r/github • u/thehacker13yearold29 • Jan 08 '24
Why do GitHub users seemingly die after making a project???
There are so many projects on GitHub that never gets updated again in months/years, heck I've even seen last updated in 2016, but why??? Like who are these people???
10
u/thequestcube Jan 09 '24
Most github projects are hobby projects, maintained by the community. Not everyone has the capacity to work full-time for long periods of time without pay. However, since everything is open source, everone can contribute. If you see a repo that lacks an update, i.e. a new feature or a bug fix, why don't you contribute the implementation or fork the repo with the fix to make it available for others as well?
2
u/Temporary_Quit_4648 Jan 10 '24
Github projects aren't necessarily open source unless they're explicitly licensed as such
-17
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
They are the ones coding it. They signed up for a responsibility to maintain updates and making it update-less is like having a huge rally of people supporting you, then one day never showing back up again. You get it ??
10
u/TheTechRobo Jan 09 '24
This is the dumbest take I've seen. Does that mean that if I started a YouTube channel, I'd be greedy if I decided to stop uploading?
You seem to think that everyone owes you something. Yes, it's frustrating when a project is no longer maintained, but if you really need it so badly, then pick up the project from where it left off and maybe you'll help someone else.
-6
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
Why should I do that instead of just relying on the person who made the project to update it, huh? thats like saying "if you dont like windows 11 new update then decompile the whole os and remove it urself"
8
u/TheTechRobo Jan 09 '24
The project maintainer has almost certainly never given you a guarantee that they will continue maintaining the software. If you want them to, pay them. Just like how you pay Microsoft to maintain Windows 11.
And before you call the developer greedy for that, what gives them any obligation to help you out? They have their own life, you have yours. Does that mean that you will never, ever stop supporting one of your projects?
1
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
Yes. I am still working on one project I started in May 2023.
4
2
0
Jan 09 '24
[deleted]
-1
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
No it is an ai chat bot.
3
u/ceojp Jan 10 '24
Guess you'll have to shut that business down too once the people doing the actual work stop giving you free work.
5
u/yurinnick Jan 09 '24
Because beggars can't be choosers. I gave you something for free, you can use it. If you need something, you can do it yourself or wait for when I have time and energy to work on your feature or pay me to implement it right now (and I have a right to refuse anyway). There's no support contract and no obligations on my side.
2
14
u/mkosmo Jan 09 '24
Wow.
When you signed up for a reddit account, you agreed to not be an asshat, but here we are.
12
u/thequestcube Jan 09 '24
Not really. There isn't a sign-up sheet where you need to sign that you take on the responsibility to maintain a project once you start it. People just stark working on things that they enjoy. If the project is successful, a community around it will form and will eventually provide a stable basis for maintanence. Some projects just continue to be small fun side-projects of people that did that in their free time, continue to be available for people that don't need updates or as inspiration for other people who want to build similar stuff, and that is fine.
If you use software or libraries, it's your responsibility to take some effort to consider which projects have a sufficiently stable platform to suit your use case. If you need a dedication on maintainence, updates and stability, make a contract with the software provider and pay them for the support, like every normal company does it.
4
u/ThunderChaser Jan 09 '24
No?
Pretty much all of my non-work projects are things I thought were neat, and quite frankly I don't care if they had zero users or a million, and if it wasn't interesting to me anymore I'd simply stop working on it.
2
u/CerberusMulti Jan 09 '24
No one signed up for any responsibility, if they don't want to maintain their personal pet project then they don't need to.
You sound very entitled, must be a troll..0
Jan 09 '24
[deleted]
2
u/sneakpeekbot Jan 09 '24
Here's a sneak peek of /r/ImTheMainCharacter using the top posts of all time!
#1: Finally someone acting the opposite 🙌🏻 | 3451 comments
#2: Chick gets offended cause someone dared to walk between her and her phone. | 4249 comments
#3: Yoko Ono can’t bear not getting enough attention so starts wailing during her Husband and Chuck Berry’s performance until a sound engineer cuts her mic. | 2104 commentsI'm a bot, beep boop | Downvote to remove | Contact | Info | Opt-out | GitHub
43
u/CerberusMulti Jan 08 '24
Dobthey need to be updated? Not all projects need to be updated, many are just short time projects that owner has no use for.
People are also hnder no obligation to keep their personal repos updated if they dont want to, might even have abandoned them. They could also have moved the updated project into private repo.
Also many projects have been forked/cloned and might be updated by the user who did that.
21
u/cginc1 Jan 08 '24
OP wants a release cycle like Apple for FOSS.
-78
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 08 '24
Do you see Google chrome deciding to stop randomly updating chrome one day and to tell users "fork it and update it urself" ??? No....
15
u/cginc1 Jan 09 '24
I'll give you a break since you're obviously a kid. One day when you stop living off your parents, probably when you're in your 40s, you'll understand why its important to get paid for the work you do.
-57
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
Why because were supposed to be greedy??? Last time i checked, it costs $0 to code buddy. and even if something costed money like api bills, the coder ccan just.... hmm mIDK MAYBE GET A JOB ????
9
u/mkosmo Jan 09 '24
Last time i checked, it costs $0 to code buddy.
Time is money, right? In any case, time with my family and time with my other hobbies is more important to me than you wanting to see updates to something I already gave you for free.
-13
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
That just shows how greedy you are. Me personally, I always update all my GitHub repos regularly. Why? Because I care about my users. You however you care more about your mom.
Let me ask you this: How would you feel, if an very important tool you loved, was delayed updates for several updates because "they wanted to see their mom". Any normal person would be like "Who cares, I don't even know them" and so should you, proioritize updates, why, because people literally depend on you. You're undepedable, literally.11
u/mkosmo Jan 09 '24
Mom? Who said anything about my mom? My kids depend on me for their life. They trumps you, bub.
-6
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
Family = Mom, dad, etc. What??? My point still stands. Stop avoiding my arugement/stop beating around the bush, pal. I see right through you.
2
u/ceojp Jan 10 '24
So you think people should do things(code) for no pay so that you can get updates for software that you aren't paying for in the first place?
Why do you think that?
3
2
2
0
Jan 09 '24
[deleted]
-19
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
Buddy I have made three businesses within the past three years. I'm 15 right now. I've been starting coding since I was 12. Let me list some.
Kahoot Botter: A website that allowed you to flood kahoots with bots. Shut down because the code I was using from someone else broke.
Zenly: An AI Chat bot that let you use AI chat in school and it bypassed the firewalls. Shut down because of brand rename
Backdoor AI: My new AI chat that lets you use AI chat in school.
Now that I got that out of the way, do you know how many hours I spent on all of these projects? Well over 600 hours. I made $0. In fact, I am in a net loss of $70 over the past 3 years. Why? Because I care about my users.
But, people like you exist, where you only code for money. Money money money. It always has to be about money. You don't care for the user, you only care for the paycheck. Thats why (likely) all your projects fail, while mine are likely to succeed.
4
u/davorg Jan 09 '24
Buddy I have made three businesses within the past three years.
And...
I made $0. In fact, I am in a net loss of $70 over the past 3 years.
You don't have three businesses. You have three projects.
2
u/cginc1 Jan 09 '24
I've been "coding" much longer than you've been alive. I started in my teens as well. I also built and successfully exited companies. So heed this advice - you're passionate. good. but this shitty attitude of yours is your biggest blocker from growing.
3
2
u/ceojp Jan 10 '24
Lol. If it costs $0 to code then why didn't you "code" #1 yourself instead of using someone else's code?
0
Jan 09 '24
[deleted]
3
2
-8
u/thehacker13yearold29 Jan 09 '24
No, buddy. You are not seeing what i am seeing.
First of all, they are businesses because I bought unique URLs for them I paid $12 a year for some, they are all expired but one but it used to be: https://flooder.us then https://zenlysocial.com and now the current project im working on is https://backdoor.best.
I don't know who you think you are, but being an previous CEO of two businessses that had shut down really gave me some CEO insight. For example I code for free, and I literally laugh when I see broke pesants like you begging for people to pay you to code. If you wanted to code so damn badly, then you would've made it as a passion project for free; LIKE HOW I DO IT.
Also, I don't know what your getting at pal, but I have literally spent over 200 hours in my newest project. Like I have added dark mode, big text, etc. However I see peoples coding projects like your have this hideous UI that makes me want to barf.
So with that being said I dont care because your people literally code shit for money while I literally perfect every little thing about my public projects... for free. Isn't that amazing? Oh wait, you don't do that, how could I have forgotten.
14
u/ThunderChaser Jan 09 '24
First of all, they are businesses because I bought unique URLs
Ah yes, the defining feature of a business is owning a domain name for it. Fuck making money, a business is solely defined by having a domain name.
I don't know who you think you are, but being an previous CEO of two businessses that had shut down really gave me some CEO insight.
Lmao, if all three of your "businesses" made nothing then you're clearly not a very good CEO.
and I literally laugh when I see broke pesants like you begging for people to pay you to code
Almost like life is expensive and under our current economic system one needs a substantial amount of money to not you know... die.
→ More replies (0)5
u/yurinnick Jan 09 '24
I can't even tell if this is a joke, because if this is, it's quite funny. But if you're really writing it unironically, you need to stop watching these tech startup tiktoks or whatever you're watching and get some reality check.
Purchasing a domain and making a low-effort AI project doesn't make you CEO. You learn from it, maybe save it for your resume and move on.
Speaking about money, the moment you'll have to pay rent and insurance, you'll understand why people don't code in their free time as much as you want it. Nothing is free. Someone pays for it with time, money, or both.
3
2
2
1
u/Tearnalte Feb 19 '24
I just came across this thread now and I find it rather funny that backdoor.best has been shut down.
48
Jan 08 '24
Did you just compare a professional corporate project with paid developers that happens to also have a open source component to random projects on github?
Well, if you want these projects updated, pay for them, send money to the people working on them, will you?
9
u/Moscato359 Jan 09 '24
Do you have any idea how opensource works?
There are
A: Passion projects, where people make stuff because they want to
B: Corporate funded projects
Chrome is a single well funded project in a sea of unfunded projects
Do you know what the funding for OpenSSL was prior to heartbleed? It was 3000$ a year. That's it.
5
u/Zealousideal_Yard651 Jan 08 '24
Is chrome made by unoaid decs who creates and maintain chrome just for fun or personal need?
2
u/FacepalmFullONapalm Jan 10 '24
I mean, Google has been known for that. Just not with Chrome, yet...
2
2
u/CerberusMulti Jan 09 '24
If there ever was an example of an entitled millennial not understanding how things work this would be it..such a moron
2
u/Solonotix Jan 11 '24
might even have abandoned them.
One such project I'm intimately acquainted with is Bluebird. It was a 3rd-party library that provided a convenient interface for a new up-and-coming feature for JavaScript called "promises"! After the Promise API became standardized across JavaScript, Bluebird announced they would be discontinuing the project. It was last updated in 2019. Other projects built on the backs of Bluebird, most notably for me
request-promise, shuttered when faced with the technical debt that had just landed in their laps.In short, there are perfectly good alternatives out there that didn't rely on Bluebird, like
axios, so why wouldrequestmaintainers spend weeks of their time doing something that had already been solved by someone else?
32
u/pborenstein Jan 09 '24
I wrote something I needed for myself.
If I needed it, someone else might need it, so I made it public.
After a while I no longer need the thing I wrote, but I leave it up for anyone who could use it as a starting point.
we leave things up because they're useful to the future
11
u/sohang-3112 Jan 09 '24
we leave things up because they're useful to the future
This ☝️. OP if you find any abandoned repo that proves to be useful, consider forking the repo and building upon it so that it's more useful to both you and anyone else in future.
22
10
u/Jmc_da_boss Jan 09 '24
This is a fucking hilarious post, i love a good OP outing themselves as a moron
3
4
u/1998CPG Jan 09 '24
Why are most of the posts from this community that pop up on my feed usually about someone throwing some kind of childish tantrum, like this post or the countless 2FA complaints?
2
u/CerberusMulti Jan 09 '24
Because the admin and mod team are ether afk or just can't keep up with posts. Ether one is not good and would love to have it fixed or at least try to help.
3
u/sohang-3112 Jan 09 '24
Because people move on when the problem no longer interests them? Also school / college projects usually won't be updated after they have been graded (because the projects are done).
3
u/drcforbin Jan 09 '24
I put my projects out there in case someone finds some of the code I wrote useful. Most of my projects are abandoned, but the alternative is just not publishing it at all, which seems a bit of a waste. I don't owe you maintenance just because I created something, and if you don't like that, suck it up and nove on
0
Jan 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/drcforbin Jan 11 '24
That's an interesting opinion. I don't usually think of it from the end user point of view, I'm a developer and think of it from that point of view. When I'm trying to solve a problem, other people's solutions are extremely helpful. I don't really care what's in the manual or whether one exists, I can read code.
An example... recently I was trying to write some code to communicate with multiple strings of programmable LEDs. I wanted to refine the timing code, to try to write to more than one at a time. I searched for other people's code that worked with these LEDs, reading the code and comments in the code. I didn't bother trying to run any of them or try to check whether they were abandoned. Going back to some now, I see the most helpful one to me hasn't been touched by its author since 2015.
If that code wasn't out there, I'd be working from scratch, trying to create a solution to a problem someone already solved eight years ago. That's a waste of time. The whole point of open source is making code available.
Another example, the Apollo 11 Guidance Computer code...regardless of the documentation in the code and manuals around it, you will not find any use for the software. It has been abandoned a very long time, but the code itself has a great deal of value.
1
Jan 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/drcforbin Jan 11 '24
I'm not sure what you think should happen here. Is it that code that isn't actively maintained should be unpublished? Or is it that you just want more documentation for the code that's out there?
1
Jan 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/drcforbin Jan 11 '24
I'd like to think I write good code and document it well enough. If something is more than a proof of concept, I usually create some instructions. I strongly disagree that I have a responsibility to make sure the average user or even average developer can understand or use my software.
Another example...I created a C++ port of clojure's persistent maps. The library it is in includes a logging framework, benchmarking tools, and a small unit testing library. It was developed for another project.
The persistent map class required a significant investment of my time. It has a pretty straightforward interface, and the other project provides good examples for using it. While it's not well documented, you might run across it in a search if you were trying to implement the data structure yourself, and the code would be familiar if you were familiar with the original Java version. It would probably even be helpful. Do you really believe I have a responsibility to go back now, five years after its last update, and invest more hours in it?
3
u/juanfdo82465 Jan 09 '24
Like who are these people???
Not your employees, so no obligation to you or anyone to update their projects
3
3
u/flamesfromash Jan 09 '24
Lack of resources, contacts, financial support, and legal counsel. Often times it for portfolio's and just a lucky project landed. I hope to see more from thoughts that truly pursue their career's and know the basics. Most of all I use reddit to gain programs that better my software and contacts. Try hard to all with knowledge gained and upload good work never give up
Holy regards,
In flames with Daniel.
2
u/jedrekk Jan 09 '24
I have projects I've worked on that have been superseded by a wife, a daughter, an international move, a parent passing, me taking better care of myself.
2
2
u/RobertD3277 Jan 09 '24
Speaking of somebody who has an open source project that I've spent 4 years of my life working on, it can be extremely difficult to maintain an update schedule with the rigors of life.
Unfortunately, the one thing that doesn't often get mentioned enough is that even though open source is free to use, it is not free to develop and there are real world costs outside the programmer's time to maintain a project. In my own situation, VPS costs and electricity for running my equipment are just a few other things that I have to pay attention to and with the economy being what it is, a lot of people just don't have the time anymore to spend because they're focusing on just staying above water.
Even though many GitHubs offer sponsorships that are reasonably priced for providing a product and to help continue covering the real world costs, they often don't get the sponsors they deserve. I would like nothing better than to be able to dedicate my time to my project and keep it going with constant updates and enhancements. Realistically though, like many others in this current economy, I simply cannot afford to do that and real world expenses take priority.
So my challenge to you is very simple, if you find a project that does offer a sponsorship and you want to see that project continue, consider sponsoring it to help the programmer cover his real world costs to be able to dedicate time to continue the project.
Rather than complaining about the problem, become part of the solution to help open source to continue to grow.
1
u/corkbar Jan 10 '24
people get jobs, or get busy with other things in their life or find more interesting hobbies and projects
1
u/DingleberriedAlive Jan 11 '24
Dude if you think open-source software is bad, wait til you hear about what some people do with their actual human babies.
1
u/lostinspaz Jan 11 '24
better question: Why is there so much useless code on github?
(Its a rhetorical question; its kinda like asking why are there so many really bad videos on tiktok/youtube/whatever. Because anyone can use it.)
1
u/Present-Breakfast700 Jan 11 '24
bro that's the DREAM. So many projects have to be updated constantly, but those projects where you make it and then it's done, are just the best. They're doing it right
•
u/davorg Jan 09 '24
Hi, mod here.
I've had a few reports asking to close this discussion down because the OP is a troll. Honestly, I think it's just a kid who doesn't know how the world works so I'd rather leave this here as a teachable moment. People have given the OP some good insights into how the open source ecosystem works - but whether they choose to listen is a completely different matter.