r/github • u/nikneem • Jun 03 '25
Question Is this allowed?
Just a question, I saw this on an open source library, but I wonder if this is allowed and complies with the GitHub Terms of Service.
186
u/cgoldberg Jun 03 '25
That repo is MIT licensed. Take the code and do whatever you want with it. If it really has some stupid feature that phones home and reports whether you starred the repo, remove the code that does that and carry on with your day.
Personally, I wouldn't touch software that tried to place an idiotic restriction like that.
20
u/Atulin Jun 04 '25
It's the IDE plugin that supports what's on the repo that's locked behind starring it. Far as I can tell, those plugins are closed-source
6
u/lavahot Jun 04 '25
This looks sketch as hell. I wouldn't touch that software with a 10 foot software toucher.
15
12
1
u/Safebox Jun 10 '25
Technically it's not illegal. Apps and mobile do this all the time with reviews, I don't think it's been taken to court and it isn't really protected or forbidden under any laws that I can think of. Though even if you did take them to court over it, I imagine they'd argue something like preventing bot spam; which is ridiculous but worse arguments have been made successfully.
1
u/nikneem Jun 11 '25
With illegal, I was more referring to the GitHub Terms of Use instead of a certain country's law
6
u/philthyNerd Jun 04 '25
That would definitely be reason enough for me to distrust the project entirely and not use it.
If it's actually against GitHub ToS, it would be interesting to have a reference to the specific section that targets behavior like this.
5
u/iconic_sentine_001 Jun 03 '25
Reading the name and not seeing the logo got me wondering what these people were building, infact it was scary.
6
u/-Kerrigan- Jun 04 '25
https://github.com/nuke-build/nuke
Personally, I'll stick to Jenkins or GitHub Actions
0
u/iamprogrammerlk_ Jun 08 '25
No.. Charge your phone please...
1
u/nikneem Jun 08 '25
You came 4 days late... And yes, look at the comments, indeed seems illegal
1
-32
u/Noch_ein_Kamel Jun 03 '25
Why do you think it's not?
29
u/nikneem Jun 03 '25
According to the acceptable use policy, this is manipulation of the platform, which is not allowed.
36
u/YT__ Jun 03 '25
Could be flagged as Rank Abuse, since requiring users to start your repo is going to artificially inflate it.
I feel like this, or something like this, was brought up a few months back and it was a shit show in the comments.
0
Jun 04 '25
[deleted]
-5
u/Noch_ein_Kamel Jun 04 '25
Imagine being downvoted for not knowing and asking questions!
1
u/andynzor Jun 05 '25
If everyone asked "why" every time they came across something they did not know, Reddit (or just about any other discussion platform for that matter) would drown in noise and become unusable.
Ask "why" from yourself instead and you might learn something.
1
u/Noch_ein_Kamel Jun 05 '25
Ooor... people just post their reasoning when they post on reddit implying someone is breaking the Github ToS?
0
Jun 03 '25
[deleted]
77
u/nikneem Jun 03 '25
Yeah, it's fun stuff... But still, if you want to monetize your OSS project (which is reasonable imho), put a proper license on it. This is not the way
0
Jun 03 '25
[deleted]
71
u/Redmega Jun 03 '25
Each star fragment is worth 300 rupees, but they’re a pain to harvest cause you have to go sky diving.
25
u/really_not_unreal Jun 04 '25
Not to mention that you need to collect them before 5 AM or they'll despawn.
7
u/trust-me-br0 Jun 04 '25
You guys are kidding, right?
Right?
23
u/really_not_unreal Jun 04 '25
Nope, Nintendo made it an intentional game mechanic when developing GitHub.
2
u/Optane_Gaming Jun 30 '25
Nintendo developed GitHub??? 👀
1
u/really_not_unreal Jun 30 '25
Absolutely
1
u/Optane_Gaming Jun 30 '25
I just want to grasp and understand in the correct way as possible... Like were the founders of Nintendo who developed it?
→ More replies (0)
0
Jun 03 '25
[deleted]
33
u/Booty_Bumping Jun 04 '25
It's not allowed, as per the Github Acceptable Use Policy
10
u/assembly_wizard Jun 04 '25
Which part? I've gone over all of it now and couldn't find anything wrong
There's no automated starring, no spam, no personal data
28
u/Booty_Bumping Jun 04 '25 edited Jun 04 '25
I guess it doesn't explicitly say anything about this kind of manual star gaming where the only automated part is the check, but certain sections point to "inauthentic activity" broadly.
Edit: This is probably the closest rule:
[Spam or Inauthentic activity] incentivized by (or incentivizes inauthentic engagement with) rewards such as cryptocurrency airdrops, tokens, credits, gifts or other give-aways.
1
u/timonix Jun 05 '25
I may be wrong. But this doesn't feel like it applies. They aren't getting a reward. Beyond the product itself that is. Which surely can't count
2
u/ElPablit0 Jun 05 '25
Not getting a reward but this is very likely related with « inauthentic engagement » as user is forced to star
-23
Jun 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/drcforbin Jun 04 '25
I'm genuinely curious, why?
2
Jun 05 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/drcforbin Jun 05 '25
It never occurred to me that stars and security were related, but I can see how you'd get there, a wisdom of the crowd kinda thing. I'm certain I've done similar, and that most of us do it all the time one way or another, choosing one library over another because of its popularity.
9
u/chris5790 Jun 04 '25
The sad thing about Nuke is that the tooling itself is really great but the author is a d*ck in every way possible while he wonders nobody is helping him out. It’s really weird that JetBrains is employing people with such an personality.