r/genewolfe • • Aug 08 '25

Illustration of Claw of the Conciliator

Post image
0 Upvotes

Using ChatGPT 5 I managed to produce an illustration of the Claw. I basically had to edit the image in Photoshop because it produced two joint thorns at their bases in the center.


r/genewolfe • • Aug 14 '25

Shadow of the Torturer

1 Upvotes

It seems very odd to me how so many of you read the New Sun series. Rather than ask 'what does this incident reveal about us' you ask 'what does this incident reveal about Severian, Urth?' when, to my mind, the book is littered with some of the shrewdest insights about the nature psychology, symbolism and the archetypes that course through all things, memory, perception, semantics, the unity of opposites, death, life, and obliquely justice and culture, by presenting perverse notions thereof.

I rarely see discussions, for instance, about Severian's ingenious 'mindless patterns of the guild repeating itself' or the extended motif of symbols acting through us - not in the sense of the example of being handed a coin, but when they awaken and direct him as for instance when he meets Agia, or when the Undine/Mother/anima casts him back on Gyoll's shore. Or the three meanings passage; how difficult it is to distill the mereology Severian identifies and gives an example of when he performs the play. Or why it is that Ultan, whose mind possessed of inutile facts, is so repulsive to Severian, whose memory oppresses him; and how both, stuck in the past, suffer from 'this death in life that grips me even as I write these words' like 'a fly in amber [that] remains the captive of some long-vanished pine' (I think this is from Claw, but I digress).

I find myself so captivated by these ideas, perhaps it is because I read Jung before I read these books, that I find that I allow the mysteries to remain mysterious. I don't particularly care if Severian is time-traveling when he recalls the past because I myself know that I am time travelling when I recall the past and continuously reauthoring it to suit my present sense of self, as almost everyone does whether they want to admit it or not.

And I know that I, like Severian, allow the artificial categories to acquire completely subjective meaning - as when Severian identifies a grave-robber and an eater of the dead a figure of justice; the rabble figures of dissolution. Or how Severian perceives Nessus, bustling with life, to be a city crawling with death. How could this be true?

I wonder what Wolfe would have made of all of this? Certainly he has more brainpower than most of us, maybe he meant for us to pick up on everything? I personally feel when reading these books that I am so overwhelmed by the influx of ideas that I feel as Severian did wandering the streets of Nessus, struck by the incongruent architecture which seems to represent all time condensed to a single building or series of buildings.

I think Wolfe is primarily driving at the idea that we don't understand phenomena because the teleological and the theological meaning is forever hidden from us. Or at least that is the impression that I am left with. There are entities that we sometimes identify as emotion, sometimes as something completely external to us, operating through us and acting out dramas, petty or grand, that we're scarcely aware of.

I'm now on The Claw (second read through) and look forward to reviewing what I've written here. Maybe I will be more invested in the nature of the flagae, their manifestation, then. Or whether Morwenna murdered Eusibia or whether Eusibia killed herself in the crowning moment of her life, as there is nowhere to go but down from revenge. Or whether Severian and Agia (and Dorcas) are tokoloshe - whether we aren't all tokoloshe formed at the moment our ancestors zigged rather than zagged.

P.S. If anyone has any books on comparative mythology that they'd particularly recommend, I'm all ears. Reading Jung certainly shaped how I interpret virtually all literature, and I think a steadier grasp of myth would further hone the lens.


r/genewolfe • • May 31 '22

Anyone else feel this way about Severian?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/genewolfe • • Jul 20 '25

Afraid to read "The Shadow of the Torturer"

Post image
32 Upvotes

I recently discovered that there is a certain level of misinterpretation of women and homosexuals in Gene Wolf's works, however, I really wanted to read The Torturer's Remains.

I finished reading 3 body problem recently, and, naturally, found out about the difficults that Cixin Liu have writing womans with the much or equal expressibility as the males he writes. BUT, hes misjudgments have origin in his lack of social habilities and not in any belief system, what explains why his storys are still comfortably readable. And my fear is about that. Is Wolfe's writing and storytelling ways, in any chance, agressive to be read by the groups said before? or its something casually swallowable, remaining as fun and interesting as it could be?

(sorry if my english is difficult to understand, for i am using the assistence of the google tranlator) (im a homosexual) (I've never read anything from Gene Wolfe)


r/genewolfe • • Jul 13 '26

Now I get why Book of the new sun is such a unique book - but only after I ve read the Claw of the conciliator

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

I have finished the 2nd book of The book of the new sun. Talking about my thoughts why it is spiritually dense in the link. I am curious to hear yours. What were your thoughts after having read his first two books? It is spoiler free btw.


r/genewolfe • • Aug 20 '25

The Book of the New Sun directed by Denis Villeneuve

0 Upvotes

Is it possible?


r/genewolfe • • Sep 23 '25

Is the Sun conscious?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Severian Calling


r/genewolfe • • Aug 16 '26

Robert Eggers

0 Upvotes

Anyone get heavy BOTNS vibes watching the trailer for Werewulf? Reflecting on this i realized that literally every Eggers film has extremely Wolfe vibes. Right now he's the only director i can imagine tackling Wolfe/BOTNS and if it never happens i will cry.

*postscript* i used to think Aronofsky would be a good fit for a BOTNS adaptation in that sweet spot between The Fountain and Noah bht i've soured on him considerably in the back half of his career. Is there *anyone* else?


r/genewolfe • • Apr 07 '25

Has the entire BOTNS just been spoiled for me? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hello, first time getting round to reading BOTNS.

I'm half way through Shadow, and loving it. Whilst looking around for ePubs of the rest of the series to buy on my Kobo, I came across a synopsis for Urth of the New Sun, which had a major spoiler in the first line that I glanced over, concerning Severian. Said spoiler below...

It stated Severian is now the Autarch of blablabla...

Obviously it's not outside the realm of plausibility that I could maybe think the series ends like this... but is this a major twist/plot point that I've now ruined?


r/genewolfe • • May 16 '25

The sea people are useless

0 Upvotes

I've just finished Sword of the Lictor

The sea people are so useless

My girlfriend couldn't open a jar

She might be a sea person


r/genewolfe • • Jul 15 '25

"Mean Gene"?

0 Upvotes

Do you think anyone ever called him that?


r/genewolfe • • 19d ago

Did anyone else not particularly like Wizard Knight?

3 Upvotes

I often see people raving about it and how much they like it, recommend it as the next thing to read after the various Urth books, etc.

I first read the whole of Long/Short Sun and then New/Urth novels. Masterpieces, all. I then dived into various short story collections and absolutely loved them. So many amazing short stories!

Next, I read the three novellas in Fifth Head of Cerberus. Absolutely amazing! Some of the best fiction I've ever read. Loved how they were all connected, put together, the mysteries and unresolved puzzles that just make a reader think long after they finished reading.

I quickly bounced off my first attempt at An Uninvited Guest, though eventually I did come back to it and enjoyed it.

After the bounce, I read through Wizard Knight, and it wasn't bad. I actually did quite like Knight once I got into it, but fell off quickly after starting Wizard. And I finished it more because I don't generally quit books I've made a significant start in, moreso with anything Gene Wolfe... but I never really did come to enjoy Wizard all that much.

Edit: After reading Wizard Knight, I immediately read Pirate Freedom and to me that is the absolutely ultimate "first Wolfe book to read" for either complete beginners or people who bounced off the New Sun. On the other hand, if someone LOVED the New Sun (and Long, Short, Urth) series then I'd recommend Fifth Head as their next read.

Since Wizard Knight is so highly regarded on this sub, I'm curious who else just didn't really like it compared to most of Gene's works?


r/genewolfe • • Mar 12 '25

Hot take: "Starcrosser's Landfall" is a better title than "The Book of the Long Sun"

0 Upvotes

Discuss.

(Edit: for those not in the know, Starcrosser's Landfall was Long Sun's working title)


r/genewolfe • • Oct 09 '24

Does anyone else get strong Long Sun vibes from this picture?

0 Upvotes

Maybe it's just because my copy has similar cover art.

Théâtre D'opéra Spatial - Wikipedia


r/genewolfe • • Jun 11 '19

Severian the pederast? Does Wolfe NOT situate himself within -- his usually spectacularly enabled -- protagonists... or does he, and he'd encounter himself even as this? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

bsharpoflat has made the intriguing assertion that Severian is a pederast. Specifically, he argues that Severian made pederastic use of little Severian... I believe I am correct in this (I scrolled through so many posts... one finds oneself in slightly too many places, and vulnerable to mis-attributions/mis-takes). I can't believe this is so, mostly because it doesn't feel right to how I experienced their time with one another, and secondly because I believe Wolfe situates himself within many of his key protagonists, using them... perhaps to a certain extent, to provide a counter image of himself that has a more sure sense of, well, formidability, and I know for sure he wouldn't do that if it meant situating inside a pedophile (and not because he can't be inside a rapist, "partake" in half-real rape, which he can, but very specifically because he cannot be inside someone who has sex with boys... could possibly presumed himself to be homosexual).*

It's tough to know what has been answered already in depth, but I'd like to hear, bsharpoflat, your reason why you think so. I don't mind simply be redirected (and I would have linked to it if I could have found your comments again). (Note: I also don't think that Wolfe makes the torturers pederasts as well.... Wolfe withdraws psychological plausibility, it seems to be, with certain kinds of people... in certain situations, while bearing down astonishingly acutely in others, is my read. Where and where not, would require a lot of thought... but it is something I've certainly noticed, and hope to explore.

Others may already have chimed in on this, but if so inclined, please feel free to do so again.

*(Note: I do think Severian betrays little Severian... or the Wolfe inside Severian does, but in a different manner. He lets himself be distinguished from the, if not always weak -- he does bravely confront Severian as to his intention to actually save his mom -- certainly consistently grandiosely reckless child, the one who twice ran about and always into situations where he was made massively vulnerable, while amidst the predator who got him, while amidst Typhon... something that seems to happen every time some grand authority stands between our key protagonist in a Wolfe novel and the sacrificed noticeably very vulnerable person he ostensibly would have saved... or that's my sense.)


r/genewolfe • • Aug 31 '22

I gave up halfway through Urth of the New sun

0 Upvotes

I couldn’t do it, guys. I just couldn’t do it anymore. After Severian admits what he did to Jolenta and following with “but she wanted it anyway”. I was done with him and his story. I hung on for so long but that was the last straw.


r/genewolfe • • Oct 03 '21

Does The Book of the New Sun get better? Just finished the first book and I'm thoroughly unimpressed

9 Upvotes

From what people told me, this series had all the potential to be one of my favorites. The unreliable narrator coupled with twists and such... "smart writing" that doesn't try to please the reader.

I just finished The Shadow of the Torturer, and I just don't like anything about it. The book was ~250 pages long, but it easily felt like a thousand. Each page takes me at least twice as long to read compared to the average book. Everything was strongly unremarkable and uninteresting. It really does feel like a man is telling it's story - just a story among many, nothing interesting or book-worthy. But at the same time I'm sure that's the author's intention.

Anyway, what I wanna know is if "the good stuff" has already started and I happened to miss it. Or if the first book only shows it's glory after you read the next ones. Or if it does indeed have a slow start and the good stuff will happen in the next books. Or if that's really it and if I didn't like it so far I shouldn't keep reading.

What do you think?


r/genewolfe • • May 17 '25

Doctor Telos’ name Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hi.

I just finished Sword of the Lictor and I cannot get something out of my head, and if I googled it I might find spoilers for Citadel and the rest.

Anyway, this is something that has been on my mind since book one: Telos means, approximately, ‘purpose’ and for a long time, I thought Doctor Telos was named as such as a play on his role in the story (he provides purpose for moving the characters to places, such as setting up Severian’s access to the House Absolute) and his modus vivendi (he provides a purpose to the bargirl who becomes an actress and great beauty, but without him she loses her reason to be and is swiftly removed from the story, returned to her original self).

Later, when we find out he’s a homunculus, I was like ‘OH. His purpose is to be a Doctor. He’s literally been created to be the ideal doctor!’

But… that doesn’t quite work for me. Why can a homunculus who was created for one purpose also be a dazzling dramaturge and play write? Why is he so charming? Why does he play with language and mislead so often?

And then there’s the whole thing with him labelling Severian ‘Death’ and calling him ‘Friend’ - I would have thought a doctor the mortal enemy of death.

And there’s Dorcus reflections on him having a goal by labeling Severian.

Does he pop up again later? I feel like he might show up again, since he was just knocked out and he’s been in every book so far. Is the ‘reveal’ at the end of book 3 the final line?

If so, I’m kinda disappointed. Being only Baldanders’ home-grown medic feels anticlimactic.


r/genewolfe • • May 29 '26

Do Women Appreciate The Wizard Knight?

5 Upvotes

I just re‑read The Wizard Knight, and it occurred to me that the heroic, chivalric passages resonated strongly with me—Able’s slaying of Grengarm, for example, feels deeply stirring in a way that's tied to what to me seems like a traditionally male heroic ideal, and I wondered whether female readers would feel that the hero's feats were as aspirational and emotionally stirring as I did.

I know It's not something you can really quantify, but just having a discussion around the topic would be interesting.

I should say that I spoke with a women who enjoys his work, which surprised me and probably planted this idea in my mind, since before that I had thought of Wolfe as an author who would appeal primarily, perhaps exclusively, to a male audience, at least based on the (admittedly, limited) works of his I’ve read (BoTNS, TWK).

I wish I could ask my wife, but she reads self-help or science based books almost exclusively.

So I’m curious: are there women here who’ve read The Wizard Knight? What was your experience of it, especially the more “heroic ideal” moments?


r/genewolfe • • Mar 03 '26

Is Sword of the Lictor the "worst" book of the pentalogy?

5 Upvotes

I'm re-reading the first five books of the Solar Cycle for the first time in 10 years. I loved Shadow. Loved Claw. Remembered Sword vividly because of some memorable settings and characters, but overall I've found it to be far slower-paced and less compelling. The narrative digressions and episodic nature of the first two books just feels a bit aimless and random here, other than three standout chapters (in the cabin, atoo the mountain, and at the lake, to avoid spoilers).

Should I just take a break? I thought Citadel was the consensus "weakest link," even among those of us, like me, who think the books are a masterpiece. But this time through, at least, it's Sword for me.


r/genewolfe • • Jan 21 '24

What is the purpose of the rape of Jolenta? Spoiler

29 Upvotes

I know that this point is debated far and wide across any discussions of this book, but I think it's for good reason - because I think this plot point fucking sucks. I'm sure this will be a hot topic, so to set it straight, I'm not interested in debating whether or not it was rape; if you come into the comments to do so, you will not get a response from me, as I see no other interpretation of the events even as dubiously described as they are by Severian himself.

What is the purpose of the rape Severian commits in the grander narrative? Without spoilers, as much as possible, please. I only read up until that point because that scene made me so uncomfortable I legit had trouble continuing to read the book.

I'm having a hard time wanting to finish the book. Which, frankly, is a real bummer, as I was profoundly enjoying it up until that point. I would like to continue enjoying it. But I can't see a single reason why that plot point was even necessary. If it was to show Severian as unreliable or morally questionable, for example, those points had been proven many times in many other ways throughout the narrative.

I kind of draw the line at unnecessary depictions of rape for drama in narrative - I think they do more harm than good - and I'm not really interested in debating that, either. I have my reasons, and you won't change my mind, and I won't change yours. All I'm wondering is if you can reasonably describe why you think Gene Wolfe included that scene, and/or what purpose you think it serves in the grander narrative (again, without spoilers, unless absolutely necessary, and tag them as such, please and thank you).


r/genewolfe • • Jul 06 '23

Why Jolenta wasn’t raped

15 Upvotes

Within the context of the scene, Jolenta is relating to Sevarian the men and women she’s seduced. This isn’t a random conversation, she’s not making small talk, she’s trying to seduce him. Her entire monologue is about how people have no power over themselves when faced with her beauty.

If this is the case, why doesn’t Jolenta doesn’t just ask Sevarian to sleep with her? This is because Jolenta’s pride lies in her being irresistible. If she gave herself to Sevarian, she’d be acknowledging his ability to refuse. She wants him to take her, because in doing so, that solidifies her confidence that even the man who prefers Dorcas has no power over himself when faced with her. This is why she doesn’t resist, or really seem to care when he starts having sex with her.

In the end, Jolenta loses this power game. Sevarian sleeps with her, but is still indifferent to her, so she ends up humiliated and beaten at her own game. This is also why neither Jolenta or Sevarian treat each other as rapist and rape victim post the incident. It was a consensual power game between two incredibly mentally ill people.


r/genewolfe • • Jan 23 '26

Getting there.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’m trying to get ChatGPT to give me some Urth content. Not quite where I want it yet but I thought I’d share.


r/genewolfe • • May 11 '21

UoTNS really isn’t necessary

0 Upvotes

So I’ve just finished a second read of BoTNS (first read was years ago) and I now fully understand why some folks find Urth to be totally unnecessary and don’t even include it in the Solar Cycle.

I was going to go right into Urth this time, but The four texts of TNS are meant to be read more than once. The work requires it. It’s the second read that completes the book,not UoTNS.

I’m not saying that everything is obvious in every detail, but the second read gives you everything that you need to basically understand Severians journey and Destiny while still giving you generous room for satisfying possibilities. Wolfe leaves room for you to expand the universe as far as your own mind can and would like to go.

I don’t begrudge anyone who enjoys continuing on with the story with Wolfe’s company, but it really seems to disrupt the ultimate effect of the work, IMHO. Imma headed to the Whorl, instead.

TLDR: Don’t read Urth of the New Sun. Reread the Book of the New Sun, instead! Then, go straight to Silk!