r/georgism • u/freudsdingdong • Apr 03 '25
r/georgism • u/LowCall6566 • Apr 30 '25
Image Concept for the georgist coat of arms for poland( chatgpt)
Motto translates to:" for justice, in it's core". Word for word translation is:" for justice, in the ground of things", it's a play on polish idiomatic phrase. The hedgehog is a play of polish translation of George's name - Jerzy, which is very similar to word jeż( hedgehog), in both spelling and writing. Any thoughts?
r/georgism • u/4phz • Dec 23 '24
NPR Shuns Anything That Smacks of Georgism
NPR will occasionally make room in it's busy day of jerryspringering culture wars for economic issues
A couple weeks ago NPR got off culture wars long enough to criticize Biden's rope pushing trying to sell his economic numbers.(Biden's approach was easy to ridicule so it appeared frequently back while Biden was the presumptive nominee. Touting economic numbers like job creation to voters is like trying to pick up a woman at the gym by touting the number of Murphys you did last year. Even if you get any votes that approach isn't what did the trick. If you have a stellar economy you don't have to tout economic numbers anyway because you are too busy denying you had sex.)
But NPR will never discuss anything that might bring up, say, the total amount of land value owned by the coastal elites who run the Democratic Party. It's probably in the trillions.
r/georgism • u/McKoijion • Dec 21 '24
Video Peter Thiel is a Georgist. Maybe we're closer to a land value tax than we think.
r/georgism • u/Mongooooooose • May 15 '24
Image Before and After photos of new Suburbs. Look at how much environmental damage suburban sprawl causes.
r/georgism • u/SocialistsAreMorons • Aug 29 '26
Reminder to all the new socs here, general wealth taxes are theft
Tax land, not man. Hands off other people's capital. What was created by nature belongs to all, but what was created by man belongs to the individuals who created it. We are georgists, not thieves.
r/georgism • u/[deleted] • Jan 20 '25
Stocks are not Capital
I've seen this issue lead to some confusion in posts here so I think this is something that needs to be pointed out, especially to people who have only recently gotten into political economics.
Political economics like Georgism only deal with a society's overall production, the factors that go into that production (land, labor, and capital), and the return to those factors (rent, wages, and interest, respectively). Under a Georgist definition, stocks are not capital, because capital refers only to wealth that is invested and used up to create more wealth. Stocks, on the other hand, represent a right to the profit of a business. The business profits off of the value that labor creates with its assets, minus the return to labor. Both capital and land contribute to the value of labor, but investors don't care about that distinction.
This is important, because since part of the value of stocks from come land, that means that feedback loops caused by land speculation can appear as stock market runs. This creates the illusion of an economy "overheating", "overconsuming", or "overproducing", when in fact nothing new is being created at all, wealth is just being diverted out of capital and into land.
r/georgism
•
u/Various_Advisor_4250
•
Feb 02 '26
What is the difference between a classic liberal and a libertarian?
If a libertarian is anti statism on principle regardless of outcome. Where do classic liberals fall in relation to them? Strictly on a spectrum of pro/anti coercion, where does Georgism inherently fall.
r/georgism • u/OutrageousPair2300 • Jun 12 '26
Meme Fair Treatment for Past Buyers of Land
r/georgism • u/freudsdingdong • Jun 18 '25
Discussion I asked ChatGPT why LVT isn't promoted more by even the radical, pragmatic, economic justice movements. The answers are expected but sad.
I've been on the Georgism train for a few months now and I fully understand its advantages, and to an extent why it isn't as popular as it should be. Still it feels like a conspiracy theory that not even radical socio-economic justice politicians or movements don't mention it at all. So I asked GPT why LVT isn't promoted in politics. Not that GPT is the source of truth, also probably understood that I support lvt and played along a bit, but i think its answers are on point here.
(left out unnecessary parts)
Powerful Opposition: Landowners Run the World
LVT directly threatens wealth concentrated in land: big landlords, real estate developers, corporate property holders.
These groups have enormous political power, and LVT cannot be hidden or avoided — so they fight it hard.
Even progressive parties are often backed by real estate donors or cautious about disrupting the status quo.
It's Too Rational for Politics
LVT is economically "clean" but politically "dirty".
It lacks the emotional resonance of:
“Tax the billionaires!”
“Universal basic income!”
“Cancel rent!”
It’s a technocratic fix in a world that wants narrative and passion, not diagrams of deadweight loss.
Implementation is Logistically Tricky
---(the common criticism, not justified imo)---
It’s Usually Not Framed as Leftist
LVT is ideologically ambiguous:
Supported by libertarians (Georgists).
Loved by neoclassical economists.
But also advocated by some eco-socialists and urban leftists.
As to why left movements don't promote LVT:
Many Radicals Have Property, Too
Academic leftists, NGO leaders, union officials — many own homes, and often in cities where land values are exploding.
They may rail against capital, but LVT would hit them personally in a way that, say, wealth tax proposals often wouldn’t.
There's an unspoken alliance between the professional class and the landlord class.
It Doesn’t Signal Virtue
The left thrives on morally charged language: “exploitation,” “liberation,” “racism,” “justice.”
LVT doesn’t easily plug into those narratives.
It doesn’t bleed.
It doesn’t cry.
It doesn’t march.
Even though it's deeply anti-exploitative, you can’t chant ‘Tax the land!’ and expect goosebumps.
It Doesn’t Fit a Historical Template
LVT is not Marxist, so Marxist movements don’t know where to put it.
It’s not Keynesian, so social democrats ignore it.
It’s not neoliberal, so the center won’t touch it.
It lives in a strange void where no one feels ownership of it, even though it could benefit everyone but landlords.
r/georgism • u/Cautious-Rush-363 • Jul 01 '26
Is georgisim neoliberal or socialist?
Neoliberalism is all about the free-market, low levels of government intervention, and deregulation. It's been marked with politicians like Thatcher and Reagan.
Socialism is all about social ownership, a command economy, and more worker friendly policies. It's major politicians in the modern day are people like the prime minister of Spain or Bernie Sanders.
Georgisim seems to me to be something like a mix, Henry George argues for thr free-market but at the same time for things like the citizens dividend.
So is georgisim a take on socialism and a good avenue to it, or a form of neoliberalism?
r/georgism
•
u/HadeanBlands
•
Sep 22 '26
The California "Billionaire Tax" is clearly immoral on Georgist principles
But then why do Georgist-friendly economists like Stiglitz or Acemoglu support it?
r/georgism • u/EdisonCurator • Mar 29 '24
Why not just abolish land ownership?
Similar to an 100% tax on land value, abolishing personal land ownership gets rid of rent extraction. However, a LVT is difficult and expensive to implement. It necessitates land value assessments. These assessments exist but can be inaccurate and gamed by people who stand to gain a lot from dodging these taxes. Jon Stewart's home, for example, was assessed to be 10x less than it was sold for (this is not to say that he is intentionally committing fraud). Of course, people should have housing security, and this means that they should be able to form reasonable expectations that they can live in their homes for years to come without getting evicted. But this can be achieved with tough eviction laws. As a moral principle, land is something that humans inherited in common, that we are born to. Even if it was worked on, most of the work was done by people who has long passed away. What you do with your land is also something your neighbours have an interest in. They would rightfully object if you build a factory near their residence. Ownership rights give people the right to do whatever they want (within regulatory boundaries) with the land. Why should such a right exist in the first place? Isnt it just an outdated vestige from aristocratic and landlord rule?
r/georgism • u/ContactIcy3963 • Jul 14 '25
Meme What if the scarecrow from the Wizard of Oz got a brain and has a Georgist epiphany?
r/georgism • u/SocialistsAreMorons • 16d ago
Washington georgists, reject the income tax!
Abolish the income tax. Tax land, not man. The empirical evidence shows that it does more harm than good.
r/georgism • u/SadistikExekutor • Jan 13 '26
Heads up, Georgists: A common Lenin "quote" is being used against you (and it's taken out of context)
Interesting intellectual choice you all make, leaning on that Lenin quote. You know, the one where he supposedly calls Georgism "perfect capitalism." It does have a certain radical chic, doesn't it? A communist revolutionary giving you the nod. Very flattering.
But let's be intellectually honest for just a second. Have you actually read the source, or just the meme? Because pulling that line is like proudly displaying a "Kick Me" sign on your back to anyone who's cracked open "The Agrarian Program of Social-Democracy."
Here’s the "praise" in context, broken down for the room:
Lenin wasn't calling Georgism "perfect" like a shining ideal. He was diagnosing it as capitalism's most terminal stage—its most logical, internally consistent, and therefore most insidious form. His entire essay is a masterclass in why your project is, in his view, the most dangerous opponent to real socialism.
Think about it. To a revolutionary whose goal is to explode the entire system, what's the biggest threat? A clumsy, oppressive capitalism that everyone hates? No. It's a clever, reformed, efficient capitalism that solves its own worst excesses (like rent) and makes itself permanently tolerable. It pacifies the proletariat with a technical fix instead of class consciousness. That's what he saw in Georgism: not a ally, but the ultimate rival utopia.
His actual words aren't a pat on the back; they're a death sentence:
· He calls it a "sham reform" designed to "divert the attention of the working masses."
· He says it's a "striving to strengthen capitalism."
· He labels it a "reactionary utopia"—the worst kind, because it looks forward while trying to walk backward to purified market competition.
So, by all means, keep using the quote. It’s a fantastic, self-inflicted concession. It tells everyone you either haven't done the reading, or you’re hoping they haven’t. It lets critics say: "Even Lenin, on their own preferred turf, concluded Georgism is just capitalism's final, most sophisticated defense mechanism—the system's own immune response to revolutionary change."
It's not the "gotcha" you think it is. It's Lenin explaining, in detail, why he considered Georgists to be the useful idiots of capital. But hey, perfect is perfect, right?
TL;DR: The common Lenin "perfect capitalism" quote is from a text where he relentlessly attacks Georgism as a reactionary utopia that strengthens the capitalist system. Using it as praise is a misrepresentation. Know the source.
r/georgism • u/[deleted] • Sep 29 '23
Is there a Georgist subreddit with less socialist/Marxist infiltration?
r/georgism • u/[deleted] • Jul 06 '25
Hot take: Landlords aren’t the root of housing evil — bankers are
Just found this sub. Love the walkability and urban sprawl stuff, but a lot of people think their landlord is the evil Monopoly man or something. But I think we need to talk more about interest-bearing debt and how fiat money creation is tied to PRIVATE banks.
When a bank approves a mortgage, the money doesn't come from a vault. It’s created out of thin air via fractional reserve banking. A few keystrokes, and boom, you owe them that amount, plus interest.
Here's the catch: the money to repay the loan plus interest doesn't exist yet. It has to be created later... through more loans! That means the system requires perpetual debt expansion just to not fall off a cliff. So they need to create more fictional money, to finance the other fictional money, and now there is a bunch more "money" out there. It’s a treadmill that keeps f**king with the price of everything.
Back to housing. The more banks are willing to lend, the more purchasing power floods into the market. Prices rise not (just) because housing issues, but because people can borrow more and banks are bidding against each other with imaginary money. The higher the prices go the more interest banks earn from the homeowner, or landlord who passes the interest repayment to the tenant.
This has made the housing market more of an investment than a service. Every home is priced based on what the banks are willing to lend against it.
Banks don’t care about affordability. They care about what you can service in interest. So long as you can keep making monthly payments, prices can keep going up, monthly interest repayments keep going up, and rents keep going up.
Bankers, not landlords, are the apex predators.
TLDR: Can we get some more banker hate on here?
r/georgism • u/Constant_Forever_786 • Oct 04 '26
Effective LVT in the US is already 20-40%
I did some recent calculations based on my monthly mortgage payment, annual property taxes, and land/improvements split on my home, and I’m already paying the equivalent of around a 40% LVT.
Even if you don’t include the full property tax amount (and I see no reason we shouldn’t) I’m still paying at least 20% LVT already.
Something to consider when advocating for various LVT percentages.
EDIT: My calculations since others have asked:
I pay $687 per month in property taxes. My monthly mortgage payment is $2,620. The land is recorded as 35% of the overall property value. That means $917 of my monthly mortgage payment goes toward land rent.
If we assume the property tax comes fully out of land rent, that makes the total land rent $917 + $687 = $1,604 and the $687 tax is about 43% of that.
If we assume only 35% of the property tax comes out of the land rent, that makes the total land rent $917 + $240 = $1,157 and the $240 tax is about 21% of that.
r/georgism • u/MorningDawn555 • Jul 03 '25
Discussion Public schooling: Yay or Nay? (Discussion)
Ah, public schooling. We have a love-hate relationship with that thing. On one hand, it allows low-income families to educate their children. But on the other hand, it serves as a state tool to indoctrinate their populace into submission. Both of those are true. On one hand, a good public school can increase land value in the area, which the state is incentivised to do to collect more LVT revenue. But on the other hand, the private schooling providers are also incentivised to make their schools good, so that the chiefs would get richer thanks to a better economy. Once again, both of those are true. So, is the opportunity of educating low-income children that public schooling can provide, along with raising the land value in the area, enough of a justification to let it exist? Or is the threat of indoctrination too much to let public schooling to continue existing, and the private schools can raise the land value by themselves because they're incentivised enough to do so? Present your arguments below! (Also, looking to learn something from the discussion.)
r/georgism • u/4phz • Nov 13 '24
Land Rent Increasingly the Only Source of Income for Coastal Elites Running the Democratic Party Into the Ground
Before online law libraries a coastal elite could make a lot of dough as a trial lawyer and be a hot shot in the Democratic Party. AI hits the profession even harder in countless ways. AI could determine from the crutch terms and other counts in briefs alone what party will win with 99% accuracy.
Top media jerryspringers will also be less influential in Democratic Party politics post 2024.
Some super rich might not be into real estate but more and more most coastal elite Dems will just be rent seeking parasites.
This development is on par with the slaver South losing power in the 19th Century due to its unviable economic system. Democrats should consider Henry George if they want a viable political party.
r/georgism • u/ConstitutionProject • Mar 29 '26
Opinion article/blog The Return of the Wealth Tax, Evidence Against Them Is Stronger Than Ever
Friends don't let friends support wealth taxes.