r/github • • Sep 16 '23 • Bravo 1

Why is GitHub so shitly designed?

I'm 37. I'm defintely a geek. I mean by common vote. Not a software dev but for sure a digital / tech / computer nerd.

Yet the amount of fucking times I go to Github to download something and just feel completely lost in an ocean of fucking random code and shit and jargon and 'issues' and 'requests' and files and chats - Awesome, I totally get it's an environment for actual developers to co-author code together. I understand that. It's a very different need to n00bs who just want to download an app.

But back in real life, Infinite (ordinary) people need to download shit off Github every day, without having a masters in software engineering, and what pisses me off is there could just be a really neat, tidy page for people who aren't developers. Where is that page? It would just say "Download the fucking app". Without making us swim through a cosmos of really technical articles searching for any glimmer of hope of a link to a page to an issue to a pull request of a bug report of a readme which contains a URL to a file I can unzip on x64 v9 beta except it's in a .shar or fucking .sbx format I have to install a different verson of C+ to open to unzip to be able to install ilib in order to download regex in order to open meteor in order to install a new web browser that can read the next version of the internet and learn a new language similar to Esperanza but it's written in ancient hieroglyphics.

I pray for a world in which the genius geeks can connect with ordinary people instead of living in a bubble. Great things would be achieved.

I'm also happy to offer ideas how Github could be designed better so it meets the needs of ordinary people who I suspect represent thousands of unique daily visits to Github.

442 Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

85

u/nihillistic_raccoon Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

Github's purpose is not to enable a quick link to "download the fucking app".

Your experience can be compared to going to the home depot and asking "hey, I'd like to buy a house, where is the aisle with houses? Why can't I find a ready-to-go house anywhere?"

6

u/PardonMyGreyPoupon Jul 28 '24

The end user should never ever have to look at github. If you point your end users to your github you are a lazy developer.

To use your analogy, what if I bought a house, showed up to the lot and found piles of wood and bricks with a sign that said "everything's here just compile your new house lol."

4

u/AugustusLego Sep 24 '24

If the vast majority of my end users are developers, i would be doing a major disservice by not linking to the repo.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/blurcosp Nov 02 '23

This kind of places the blame on the user though.

Their experience is more comparable to asking an architect (developer) what would be required to get a house built (software running) and the architect points them to home depot to get tools to build their home (download and compile the software's code). They will come out of there complaining how home depot does not have built houses to go, but the blame is squarely on the developer for having zero empathy towards their end users and making them download software from a website that was literally built for professionals to figure out.

And even then, home depot is consumer-facing. So imagine home depot but you have to be an architect to figure out how to order something.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/spider_enigma- Jul 21 '24

The issue is not weather or weather not github is for devs or does or doesn't do its purpose. When a user of a website has an issue, do not link us to github link us to the solution that just works.

95% of the time when we are asking for something to solve a problem even if we are willing to pay for it, the links are directly to github, and we don't want that and never did.

Saying its not for us is like pissing directly into my face and is going around the problem.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

if github is not meant to offer any fast downloads then maybe you should tell people who use github to stop putting links to the entire github on their mod pages, and especially not writing in mods that you download this and that from github. ps great nickname you really are a nihilist

1

u/lukeflegg Jan 23 '25

Problem with your analogy is that Home depot doesn't sell ready-to-go houses. GitHub DOES host thousands upon thousands of ready-to-go apps. God knows if we could get those apps from a well laid out website, we would. And maybe it's well laid it for software developers needs, but the reality is that GitHub is the only place ordinary people can get countless apps from, so literally just what is the problem with always having a button on the front page of a project on GitHub saying "Download [app name]" and that opens a download page which HAS to include plain English download options, right at the top? Unless the project isn't at that stage yet, in which case it clearly states at the top "Not available for download yet" or something ordinary people can understand. It's so easy to serve everyone's needs rather than just go "we don't care about the millions of users who depend on GitHub every day but aren't software developers".

→ More replies (1)

1

u/WouldntBPrudent Feb 09 '25

FYI: maybe a link to a document that explains Github's purpose would be more useful. It's obvious that this user is upset. Do you think making yourself feel better by calling him an asshole is the way to go. This is what really makes people hate reddit. I don't understand why this kind of comment passes right past the moderators. I've had plenty of post rejected because "removed because it might be a tech support post" or "was removed because it was too short", or "comment has been removed as it is not a sufficient explanation" if I was a moderator I would say "This comment was removed because it was in no way helpful and only intended to agitate"

2

u/nihillistic_raccoon Feb 09 '25 edited Feb 09 '25

FYI: Not once have I called him an asshole. However, if you were a moderator, I'd call you a shitty moderator, because it was actually helpful - it stated clearly that the user, which for some reason you defend, had an attitude that could have been boiled down to "why the internet isn't adapted to ME". He came here, complaining about a website he doesn't understand and crying about something that wasn't exactly the website's fault - the person, who writes the software, should also prepare an easy to follow guide for its users, especially if they are not tech savvy. Simple as that. "It's clear that this user is upset" - so what? It's not a charity psychotherapy corner. Just because I didn't pat him on the back and said "oh you poor champ, I hate how GitHub is treating you, you are 100% correct in everything ", it doesn't mean that I am a bad guy for saying "yeah, you've misunderstood the whole point of the website."

If I found my way to a theoretical physics forum, I wouldn't start bitching about its hosting site, simply because I don't understand all the science talk.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/GTRacer1972 Apr 18 '25

I mean the developer says the only place to get it is Github, what are people supposed to do? They can look for a torrent for it, but shouldn't it be easier than that, like "Here's the file"?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rage_Your_Dream Dec 15 '25

Github's purpose is not to enable a quick link to "download the fucking app".

Yet its used like that all the fucking time. So untill people stop doing that, you won't get rid of the average retard like me being confronted with that thing.

1

u/RecordingStraight855 May 15 '26

If the purpose is not to be quick, intuitive, and easy to use, then what is its purpose?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wide-Yellow-2391 Jun 01 '26

retarded ass analogy. there arent houses that are convoluted as shit behind glass barriers in home depot. thats what github feels like. the amount of times ive found pages that supposedly are what i need but i literally cant even figure out how to DOWNLOAD them is ridiculous. this analogy is legitimately awful and i have no idea how you thought it worked

1

u/takamaruu Jul 14 '26

Except house builders wouldn't send you to Home Depot for your house when they try to sell you a house.

1

u/Laxien Aug 16 '26

Yes, programmer-elitist! Defend your "in group", instead of being a nice human being and being a bit understanding of those of us who are geeks, but not software devs!

→ More replies (62)