r/github • • 20d ago

Question Why is GitHub ignoring our DMCA counter-notice?

On 17 September, a Microsoft employee filed a DMCA notice for Mojang, the company that makes Minecraft. GitHub took down our repo, AnarchyMod, and 14 forks the same day. We sent a counter-notice six and a half hours later.

That was 45 days ago. The repository page still says "Repository unavailable due to DMCA takedown." We followed up on 7 and 15 October, and opened an appeal under "Repository Access Issues" on 21 October. Every reply was automatic. Nobody at GitHub has actually answered us.

Under the DMCA, GitHub has to put the repo back 10 to 14 business days after a counter-notice, unless Mojang tells GitHub it has sued us. Our 14 business days ran out on 7 October. Nobody has sued us. So GitHub has to either restore the repo or tell us Mojang went to court. It has done neither. We have been waiting 45 days.

For context: I run a Minecraft server, 6b6t, and it was blacklisted by Mojang, so the game won't let players connect to it. The repo is a small Fabric mod that lets players join the server anyway. It has no Minecraft code or art in it. Mojang also claimed the mod breaks anti-circumvention law. GitHub itself didn't accept that and treated it as a copyright claim instead.

Mojang and GitHub are both owned by Microsoft. That's why we think someone inside Microsoft is blocking our counter-notice. Even so, GitHub is legally required to answer a DMCA counter-notice.

Why is GitHub ignoring it? Has this happened to anyone here?

629 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

203

u/Vivid-Snow-2089 20d ago • Popcorn

call your lawyer

3

u/qbasty7 19d ago

It seems to be the best option at this point to take legal action.

53

u/Relevant_Pause_7593 20d ago • Heartwarming

This is the only real answer here. It’s likely there is legal stuff happening already, and GitHub will defer to the lawyers

16

u/charles25565 20d ago

OP has some kind of access to lawyers and the lawyer already worked around this by hosting the code on a self-hosted file server.

https://6b6t.kianbrose.com/

9

u/CraftyPlayz_ 20d ago

Yes but still not having the code on GitHub will lose potential users who try to download the mod see that message and either just assume the mod is no longer available anywhere or get scared that they will get in legal trouble and give up

-1

u/No_Departure_1878 20d ago

Can't he just move to gitlab though?

8

u/filiphsandstrom 20d ago

That’s just postponing the issue till they DMCA there too, and then he would be stuck on a much worse platform with the same DMCA issue.

1

u/Wertbon1789 20d ago

Much worse platform, lol.

1

u/filiphsandstrom 20d ago

Yes, all git platforms are rather shit but with GitHub at least you have the ecosystem and you avoid most of the people moralfagging

0

u/Wertbon1789 20d ago

Just learned a new word, lol.

Especially on Github you get such people. At least I don't know where you have to be to not get them. And on AI, I'm all for it, it's kinda terrifying how many people just accept AI now, nothing changed, arguably it got worse, but there're just less people who seem to care.

1

u/filiphsandstrom 20d ago

I wish it was as simple as just being against AI. I’ve noticed that not keeping up with (or worse being against) AI leads to no job, no job leads to no money, no money leads to no food and I rather like food. So being against it is not an option if you wanna stay relevant within the software engineering field.

0

u/entityadam 19d ago

Yeah but don't use that word. You're not allowed to use it. It's reserved for 4chan incels.

-1

u/Wertbon1789 19d ago

Oh yes, it sounds like one of those words, I just never heard it before. But thanks for the suggestion.

54

u/Ok_Bug1610 20d ago

Move you git repository and code to another provider that doesn't have conflict of interest, like BitBucket.

17

u/cornmonger_ 20d ago

and if they go after that, self-host

0

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[deleted]

6

u/cornmonger_ 20d ago

forgejo works pretty well

2

u/Ok_Bug1610 20d ago

I'll check it out, thanks!

1

u/i-k-m 11d ago

BitBucket was good before. But with their "Just delete inactive repositories" plan, they lost several of my repos this month...

71

u/cyb3rofficial 20d ago

Before anyone does chatgpt or some ai search and gives you a generic copypasta garbage reply, Check whether your counter-notice ever appeared in the public github/dmca repo. If it never got published, that can mean it is still stuck in the initial review queue. GH Counters show up in the repo censored like originals.

7

u/mkosmo 20d ago

It's not. The only mention is in the original takedown notice published.

8

u/KTrain5369 20d ago

then it's likely stuck in the queue for some weird reason

6

u/Mobile_Syllabub_8446 20d ago • Popcorn

Just to be clear it doesn't matter about their beurocracy or ineptitude; the law is clear about what MUST happen and the timeframes.

5

u/KTrain5369 20d ago

oh absolutely, I'm just saying it's stuck there for reasons only (whoever tf heads GitHub now) knows

5

u/Wertbon1789 20d ago

Wasn't it Microsoft's AI lead, that also leads Github now, for some stupid reason. They probably have other things to do. Man, I would love for this to be blow up in their faces, but US laws are just shit.

5

u/mkosmo 20d ago

That or OP didn't properly file the counter.

5

u/KTrain5369 20d ago

didn't consider that somehow. but sounds like they already have filed it properly. either way they should've gotten a response back in <40d if it was or wasn't the proper place to file

15

u/PopehatXI 20d ago

13

u/PopehatXI 20d ago

I hope 6b6t is able to have their repository restored, and think Microsoft is in the wrong, but I think OP is leaving out important context. Like what Microsoft/Mojang are actually arguing. Good luck to the 6b6t team, though!

10

u/charles25565 20d ago

Oh, glad to see you guys! Yet somehow nobody noticed.


Under the DMCA, GitHub has to put the repo back 10 to 14 business days after a counter-notice, unless Mojang tells GitHub it has sued us.

I think that was a little bit of an understatement. That is a "safe harbor" provision and sadly, most platforms literally ignore it. Nearly all platforms that require the person filing to be authorized don't care, which is most websites, including GitHub.

There was little reason for GitHub to reinstate it because of that.

8

u/throwaway275275275 20d ago

The DMCA is worthless, notice how all the notices have the language of a sworn statement, something like "I swear under penalty of perjury that this claims are accurate". Yet we've heard of thousands of fake claims, and how many people have suffered the penalty of perjury ? It's made for big companies to censor you, and you have no protection against them

2

u/FelesNoctis 19d ago

The DMCA process was made for a much older, more primitive time in computing, and primarily aimed at video and music piracy. It's widely considered by anyone in the know to be outdated and in desperate need of an update due to both the march of technology and new concepts that weren't or couldn't be considered at the time. Unfortunately, both media and software corps lobby very hard to keep it this way, because updates to the process would make it more difficult to abuse.

8

u/PloxNox65 20d ago

A counter-notice has no meaning if the company just doesn't want to host your stuff anymore.  It just tells them they may put it back and not worry about liability,  but it doesn't force them to put it back.

Now if you where a paying customer they'd be slightly more inclined to put it back to keep your business,  but since there's no mentioning of that i think you're out of luck.

Just host it somewhere else

4

u/PopehatXI 20d ago

Why why’d they bother with the DMCA when they could have just blocked it with no reason given

2

u/Hefty-Reaction-3028 20d ago

In case it got OP to leave them alone

Counter-notifying is risky because the next step is getting sued if they don't take it down. So it can be used as a deterrent

I have no idea, this is a guess

1

u/HaMMeReD 20d ago

Probably to tell you they'll DMCA it if you put it up somewhere else.

3

u/SmashKick124 20d ago

Sounds like it's time for another Minecraft Anarchy News Special Report.

2

u/Moist_Heat9523 20d ago

Github belongs to Microsoft. They don’t shit in their own bed.

1

u/Dense_Gate_5193 19d ago • Popcorn

> Mojang also claimed the mod breaks anti-circumvention law.

earlier…

> I run a Minecraft server, 6b6t, and it was blacklisted by Mojang, so the game won't let players connect to it. The repo is a small Fabric mod that lets players join the server anyway.

IANAL but seems ToS busting no? also as comment op pointed out microsoft owns github and mojang. so, i’d host it elsewhere like bitbucket or gitlab or something.

2

u/GenericFoodService 17d ago edited 17d ago

Under the DMCA, GitHub has to put the repo back 10 to 14 business days after a counter-notice, [...] That was 45 days ago.

As far as I understand it the law does have other reasons listed that they could choose not to restore the content. GitHub did give a public reason in the notes above the markdown copy of DMCA notice itself;

One or more repositories in this DMCA takedown notice has been processed in accordance with GitHub's prohibition on sharing unauthorized product licensing keys, software for generating unauthorized product licensing keys, and/or software for bypassing checks for product licensing keys.
You can learn more in GitHub's Acceptable Use Policies.

The claim in the notice was that your code only exists and functions for the purpose of circumventing "technical and policy-based restrictions" and "facilitating continued access to a service operating in violation of Minecraft policies" which they allege violates 17 U.S.C. § 1201.

Your software, from what I can tell, circumvents copyright protection (modifying the game code to allow using your blacklisted service), specifically advertises the fact that it allows playing on "cracked" or pirated versions of the game on the homepage of your website, and is a commercial for-profit service.

If GitHub itself thinks that your repo violates their terms of service or some other U.S. Law, I'm not aware of anything in the DMCA itself requiring them to put it back up. Again, not a lawyer. If you think you have a case, get with a lawyer about it, but I'm not so confident in your side from what I can glean.

It swore, under penalty of perjury, that "The entire repository is infringing." Lying in a sworn statement like that is a crime.

I would advise avoid public statements like that. Similar statements sometimes constitute tort, and as a person who is not a lawyer, I see no reason to risk it.

We are in the European Union, [...] In 40 days, the only answer we got came from a machine. That is not a reasoned decision. It is not a decision at all.

Unless I am mistaken, GitHub gave their reason in plain English in a note above the copy of the DMCA notice; they believed that the DMCA notice is not strictly valid, but do still believe the repository violates the terms of service. Maybe I'm misunderstanding it

5

u/zorecknor 20d ago

You may opt to lawyer up and try to get the DMCA counter-notice to move forward, but bear in mind you are in the wrong. The "anti-circumvention law" is part of the DMCA (Section 1201) and is, infact, in the domain of a DMCA takedown.

That repo effectively bypass the DRM put in place to blacklist minecraft servers. It will be taken down one way or another, and the DMCA takedown is the less painful way.

Disclaimer, I'm not a lawyer. I just not a bit about the DMCA.

12

u/MetaHerobrine1 20d ago

OP explicitly states that GitHub is the one who dismissed the anti-circumvention claims, not OP. The very first sentence of Microsoft's takedown notice is as follows:

While GitHub did not find sufficient information to determine a valid anti-circumvention claim, we determined that this takedown notice contains other valid copyright claim(s).

So GitHub's own lawyers evaluated the claim (at least, I hope they're using lawyers to handle DMCA claims) and decided there wasn't enough evidence to move forward with an anti-circumvention takedown.

1

u/zorecknor 20d ago

Github DMCA are not handled by lawyers/councel (google it) so it is perfectly possible they missed it due ot the way the things are worded in the repo.

But as soon this is put into legal scrutiny and experts are brought to the table, it will be determined that they circumvented the blacklist mechanism.

Which they did. That is a fact. OP even said so.

I trust a Microsoft lawyer way more than Github Trust & Safety staff in matters of law.

3

u/john_dunlap 20d ago

Don't use GitHub

1

u/saltyourhash 20d ago

Microsoft gonna Microsoft.

1

u/ExitWP 20d ago

Sounds about right for MS

1

u/scott9426 19d ago

Not a lawyer but attempting to circumvent a TOS blacklist like you stated that your server was blacklisted can get your account/Ip ban or even a lawsuit. This is just outside of the repo to be informative. I would seek legal advice on that tho.

1

u/Only_Says_Idk_dude 18d ago

Microsoft has been pissing all over the place ever since Bill Gates appeared in the Epstein Files, fucking up elder scrolls, fucking up halo, fucking up minecraft

1

u/Hungry-And-High 18d ago

I actually have been keeping up with your story mate, you're fighting the good fight. Gitbub is owned by microsoft tho, it's a losing battle. I'd switch to gitlab or any self hosted solution.

You can also just do it trough torrent, not ilegal. Only if you were sharing IP protected stuff

1

u/Odd_Act_7673 17d ago

U ain't got enough money

1

u/elaineisbased 16d ago

I mean your add-on by its very nature circumvents digital restrictions they put into the game so they do have a right to remove it from GitHub as unfair as it may seem. You developed a mod that circumvents restrictions that the game put into place on how its copyrighted materials can be accessed.

1

u/AlexDeFoc 15d ago

Github support is KNOWN for having bad response times. I'm assuming Github and obviously the parent company Microsoft are up and coming company and still in the starting stage and cannot invest enough money into support, so hang in there. 💗

1

u/Ahmouse 14d ago

TIL that Mojang blacklists servers now. Microsoft does not like even the smallest forms of freedom.

1

u/Hopeful_Minimum95 9d ago

gitea, gitlab, codeberg... alternatives

1

u/Hopeful_Minimum95 9d ago

nintendo always dmca haha

1

u/1_ane_onyme 20d ago

Call your lawyer

Also just saying, but a mod shared from user to user or distributed by players themselves through a torrent cannot be taken down. Don't opt for these options yourself tho, it'd be circumventing their measures.

0

u/just_a_random_guy733 20d ago

This is not uncommon. I've had similar experiences with a repo where it took over 2 months before GitHub processed our counter-notice and restored the repo. I think you're in for a long wait.

0

u/DoubleOwl7777 20d ago

just host it somewhere else.

-1

u/Aggravating-Salt6284 19d ago

GitHub does not have to put it up under DMCA.

They can now put it up and remain in safe harbour.

They can also choose to not host it for any reason or no reason.

-2

u/Aggressive_Ad2122 20d ago

6b6t?

hey 2b2t players, someones trying to copy you lol

-4

u/Spiritual_Shine_1184 20d ago

Microsoft is Github and they do not need to protect themselves from themselves legally so DMCA notice is irrelevant and they are using their right to ignore you on their own platform at this point. Find a non Microsoft host where the DMCA notice probably wouldn't hold up.

2

u/tcptomato 20d ago

using their right to ignore you on their own platform at this point.

There is no such thing.