r/goodreads • • Nov 05 '25 This Bravo

Shelves I wish Goodreads had a “Did Not Finish” Shelf

5.0k Upvotes

When I give up on a book, I am left with a choice. Do I leave it in Goodreads? If I leave it, then I either mark it as “Read” (even though I did not actually finish it) or leave it forever in “Want to Read” where it just clutters the list. On the other hand, if I delete it, then it disappears as if I never touched it. None of these options capture what really happened. I have seen some people mark such a book as Read and then mark it with a dnf tag, but that does not work for me because I did not really finish the book, snd so I cannot say that I “read” it. Saying I read it implies that I finished it.


r/goodreads • • Jan 23 '25 Helpful This Heartwarming Take My Energy Bless Up

Discussion Yes, it does count towards your reading goal.

2.0k Upvotes

If you can find it on Goodreads, it counts. Yes, that includes manga, audiobooks, graphic novels, poetry, manuals, textbooks, novellas, plays, essays, cookbooks, rereads, short stories, children's books, fiction, and nonfiction.

There’s no rulebook for this. The challenge is for you to track your personal reading goal, whatever that looks like for you. There’s no right or wrong way.


r/goodreads • • Mar 01 '24

Discussion Anyone else ever feel really dumb after reading the reviews for a book you enjoyed?

1.7k Upvotes

Goodreads does a great job of highlighting reviews from both ends of the spectrum but does anyone ever feel really dumb when you go to the reviews for a book that you really enjoyed or a book that really affected you and then see a bunch of reviews from people saying that the book was really shallow or really dumb? I definitely appreciate seeing different opinions than mine but I’d be lying if I said they didn’t make me feel like a dumb simpleton every time I read them. Ok that’s all. Thanks


r/goodreads • • Dec 12 '23

Current Event First-time author loses book deal for ‘review bombing’ authors on Goodreads

1.6k Upvotes

A first-time author lost her book deal Monday after readers and fellow authors accused her of creating fake Goodreads accounts and repeatedly trying to sabotage other writers’ books through negative reviews.

Cait Corrain, the author of the sci-fi fantasy novel “Crown of Starlight,” which was to be published in May 2024, has faced backlash over the past week after literary fans on X and TikTok accused her of “review bombing” fellow authors for months by using several fake accounts to post scathing reviews on Goodreads, the popular Amazon-owned review site. After some writers claimed that an unnamed author was writing one-star reviews for books written by debuting authors of color, authors and readers tracked the fake Goodreads accounts back to Corrain, who gave her own book glowing reviews.

The discussion surrounding the controversy led Del Rey Books, an imprint of Penguin Random House, to announce Monday that Corrain’s book would not be published next year.

“We are aware of the ongoing discussion around author Cait Corrain,” the publisher wrote on X. “CROWN OF STARLIGHT is no longer on our 2024 publishing schedule.”

The publisher’s decision to drop Corrain and “Crown of Starlight” resulted in her losing other partnerships she had in the works. Hours before the announcement, Corrain’s literary agent, Rebecca Podos, said that she also had cut ties with her client.

“Cait and I will not be continuing our partnership moving forward,” Podos wrote on X. “I deeply appreciate the patience of those directly impacted by last week’s events as I worked through a difficult situation.”

Read the full story here, and skip the paywall with email registration.


r/goodreads • • Nov 11 '25

Discussion I FINALLY WON!

1.4k Upvotes

After a YEAR of entering book giveaways, I woke up to a “congratulations, you won!” email! It’s funny because I found this page yesterday after googling “does anyone actually win Goodreads giveaways”. Anyways, I’m going to ride this high all day 🤣 hopefully the book is good lol Has anyone else won? Only once? Multiple times? Never?


r/goodreads • • Jan 27 '24

Discussion if it’s a book and you read it, then it counts.

1.4k Upvotes

I’ve seen so many posts on here from folks who genuinely seem very concerned that they’re “cheating” at goodreads or something. they don’t want to be labelled as a fraud because they’re counting manga/comics, assigned reading, and short books towards their their total list of read books. but here’s the thing: those are books, too, and if they weren’t, they wouldn’t be listed as such.

you aren’t “cheating” or “being dishonest” by putting everything - even very quick reads - on your profile. nobody (or, no reasonable person) is going to take up issue with you for adding that one volume of Card Captor Sakura or that quick Victorian novella to your collection of finished titles. this is not a professional competition. neither awards nor cash prizes will be handed out.

I, myself, am mostly only able to read titles that fall into the "quick and easy" category. I'm an overbooked (ha) student and I work part-time, so reading for leisure can't be my priority. most of the reading I do is of academic papers (which can't be tracked on GR), so what I am able to add is a gift. I've been taking 5-10 minutes each day to read one chapter (and one chapter only) out of my favourite manga series. this has been so great for me and it's something I really look forward to, even though it pales in comparison to the extensive (and extremely admirable) amounts of reading that many very dedicated users get done each day.

and guess what? IT STILL COUNTS! they're books and I'm reading 'em. that's all there is to it. if reading short/"easy"/whatever books were really "worth less," then goodreads would measure progress in pages or minutes read. leave the worrying to them. just focus on reading what YOU want the most. whatever that looks like.


r/goodreads • • Feb 17 '26

Discussion Did Not Finish Shelf is Coming SooN

1.0k Upvotes

I just got an email from Goodreads saying a Did Not Finish Shelf is coming soon:

Psst... The Did Not Finish (DNF) shelf is coming soon. You're hearing about it first because you already track books you started and set aside.

Things to Know

If you created an exclusive custom shelf named exactly "did not finish," "dnf," "abandoned," "unfinished," "didn-t-finish," or "dropped", we'll automatically convert it to the new default Did Not Finish shelf. Your reviews, ratings, and reading history stay with your book.

If you created a tag or non-exclusive custom shelf, it will remain unchanged with one exception. Those currently named exactly "did-not-finish" will be automatically renamed to "did-not-finish-2" to avoid duplication.

If you prefer to keep your current setup, rename your shelf or tag to anything else before Feb. 28.

What to Expect

As we prepare for launch, your existing shelf or tag may show a different name or appear non-editable. This is expected as we work behind the scenes to ensure your books, ratings, and reviews transfer smoothly. Don't worry! You can still add and remove books from your shelf as usual during this time.

Stay tuned,

The Goodreads Team


r/goodreads • • Dec 28 '24

Discussion Ever read a book and get really disgusted by the ending then go on Goodreads and get even more irked by all the gushing 5-star reviews?

814 Upvotes

r/goodreads • • Mar 17 '26

Suggestion not enough dnf emails from goodreads

774 Upvotes

Dear Goodreads,

Please send me at least five more emails on a weekly basis about the status of the dnf shelf. This is really poor and insufficient communication on your part. Why am I not seeing the git commit messages from your developers? Where's the diff? Where's the changelog? Disappointed at how sparse my inbox is with information about the dnf shelf. The dnf shelf will change my life.


r/goodreads • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion Half & quarter stars are officially coming!

720 Upvotes

A video was posted on Goodreads’ TikTok, not sure if it was also announced elsewhere. FINALLY.


r/goodreads • • Dec 05 '24 Take My Silver

Discussion Serious Question - how do you read 150+ books / year

684 Upvotes

I see a lot of people talking about reading 150+ books per year, which is effectively 3 books per week. How do you accomplish this? Is it audiobooks? If you're reading average length books, that's about 24- 30 hours of reading a week. Do you actually enjoy the books and read each page? Or are you reading them to finish them rather than to immerse yourself in the story? I am genuinely curious.


r/goodreads • • Jan 17 '24

Suggestion I wish GoodReads had a "book journal" to write your thoughts about the book privately....

643 Upvotes

I would love after finishing a book to have somewhere to write what I enjoyed/disliked about the book, and what I want to remember when I look back at the book in a few years. My brain just gets jumbled when reading lots of books so when I mark a book read, just writing key words and things would be so awesome.

I would love after finishing a book to have somewhere to write what I enjoyed/disliked about the book, and what I want to remember when I look back at the book in a few years. My brain just gets jumbled when reading lots of books so when I mark a book read, just writing keywords and things would be so awesome.


r/goodreads • • May 13 '25

Discussion Annoyed at book status options.

620 Upvotes

Anyone else annoyed that DNF isn't an option for goodreads?

The only option once you mark a book as currently reading is to mark it read. That's annoying, because it marks it as read toward your reading goals. And I really don't want a book I read ten percent of to count toward my reading goals.

So if they are going to force me to mark it as read I will 100% rate the book 1 star. Whereas if DNF was an option I wouldn't bother rating it.


r/goodreads • • Jan 01 '25

Discussion What is everyone's first read of 2025?

606 Upvotes

I'm reading 'Upgrade' by Blake Crouch for my first read, already halfway through. I set my reading challenge at 50 every year, so I have a week to read each book. But this one is so good, I can't put it down. What are you all reading for your first of 2025? 📖


r/goodreads • • Feb 28 '23

Discussion Goodreads should add half stars

584 Upvotes

Half a star makes a huge difference in a rating. And I constantly see people putting half stars in their reviews, but half the people round down and half round up.

It's a fantastic app but would love if they added half stars into their scale. Would add a lot of depth to what is the crux of the app.


r/goodreads • • Feb 01 '25

Discussion Book review vs. book summary

582 Upvotes

Why are so many “reviews” on Goodreads just a summary of the book? A book review and a book summary are two different things. I didn’t come to read the reviews for 50 different commenters to tell me in their own words what happens in the book. Can someone help me understand why we don’t see more actual reviews?


r/goodreads • • Apr 05 '24

Discussion Books read in a year

551 Upvotes

How many books does the average reader finish in a year? I saw that in 2023, the pledge was 43 and I was astonished because that seems like so many more books than I thought (I read 27 and was really proud haha).

I know Goodreads is a specific niche of book lovers but am just curious what your guess as to what the average person reads in a year.

Edit: Thank you for all your responses!! Sorry if I can't respond to everyone, but I read all your comments and appreciate your thoughts/insights! <3 Good luck on your reading goal this year!


r/goodreads • • Dec 30 '24

Discussion A reminder for the New Year

545 Upvotes

Happy New Year everybody (and happy reading challenge reset!)

I’m seeing a bunch of posts asking about what does and doesn’t count towards the goal and want to pop on and say that the challenge is for YOU and your interests.

Don’t be worried about strangers not thinking [blank] doesn’t count because it’s not [blank] because at the end of the day- did you read it in 2025? Then yes, it counts if you want to add it to your goal. If you don’t want to you don’t have to either!

It’s not a literary merit and word count challenge. It’s not a reading competition. It’s a personal reading challenge!

Don’t be discouraged from picking something up because it doesn’t count- remember to enjoy yourselves :)!


r/goodreads • • Jan 29 '25

Discussion Have you been giving more books low star reviews as you become a more seasoned reader?

538 Upvotes

I was looking at books I gave 5 stars and most of them were from 2017 and earlier. 2017 I started to get into audiobooks and before that I only read one or two books per year. Many of them I wonder if I re-read them now, what review would I give?

My friend said every year her average rating on her year in books gets lower and I realized I have the same phenomenon. Searched this subreddit - do newer raters/readers generally give higher star reviews?

Would explain some of these booktok books with over inflated star ratings…


r/goodreads • • Jan 01 '25

Current Event 2025 Reading Challenge is live! Happy read everyone!

483 Upvotes

r/goodreads • • Jan 18 '24

Tech Help Anyone else getting a glitch that keeps asking you to update the app?

483 Upvotes

wouldn’t surprise me if it is buggy, bc what else is new, but i’m just trying to figure out if it’s a widespread issue or just me lol. i’m using the ios app and every time i open it, one of those “new version available — not now/update” pop-ups appears. my app is up-to-date (clicking the update button just takes me to the app store where there is no update available) and i’ve already tried deleting/reinstalling and such so it’s definitely some sort of glitch.

edit: approximately 20 hours later, it’s finally stopped on my phone — something about patience is key… the search function (which stopped working a few hours after i posted this) is also working. hopefully it sorts out for everyone soon enough as well!


r/goodreads • • Jan 21 '24

Discussion do you count books read for school towards your yearly reading goal?

469 Upvotes

just curious. i’m reading several self help style books for a senior seminar and i have a couple of other novels and ethnographies that i have had to read for class. curious if other people count those towards their goal or not.

EDIT: just want to clarify, im a college student. not doing this for class or anything. im just curious as to whether other people include their readings for class. (not textbooks. i’m talking entire books read start to finish)


r/goodreads • • Aug 31 '23

Discussion I hate summaries in reviews!

467 Upvotes

I immediately will scroll past your review if I see "So basically this book is about..." It just annoys me!

THAT IS WHAT THE SUMMARY IS FOR!!! I'm looking to see what you thought about it since I usually read the reviews AFTER I read the book.

I understand that maybe it's for the people who want to read some reviews before they pick up the book, But the summary is literally right there >:(

I'm working on my reviews because I am not very good at putting my thoughts into text. trying to look at others to better my own is useless though when it's just spark-notes of the story.

Does anyone else feel like this?


r/goodreads • • Apr 19 '25

Tech Help Is it possible to hide certain books from your public profile but to still count them toward your reading goal?

466 Upvotes

I’m currently reading Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents by Lindsay Gibson and want to count it toward my reading goal but the problem is, my mom is one of my friends on goodreads. Now she doesn’t use Goodreads often and never comments on any of the books I’m reading, so even if the only thing I can do is hide the book from my newsfeed I’d be okay with that. Thank you!


r/goodreads • • Jan 14 '26

Discussion Has anyone else had an author respond to their review?

427 Upvotes

I found out last night that the author of a book I didn't like left a kind of passive-aggressive comment on my review. I didn't think she'd ever see it, my understanding was authors are discouraged from reading their Goodreads reviews, much less responding to them.

Thing is, I loved her other novel, which was why I bought her second one and I was really disappointed by it. I'm not the only person she's responded to leaving a negative review, but my friend told me she's apparently now following me on Goodreads and I'm kind of weirded out.

Should I just block her and move on?

EDIT: Thank you, guys, I feel much better now I've gotten this off my chest. Apparently the author has been doing this to quite a few people so I guess I'm just part of a big reaction.