I'm well aware that I'm not the first to say this, but yeah this movie was not good. Technically, visually and musically, yes, but on a storytelling and thematic level it is an absolute mess.
The first half of the movie was intriguing and held a lot of potential for a truly emotional experience, and I was genuinely curious about where the movie would go. Then once we got to the magical world everything slowly fell apart.
Strange creatures and characters from this world are introduced one after the other and then are forgotten about before moving on to the next visual spectacle with no rhythm nor rhyme. At this point it's 2/3rds into the movie and it feels like I'm still waiting for the plot to finally kick off and it just NEVER happens. Then we get introduced to these random evil parakeets before fire girlie saves Mahito out of nowhere. Then we meet the grand uncle and he asks Mahito to carry on his legacy and to add another piece to his tower (??) then it cuts back to Mahito being captured and then we go on a mission to save fire girlie who is now taken hostage by this random evil parakeet king who was introduced in the last 20 mins of the movie.
All this culminates in Mahito and the grand uncle having the exact same conversation about continuing his legacy before the evil parakeet king destroys everything. Then it abruptly turns out that fire girlie is Mahito's mom and then everyone escapes and lives happily ever after. WHAT??
I've seen SO many people defend this movie's utterly nonsensical plot with such pretentious platitudes like "no you will only understand this movie if you've gone through grief" or "you don't understand, this entire movie is a culmination of Miyazaki's legacy and everything that happens in it is a metaphor for something much deeper” and like... sure I understand using metaphors and other thematic tools to convey a message. But the thing is, a good metaphor should work on two levels: it should be able to help tell the story AND support any other themes that the movie is trying to portray. This movie does not do that. It should be watchable and understandable without any of its supposed themes and symbolism attached to it. “Themes” do not hold up a good story. A good story holds up a good story. There is no way around it, and by that logic, this movie falls apart because the relevance of all its plot points seems to be completely reliant on “symbolism” in order for it to be palatable. And that is going by the assumption that it is indeed trying to tell me something deeper. I did not feel like it was whatsoever, no matter how hard i tried to read into every element of this damn film.
To me, this movie felt confused, the tone was inconsistent, the pacing was ATROCIOUS, and the characters’ relationships with one another were not fleshed out properly. If this movie had focused less on the redundant and overly ambitious magical elements and more on the relationship between Mahito and Natsuko and actually showed more interactions between the two of them, then it would have been far more enjoyable. One of the better scenes in the movie is when Natsuko berates Mahito in the birthing chamber, but it falls flat because for most of the movie she is missing in action. Mahito and fire girlie also don’t have any sufficiently meaningful interactions before the revelation that she is his mother either.
Everything that happens in this movie felt like Miyazaki just ticking off a list of stuff that needs to happen and weird creatures that need to be introduced. There is nothing in this movie that has not already been done before, and much better, in any of his previous movies.