r/grammar • u/Solid-Code1717 • 11h ago
quick grammar check "As a member of x, you might like y" - correct or incorrect?
I work in a marketing-adjacent role and have frequent patrons I interact with regularly. One of them has a bee in their bonnet about the framing in the title. Let's say the email goes "As a loyal supporter of our products, you might enjoy this new thing".
She frequently complains that this implies that the sender of the email is the loyal supporter, rather than the recipient of the message, and thinks that it should be "As you are a loyal supporter, you might enjoy..." etc.
I think that the first version is perfectly clear and understandable, from context, and it's not an ungrammatical construction, nor is it an uncommon one. I think her version is much more awkward and clumsy. However, she's pointed it out several times, so I have to ask - who do we think is right?