TLDR: If you want to contact a student of a prospective PI to inquire about the PI and their experiences, introduce yourself and first ask if they have some time to answer your questions. Better yet, avoid the cold email and ask the PI if they may introduce you to their students to chat. Or wait for a chance to ask more naturally in person, like a grad visit day. That’s all.
—————————
I just received an email from a prospective student of my current PI, asking me about 12-15 questions about his teaching style, his lab and how they’d run it, how I like him, etc.
Now I understand common advice is to ask students of a PI about how they are. But after receiving this email, I felt the need to share that it is not a great idea to cold email a student asking all of these questions. PhD students are sometimes even busier than their PIs - especially if they are late-stage and ABD (All But Dissertation). They will likely not have time to answer your email, and you may be setting up an image that you wouldn’t like too much. For example, I would love to answer this student’s questions, but I have absolutely no time between running my final project, TAing, being on several conference committees, and writing papers + my dissertation, and the questions I was sent would have taken an essay to answer. Looking at my website would’ve clearly shown that I was late-stage and near the end of my thesis too. If asked about you in the future, I will unfortunately just remember that you were the student who sent me a 15 question review of my PI to complete.
If you want to ask about your prospective PI, I would highly suggest waiting until whatever grad visit day exists for your department - students will be prepared and in a proper mindset to answer these questions, and it will be way more casual and less overbearing.
Edit: In response to some comments, I think if you are going to send an email, just try to make it easy to read and respond to. It’s better to ask for a time to chat then making them write a long email. Maybe ask the PI if you can talk to their students, then the PI can tell them ahead of time or even introduce you directly - many PIs are happy to introduce you to their students to ask questions, instead of going the cold email route.
Edit edit: No one said don’t email students at all. I said don’t COLD EMAIL them. And don’t bombard unsuspecting PhD students with a very long unexpected email that they may feel obligated to respond to. Find an opportunity where it’s easier to ask these questions - either by getting an introduction by the PI, or asking during a grad visit day. Or don’t. Everyone is free to do what they want. Just trying to provide some realistic advice here.
Edit edit edit: Final edit since I seem to have stepped on a lot of nerves. This post was meant to advise on how to (and not to) first contact a student of a prospective PI. Do not immediately introduce yourself with an interview set of questions for them to answer when they don’t even know who you are. My proposal was that leaving these questions for a grad visit day would be the most natural and easy way to ask these questions, but if you want to email, introduce yourself first, and then ask if they have time to chat and answer some questions you may have about their PI. Or ask the PI if they can email their students and the PI will do the intro work for you. That is all I’ll say on the matter.