r/github • • Jun 29 '24

Why is it sometimes so difficult to find software downloads on GitHub?

I know that it's primarily for source code, but it's also used to host a lot of compiled software as well, often with no other official downloads on other websites. It feels very unintuitive for this purpose, as many times I will try to find the download page only to end up looking at individual assets and code unable to make any progress. Currently, I'm trying to download and old build of RPCS3 because I got a patched version of the executable to make a specific game work properly but it's 2 years old and the dlls in the most recent archives won't work with it, but I can't find where I'm supposed to download the software itself. Why is this site designed like this

2 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

GitHub isn't a site to download your everyday software.

It's a platform for developers to store code and do version control and collaboration. It's intended to be used by programmers and engineers, if you aren't an engineer or a programmer you shouldn't be using the platform in the first place because it's not your "software downloads 🤓" website.

1

u/PineappleOnPizza- Oct 26 '25

Late reply obviously but I think this is an unfair representation. People like myself who are very unfamiliar with github are not using it because we want github to be a download centre, it's because many small odd programs that are needed for niche things like mods or specific tools are *only* available on github and other download sites don't exist.

It seems very odd that such programs are expected to be exclusively used by professional software engineers who already know how github and building projects works.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26

But there are mods that are only available on github. At least make it easier for us non-autistic devs to download y'alls shit.

1

u/Ryetz Aug 02 '26

You and Quora should make out.

1

u/Natural_Cod1420 Sep 12 '26

wo would like to avoid using it to download things, but some devs do publish software there.

0

u/Careful_Huckleberry Jul 15 '25

what a reddit ass argument
just the nice implication of being superior
actually defending the horrible design is insane

1

u/StarChaser1879 Mar 01 '26

Doesn’t matter what a lot of people use it for, it was made for code sharing and collaboration not for downloading and hosting software

0

u/TheCovid-19SoFar Mar 16 '26

Doesnt matter what it was meant for, people don’t need to be completely headass about answering such an inoffensive question.

1

u/StarChaser1879 Mar 16 '26

Except the way the question was asked isn’t inoffensive, and Google has plenty of answers

1

u/TheCovid-19SoFar Apr 13 '26

Lmao you’re offended by the OP?

Google led to this post, genius.

-9

u/nerfClawcranes Jun 29 '24

a lot of people seem to use it for the same sorts of things I look for even though I'm not a programmer, like some modding tools and whatnot

6

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

Still it's not intended to be a software download website and it's normal that it won't work that way.

-7

u/nerfClawcranes Jun 29 '24

why do people use it to host software? that's not even meant as an argument against your point or anything, i get what you're saying. it's just i'm confused as to why people use it for that purpose when that's not what it's even for. isn't that really counterintuitive?

7

u/creeva Jun 29 '24

They do t want to run a second site or location.

2

u/eccentric-Orange Jun 30 '24

It's convenient and free.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24

[deleted]

1

u/sysnickm Jun 30 '24

I think he means hosts the software downloads in addition to the code.

1

u/Lenni009 Jun 30 '24

Here are two examples of software that I regularly use that only host their executable on GitHub, but keep their code closed source (although one of them intends to publish the code at some point in the future):

https://github.com/goatfungus/NMSSaveEditor
https://github.com/zencq/NomNom

2

u/random_redditor24234 Jun 30 '24

Doesn’t matter what a lot of people use it for, it was made for code sharing and collaboration not for downloading and hosting software

32

u/Snipedzoi Jun 29 '24

Github is a code repository for code, not software. Software takes extra work to build. Open Source Maintainers Owe You Nothing If it is compiled look in Actions or release, or see whether there is an external download page.

2

u/An_Actual_AI Jan 10 '26

Then why is more than half of the shit on github meant to be downloaded by users lol

1

u/StarChaser1879 Mar 01 '26

it isn't.

1

u/TACOMUSTDYE Jun 10 '26

but it is lol

1

u/StarChaser1879 Jun 10 '26

more than 70 is niche packages.

11

u/sysnickm Jun 29 '24

Depends on the app, but many need to built on the platform they will be running on.

Many repo owners don't want to maintain binaries and support for multiple platforms.

3

u/kurucu83 Jun 30 '24

GitHub is primarily for the development of software, not the release of it.

Whether repo owners want to build binaries or not, they may not put them on GitHub at all, or make them easy to find there.

1

u/kabiskac Jul 11 '26

Just set up CI builds for all those platforms. It's easy and free, no excuses.

5

u/Jmc_da_boss Jun 29 '24

This is like asking why it's not clear how to tow a trailer with a formula 1 car

"Why is this site designed like this"

Because of your first sentence lmao. It's for source code. Not for end user binaries, full stop.

Some open source devs choose to publish binaries on GitHub for some idiotic reason but that's them abusing the sites features for a purpose it's not designed for, which isn't GitHub's fault.

3

u/eccentric-Orange Jun 30 '24

I often put binaries and such in a release. Do you think that's wrong or against the convention too?

Just wanted opinion/advice so that I can better maintain my repos. Thanks!

1

u/Jmc_da_boss Jun 30 '24

Is your software meant to be distributed as an end user application for common consumption outside of programming?

If so yes that's a poor use of the release feature. You should spin up a small website and serve it that way with a standard download button.

2

u/eccentric-Orange Aug 06 '24

Hey, sorry I never replied to you!

No - mostly, not intended for end "end" users. I usually design hardware products (such as PCBs) and embedded firmware. So, the binaries are usually fabrication files and similar.

Sometimes, yes, I do write desktop-software that produces executables. For that, I'll keep your advice in mind, thank you!

1

u/davorg Jun 30 '24

As others have said, that's not what GitHub is for. That said, there are a few features that can make it easy to distribute software using GitHub:

  • There's no practical limit on the size of a project's README file. So you could easily include a section aimed at end-users, telling them how to download, install and use your software

  • The "releases" and "packages" features (visible in right-hand column of the repo's main page) make it easy to distribute an artifact that is build from your source code. You can even your GitHub Actions to build and release those artifacts automatically

  • You can use GitHub Pages to build and host an entire web site for your project

So the tools are certainly there. But it's up to the individual projects to decide to what extent they make use of them.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '24

It is just that everybody misunderstands the idea behind GitHub, despite the fact that it is very simple. It is not a site for uploading software for users. It is a site with which developers can assist each other, and academic research.

1

u/oFradique Jun 30 '26

I started my professional career as a developer (in the 90's, when "GO TO"s were a thing) so I kindly ask "developers" to spare me the usual BS about how superior "they" are. Spoiler alert: developers are also end users. If I'm developing code, with a -2 (minus two) hours deadline, my boss fuming, the client waiting, 4TB SSD almost full, the HDD developing bad sectors, and I quickly need some kind of niche tool... how long do I have to RTFM on GitHub and "compile" code? ;-)

0

u/dcoupl Jun 29 '24

Learn to build the software you want using the documentation in the repo or GTFO

0

u/YeNerdLifeChoseMe Jun 30 '24

I'm sorry you're getting several unhelpful answers. I've been a software developer for over 30 years and use GitHub professionally. I don't feel the need to belittle you if it's not making sense to you. Feel free to ask me questions directly.

TL;DR -- Releases/downloads are often hard to find because that's not the sites primary purpose. The responsibility rests on the repository owner to make those available and easy to find. Many repository owners don't have the time or knowledge to do that.

Like others said, the site is geared towards software developers and specifically the emphasis is on hosting source code.

But many people and companies do use GitHub to build their software and host the releases. There's a whole system called Workflows that's specifically there to build software (among other things). And there's a whole system for releasing packages.

It's up to the repository owner to use these tools properly and make it easy for the people to find the downloads. Many repositories have links to the latest release in their README file on the main page.

But many repositories are owned by people or groups that are doing this on their own time and they either don't know all the details of releasing software on GitHub or they don't have time/resources to do it nicely and their priority is sharing the source code for other technical people to use (open source).

The confusion you're seeing when you go to Release and just see assets like zipped up source code and no binaries is that when you create a git "tag" on the repository, it shows as a "release" even though it might not be. You only get the actual release of the repository owner specifically builds and releases (often done with GitHub Workflows).

As a programmer, I was confused at first about these source code only "releases", so it's understandable that it threw you off.

2

u/TheCovid-19SoFar Mar 10 '26 edited Mar 10 '26

Dude, thank you.

Some generous people create and offer tools and direct you to download them on GitHub, but it can be annoyingly difficult for an end user to find where to simply download it. That’s all that’s happening to us normies.

You came at the bottom of this post when googling the issue.

1

u/YeNerdLifeChoseMe Mar 11 '26

Man revisiting this post due to your comment and reading the other comments. OP was just trying to understand, wasn’t being a jerk, wasn’t being entitled. Was just confused and wanted to understand and people were being jackasses.

2

u/AngelicalGirl Mar 21 '26

The fact that you are the only kind and helpfull answer and yet is shown as the last comment makes me sad.