r/gentleparenting • • Jul 05 '26

Why is punishment-free parenting so controversial?

2 Upvotes

For years I've said that punishing children is neither ethical nor effective at bringing about positive behavioral changes. But anytime I've brought up such ideas, I've always been met with very aggressive hostility about how "disrespectful" of an idea that is. Even teenagers who I've encouraged to ignore and resist the punishments their parents give them have yelled at me for suggesting such a thing, even though they were complaining about being punished.

I honestly find it really disheartening that most people insist on subjecting children to suffering in order to teach lessons or change behavior for the better. When you suggest non-retributive methods of dealing with poor behavior people display a very antagonistic view of humans and insist that a third party must necessarily inflict suffering onto someone for them to learn something. It's quite dark when you think about it.

Have you ever encountered such confrontations? How do you explain to people that there are kinder, gentler, and more civil ways of addressing undesirable behaviors?


r/gentleparenting • • Jan 11 '24

Partner wants to start spanking to demand respect from 3 year old…

1 Upvotes

Need advice. My partner and I are admittedly shitty parents but we do our best! We are feeling increasingly more and more helpless with our daughter’s tantrums becoming more frequent. (Turning 3 this month) We try time-outs (a minute for each year old she is, so 3 minutes) and it NEVER helps. It helps us get ourselves under control, but she’s always still tantruming by the end of the time out. We’ve been trying to tell her “we are in charge, and when we say we say _____, you need to listen” and “if you don’t ____, you’re getting a timeout” Are there better approaches??? There’s got to be because it feels like shit and we’re not getting anywhere. She’s also now flipping the switch on us and saying “mommy, if you turn the bath water off you’re getting a timeout” so it’s like… alright there’s a major disconnect happening. Are y’all just sitting silently while your toddler tantrums? We have neighbors, we live in an apartment! She bangs on the walls and SCREECHES. It’s super embarrassing. Partner thinks spanking is the way because his Dad quote “spanked him one time and never had to again” Kay…… I’m not open to this approach, but I guess I don’t have a better option. HALP. Thanks.


r/gentleparenting • • Sep 10 '25

Gentle parenting is all good and well, until they go to school

0 Upvotes

Unlike gentle parenting, school sees a kid as a student, not a individual with feelings. There's consequences, yelling and shaming at school. I don't think a child who has never been deciplined will not handle that.

By the way I know this is going to get a lot of hate. So just be kind, I'm genuinely curious.


r/gentleparenting • • May 14 '25

Am I Overreacting - my mom called my 5yo son a “mean-spirited person” and I gave her an ultimatum.

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

My kids stayed the night with my mom on Saturday night and things went well until around 10am Sunday morning. She called me and told me my 5yo pushed my 16mo off the couch and hurt the baby. Then she went on to say “I don’t know why he’s so mean. Like he’s just a mean spirited person.” I immediately said don’t talk about my child that way and she was like “well that’s the truth.” I told her I was coming to pick up my children and hung up on her. Upon picking up my kids, my 5yo said he didn’t touch the baby, he just happened to be closest to him and she blamed him for the baby falling off the couch. To me, this checks for a few reasons. 1, my son has NEVER intentionally hurt his baby brother. 2, my toddler has entered his climbing phase where he is climbing and jumping off things, like couches and such.

I’m pissed that she just has that belief that my 5yo is just a mean and bad child. Imagine the self esteem issues that would cause for a child’s pretty much only grandparent having the opinion that they’re mean?? I haven’t talked to her until today. Which are the text exchanges. (Sorry about not blocking out names - idk how).

I’m very surprised when after I told her I didn’t want to go low contact that she was just like okay bye instead of being like “I’ll do anything I can to repair this relationship because it’s important to me.” That hurts so fucking much because all I’m asking for is an apology, self reflection, and accountability. Like is that really that fucking hard???

So now I’m wondering….Am I overreacting?


r/gentleparenting • • Jul 21 '25

My 4yo makes me hate waking up every single morning.

7 Upvotes

I am absolutely miserable as a parent right now. My four year old gets in bed and is asleep by 10 every night. I usually try to stay awake for two or three hours so that I can have some me time because my days with her are filled with toddler bullshit, whining, non-stop question asking, fights me on literally everything, I use 100% of mental energy to get us through the day and it’s exhausting per usual for being a full time parent.

Every. Singe. Morning. She wakes me up at 8am climbing all over me, rolling like an alligator, if I ask her not to do that or she has to leave my bed then she will whine then throw her feet at me, then I have to make her leave the bed as punishment, she cries, I give her 5 minutes, let her climb back in and tell her she can lay still and let me sleep for 30 more minutes and we can cuddle because I literally just opened my freaking eyeballs to her harassing and bullying me and I want 30 minutes to wake up before I bolt out of bed.

She then proceeds to get out of bed and roll around the floor whining and whining and demanding I get out of bed to play RIGHT NOW. There’s no patience. It’s torture. My eyes open and it’s war. I’m so done with it. She will literally do it until I get up. Sometimes she will cave and go play with her toys and I can breathe for 10 minutes before I get up to start breakfast but it’s rare.

Once I’m up and the day starts she’s fine but it takes me a good hour to get un-pissed off. I never lash out or pop off but it sets the tone for my day and I absolutely hate it.

Tips? Please??


r/gentleparenting • • 29d ago

Toddler Toothbrushing Turning Into a Battle? Try These Simple Tips. 🪥

Post image
0 Upvotes

If brushing your toddler’s teeth feels like a nightly wrestling match, you’re definitely not alone. Sometimes a few small changes can make the routine much easier.

Try brushing when they’re calm instead of overtired, turn it into a game or song, and let them hold the toothbrush first before you finish the brushing. Giving them a little control can make the routine feel less intimidating. The biggest thing is consistency. Resistance is common at this age, and repeating the same calm routine can help toothbrushing become more familiar over time.

What trick has worked best for getting your toddler to cooperate with brushing their teeth? 🦷🪥 


r/gentleparenting • • Oct 14 '26

Brother in law arrogant about child’s sleep

0 Upvotes

When I last saw my BIL he and my sister had only recently had their first baby. My BIL acted as if he’d parented 10 kids already; he was so overconfident and completely un curious about my journey in motherhood now that he could relate with his own child. He was controlling of my sister and together they had their son in a strict sleep schedule, even at 3 months old (something I never could do or even fathom how it could be sustainable). It was so hard to watch. I felt very flat given that I had always been open about my own struggles in parenting and the sleep of my 3 children. He gave me the impression that he had it all sorted and that he’d mastered infant sleep. It was very off putting and soul crushing. So now I am wondering how I tolerate this behaviour next time I see him as I already feel so anxious. I have always surrounded myself with like-minded, humbling and authentic parents, however, in this situation I have no choice but to find a way to tolerate him. Any help/perspective so appreciated.


r/gentleparenting • • Apr 01 '24

I think I want a kid?

0 Upvotes

I'm a 21 year old autistic nonbinary trans MAN. and kind of wanna get pregnant in the future? How do understand myself enough to know if having a child with my fiancee in the future would be responsible for us to decide to do. We're both autistic and trans and have trouble communicating with each other but we are getting better and have done couples therapy every week since the first week we got together and moved in together (which happened at the same time unplanned). I have been craving the emotions of parenthood. The connection to the little human potato against my bare, flat chest. I couldn't breastfeed as I've already gotten top surgery so they would have to be fed with formula and I know that isn't 100% the best in expenses and health for the baby right? just know nothing about being a parent which makes me so scared that would ruin my kid. Does anyone have any experience being a young, autistic, trans parent, and can you share some things that helped you know what the right decision was for you? I'm just so nervous but want kids later so badly.

I don't wanna have a kid just to mess them up. And I don't want to be a helicopter or absent. I want to be gentle and kind and have a sort of healthy parent like friendship with my kid where I support them by guiding instead of punishing. Consequences of their actions and explanation without forcing them to feel horrible in the process but still handling it with care and encouraging them to do better rather than forcing them to. But I can't even do that to myself. How do I gentle parent myself into being able to be responsible enough to gentle parent a kid? Help


r/gentleparenting • • Sep 30 '24

Logical consequences for deliberately wetting the bed?

1 Upvotes

Looking for advice!

Our almost 4 year old has been having some tough bedtimes lately. I’m pregnant, so we’re assuming it’s related to that.

She’s finding all the ‘excuses’ to not go to sleep, including the usuals like being hungry etc, but has recently started deliberately wetting the bed.

She’s still in a nappy at night and we’ve worked out that she pulls it down at the back then urinates in her bed…

Obviously we don’t want to encourage this behaviour (!) but we also don’t want to punish her. We’re at a loss for what the logical consequences of this could be?!

Thank you in advance for the advice ❤️


r/gentleparenting • • Aug 06 '26

Question Have you been so mad that you broke the rules of gentle parenting and it actually worked?

0 Upvotes

Im not a parent btw


r/gentleparenting • • Jul 14 '25

Toy rotation felt so aligned with Montessori… until I actually tried it 😅 Anyone else?

1 Upvotes

Hi lovely parents — I’ve been deep in the Montessori rabbit hole lately, trying to set up a calmer, more purposeful play space for my 22-month-old.

I decluttered. I made a shelf. I picked a few “work” activities.

It lasted… 4 days. 😂

Then chaos. Everything got pulled out, mixed up, and I couldn’t even remember what I had rotated in or out. I started wondering:

👉 Am I doing this wrong?
👉 How do you track what worked and what didn’t without a spreadsheet?
👉 Is it okay if it’s more flexible and less perfectly prepared?

Honestly, I am feeling overwhelmed, so I started sketching out a simple idea for myself , something to help me keep track of what toys are out, what’s in storage, and what my toddler actually plays with. Not an app, not a business , just something to make sense of the mess and maybe share with my parent friends if it helps.

I’m really curious ... how do you do toy rotation at home?
Do you plan it out or go with the flow?
Any tips for keeping it sane… or is that just a myth? 😅

Would love to hear what’s working (or not!) for you. We’re all figuring this out together 💛


r/gentleparenting • • Jul 08 '24

Food

0 Upvotes

I know we are all sensitive about creating negative relationships surrounding food with our kids. Let’s be real though, some food is more unhealthy than others. Certain foods should be limited and others encouraged so as to support a healthy, growing body.

I only buy food that I am comfortable with my kids eating at any time throughout the day so as to not feel like I have to place limits on what they can and cannot eat. I also try to create a household that is as low-tox as possible, meaning I steer clear of buying processed foods and am anal about ingredients (so much poison in US grocery stores). Sometimes when I bring my kids to the store with me, they ask if we can get certain items that I wouldn’t put in my body if I could help it (ex. Doritos). I usually tell them “Those don’t make our bodies feel good.”

I try to approach healthy vs. unhealthy foods with my kids in a “how it makes our bodies feel” rather than “how it makes our bodies look” way. That being said, when we’re at a birthday party or any other special occasion, I do not limit them. They can have cake, chips, etc. However recently at a play date, my 5yo saw his friend eating a Rice Krispie treat and said “that doesn’t make your body feel good” and I didn’t know what to do 🫣

Again, I know this is a tricky topic. I’m curious to see how everyone else handles food in their homes. Am I doing the opposite of what I want - to create healthy relationships with food? I’m trying to guide my kids to know how to properly nourish themselves, because that is extremely important to me, but realize maybe I’m doing it all wrong.


r/gentleparenting • • 18d ago

What consequences would you use for a 9-year-old and 14-year-old who repeatedly steal and lie? (Other than spanking)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • Jul 10 '25

Old Navy: Let’s Talk About the Harmful Impact of Inconsistent Sizing

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • Jun 30 '24

older kid

0 Upvotes

idk if this is the right place as when I think of gentle parenting its for ages <5, but my boyfriend and I raise his niece who just turned 18 and graduated. we have been having problems since she got cheated on back in February, it was also her first bf/first everything. she's had a big attitude and she's lying now, mind you before she was trustworthy, listened/helped around the house, etc. today though, she decided to wait around a little past midnight to disable the cameras we have in the house to monitor our dogs when we are away, and then sneak a boy in. I've had a fishy feeling all week because I woke up swearing I heard footsteps, but my boyfriend thought it was just our dogs because they do tend to sound like human feet. today though there was just this off feeling because the cameras were randomly being disabled. we thought maybe the dogs were rubbing up against it and it was becoming loose. Anyways, my boyfriend went upstairs and chewed her out, (he did lose it little, rightfully so because she was told already no for being able to go out today since she lied and stayed out past midnight the other day without even asking.) and told the guy to get the hell out of our house. All the niece said was sorry sorry and was panicking, but could hear her later in her room complaining. I feel at a loss of what to do, how to approach this in a way where she will realize her behavior has been in appropriate. her uncle has sacrificed his own life in order to be able to raise her, plus we just had a baby so are trying to start a life of our own. there's so much in between in but my question was just, how would you handle this? I know there's no right way, but i'm just at a loss how to move forward.


r/gentleparenting • • 18d ago

Question Is my kid really smarter that the others, or the other kids are just dumb?

0 Upvotes

Well, the question might sound a bit cruel, given that we’re talking about 7-year-olds, but I’m genuinely curious.

I taught my nephew (he lives with me) the alphabet when he was 5, he learned it so quickly that I’m certain he would have picked it up just as easily at age 4. Right away, I started teaching him syllables, and he grasped them in no time. Before long, he was already reading and writing simple words. By age 6, he was reading storybooks fluently; I taught him addition and subtraction, and he understood those incredibly fast, too.

Now he’s 7, and he reads at the same level as his 11-year-old brother. He can read lowercase print, follow subtitles, and he knows the 2-times table. He’s in the first grade, but for some subjects, he joins the second-grade class because he’s further ahead than his peers.

(He also takes Taekwondo. He’s terrible at sports, he just can’t get the hang of it, but when they had a theory exam, I helped him study. I was stunned by how quickly he absorbed everything. When the instructor started asking questions before the exam, she couldn’t believe that, out of all her students of various ages, he was the one getting every single answer right.)

I recently attended a parents' meeting and discovered that his classmates are only just starting to learn syllables. Do you see what I mean? Syllables, and these are 6/7yo kids.

So, what’s going on here? Is he this way because I take the time to teach him? Does it mean that all those other children are only just learning to write because no one at home is teaching them? Or is my boy just very intelligent and I am downplaying it?


r/gentleparenting • • Nov 02 '24

17 teen year old daughter out of control

0 Upvotes

My daughter has never learned to accept a punishment in hopes of her doing better. Recently she said some mean hurtful things to me things someone should never say to their mother. She ran away for 2 days left House unlocked all night. She finally comes home and 2 days later she's asking To go hang out. I told her no and now it's a big blow up all over again. I told her as her punishment she will need to improve her grade in a class and all hell broke lose over this. Help I'm so over this


r/gentleparenting • • Jun 04 '25

What can be done to Support the RIGHTS of children under 5?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • Dec 27 '23

The FDA does not mandate the disclosure of ingredients for baby products, allowing companies to deceive consumers. Please join the petition to advocate for ingredient transparency for the rights of healthy babies and consumers. Please share our petition to friends! Thank you!

Thumbnail self.choosyparents
2 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 4d ago

Question How do you keep kids interested when exploring a new city on foot?

0 Upvotes

We did a long weekend in a new city last month with our two kids (ages 9 and 12) and the walking parts went... badly. Old town, beautiful buildings, interesting history, and within 20 minutes it was "I'm bored, can I have the phone?"

We ended up handing over the phone for a game just to get through the afternoon, and then felt bad about it. We'd basically walked them past a 2,000-year-old ruin while they played something they could play at home.

I'm curious how other parents handle this:

- What actually works to keep kids engaged on city walks (not museums, just walking around)?

- Have you tried guided tours, audio guides, scavenger hunts, anything like that? Did it work or flop?

- At what age did it get easier, if ever?

Would love to hear what's worked and what definitely hasn't.


r/gentleparenting • • Oct 08 '26

Getting out of hand

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Hi, I just thought maybe I will get better advice here.

I don’t see myself as a gentle parenting person, like I can’t stand Janet Lansbury diehards, but I’m also not someone who seems to belong in that other sub where I first posted. I’m probably someplace in between?

Most of all I want gentle advice! Be gentle on other parents, that’s my motto!


r/gentleparenting • • 20d ago

Is picaridin safe during pregnancy or should I just avoid bug spray entirely

0 Upvotes

Due in a couple months and we have a backyard wedding to attend before then that's guaranteed to have mosquitoes. Normally I wouldn't think twice about bug spray but obviously being pregnant changes the calculation. Picaridin comes up a lot as the gentler option compared to DEET, wondering if that guidance changes at all during pregnancy specifically.


r/gentleparenting • • Jul 09 '26

As a gentle parent I’ve never punished my kids – boomer parenting horrifies me

Thumbnail
inews.co.uk
6 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • Jul 27 '26

I need help on how to handle my anger issue

1 Upvotes

I have a 21 month old boy and currently pregnant with one for 9 weeks now...i have very serious anger issue...i used to hit and scold my first one since he was 15 months old as then i was handling him solely without nanny...i took therapy, some parenting course...it helped a bit but still am facing the same issue...i cry a lot afterwards that i am creating a bad neagtive impact on him and eventually he will start to hate me...i really need help...if someone can suggest me something it would be helpful

u/parentingadvise u/cOnciseparenting u/psychology u/tHerapy u/cOunselling


r/gentleparenting • • Sep 23 '25

Sleep Training late? 2 year old and 4 year old. Never been sleep trained.

5 Upvotes

I'm the father-- We have a 4 and 2 year old. Neither have been sleep training

My wife's core belief is that sleep training below 6 months is abuse and below 2 is cruel and harmful to a child.

But I understand that good sleep and more sleep is better for a childs mental health and growth (as well as for the parents sanity). I also don't think its harmful and this would be difficult to truly measure because it's loaded with at the core- what is better sleep or a child feeling 'safety' and care...etc.

My wife complains and gets irritated during the night routines especially when the children are under the weather or extra stubborn going down. But she will not entertain sleep training-- is there another word for 'sleep training' i could use when I discuss this with her?

Do most of you parents who sleep trained early have issues putting kids down?

We have our night routines which are generally followed but it takes hours to get kids down. Bath, snack, brush teeth/ Then each of us lay with the kids. and tell them stories/ scratch back/ listen to podcast. We have to lay with them for 15 min on good days and 30+ min laying with them on harder nights. Sometimes there's a lot of resistance too.

Every night is pretty frustrating during the night routine as there's a lot of resistance from the 4 year old especially.