I am making this as a sort of opinion piece based off a debate I had with a friend regarding the true importance of The Cure, how influential they were and how pivotal they were in shaping the early goth scene.
I consider myself a huge fan of these early goth bands, especially Christian Death under Rozz Williams. I am open to that I may be biased and fanboyish but hear me out.
I consider goth a genre where in which the lesser popular bands, despite being less known, were much more pivotal in defining and influencing the identity of goth. Both in sound, aesthetic and theme. I want to stress that what I am talking about is not a measure of whether or not the cure had good music. They obvious had great music. But the cure also heavily lacks the boundary pushing, abstract experimentalism that the big three presented.
I am referring to Bauhaus, Siouxsie and the Banshees, and Christian Death with Rozz Williams.
Bauhaus is probably the first to really define it to its perfection. Taking the name from an abstract art school in Germany that was shut down by the nazis, you really see and even feel the aesthetic in the sound, which presents a very experimental, abstract 'artsy' vibe to it's sound. It brings a sort of dark Art Deco vibe like an old horror film from the 1920s. This is also seen heavily in Siousxie Soux's fashion.
Siouxsie and the Banshees were probably the most 'tame' of the big three, but don't take that as me putting them down. Their 1979 release of "The Scream" is neck and neck with Bauhaus in their contribution to putting it all together in a way that can be "defined".
The album takes the approach with a much more traditional punk sound and is, in my opinion, their 2nd best album, next to the absolute classic, JUJU.
Rozz William's, of Christian Death, heated the kettle all the more in the form of a much more personal approach. His music wasn't so much to do with these abstract artistic themes but was the expression of a young teenage boy who was trapped in his own skin and screaming to get out. Ready to destroy the world until he did or atleast until a guiding hand helped him through.
In these themes we see expression of sexual confusion, religious questioning and teenage frustrations that weren't so typical during that time.
These themes were expressed in very intricate and poetic lyrics. In fact, in some of his songs, the lyrics are written more in the form of a slam poem more so than the typical verse chorus verse chorus format you would see in a typical rock song.
I credit Rozz as the main patriarch of the stereotype on Gothic kids writing biting poems expressing their frustrations in life. He was probably one of the best lyricists of all rock and roll.
The music in general is definitely nothing to the scoffed at and fits the bill alongside Rozz Williams himself.
So where does that leave The Cure? When I was discovering goth rock bands and expanding my horizon of course I'm going to checkout The Cure. I mean of course! They are the most famous "goth" band of that time!
As I listened, I have to say, I was a little confused. The music wasn't terrible, in fact it was good. But it heavily lacked the type of abstract experimentalism I heard from these other bands. I would even go so far and say that alot of the music, especially their more popular songs, just sounded like 80s alternative pop rock more so than anything I'd call "goth rock".
There was nothing abstract, experimental, and absolutely nothing controversial, dark or boundary breaking.
I told my friend that, even though the cure was much more popular, Rozz Williams' vocal track on Only Theater of Pain alone was more pivotal in shaping the identity of Goth than anytbing they did. To me, if you remove the black clothes, there is hardly anything goth about their music. And yes, I'm also referring to what are considered their more particularly "goth sounding" albums like 'pornography'.
To me, at best, I'd call it "goth lite".
Thoughts?