r/github • • Sep 16 '23 • Bravo 1

Why is GitHub so shitly designed?

I'm 37. I'm defintely a geek. I mean by common vote. Not a software dev but for sure a digital / tech / computer nerd.

Yet the amount of fucking times I go to Github to download something and just feel completely lost in an ocean of fucking random code and shit and jargon and 'issues' and 'requests' and files and chats - Awesome, I totally get it's an environment for actual developers to co-author code together. I understand that. It's a very different need to n00bs who just want to download an app.

But back in real life, Infinite (ordinary) people need to download shit off Github every day, without having a masters in software engineering, and what pisses me off is there could just be a really neat, tidy page for people who aren't developers. Where is that page? It would just say "Download the fucking app". Without making us swim through a cosmos of really technical articles searching for any glimmer of hope of a link to a page to an issue to a pull request of a bug report of a readme which contains a URL to a file I can unzip on x64 v9 beta except it's in a .shar or fucking .sbx format I have to install a different verson of C+ to open to unzip to be able to install ilib in order to download regex in order to open meteor in order to install a new web browser that can read the next version of the internet and learn a new language similar to Esperanza but it's written in ancient hieroglyphics.

I pray for a world in which the genius geeks can connect with ordinary people instead of living in a bubble. Great things would be achieved.

I'm also happy to offer ideas how Github could be designed better so it meets the needs of ordinary people who I suspect represent thousands of unique daily visits to Github.

442 Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/ianpaschal Sep 17 '23

You mentioned you’re not a software developer. I am, and let me tell you the design is outstanding. There are a few stupid design choices here and there but for the most part it’s exactly what devs need. You can use Git version control with GitHub but the value it adds for people who are actually using it for what meant for is huuuge.

3

u/LukasSprehn Feb 04 '24

I agree the design of the site is amazing. However, it really frustrates me personally how badly many people document their stuff. It pins one as a horrible developer in my own eyes, having had drilled into me that science is supposed to be well documented.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DimensionsMod Jun 27 '24

But devs don't use it like that, it's used as a public facing front end incredibly often. The amount of open source projects that only exist on github for instance.

1

u/ianpaschal Jun 27 '24

Don’t use it like that? Are you confusing Git and GitHub? The point stands: GitHub does what it’s designed to do insanely well which is why it’s far more popular than any other git hosting service.

1

u/DimensionsMod Jun 27 '24

I don't even understand what git is so maybe. I'm saying people keep turning up here confused because devs keep releasing things exclusively on github with no documentation.

1

u/ianpaschal Jun 27 '24

But lazy developers aren’t GitHub’s problem.

Also if you don’t know what Git is, then you’re browsing for software in the wrong place. That’s like going to… I don’t know… an agricultural supply shop and complaining that none of the tractor parts hook up to your garden hose. That may be frustrating but that doesn’t mean the shop isn’t catering well to its primary user base.

1

u/DimensionsMod Jun 27 '24

You're not seeing where we come in to the picture, we were never trying to be github users and were not browsing github. We ended up on the site due to a direct link or googling how to resolve a dependency. It's like the shop in your example is blocking a road.

1

u/ianpaschal Jun 27 '24

I don’t know what to tell you dude… it’s far and away the most popular tool for what it does and is widely beloved by the entire software industry across the planet. If you don’t get it, that’s on you.

1

u/Confident-Ad-6348 Nov 19 '24

Förklara istälet vad GIT är då

Pm det inte är en sak att hemta hem appar/program ifrån.. Jävligt frustrerande när alla refererar till "Hemta APPEN fron GITHUB xxxx"

Och det enda man hittar är masa gilematias inte ens sourc ecode,,,

1

u/LazyVeterinarian9497 Sep 19 '24

still think it's designed badly. I'm cs major and still don't understand why I need to take 30 minutes to just find a way to download a folder instead of a repository. You could say that it's because the author used repository not the way it's designed for, but the problem is even google-research did that. I think if they build a UI interface, like the Github website, it should be easier to understand

2

u/ianpaschal Sep 19 '24

You’re going to have a rough career.

1

u/Outrageous_Calendar5 Dec 14 '24

....or a fantastic one, if he figures out a front-end for GitHub that brings it down to the common denominator, kinda like what Apple did for music players, and smart phones, and...oh yeah! Personal computers...

1

u/ianpaschal Dec 14 '24

See my above comment. It’s not meant to be any of those things. It is what it is and is generally regarded as being the most popular version of that. Go look at GitLab and BitBucket and you’ll see they have the same feature set, similar UI layout, etc.

This tool is exactly what it’s meant to be.

1

u/RecordingStraight855 May 15 '26

Ok, so if it's not meant to be easy to navigate and save people time in getting what they need, then what is it meant to be?

1

u/ianpaschal May 15 '26

Christ I can't believe 3y later I'm still having to explain this comment to smoothbrains.

It is designed for git workflows. If you do not know what that is, GitHub is not meant for you.

1

u/RecordingStraight855 May 15 '26

And there you have it, a smug a**hole that doesn't understand that people don't have time to sift through hella nested crap.

Smoothbrain, LMAO, ok there. Have fun being a jerk the rest of your life when not understanding the complaints.

1

u/ianpaschal May 15 '26

You started it off on this direction. When you phase your question, "So if it's not meant to be [good], what is it meant to be" shows you're not coming from a place of trying to understand, but rather to whine. I've explained multiple times in this comment thread that GitHub is designed to fit a certain workflow. I can only say it so many times.

It obviously IS "easy to navigate" and obviously DOES "save people time" as evidenced by its extreme popularity for years and years and the fact that all of it's competitors (BitBucket, GitLab, Forejo, etc.) all have almost exactly the same UI structure/workflow/etc.

You just might not be the person it's designed for.

I mean, hell, I don't understand your complaint because at this point all you've actually said is that 'its not meant to be easy to navigate' (as though it was designed to be the opposite of that) and that there's 'hella nested crap'. What the fuck does that even mean?

If you've got a specific problem that you're struggling with I'm actually happy to answer but for... jesus 3 years? this comment thread is just different people vaguely bitching and arm waving.

To the next person who comments here in a year: I'm sorry, we've closed down. Please mail your feedback to Microsoft.

1

u/RecordingStraight855 May 15 '26

Again, I'm not the only one that tries to get something only to find out it's nested in a shit ton of folders instead of one easy to grab place.

It's great that you think you are so much smarter than everyone else, but at this point buddy, you can just fuck off.

It's a hot garbage mess, end of story. BTW, did I tell you to fuck off? Yes, please, when you get a chance, do so.

1

u/bedmadeandliedon Aug 18 '26

There was nothing wrong with the way he phrased his question. He’s just following your scope

1

u/RecordingStraight855 May 15 '26

Translation: "I can't defend my indefensible and asinine opinion."

1

u/lucasdep14 Sep 19 '24

First result of Google search for downloading a folder from GitHub is this: https://download-directory.github.io

Also the reason why GitHub doesn't allow it could be that the main purpose of GitHub is using git. So if you need a folder just git clone it or download the zip and extract the folder you need. Most repos aren't that big in size and most people would use a script/library file and its dependencies in the rest of the repo so there is no incentive to adding something like that.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)