spam. Here is the basic plan:

1 – An hour before the release goes live, we will put up individual Servant threads for each new servant and an event Megathread.

2 – Once the game goes live, we will place the sub under Restrictive Mode. This means that every new post submitted must be approved by a moderator before it is published on the subreddit. This will last for approximately 3 hours.

3 - During this time frame, you can still contribute information about the new Servants in their respective Servant threads. The moderator who made the Servant thread will update the information in the main post accordingly, with credit given to the user who provided the information.

4 – Once all expected information have been added, the sub will be returned to normal mode.

We would like to hear your thoughts on this new system and whether you have any other alternative suggestions to help combat the problem of spam flooding that is usually seen with new events and content.


r/grandorder • • Jan 12 '23

Cosplay I cosplayed swimsuit mash ❤️

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/grandorder • • Oct 14 '19

NA Discussion I thought Shimousa was bad and extremely dissapointing

0 Upvotes

Shimousa was incredibly dissapointing. It was super hyped but I honestly think it's even worse than Agartha and Shinjuku. At least Agartha had a unique setting and interesting locales which ignites my basic want when I play video games.

  • Musashis character is honestly crap. She came off more annoying than endearing. Compared to Columbus and Moriarty I just didn't like it when she was onscreen. I was worried i would like her and use quartz on her like on Moriarty.

  • Musashi is incredibly forced. She is not only an underpowered npc support the game forces you to use her and place her in your front lines. This becomes incredibly ludicrous against enemies like Tomoe or basically every boss that wasn't Ishun. Since she straightup proves to the player that she's a liability and then takes all the credit canonically in the story, I just end up hating her.

  • Theres been lots of jokes about the roundabout prose but it really is that bad. The story is several hours long and when the writing always feels padded it just gets boring. Not to mention all the wanking of how awesome each of the characters are

  • The setting is olde Japan and thats it. Not only that but the Japanese country side is legit beautiful yet all the areas we go to are shit we have seen in anime hundreds of times already

  • The other servant characters like Kiyo and Tamamo also feel very forced. Like they wanted you to like these characters so they reskinned a bunch of npcs with characters you already know and like.

  • Ga Ga Goo

  • There are too many villains, non get enough spotlight. Agartha and Shinjuku servants(save Dahut) have accumulated a fan base because they had just enough time in their respective stories to show off. Despite the 3 EORs having the same structure(go to a location and beat up a bad guy till we reach the end boss, rinse and repeat) Shimousa feels extremely repetitive due to its large cast of villains.

  • Theres not really many cool scenes till the end. Shinjuku had Saber riding a motorcycle, Jalter sacrificing herself, Headless horseman dismounting to shield Lobo.

  • Agartha had Penth in Nightless city ignoring you to fight Megalos. Penth and Megalos fight in the background during the river segment. Columbus rediscovering his NP to chain Megalos. Both failed and successful assaults on Eldorado and the ear drum shattering Amazonian roar. The entire fucking landmass rising from the ground. Wu coming in at the last minute to use her NP where Fergus "kills" himself and uses the mcguffin to resurrect and use his NP to break the landmass.

  • Sasaki was hyped up but he was completely underused and his fight at the end had extremely little build up to be impactful. The Fight was cool though

  • The whole castle rhyming thing to be Amakusas downfall
    The best thing about Shimousa was Muramasa and that's really it. I really hope Salem is better


r/grandorder • • Aug 21 '22

JP Discussion Everyone who likes the idea of less reruns, state your reasoning!

7 Upvotes

I'm all for it tbh. Plus I already know they'll most likely do something when it comes to the welfares. People are getting butthurt too quickly, it just started. I'm never gonna miss DW... We just got proto merlin into mobile, arcueid too. But one idea that doesn't seem right and everyone starts listing every reason why Lasengle sucks


r/grandorder • • Jul 25 '26

JP Spoilers The FGO finale is overhated and I'm tired of people saying it's bad. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

While we may agree that it's not perfect, it's not as bad as people say it is.

One of the main themes of the game is hopelessness and how people can do the right thing despite having everything against them. Chaldea simply ran into a problem that was beyond their capabilities from the start, yet they still did what they could.

The issue of memory erasure is debatable, and personally, i hate that kind of endings, however, in this particular case, it didn't bother me as much because i feel it reinforces the main message, and at the very least, Guda and Mash got the ending they deserved, they earned it.

Maybe it's because I'm more open-minded about bittersweet endings so who knows. Hopefully they address some plot points in the after time thing.

I'd give it a 7/10. It's not perfect, but it's a fitting ending at least for me.


r/grandorder • • Nov 14 '19

Discussion Why I think everyone losing their streaks actually matters far more than many may think

2 Upvotes

Over the past few days, I have seen a lot of opinions on the topic, from "it's worth the quartz" to "it does not matter since it happened to everyone" and finally, the ever-so-popular "let's pitchfork DW".

Personally, at the start, I did was a little saddened, but overall, since it affected everyone equally and I got to expand my Eresh fund, I did not pay it too much mind. Until a day later when I realized a couple of things.

Firstly, it is worth noting how the actual day of the maintenance went and how the reactions of the community varied as more information was brought in.

While the first few hours were indeed hurtful as well, I think the most interesting part to observe here is how the reactions changed once we were told there are only 2 hours to catch the streak (and the tickets alongside it). I was checking quite a few threads at that point, and noticed that a lot of people just outright said "Aight, suppose it is time for a casual 3 AM alarm", which I kind of expected. However, if you think about it, that just goes to show HOW dedicated people are when it comes to the tickets. I even think that most of those people would still stay if there were no tickets to be obtained, solely for the fact that they get to maintain their pride, a perfect login streak. I was also among these people.

Then we got the information that not even that would be possible and the time would be shifted only after the reset. Interestingly enough, some people still stayed up, just in hopes they would still manage to catch the streak somehow, even tho it was outright declared impossible.

As this was happening, I also checked a few reddit threads, as there was not much else to do. I particularly took interest in one thread, in which people discussed what they did to maintain their streak in the past. From stuff like buying wifi on a boat to getting an entire new device if the initial one was broken, a bunch of interesting stuff was written there.

This all just shows HOW dedicated people are to sentimental value. Now, how does this all connect with losing the streaks being a really BIG deal?

Well, I don't know about others, but I, too, have done quite some stuff just to maintain my streak. However, as I run both a JP and NA account, which reset at different times, I happened to break my streak in JP a long time ago. The result? Well, I no longer felt so incredibly obliged to log in everyday, and in the future, I broke it 2 or 3 more times. While this may not seem like a big deal at first, people refraining from logging in daily is the first step to actually quitting the game. Naturally, this is not the first login streak game I have played, and I can recall that often times, I'd keep launching the game way past the period that I actually played it for, just to get to keep that tasty streak. Often times, this even let to my passion for the game being lit anew, since I'd eventually give in and play it for a bit again.

And I know that while I have been keeping my login streak, there were times when I slacked off more than I should, for instance, when there was an event I did not have much interest in, a rerun, a long pause period or I was just too busy irl to constantly keep grinding.

I can imagine that someone who is not too invested in the Fate universe might even stop coming back regularly now, eventually resulting in them quitting overall.

I believe this is about all that is to be said without going into too much detail. I am aware that the people who post in this subreddit are usually a little more than just casual players, which is why the resolve to obliterate one's own sleep schedule was so abundant. However, even given that, I still think it reached far more people than is rational.

Lately, my thoughts going forward? I'll keep playing FGO and have no intention of quitting, I will just feel less obliged to log in everyday. To be honest, it's a bit of a relief too, as I no longer feel so indefinitely chained to daily logins in the game. Ultimately, while it sucks, and there were some 2k Fs in that "Press F for everyone's login streak" thread, I'll take my 34 SQ and shove it into the Ereshkigal fund.


r/grandorder • • Jun 26 '18

NA Discussion The past 24 hours is further proof FGO NA needs a community manager

9 Upvotes

The drama and negative feelings of the past 24 hours are unfortunate, but are something that could have been almost completely avoided with a competent Community Manager at the helm.
The anniversary announcement was surprisingly tone deaf and left the community feeling neglected. Even though we "know" what's coming thanks to JP's one year anniversary, events have been put on hold for a convention that not even 1% of the community will participate in. Rather than feeling like a celebration of the anniversary, all of the event rewards are now just "part of another convention" and have less of an impact because of it.

Hours later, a laundry list of QoL changes are quietly announced. These aren't part of the anniversary but are tied to the Camelot update coming this week. This is where the real failure lies; a proper community manager would have been able to use this as a HUGE deflection from the ill will generated by the anniversary announcement. With a bit of spin, these announcements could have been combined and moved towards the narrative of a longer anniversary celebration.

We'd like to wish you all a happy one year anniversary to Fate/Grand Order USA. We've worked hard this time to bring you a full celebration of events. Our team has gone hard and, as you know, is bringing you the Camelot Singularity to kick things off. In honor of the actual anniversary date, we'd like to show off the long list of Quality of Life changes we have in store. Finally, we invite you all to join us at AX 2018 for our capstone anniversary event. Until then, please enjoy the new Singularity.

Instead of neglect, the community is now engaged and has something positive to begin discussing. This doesn't even involve changing anything in-game or moving around planned rewards, but is simple spin to turn negative news back into positive conversation. Everyone's happy and you can build anticipation towards the AX event instead of resentment that the community is neglected for yet another convention.


r/grandorder • • Feb 27 '25

Discussion Ideas for black Fate Servants?

1 Upvotes

Alright, I know I'm kinda late to the party since Black History Month is almost over. But I've been giving it some thought and I'm genuinely curious; what black historical or legendary figures would make for cool Fate Servants? As we all know, there's a surprising lack of them (Ozymandias and King Tut don't count since they're Egyptian and based on what I've heard that's not really the same).

Now, to get this out of the way, I don't plan to bring up Yasuke, Mansa Musa or Shaka Zulu here. Those guys are awesome, I think they'd make great Servants, but everyone else thinks so too (they're some of the most popular suggestions for black Servants), and I'd rather suggest some more underrated yet still interesting choices that other folks haven't thought of before.

First off, my #1 pick, Toussaint Louverture, the slave-turned-general who led a successful slave revolt, the most significant leader of the Haitian Revolution and one of the Fathers of Haiti, who even clashed with the forces of Napoleon Bonaparte himself. In fact, his military prowess led to him being dubbed "The Black Napoleon." For that reason, perhaps he could also be an Archer, though most artwork depicts him with a big cutlass, so maybe Saber would be more fitting.

Secondly, there's York, a slave who contributed significantly to Lewis and Clark's American expedition. Despite being Clark's slave, he was treated no differently than his white colleagues. In addition to being a better swimmer than them, he was also a great shot with a rifle. Unfortunately, York was paid nothing despite his contributions to the expedition due to being a slave; additionally, contrary to popular belief, he was not freed after the expedition by Clark, who in fact got angry that he would not go back to being a slave after the expedition was over. Because of his skill with the rifle, I feel no other class would be more fitting for him than Archer.

Lastly, we have Mathieu da Costa, the first free black man to ever visit Canada. He accompanied the French there, and was a big help on account of being a skilled translator and mediator who knew many languages, including those of First Nations peoples. Based on that, I feel that he would be best suited as a Ruler.

Two honourary mentions who I wasn't sure how to approach: Anderson Ruffin Abbott, the first black Canadian to be a licensed physician, as well as being a coroner and surgeon who served in the American Civil War; and John Henry, the American folk hero who managed to beat a mechanical drill in a rock-boring contest with just his trusty hammer, only to die soon after from overexertion. I mention them here because I'm not sure what classes these guys could be, but I believe they would also be really cool.

Do you people have any other ideas for black Servants? I'd love to hear what you folks have in mind!


r/grandorder • • Aug 10 '20

JP Discussion Emiya with his buff is now a S tier farming god equal to Lancelot(except vs Lancers).

0 Upvotes

Team setup:Emiya,Merlin,Waver,Castoria(Plugsuit).Kscope on Emiya(no superscope needed).

Turn 1:Merlin buffs.Emiya NPs

Turn 2:Swap in the other 50%chargers,both use everything on Emiya.Emiya uses Trace On,converting his NP into Arts.Full refund(10 hit Arts AOE with insane buffs stacked yolo).

Turn 3:NP

Start picking Emiyas from the SR tickets bois.


r/grandorder • • Jul 18 '18

NA Discussion To AoJ, DW, and TM: The Lack of Respect for your Western Customers and Fans.

27 Upvotes

While there is a good chance this post will be lost amid the recent developments in FGOJP and because it retreads old ground, I was inspired to post it by a thread I saw on here earlier and some reading I've done over the past few days in an attempt to get my thoughts across to the people who have the power to address these complaints.

First I would like to address AoJ (Aniplex of Japan) and DW with regards to the current state of FGONA and their silence on the matter either directly or via AoA (Aniplex of America).

It has been at least two months since a portion of the fanbase of FGONA on here, Twitter, Facebook, and other places began to voice their discontent with how FGONA is being treated compared to how FGOJP has been treated both in the past and currently. For the most part AoJ, DW, and AoA have been silent on this issue despite the fact that Shiokawa was recently in the US for the first anniversary of FGONA, where in a non-direct interview he addressed the complaint about there being no subtitles in FGONA for important things such as the Demon Pillar boss fights and both Da Vinci's shop and the shops tied to events.

It has still not been addressed why we have not been given SQ in parity with Japan when they received them for things that were under their control such as events and streams, the most notable recently being only receiving 10 SQ for our annivarsary while Japan received 30 SQ (You could even argue we received 0 SQ for our anniversary since the reason given for the 10 SQ was the AX panel.) In addition we have not received other things such as the Crystalized Lore FGOJP apparently got when Kintoki first went on rate-up nor have we received either the Heaven's Feel or Last Encore CEs.

This is to me honestly unacceptable when despite being treated to some extent as the red headed stepchild compared to FGOJP, FGONA has seemingly managed to carry its weight enough to give a boost to the overall profits of FGO and apparently brings in enough money that Aniplex sought fit to not only dub FGOVR, but also plaster Anime Expo 2018 with so much FGO advertising that you'd be led to believe it was an event centered entirely on FGO, if the apparent number of people at AX solely for FGO didn't already do that.

The subject of AX brings me to the point of how poorly we are regarded outside of the game. First of all we have the dubious distinction of FGONA being the only other version of the game besides FGOJP to be directly handled by DW directly, I say dubious because even a year after the game has launched we have no idea of how many resources DW actively has devoted to FGONA. Do we have an entire team devoted to us or is it just who ever DW can scrounge together when they're not as busy working on FGOJP? This lack of knowledge creates discontent within the community because it brings up the very real possibility that we are not being given adequate resources and out maligned treatment is simply the result of DW being first and foremost concerned with FGOJP, something that may only get worse as DW now begins to ramp up work on the Lost Belts.

Second, basically no community interaction exists because AoJ seems content to staff AoA with a skeleton crew and have people such as Albert, Anthony, and Rebecca handled both the PR for both FGO and Aniplex's various anime properties. This is unacceptable to both us and potentially to the visible employees of AoA who have to suffer the brunt of the backlash from the ignorant, something I have no doubt AoJ is content with. Albert in particular has received the worst and it seems that his relative poor performance at the anniversary panel could be easily explained by having been worked to the bone beforehand having to play chaperone for Gudako before the panel and after. There are videos of Gudako at AX on Youtube and one in particular seemingly set after the panel appears to show a worn out Albert.

The above stands in stark contrast to FGOJP who not only get streams and things such as Chaldea Radio, but can directly contact DW and AoJ without having to go through a middleman. The convention panels that FGONA has gotten are basically a wash considering that to my knowledge none of them bar those at AX 2017 and 2018 have been live streamed and thus the majority of the fanbase is excluded.

In conclusion to AoJ and DW I say that we deserve much better treatment than we have so far received. We deserve parity with Japan and we deserve a PR team whose full time job is FGONA and who assure us that our questions and complaints are heard.

Now I will turn my attention to TM, despite having little faith they themselves will see this and can only hope that the intention will be conveyed by the connection they seemingly have with DW and AoJ.

FGONA (Along with possibly the various animes releases from AoA, Extella/Link, and other things) has shown that there is interest for Fate and TM's other works in the West and FGO in particular has probably served as an entry point just as it did in Japan. Yet despite this we have received no acknowledgement, we are nearly unable to appreciate TM's works unlike someone in Japan who can dive deeper from FGO. There has never been an official English release for F/SN, F/HA, Tsukihime, or Mahoyo. There has never been an official English release for F/Zero, Apocrypha, KnK, Case Files, Fate/Strange Fake, or Prototype LNs. There has never been an official English release for the Prisma Illya manga. The official English releases of the Materials books have been few and are likely finished for the moment. Why do Western fans have to settle and scrounge for anime adaptions and fan translations despite showing that we have interest and are willing to spend money?

In response to this I'm sure there are those who will say TM is niche and that it's a lot of text to translate. To them I say to look at the profits for FGONA and the amount of text in FGO itself that has been and will be translated, to look at the number of people in the West who have spent money on TM merchandise, to the various other VNs and LNs that have received English translations. I want them to look at all of that and tell me that TM is still niche or that there isn't enough money for their coffers.

At the moment given that TM apparently is the size of a circle despite being a company, I'm not willing to attribute malevolence to their lack of action. Instead I would hazard ignorance and/or red tape depending on the publishers of the various items listed above is instead to blame. At the same time however, we now live in a world that is more global or more interconnected than ever before and I have a hard time believing that no solution to these problems exists and that there don't exist people within the TM fandom who have the skills to tackle them and who wouldn't jump at the chance to do so.

I once read that Nasu or someone else at TM said they wanted Fate or TM itself to be the Marvel of Japan. I'm no expert on Marvel's history, but I don't think they would be in their current position, in a position where a child from Vietnam can eat a traditional rice treat in the shape and colors of the Hulk, if they have done nothing but navel gaze.

This post has been long, it has been rambling, it is probably disjointed It has retread the ground of months and of years. Yet I believe now that we are in a situation where this can change and that it is important to keep the fire alive rather than let it gutter out.


r/grandorder • • Mar 11 '18

Fluff Upvoting/Downvoting in r/grandorder

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/grandorder • • Sep 26 '23

NA Discussion Is Mash an interesting charcter?

5 Upvotes

Before Avalon came out I knew it was supposed to be a big chapter for Mash. And well now that it's out and I've sat on it a while I felt Mash was boring. This could just be my own bad opinion but the whole amnesia story line she had no motivation just a agreed to do anything. And once she rejoins the master she doesn't feel like she's grown from her journeys. It doesn't feel like she has any new opinion or anything. Just once I'd like the master and mash to have a disagreement about something. Maybe later lost belts will expand on her more or maybe she's will always be destined to be nothing more then a supporting charcter


r/grandorder • • Aug 11 '20

JP Discussion Honako Green spitting facts about the 5th Anniversary

0 Upvotes

Honestly bummed by the Anniversary, it really feels like DW are resting on their laurels and aren't doing much to improve the game.

Honako feels about the same https://clips.twitch.tv/EnthusiasticSullenJaguarPanicBasket

Edit: Removed the 1st clip since people felt it came across as whiny.


r/grandorder • • Apr 04 '18

Discussion Since people don't seem to get why removing doujin content is a bad thing.

14 Upvotes

The point is not that it's just fap material, people aren't just coming here looking for porn it's a forum to discuss these doujins and your favorite characters in them with other people. r/grandorder is the ONLY place with a large following of people to talk about doujins with.

Other doujin websites aren't specifically for fate and they don't have a lot of discussion about things in the doujins other than the porn and since other subreddits don't have the following you won't ever get the opportunity to talk to as many people about it.

This subreddit provides this exact unique experience and if theres another website with this amount of people, that's specifically geared for fate that talks not just about the porn but also the characters, how well the artist portrayed your favorites and brings likeminded people together to fantasize about your favorite ships then I'm sure we'd all be happy to leave this reddit.


r/grandorder • • Jul 01 '18

Fluff F2p's be like

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/grandorder • • Jul 13 '19

Discussion Is Anyone Else Disheartened By the Lack of Gender Differentiation in the Story?

2 Upvotes

I've thought this for a while, but the lack of effort put into gender differences during certain scenes in the story really do feel like wasted potential for better immersion or interesting commentary.

It's especially present in the newest Pseudo Singularity, Agartha; a plot where the focus is on women, and yet even if the player character is female, you are still implied to be male, which is a big missed opportunity to add more intrigue to the story if you ask me.

This isn't to start a debate, but rather to maybe have a discussion on whether or not this issue can be worked on, if anyone else thinks it's worth trying to better, if you don't think it's a big deal, etc.

(Just so we're clear: I understand the main demographic is mostly male, but when you have the option for the avatar to be female, I think they could try a bit harder to add that detail into the story during scenes where it references it, at the very least.)


r/grandorder • • Aug 11 '18

Fluff I want to start a fight.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/grandorder • • May 29 '23

Cosplay Cosplayed Astolfo!!! He’s so fun to cos

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/grandorder • • Sep 07 '22

Discussion Raikou has been powercrept so hard it's not even funny

2 Upvotes

I gotta say, it's been a rough couple of years, being a Raikou fan.

  • She's severely outclassed by the other AoE Berserkers (with all of them being able to do 3-turn loop farming in some capacity).

  • Even Xiang Yu, an arguably fringe servant, has been buffed by quite a lot with the introduction of R.Skadi.

  • The last buff she got was two years ago, one full year after the introduction of Arjuna Alter, and it didn't do much to help her (it did improve her damage but Arjuna would still deal more damage at similar NP levels).

  • Summer Ibuki has everything Raikou is severely in need of and then some, on top of being an Arts servant (the best card type in the game).

  • Summer Ibuki practically obsoletes Summer Raikou's as a support servant as well (with debuff clear being the only thing going for Summer Raikou).

  • She finally got a banner after two years of not being in one, and it didn't bring any strengthening that could have helped her in any way.

How do you imagine Raikou's situation would progress going forward?

  • She gets her a good buff at some point (that at least brings her up to date as a servant).

  • She gets an underpowered buff once again.

  • She is replaced by a better (more powerful) Raikou in a different class (thus making me a very salty NP5 LV100 Raikou owner)

  • She remains the same until the game finally closes shop in a couple years.


r/grandorder • • Oct 25 '18

Discussion NA players - Stop posting story screenshots

22 Upvotes

We get it, you're excited and enjoying the event. But, everyone and their mothers are also playing the event. We ALL have seen the same scenes.

TL;DR

STOP POSTING SCREENSHOTS


r/grandorder • • Apr 03 '19

NA Discussion Censorship: Why it matters, why you should care, and why it's worth talking about

0 Upvotes

So lately, there's been a lot of commentary about censorship on the subreddit, with most of the popular posts about it either defending or dismissing it. With that it mind, I think it's important to keep in mind that, as much as we all enjoy the game, there's room for criticism with this kind of decision.
Before launching into all this, I would encourage anyone that hasn't to read the summary of the Localization Panel. It's very enlightening as to the though process and general methodology of the localization staff, and I'm going to reference it quite a bit here.
Also, please, please, do not harass anyone on the translation team. I know it seems obvious, but I've seen the nasty stuff that gets thrown at them on twitter, and I want to be clear that I'm 100% against that and anything like it. This is not an attack piece.

Censorship is tricky because everyone has a different idea of what's appropriate and what isn't. To throw out a quick example, one of the most popular parts of the story involves the protagonist going to the middle east to help an extremist Islamic group against Western invaders. It comes complete with suicide attacks, unstoppable death from above, support from a third party with a dictator who provides military support to the Islamic group, etc. That's some extremely politically charged stuff! If it were the plot of a Hollywood blockbuster, there would be protests and national news coverage.
To date, I have yet to see a single person here complain about it. It's not an issue because it's mostly unknown to the people that would care, and it can't generate bad press in a single image like Abby potentially could. It might seem over the top to suggested that NA would ever censor a story, but consider (spoilers) that in Lostbelt 2, Skadi kills any member of society that hasn't reproduced by the age of 15, and kills everyone else at 25. For her, this is a way to keep the human population small enough to live well within the limited resources available to them. Would NA feel comfortable having a story that featured this content, particularly when you can then pay for the privilege of using the character who did it?
Some people say that Abigail is safe from censorship because there was only a one-off line dedicated to her in the interview. However, that one line is very important:

Or when they just cross the line and be like, 'hey, let's combine like, loli and tentacles.' Why, Japan?

Albert very clearly states that he considers Abigail's design to be crossing the line. Given that he's the one who suggests to DW what is and isn't acceptable, this is extremely important. He has claimed in the same interview that "They don't want to dishonor artists' intentions, but...", yet in the same interview, when asked about the possibility of translating the FGO materials books, he mentions

Jokes aside, if they can localize it, he'd love to. Might require some edits (like the aforementioned Emiya Alter line) and they don't have the resources to do it just yet, but if they can, that would be great.

The line he's referring to is a direct quote from the artist on the origin of the design. Censoring not just the design of a character, but also why that design existed in the first place, is extremely worrying to me.

Another line I hear thrown around a lot is that Albert has no control over FGO. He himself says this, and I don't doubt that he's the one deciding not to give NA quartz for April Fool's, but that's not where it stops. When talking about the potential editing of future servants, he says

For objectionable things, NA will be like "please stop". Sometimes JP agrees and changes it, sometimes they do it anyway.

This, more than anything else in the interview, is incredible to me. It seems to say that what Albert views as objectionable has some level of influence with the JP staff, and has at some point changed the design of something in FGO that we'll never know about. On some level, Albert is part of the creative process, and the fact that a translator has altered the development of the original version of the game means that NA censorship has become an issue you have to worry about even if you don't play NA.

Albert has a limited level of communication allowed by his bosses over at DW. The lack of communication is almost certainly not his fault, and honestly, I don't think it will ever change unless he manages to convince them to allow it, which would be an impressive feat. However, he does read what's posted here, and if he's just casually browsing the sub, he'll see that a significant number of people will defend all of the current censorship and even advocate for more. I want to make it clear that there are also many people who would prefer not to have censorship of any kind, and, judging by the comments on posts like this, many more who don't think that there's even a possibility of more censorship in the future.

Albert, if you do read this, please remember that we really appreciate what the localization team does, particularly seeing it improve so much since launch, but also that everyone has their own idea of what's acceptable and what isn't, and people deserve to be able to make their own decision.

Thanks for reading!


r/grandorder • • Apr 01 '19

NA Discussion The State of NA EoR Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Demiya discriminated,

CCC event terminated,

Agartha soon castrated,

Shimosa unrelated,

Abigail change uncompensated,

Long have we awaited,

NA got jebaited.

(if you've reached the end, happy April Fools day)


r/grandorder • • Mar 22 '18

Fluff You think we'll stop posting Save for Jalter after the Da Vinci event? Think again…

Post image
12 Upvotes