It seems very odd to me how so many of you read the New Sun series. Rather than ask 'what does this incident reveal about us' you ask 'what does this incident reveal about Severian, Urth?' when, to my mind, the book is littered with some of the shrewdest insights about the nature psychology, symbolism and the archetypes that course through all things, memory, perception, semantics, the unity of opposites, death, life, and obliquely justice and culture, by presenting perverse notions thereof.
I rarely see discussions, for instance, about Severian's ingenious 'mindless patterns of the guild repeating itself' or the extended motif of symbols acting through us - not in the sense of the example of being handed a coin, but when they awaken and direct him as for instance when he meets Agia, or when the Undine/Mother/anima casts him back on Gyoll's shore. Or the three meanings passage; how difficult it is to distill the mereology Severian identifies and gives an example of when he performs the play. Or why it is that Ultan, whose mind possessed of inutile facts, is so repulsive to Severian, whose memory oppresses him; and how both, stuck in the past, suffer from 'this death in life that grips me even as I write these words' like 'a fly in amber [that] remains the captive of some long-vanished pine' (I think this is from Claw, but I digress).
I find myself so captivated by these ideas, perhaps it is because I read Jung before I read these books, that I find that I allow the mysteries to remain mysterious. I don't particularly care if Severian is time-traveling when he recalls the past because I myself know that I am time travelling when I recall the past and continuously reauthoring it to suit my present sense of self, as almost everyone does whether they want to admit it or not.
And I know that I, like Severian, allow the artificial categories to acquire completely subjective meaning - as when Severian identifies a grave-robber and an eater of the dead a figure of justice; the rabble figures of dissolution. Or how Severian perceives Nessus, bustling with life, to be a city crawling with death. How could this be true?
I wonder what Wolfe would have made of all of this? Certainly he has more brainpower than most of us, maybe he meant for us to pick up on everything? I personally feel when reading these books that I am so overwhelmed by the influx of ideas that I feel as Severian did wandering the streets of Nessus, struck by the incongruent architecture which seems to represent all time condensed to a single building or series of buildings.
I think Wolfe is primarily driving at the idea that we don't understand phenomena because the teleological and the theological meaning is forever hidden from us. Or at least that is the impression that I am left with. There are entities that we sometimes identify as emotion, sometimes as something completely external to us, operating through us and acting out dramas, petty or grand, that we're scarcely aware of.
I'm now on The Claw (second read through) and look forward to reviewing what I've written here. Maybe I will be more invested in the nature of the flagae, their manifestation, then. Or whether Morwenna murdered Eusibia or whether Eusibia killed herself in the crowning moment of her life, as there is nowhere to go but down from revenge. Or whether Severian and Agia (and Dorcas) are tokoloshe - whether we aren't all tokoloshe formed at the moment our ancestors zigged rather than zagged.
P.S. If anyone has any books on comparative mythology that they'd particularly recommend, I'm all ears. Reading Jung certainly shaped how I interpret virtually all literature, and I think a steadier grasp of myth would further hone the lens.