r/github • • Apr 16 '26 • This 1 Mindblown 1

Discussion A broken GitHub support system is destroying careers overnight

Before anything else: this is not an account recovery request.

This is about what happens when a support flow stops leading to a human being — or breaks due to a UI inconsistency that made it into production.

Right now, accounts can be flagged by automated systems or false reports and pushed into a dead loop. That is a serious failure mode, and there is currently no clear way out of it.

When an account gets flagged, it can effectively disappear — along with all of its repositories.

And what if you have maintained that repository for over 9 years, it is used by more than 230,000 projects, and it has thousands of stars? Apparently none of that matters. It still gets handled entirely by automation.

You do not get a proper explanation. You do not get a clear reason. Your account just disappears — no prior notice, no warning, no follow-up.

Then you open a ticket, and you automatically receive a response telling you that, if you do not want to see that message again, you should check a box confirming you have already contacted GitHub about this issue.

So you open another ticket — but there is no field where you can answer “yes” to that question.

So what do you do? You fill out the form, include the previous ticket number to show that you already contacted GitHub — and what happens?

You receive the exact same automated response again, telling you to check a box that does not exist.

That is not an appeal process. It is a dead loop.

The most disturbing part is not that systems can make mistakes. Any system can fail.

The disturbing part is that human review — the absolute minimum in a case like this — is no longer reachable.

And that is where this stops being about one account and starts becoming a trust problem.

Because trust in a platform starts to collapse when:

- automation can flag you

- automation can close your appeal

- and the official instructions send you to a step that no longer exists

At that point, this is no longer just a bad suspension.

It is a production failure in a system people rely on for work, reputation, open source, and income.

And if this can happen to someone maintaining code used by 230K+ projects, it can happen to anyone.

Including you.

---

Note:

I’m not asking for a review of my case. I’m not asking for privileges or priority.

I’m asking for something much more basic: a support process that is real, consistent, and reachable.

Because right now, this is not just about one account, one project, or one developer.

It’s about what happens when a system people depend on for work and income fails in a way they cannot recover from.

My income depends entirely on open source. Today, I genuinely don’t know how I’m going to pay rent next month or even cover basic expenses in the coming weeks.

But this is not about sympathy.

This is about a production system that, in its current state, can silently remove someone’s work, reputation, and livelihood — without a functioning path to resolution.

And that should not be possible.

https://web.archive.org/web/20260221170523/https://github.com/jonataslaw/getx

892 Upvotes

145 comments sorted by

27

u/GreatRedditorThracc Apr 16 '26

I hope you get your account reinstated soon!

7

u/JonatasLaw Apr 17 '26

thanks bro!

4

u/Fluent_Press2050 Apr 17 '26

You will. It took a few days for mine.

They said automated systems flag accounts for manual review. Not sure what caused the flag. 

3

u/insoniagarrafinha Apr 18 '26

Any update fren?

90

u/mpersico Apr 17 '26

Tomorrow, not that I support anything anybody uses, I’m going to propagate my stuff from GitHub to GitLab, codeberg and I’m going to stand up gitea locally.

18

u/TravisVZ Apr 17 '26

I've got all my repos mirrored to my own Gitea, which is backed up nightly to R2 - both to a "dailies" bucket and once a week to a "weeklies" bucket. A script on my server automatically picks up new repos and mirrors them as well.

The only annoyance with this setup is that once a year I have to update my GitHub token for my private repos; this is tedious because it has to updated for each one, there's no blanket "do them all" option - unless you know where the config files are on disk and can finagle sed into rewriting the tokens for you!

5

u/TjFr00 Apr 17 '26

Want to do exactly the same. R u willing to share some details on your setup and experience? I’d like to know how you handled this process, bc I’d seems an unbelievable amount of manual work to get to that point. Thanks in advance!

6

u/praetor- Apr 17 '26

Here's a GitHub Action that mirrors in real time (as opposed to on a schedule): https://github.com/slskd/slskd/blob/master/.github/workflows/mirror.yml

3

u/TravisVZ Apr 18 '26

Somewhere on the web I found a script that can scan all the GitHub repos on your account, check if they're in your Gitea, and add the ones that aren't. In Gitea you can set the default mirroring interval (how often it pulls changes), which you can also change per repo; my more "important" ones I mirror every 10 minutes.

In Gitea's documentation are the necessary commands to export a backup, including the git repos themselves. Importantly, you need to stop Gitea to guarantee a stable snapshot, but it's quick and then you're back online; plus I have it scheduled for the middle of the night, when I'm not coding anyway, and I'm actually committing to and working from GitHub anyway.

The final piece is a tool called rclone, which can sync a directory to an S3-compatible bucket; I use Cloudflare's R2. I actually have two rclone commands in the backup script: one uploads to my "dailies" bucket, which is set (IIRC) to retain items for 14 days; the next, which checks the date and only runs on Sundays, does the same to the "weeklies" bucket, which I keep for 3 months.

I can share the exact scripts I use later, after I make sure I don't have any tokens/keys in them (I'm bad about that, especially when "I just want to try something" turns into "oh look now I depend upon this critical functionality"!)

5

u/Qs9bxNKZ Apr 17 '26 • Heartwarming

The problem with GitLab (and I have quite a few repos there for production deployment to AWS, business use-case) is that it’s just not popular. A lot of people aren’t looking to deploy to GitLab and a recent post made it obvious how popular and visible a GitHub repository is by comparison.

And the cost isn’t all that different. But you get a whole lot more features (and upgrades like GHAS) built into GitHub.

1

u/TheStormers Apr 25 '26

It’s better for teams or orgs but personal projects should exits in GitHub for the searchability . But if you’re a team having big monorepos the built in CI/CD is worth its weight.

5

u/profcube Apr 17 '26

How is GitLab or codeberg better? Asking for a friend.

9

u/kivimango23 Apr 17 '26

Not pushing AI shit and stupid alghoritms into a site serving static git files/repositories ?

1

u/Qs9bxNKZ Apr 17 '26

It’s not. Cost is about the same (for GitLab) and the feature set is lacking (but in some ways, project hierarchy is nice)

Given a choice, and I give people choices as we just foot the bill, they prefer GH by 99:1

That one is for the DevOps and project structuring in a more regimented and audited environment.

1

u/mpersico Apr 18 '26

Not necessarily better, but they serve as backup resources.

2

u/jefwillems Apr 18 '26

I started using codeberg and have been pretty happy with it. There is the occasional downtime, but github has the same lately so yeah

1

u/Idiotasincero Apr 30 '26

Eu uso o google drive kkkk Old School

39

u/cowboyecosse Apr 17 '26

They are so understaffed in Support for sure.

25

u/AlephNull0207 Apr 17 '26

“Replaced” by AI

7

u/veverkap Apr 17 '26

Mind bogglingly understaffed

3

u/luizhrios Apr 18 '26

Also incompetent

30

u/insoniagarrafinha Apr 17 '26

Straight up nightmare fuel

15

u/hal0sin8 Apr 17 '26

This is a problem that will only grow worse as we become more dependent on AI. Same issue with youtube right now. No humans in the process.

13

u/greenstake Apr 17 '26

Sounds like the appeal process is working as intended: frustrate people until they give up and go away. Problem solved.

7

u/Noch_ein_Kamel Apr 17 '26

Appeals? Our banning process is so elaborated we get 0 appeals.

6

u/guilmour Apr 17 '26

What a nightmare. Good luck, OP

4

u/-Animus Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

There is an European alternative that is a nonprofit: codeberg.org

4

u/AtoZicX Apr 18 '26

Got my account of 8 years banned with no clear indication of exactly why. Raised a ticket in support after jumping weird hurdles. And that's it. no responses, no updates, been 2 weeks, and I have lost all hopes of getting it back. This really sucks.

4

u/shadedjedi Apr 20 '26

I’m dealing with something similar right now and it’s been really frustrating.

My GitHub account (7+ years old) got suspended out of nowhere with no prior warning. I’ve only used it for personal projects, open source forks, and as a portfolio for job applications. Nothing unusual.

I reached out to support immediately when I noticed (was getting 403 errors first), but so far I’ve only received the same generic response saying I violated ToS related to GitHub Actions. No mention of which repo, which workflow, or what exact clause.

I’ve opened multiple tickets at this point:

  • #4296198 (no replies on this ticket yet)

  • #4301782

  • #4302067

All got basically the same copy-pasted reply, and I haven’t been able to talk to a real person yet.

The most frustrating part is there’s no clear way to even recover my data if they won’t reinstate the account. This is stuff I rely on for my work and job applications.

If anyone has gone through this and managed to get a proper review or recover their repos, I’d really appreciate any advice.

1

u/Jolly-Personality-45 10d ago

What happened?

1

u/shadedjedi 10d ago

It got unblocked one day on its own, the team emailed me, but no clarity on why it got banned.

1

u/No_Teacher_5775 7d ago

how long, from 7 months ago was this?! i need to know

1

u/shadedjedi 2d ago

Took about 2-3 months to get unblocked.

3

u/brnom Apr 17 '26

good luck

3

u/Technical-Macaron367 Apr 17 '26

Thats a crime github, you gona pay for that!!

9

u/_simple_man Apr 17 '26

Fuck microslop and their push to AI on everything

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '26

[deleted]

2

u/notify-ctrl Apr 17 '26

Yeah typical "it's not ... it's ..."

2

u/ggGTravis Apr 17 '26

So sorry for that man

2

u/x0zerolight Apr 17 '26

good luck with this, op. hope this gets fixed asap.

2

u/DKatri Apr 17 '26

Did the email from support not give you any explanation at all?

2

u/Medical_Toe_853 Apr 17 '26

vai dar certo

2

u/Ok_Box_6519 Apr 17 '26

I gave my upvote to help. I hope you're lucky

2

u/Fluent_Press2050 Apr 17 '26

Support is wild. 

One ticket got a response in 3 days another ticket got a response in 57 days.

I also got my account restored but now I got rebilled for everything. I wonder how long it’ll take to get a response from billing. 

1

u/Qs9bxNKZ Apr 17 '26

If you pay, 1-2 days.

1

u/Fluent_Press2050 Apr 17 '26

I’m on Teams. So $4/mo

It doesn’t make a difference. Maybe on enterprise it does. 

1

u/Qs9bxNKZ Apr 17 '26

Yes that is probably it.

1-2 days here if I represent the company or use my personal Gmail account.

I’d be pissed if spending 1000x or infinitely more than free getting worse performance in the queue.

I know they have enterprise customers numbering in excess of 20000 subscribers (eg GSK) and that’s just a licensed count.

2

u/Dear-Somewhere-8104 Apr 17 '26

I hope the best asap

2

u/SallesTTT Apr 17 '26

Help a bro out GitHub !

2

u/Tiny-Manufacturer187 Apr 17 '26

My 10+ apps are in risk, @github please resolve this suspend issue ASAP

2

u/Pretend-Pangolin-846 Apr 18 '26

Codeberg seems to be the solution

2

u/luizhrios Apr 18 '26

Github has the worst support I have ever seen, when it's not bots, it's the most incompetent and retarded person ever.

I hope Github dies one day. Until then, my company uses self hosted git and when not, GitLab, way better.

2

u/DeadLolipop Apr 18 '26

It's not just their support system, their interview system was borked when I tried to interview. And even pointing out it was fucked, they did nothing and ghosted me.

2

u/techy-tech69 Apr 20 '26

Any organization of any size needs a Support Team of HUMAN staff the actually handle cases. I agree 100% with you, when automation can close your appeal, that is where real problems are systematically ignored.

Hope you get your account reinstated quickly bro

2

u/Datarecovery09 Apr 20 '26

When in doubt, threaten to sue them. (Doesn't matter if you actually have a case or not, just claiming that you might do that increases your chances to talk to a human drastically.)

2

u/Fit_Elderberry_5956 Apr 21 '26

I was banned before a few weeks . Then I try to contact the support via their support website. After 2 weeks I get my account back with the sentence : Sometimes our abuse-detecting systems highlight accounts that need to be manually reviewed.

Upon review, we’ve cleared the restrictions from your account, so you have full access to GitHub again. So I really not understand why they banned accounts without a reason

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 24d ago

Got this message a year ago when they misflagged my hexdump repository as hate speech. Not even an apology, just the generic "oops our systems did it again"

3

u/SOLID-DevMan Apr 17 '26

Support what support?, they are the definition of dis functional

2

u/Fantastic-Monitor946 Apr 19 '26

That’s terrible! Hope that you get your account reinstated as soon as possible!

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 24d ago edited 24d ago

I got suspended as well. I logged into GitHub one day, changed my login information because it was outdated, then changed my display name, and then created a new organization. Shortly after, I would get 403s and "Your browser did something weird" errors before getting suspended.

Edit: I have been on GitHub since about 2022 by the way.

I used GitHub for my personal projects, a game me and my team are working on (that we now no longer have access to), and also backup repos too. But I also use it for my CIS115 class. Yet, when I sent them a support ticket over 9 days ago, all I got was this.

Hello,
Thank you for contacting GitHub Support.
Some activity on your account was flagged by our abuse-detection systems for manual review, as it may conflict with our Terms of Service.
Could you please share a bit more about how you plan to use GitHub?
We look forward to your response.
Thanks,

I gave them my name, my exact issues, exactly how I was using github, and not only am I not addressed by name, but they ask me a question I already pretty much answered.

But I try to be patient and reasonable and give them a more detailed answer... and now I am sitting here waiting. My instructor literally had to give me alternate versions of the assignments through emails because I can no longer use codespaces for the labs.

Edit: May I also add that on my home wifi, every time I try to see other repos or organizations, it now tries to force prompt me to login despite knowing I am suspended, which is really cruel in my personal opinion as now I've basically been locked out from the community as well as my account.

----

IF GitHub's support team even unsuspends me, I am moving my repositories to GitGud.io because I already talked to the owner of that website personally and I know they will not suspend me for working on my original projects or doing anything else.

Edit 2: This is not the first time their moderation systems have flagged me before as in the past my old hexdump repository got flagged because apparently sarcasm in the readme their moderation system interpreted as hate speech. It took them a couple of days but they fixed it last time although I was not fully suspended. It just made my contributions private and made my stars worth nothing and my repos hidden. They could've just done that again because at least I would have been able to move my repos and still do my assignments... but no a year later they had to suspend me because apparently making my login info not suck is suspicious

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 21d ago

Update: They finally unsuspended me with this message:

Hello,

Thanks for contacting GitHub Support. Our apologies for the delay in getting back to you; we are currently dealing with higher than usual request volumes and are working to respond to priority issues such as yours as quickly as possible.

Sometimes our abuse detecting systems highlight accounts that need to be manually reviewed.

We've cleared the restrictions from your account, so you have full access to GitHub again.

Please let me know if you need anything else.

Best regards,

Although I'm glad they unsuspended me, this is the exact message they sent me last time verbatim. Also because of this whole drama, I am still going to move my repositories.

I am just grateful that I have access to my organizations repos again and can now do my assignnments for CIS115 again.

1

u/Jolly-Personality-45 10d ago

Thank you for the update and I'm glad you have access to your repos so that you can at least move them elsewhere. I would span GitHub with more accounts to hold your repos just for safety and put your eggs and duplicate them across different platforms if you can't safely store them locally.
I just got my generic support first email yesterday asking me what I'm going to use Github for, and I hope it gets resolved.
It seems like it took them 3 days to get back to you, so I'm hopeful....

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 8d ago

It took them 8 and a half days actually (I made the post days after waiting), but yeah thanks for the suggestion. w^

1

u/xxalct Apr 17 '26

up up up

1

u/soscavuca Apr 18 '26

Help this guy

1

u/GentleHawk1 Apr 19 '26

Any updates, bro?

2

u/WinXaito Apr 19 '26

It seems the repo is back https://github.com/jonataslaw/getx But it would be great to know why/what happened ?

1

u/dvdnotfound Apr 19 '26

That’s sucks man

1

u/Negative-Security299 Apr 20 '26

Help our dev brother 

1

u/stvaccount Apr 20 '26

This is Microsoft, one of the most hated companies in the world.

1

u/belheaven Apr 20 '26

Its back, right? Just checked

1

u/juanluisback Apr 24 '26

This is a threat I had never even considered. I had stopped using GitHub for personal stuff (very happy with Tangled) but the possibility of having my account and activity of 17 years wiped out had never crossed my mind. After reading this, I've started exporting all my data and will think of how to properly back it up.

1

u/HydraDragonAntivirus Apr 24 '26

Samething happened to me but my project is not big as yours.

1

u/ilooperal Aug 17 '26

I got banned too. I was just merging my side branch into the main branch when GitHub suddenly stopped working. After refreshing the page, I saw that my session had ended and my account was suspended. I created a ticket and its been 2 days already. And they replied to my ticket asking, 'Could you please share a bit more about how you plan to use GitHub?' WTF? I've been using GitHub for 7 years and they're asking me how I plan to use it!

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 24d ago

I got that exact message too.

1

u/ilooperal 18d ago

My account was re-enabled two months, after my second ticket. They didn’t even provide a proper explanation.

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 18d ago

Mine got reinstated like a day or two ago with no explanation either.

but im glad its back now

1

u/Gandalf_bruxo Apr 17 '26

Not the first and definitely not the last case. GitHub support has been a joke for some time, hope they reinstate your accout ASAP

3

u/veverkap Apr 17 '26

Or it’s too few employees who are overworked and trying to help people with the few tools they have.

1

u/skroll Apr 17 '26

Critical infrastructure should not be hosted on Github.

1

u/hondashadowguy2000 May 01 '26

The irony of complaining about how AI is ruining the internet when this post was very clearly written with ChatGPT.

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 24d ago

There's a difference between using AI to help you reach your goal rather than relying on AI as a moderation system with little to no human involvement. ChatGPT could not have attached those screenshots or properly opened archive.org. More than likely, this post was written originally by OP, then they put it through an AI to make it sound more coherent.

0

u/Acebulf Apr 18 '26

SlopGPT post

-2

u/AaronBonBarron Apr 17 '26

Ironic that you're upset by AI, but couldn't even write a Reddit post without it.

1

u/Squirrel_Nuts-333 24d ago

I get why you are pointing this out but there is a difference between using AI to help you reach your goal rather than relying on AI as a moderation system with little to no human involvement.

An LLM couldn't have attached those screenshots or properly opened archive.org. More than likely, this post was written originally by OP, and then they probably cringed at their and put it through an AI to make it sound more coherent.

And look, I get that wanting to hear a human speak instead of an AI is something most of us here prefer, but at the same time what if the original version of what OP would have wrote was incoherent and not consistent to anyone but them?

0

u/Vast_Abrocoma_7770 Apr 19 '26

Not everyone is fluent in English dude

3

u/AaronBonBarron Apr 19 '26

I'd rather read an ESL attempt at English than soulless ChatGPT slop

1

u/Vast_Abrocoma_7770 Apr 19 '26

Soulless is what you are

2

u/NatoBoram Apr 20 '26

Tu remarqueras que de traduire un texte en anglais n'ajoute pas des signes d'IA à en plus finir.

In other words, you're making the argument that ESL people are incapable of writing in their own language, which is very disrespectful.

0

u/Vast_Abrocoma_7770 Apr 20 '26

That's not what I said. Not even remotely. Try reading what's actually written next time.

-1

u/ThinkMarket7640 Apr 17 '26

I’m not reading your slop

0

u/Qs9bxNKZ Apr 17 '26

How much are you paying for GitHub?

If you’ve not moved to a GHEC solution, paying for the platform, what do you expect? Top tier service for nothing?

Look at it from a Microsoft perspective, they know you are a captive audience and aren’t monetized by you directly. Are the going to focus on the guy with the CC or the one who is an influencer and crowd-source (or bot driven) popularity?

Remember it’s a business and no business is giving you everything for free.

2

u/countnfight Apr 17 '26

Think of how much open source was on GitHub before Microsoft bought it. Sure, it was always a business, but many of us were using it (and unknowingly training Copilot) years before it became...whatever it is now.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/JonatasLaw Apr 18 '26

I hope so, thank you for your support all these years