Is this valid???
Hello, philosopher here. During my lectures we debated the existence of God. I know, the topic is classic but here me out. One person said - commenting on the theleological argument - it is possible that God exists but it is also possible that it does not.
Suddenly something stroke me. Listen to thought that was born in my mind: If it is possible that God does not exist then the God is not the God and therefore it cannot exist. Why? Because we define God as neccessary being. And if neccessary being is not neccessary that it cannot exist, right?
So look at this (1) Assume that my shirt is red (2) Assume that it is false that if my shirt is red then God exists (3) It follows: My shirt can be red and God could not exist (4) Then: God could not exist But if God could not exist, then God would not be God so it is contradiction.
So, if anything fails to prove that God exists, then God cannot exist?
Is it valid or not? What do you think?
Have a great day everybody.
0
u/Cheeslord2 Dec 05 '23
I wouldn't know, because I am not a Philosopher so I don't know your cant, but as a human who has read the words that you have written, it seems that this is subject to your arbitrary definition that it is necessary for God to exist. Some people have different definitions of God. You could define God as a being that exists and then it is not possible that God does not exist and you are still being logically self-consistent.
-1
Dec 05 '23
It’s not. That contradicts life itself. Humans that believe there’s nothing above them authority wise… that goes against basic fundamentals of this world. I think the problem is, we can’t grasp the concept of God out brains literally can’t do it. There’s a passage that says something like… I’ve showed (told?) you worldly things and you do no believe me, so how do you expect me to tell you heavenly things. There’s so much we don’t know, and to assume we know it all is truly ignorant.
1
u/Bossaveli Dec 06 '23
Lol..
I will keep this simple, Do you know who Imam Al-Ghazali is?
If you don't, know that you know nothing.
Watch this video, and you will see yourself.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JtN0Qwja8fk&pp=ygUYSW1hbSBhbCBnaGF6YWxpIGV0ZXJuaXR5
Goodluck.