r/github • u/BlackWarrior322 • Nov 25 '23
This is why GitHub issues exist
Not to mention the low effort question with zero context, I find it extremely annoying lol š¤·āāļø
113
u/afooltobesure Nov 25 '23
Sir could you pls fix my program which depends on your library. What problem? Figure it out yourself. I'm a very professional programmer who is too busy to make a pull request or fork the repo.
62
1
u/Marxomania32 Nov 30 '23
Why would you fork the repo in this case?
1
u/ArachnidCompetitive3 May 11 '25
To make changes on "his" repo for "your" issue. Or you would do the pull request if it fixes a issue that should not be happening for anyone.
10
u/IgnisDa Nov 27 '23
The first time I received an email like this, I remember being so happy that someone had noticed my project, and helped them (through an email chat). The third time, I blocked the sender and reported it for spam.
Low effort requests like this get old pretty fast.
2
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 27 '23
Lmao I still feel that way to be honest, this is a small repository(guessing the one he emailed about lol) I have resolved a few issues raised and felt so happy people actually used it. But the email quality is terrible here, zero context regarding the issue faced and he even failed to mentioned the repository lol
3
u/Jeklah Nov 27 '23
Reply with "Sure, make an Issue ticket on the repository with the relevant details and I'll have a look."
1
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 27 '23
Nah maybe Iām not a kind person, but Iāll only reply to messages with some effort.
6
Nov 26 '23
Frankly it really makes me want to write āFuck offā.
3
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 26 '23
Haha agreed. But Iāve learnt itās always good to refrain from writing anything bad since itās like a permanent document.
1
Nov 26 '23
Iāll just have a contribution/reporting.md section that particularly specifies how should one act in such case and I could politely point them there instead of having such ping pong
1
67
u/CharlieOxendine Nov 25 '23
Sounds like a hostage script
13
1
62
u/chamberlain2007 Nov 25 '23
I have an open source project and people often donāt seem to understand that this is not a product theyāre paying for, and they DEFINITELY arenāt paying for tech support.
10
u/jayerp Nov 26 '23
Just respond with ākā
8
u/frantically_unfinish Nov 26 '23
I usually just reply with "Thank you for submitting your credit card information. Payment has been successfully processed."
1
1
u/idenatin Nov 27 '23
What's your project?
2
u/chamberlain2007 Nov 27 '23
Itās a custom component for HomeAssistant for integrating a particular brand of thermostat. Itās a little niche, but helpful to those who need it. https://github.com/chamberlain2007/aprilaire-ha
1
3
u/bitingteeth Nov 26 '23
Iām just starting on GitHubā¦any tips so I can consciously avoid on being an asshat like this one?
7
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 26 '23
The other comment has explained it wonderfully!
But just to add and highlight some important points.
Use GitHub issues, that way youāre not asking just a single person and anyone who uses the repository could possibly help you. Also itās very nice to link issues to pull requests when a fix is eventually implemented.
And regarding asking the question the right way, I myself was quite bad when I started asking doubts on stackoverflow. Then I understood how to ask a āminimal reproducible exampleā. It boils down to this: Youād like someone to spend their time to help you out, show them why they should do so. Provide complete context and put effort into the question :)
12
u/u_int16 Nov 26 '23
Be very very very very very sure the problem is not your fault before you open an issue.
Make sure your issue contains enough information such that someone investigating it can cause the issue to happen, but not so much information that it is difficult to recreate your scenario. Fixing your issue will likely be harder than making the ticket for the issue, put effort into it.
In general remember nobody owes you anything. The nicer you ask and easier you make it for your issue to be fixed the more likely it will be fixed.
Take this personās case:
They sent an email which is private and wont allow other people to look and try to fix things. Putting the onus directly on OP.
They didnt even copy paste the error (which could be searched) instead summarizing it.
They did not include any information on where the error was coming from. Not in location in code or in context of execution.
Honestly just use common sense. Youll be fine.
4
u/lupinegrey Nov 26 '23
Be very very very very very sure the problem is not your fault before you open an issue.
Be able to prove, reproduceably, that the problem is with their code.
4
u/xTakk Nov 26 '23
My small tip.. write it in a manner that is useful for fixing the product. You don't have issues, the code has issues. If you can't write a small code sample to expose the issue to be fixed, it's usually your issue and not an issue with the code.
The point overall is that GitHub is not about "free software". It's about sharing code. If you need product or code support, that probably belongs in a forum or in Discussions rather than Issues.
If you just show up for the code, you will be golden.
2
u/Balance- Nov 27 '23
Always include a minimal reproducible example https://stackoverflow.com/help/minimal-reproducible-example
If you donāt know if itās a bug yet, open a Discussion instead of an Issue.
7
Nov 26 '23
Surprised there is no, "please do the needful" š
6
18
u/Jmc_da_boss Nov 26 '23
Stuff like this pisses me off do not fucking email my commit email with inane shit like this, if I'm feeling nice block, if I'm feeling rude respond back with a middle finger
2
u/Dramatic-Mongoose-95 Nov 26 '23
Yeah, that guy is sort of being rude. But just respond with an estimate $$$
He might accept and you could make some money.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Brahvim Nov 27 '23
I'd say the best way to respond is to open an issue yourself, make some progress, and reply to the mail with a link to it. Let the man post comments about it on GitHub after that.
If he ain't doing that, he did it this way probably only for privacy.
1
-4
u/Empyrealist Nov 26 '23
2
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 26 '23
Lmao š
4
u/Empyrealist Nov 26 '23
I dunno why we are getting downvoted - this was meant as a joke about the help request
2
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 26 '23
Damn, itās confusing these days. The meme made me laugh though lol, thanks :)
3
u/Seankala Nov 26 '23
I'm assuming most people don't know about Oliver Twist. They also don't have a sense of humor.
0
Nov 27 '23
[deleted]
1
u/BlackWarrior322 Nov 27 '23
Mine is a small project haha, total of 5 issues raised there š But I can only imagine all the issues people with serious projects might be reading.
13
u/[unknown] Nov 26 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
-3
-10
u/systemd-bloat Nov 26 '23
You thought you'd get away with being a racist and no one would call you out? This is like the same "pattern" Nazis used to talk about. Down with the racists like you.
4
u/Seankala Nov 26 '23
Lmao nah this isn't racism. It is funny though.
-8
-11
u/xXWarMachineRoXx Nov 26 '23
I think then you should add an /s
So that you donāt get called out for being a serial racist ( xD)
-5
Nov 26 '23
It is not racism if it is true.
3
u/Seankala Nov 26 '23
Ehhhhhhhh I mean... The saying "stereotypes are stereotypes for a reason" is somewhat true, but just because there's a higher statistical likelihood doesn't mean that it's not racist.
1
151
u/lupinegrey Nov 25 '23
pls dont ignore this, reply soon.
plz respond.
plz.