r/godot • • 4d ago

discussion Can we just ban AI already?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I thought bullying the people who post AI slop in the comments would make them leave but they just keep coming. I don't think anyone would be against this, as all the AI posts I've seen get downvoted. Petition to revise Rule 10 to ban AI altogether.


r/godot • • Sep 29 '23

Discussion External editors are treated like second class citizens

31 Upvotes

Coming from Unreal/Rider, Godot/VScode feels awful. I've been dabbling with Godot for a while and the VScode plugin has always felt clunky, slow, and been behind the internal text editor in Godot specific functionality. Now, I like VScode, it's just the integration with Godot that's lacking. To this day I don't understand why Godot has such emphasis on their internal editor when that will only ever be a toy to the typical software engineer. They simply can't compete with the likes of VScode or any other editor for that matter. I'll never use the internal editor for more than a couple lines because I need VIM bindings (and all my other plugins for that matter)

I'm sure there are reasons for the internal editor to exist but external should be first class, not some pet project plugin.

Edit: Can't even have a discussion with Godot users. It's just like "go fix it urself then lol." This isn't something that can be fixed with a pull request because that change would include wiping the entire internal editor, which would obviously be rejected. This is an issue at the project level, a disconnect of philosophy, and this post isn't even asking for it to be fixed as much as elaboration on a big reason I'll stick with Unreal.

Edit 2: This sure is a spicy one guys. I never thought I'd get to the top of controversial by confessing my preference for external editors. I've been enjoying myself so much I'd like to see it continue. External editor support is just the immediate problem I have with Godot every time I use it. Here are some more thoughts:

  • Users? pretentious

  • Documentation? outdated

  • Development? slow (engine and your game lol)

  • Tutorials? amateur

  • GDscript? slow

  • Text editor? covered

  • The 3D looks like shit. You'd think that's an asset level issue but damn if it's not so prevalent that I question the engine.

  • 2D is pretty neat

  • Ragdoll is glitched to hell, probably because they swapped to their own physics engine (text editor wasn't enough, huh?)

  • "Top Ten Reason Why Godot is the Future of Game Dev!"

  • Lots of little things are just broken in that Linuxy way where people are like "oh just go to this cryptic file hidden 8 folders deep called ebsys.xyz and make a small edit to a line whose syntax is specified 23 pages deep in the ebsys manpage"

  • Real "small family business please understand" energy

  • The UI is hot garbage programmer art

  • "Man won't it be cool when this works better in a couple years!"

  • Hipster cult

  • Though development is slow they manage to change the C++ extension framework completely every 5 minutes

  • GDscript could probably have just been lua, no matter how much thy docs protest

  • Nodes are cool. I like the nodes.

  • "Fix it yourself or fork off"

  • 2D platformer 356206245097

  • Flagship 3D title is Cruelty Squad. Fun game, but cmon look at it.

Edit 3: Edit 2 sure was a wild ride, huh? With the OP a few people agreed with me, then Edit 1 and people were like "yeah guys we need to do better." Then Edit 2 came and turned any goodwill into "nah fuck that guy holy shit." We've had our ups and downs /r/godot. Good times and bad, but I think along the way we learned a thing or two.

From /u/Meshi26 I learned that Godot may have a different identity from what I expected, a different goal. I and I'm sure many others want Godot to be the next Unity, but glorious and free, and maybe that was never the intent. I never considered they might want Godot to be an entry point not only for someone new to game dev, but someone new to computers in general, which is the only reason that makes sense so far for the internal editor's existence. Admirable, but not the tool I need. From /u/_tkg I experienced decent discussion free of insult, Godot Gandhi in the flesh, this person even addressed and agreed with several points from infamous Edit 2 and disagreed with others politely. A shining beacon to strive for. We could all learn from this person.

And maybe some of you Gobots learned something from this exchange. That people are indeed looking for a new Unity and that, especially as an open project, Godot is vulnerable to change, and that's okay. Someone like me that's not a lazy asshole might come along, gather support with their superior soft skills, and start moving this project on a different path, a path of power and complexity. Of efficiency, which may involve cutting features that no longer align. That might be scary, but I believe in every one of you. I believe you can learn to wield the power that comes with such change and make games beyond what anyone thought Godot capable of.

Most importantly, I think we learned that if we put half the effort we spend arguing online into our games they'd be done already.


r/godot • • 1d ago

selfpromo (games) Work on my No AI game’s intro

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

this is the work I’ve done for the intro cutscene of my new project, Fallen Realm. It’s like Zelda meets Metroidvania meets parkour. I’ll be posting updates more frequently.

TO ANYONE WHO THINKS ABOUT COMMENTING:

This is a prototype. I'm not asking for anyone to criticise me or my work. I'm just posting for the sake of finding out what good FX to add and try out.


r/godot • • Feb 05 '25

fun & memes Godot 4.4 has some new GREAT features NSFW

6 Upvotes

r/godot • • Sep 29 '26

selfpromo (games) My first PvE encounter test with player bots - Godot Indie MMO

35 Upvotes

Hi,

This week, I moved into a new stage of development: creating content to get a better sense of how the game actually plays.

As a solo developer, my workflow focuses on finding solutions that allow me to test and validate everything.

I’ve built a new system that let me rebalance encounters based on the current state of the game, using Monte Carlo method. The current test encounter has an 80% wipe rate against bot players, whose only limitation is a random reaction-time penalty when responding to objectives.

Claude (Fable/Opus) and ChatGPT are used during development.


r/godot • • Jun 16 '25

selfpromo (games) quit my job before this game, working on this for the last 4 months

3 Upvotes

I have 6 different guns at the moment. If you wanna check out the game, it's on web: https://paranoidstudios.itch.io/ball-fighters


r/godot • • Apr 15 '26

discussion Opinion: We should take obfuscation more seriously and stop treating it like it does not matter

6 Upvotes

Slay The Spire 2 was a bit of an eye opener for me.

Slay the Spire 2 on Godot was a huge success, which is great for this game engine and gave it the credibility it deserves. At the same time, anyone who now releases a game in Godot in C# or GDScript is immediately vulnerable to their code being directly stolen.

The makers of STS2 did not really have to worry about this - they are big enough to protect themselves, and have the power to pursue legal action against anyone. Also, players will naturally veer towards STS2 anyways due to its huge popularity.

But for small indie devs, especially as we are incentivized to release demo's... we are very vulnerable.

Even something as small as a demo will effectively release all your source code and games core mechanics out in public, and if your game is remotely original/successful, anyone (or any team) from anywhere around the world can easily steal the code, and recreate their own version of it in a matter of days. Especially if they already have mechanisms in place to do this at scale.

Speaking from experience, using AI to code in Godot (and probably other game engines) still takes a massive amount of work. We thankfully aren't at a point where an AI can just spit out a fully functional game from a single prompt, meaning recreating mechanics from scratch still requires real effort. However, Godot's easily fully retrievable source code completely nullifies that barrier. A bad actor doesn't need AI to reverse-engineer your game—they can just steal your code directly, then use AI to change the assets.

Counter argument: Some claim all code can be reverse engineered. This is not necessarily true. Packaging the code in a binary makes it much much more difficult to do so.

I am not saying we should all freak out tomorrow, but the general consensus when I research this topic seems to be dismissive, and I think that's the wrong mentality to have. In the same way that you lock your car door, or use a password - you should protect your code.


r/godot • • Dec 18 '25

selfpromo (games) My experience with Godot and a warning to anyone wanting to start gamedev

Thumbnail
youtube.com
25 Upvotes

r/godot • • Jan 18 '26

fun & memes Lightning shadow bug IRL lol

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/godot • • May 24 '24

resource - other What AI is good to use for Godot 4?

1 Upvotes

Wanting to get back into making a game in Godot 4 and wondering if there's a suitable AI to help code.

Does anyone use some sort of copilot, if so which one and how does it work?

Many thanks in advance.


r/godot • • Jun 24 '26

discussion I finished a 10-hour Godot 4 3D course — BotW-Inspired 3D Game

21 Upvotes

Hey r/godot! 👋

I just finished the Clear Code "Recreating Zelda: BotW in Godot" course — took me about 2.5 months working part-time.

Here's what I built and learned:

The prototype includes:

  • Third-person character controller with smooth camera

  • Melee combat, hitboxes and enemy reactions

  • Basic patrol/chase/attack AI

  • Hand-crafted 3D level with terrain and props

  • Dynamic lighting setup

  • Custom shaders (water, outline, grass wind)

  • Particle VFX for hits and ambient effects

Links:

💻 Source on GitHub: https://github.com/Lazy13909/Recreating_Zelda

It's not a real game — just a learning project. But I'm proud of how far I came from knowing nothing about 3D in Godot.

This post was written with the help of AI to correct grammar / structure my thoughts


r/godot • • Oct 02 '23

Discussion Is the discord affliated with this subreddit? Because the mods are on some insane power trip. Got banned for saying the word "ironic"

9 Upvotes

Edit: I have been unbanned.

One of the mods said this, and I'm saying it as best I can from memory:

"If someone misgenders someone by mistake, than that's fine,

If you keep misgendering someone even after they correct you then that's not ok, it's the same as calling someone a name they don't like

If someone has an issue with politeness, they can fuck off"

To which I replied to the last sentence "ironic" because he said to "fuck off" while mentioning politeness in the same sentence which I found... ironic.

Did they find me guilty of transphobia immediately and just permaban me from the sub?? I can't even appeal or message them?? I'm genuinely baffled at this.

Edit: removed unnecessary snarky comment.


r/godot • • Jul 09 '25

fun & memes Godot logo PNG icon image in trans pride colours

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/godot • • Dec 13 '23

Anyone else disappointed with W4 console porting pricing ?

0 Upvotes

Assuming that you want to port to all 3 consoles , the price (2000$) is identical to Unity Pro (2040$) , and almost 3 times more expensive than Game Maker(800$) , with Unreal even being free. Not to mention that Game Maker even has monthly option and they stated that they don't mind if someone takes 1 month sub just to export the game.

This squarely makes an engine that is famous for being free, into most expensive one for solo or small dev project.

I was hoping for at least one more tier of cheaper pricing for truly indie hobby devs, to help them in their game developing journey....


r/godot • • Sep 23 '26

selfpromo (games) My games keep getting compared to games I’ve never played!

0 Upvotes

r/godot • • Mar 26 '26

discussion Can we PLEASE do something about the moronic "can walls jump" spam?

67 Upvotes

It wasn't funny the first time around and it's literally just harrassing and dogpiling the original poster and confusing the living shit out of learners at this point.


r/godot • • Sep 20 '23

Unpopular opinion: I don't care about Unity devs at all

0 Upvotes

Sorry to everyone who might feel offended by the title but I'm sick of reading any warnings from anyone just migrating over from Unity. I'm not an expert in godot either, I just play around with the engine and I'm loving it. In _my_ opinion one of the best tools to teach you the basics of game development. If godot is not your safe harbour as a Unity dev: Fine, there's plenty of other options to explore. It might just be my personal experience, but I feel it's getting way out of hand with the "professional critisism" about godot.

I just want to thank the Godot Team for their great work, the passion that drives this project and the continuous updates we received over the years. And I'd like to mention this without 2 pages of criticism first. I'm having a blast using Godot!!!

Edit: this received way more feedback than expected. Clarification needed: it’s not addressed towards the post and articles that really post helpful stuff that with hints how to solve issues. I consider these part of the solution. But there’s also blame out there that just tells us how disappointed some people are because eg Godots 3d lacks features ✌🏻


r/godot • • Feb 19 '25

discussion Why showcasing your work in the Godot Community get backlash If It’s not free?

0 Upvotes

I’ve noticed an ongoing discussion in this community, and I’d love to hear your thoughts on it. Let’s put things into perspective:

Imagine you develop a game and decide to release it on Steam for free. That’s great! But while it’s free for players, it wasn’t free for you to make. You’re still covering costs like electricity, internet, food (because time is an investment, and we all need to eat), and other development-related expenses.

Now, let’s consider another scenario. You develop a game with Godot, which is fantastic because it’s open source, but this time, you want to sell it on Steam. If everything is expected to be free, how would independent developers sustain their work? And what happens if your game is successful and you want to grow into a studio? Suddenly, there are taxes, operating costs, software licenses, and many other financial realities to consider.

The fact that Godot is open source is a huge advantage, it gives us creative freedom without barriers. But that doesn’t mean everything made with it should be free. Even open-source projects have costs, and if the Godot developers ever wanted to, they could charge for the engine because "open source" doesn’t mean "without value." For example, publishing a multiplayer game on PlayStation requires paying for a license, it’s just part of the industry.

So why is it that, in this community, some people criticize others for sharing or promoting their work?

I run a small studio called Jettelly, where I create educational content related to game development (including Godot, like The Godot Shaders Bible). I started just like many of you, indie, working in my spare time, trying to make things happen. Now, I’m finally at a point where I can sustain my work, but I’ve noticed that whenever I post here, I sometimes receive backlash. Some people accuse me of making "ads" or insist that my work should be free, even though I also provide free assets.

I’m genuinely curious: How do you all feel about this? If we want this community to grow, shouldn’t we support developers, educators, and creators instead of discouraging them from making a living?

Wishing you all success in your projects, I’d love to hear your thoughts on this!


r/godot • • May 26 '24

resource - other Who’s made money?

0 Upvotes

Who here has made money with a godot game? How much and what was it? I’m trying to figure out if I could sell a game I made on steam or not.


r/godot • • Jul 07 '26

selfpromo (games) My game prototype

0 Upvotes

r/godot • • Oct 05 '25

help me How do you guys learn coding? Im frustrated that I had to use AI

0 Upvotes

I just replicated PONG. I made it good. The ball gradually becomes faster, the CPU opponent has a simple but cool feature where it detects the ball in a certain amount of range. It doesnt have a scoring system yet, but I was happy with what I made and i'm a complete beginner. However, 80-90 percent of the time, I use chat-gpt which i'm not proud of. Tho I made a memory for the ai to only describe to me what should I do first and not give the code, so I can learn the API, the nodes I should use, what signal I should connect, etc. But eventually I got frustrated and just ask the code then copy it (with some modifications I learned yt).

I'm beginning to get frustrated enough that I think i'll just stick to drawing. But i want to make games tho...BUT I CANT MAKE A DAMN SINGLE LINE CORRECTLY WITHOUT THE AID OF AI.

Do you guys experienced this? or maybe have a way to learn? or maybe I'll just stick to using AI until I learn, coz I actually learned some. Like lerp, clamps, signal, tho I still don't know how I can use them on my next project


r/godot • • Jan 28 '24

Your own issues are not Godot issues

50 Upvotes

I've been watching a lot of game jams lately and I've noticed a few things that happen to almost everyone that I watch.

They delete a file of which they previously added to another scenes scene-tree and when that scene breaks because it can no longer find the scene that they added, its automatically Godot's fault.

Now in their defence, Godot could help them out here and make steps to help removing the offending line(s) in the broken .tscn file without the need to open it in a text-editor, but it doesn't stop these people from saying its 100% Godot's fault.

I've also seen this issue pop up here numerous times and its usually the same thing. "I deleted a file and it broke another scene which that file was instanced in".

edit: While I still feel users should be more responsible after reading all the comments, I might have jumped the gun and Godot has taken steps to help with this. Thanks /u/cousinbenson


r/godot • • 29d ago

free tutorial Learn why my Godot game failed so yours doesn't

15 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

​I created a short video where I talk about 5 big reasons why my first major Godot game release failed. I highly recommend you take a look if you ever plan on publishing a Godot game so you can learn from my mistakes.

​Basically, I list out a few key issues and then share some strategies I wish I had known earlier to avoid them. Most of these were simple planning issues, but fixing them will help you get the much-needed growth I wish I’d had personally.

​It’s only about 8 minutes long, so let me know what you think: https://youtu.be/AijOoLnbxp4?is=8rjJS6luga16VwNK


r/godot • • Feb 01 '24

Discussion Last week I asked about your opinion of using AI in game development or not. I would like to share the results with you!

3 Upvotes

Nearly 300 game devs filled out my survey here on reddit, if to use or not to use AI for game development. I asked for their opinion on the subject and share the reasons behind their stance, which I have summarized in the following.

Top 3 Concerns Regarding AI-Generated Content:

  1. Quality and Integration Concerns: Developers express concerns over the perceived lack of quality and seamless integration of AI-generated art into gaming environments, citing deficiencies in design skills and aesthetic cohesion as prevalent issues.

  2. Ethical Issues and Copyright Infringement: A prevailing sentiment against AI-generated content, particularly in art, is rooted in fears of infringing upon human artists' work without consent, emphasizing the legal and ethical risks associated with potential copyright infringement.

  3. Negative Player Perception: Developers fear player rejection of AI-incorporated games due to the perceived subpar quality of AI-generated art, highlighting concerns about swift player recognition leading to a negative perception and subsequent loss of player engagement.

Top 3 Affirmative Perspectives using AI:

  1. Efficiency and Productivity: AI serves as a transformative force in enhancing efficiency and productivity by automating tasks like code generation and prototyping, offering valuable templates for further customization.

  2. Access to Skills: Acting as a resource for individuals lacking specific skills, AI enables non-artists or non-coders to access capabilities that would be challenging to obtain, filling skill-related gaps and facilitating the achievement of desired outcomes.

  3. Innovation and Exploration: AI fosters innovation by providing new avenues for creative expression and problem-solving, allowing developers and creators to experiment with novel ideas and push boundaries, potentially leading to breakthroughs and advancements in various fields.