r/genetics • • Feb 28 '25

Is this eugenics or ...

40 Upvotes

So this has been nagging at me. My spouse and I both have physical disabilities that have minimal effect on our daily lives, as in I was able to obtain higher education and now am a SAHP while he has held down a job for years, we support ourselves and are totally functional adults. His condition is less severe than mine, but is also more heritable and follows an autosomal recessive inheritance pattern. Mine is rarer and not extensively researched, but has never occurred on either side of my family in living memory, and what little research I have been able to find on the condition seems to point to it potentially being linked to environmental factors in utero. Our disabilities do not make us more susceptible to any other illnesses or conditions. We recently had our first child after a complicated delivery. Immediately after birth, literally as I was still waiting for the epidural to wear off, the on call pediatrician who was tending to our baby began asking us in what I would deem a forceful or insistent way whether we would like to be referred to a geneticist to rule out disability and for purposes of future planning. My husband's disability is more visible than mine, so it was immediately apparent that our child is not affected. Mine can be ruled out at a routine doctor's visit, and was when our child was five days old. I declined the offer of a referral and explained what I've written above, but the doctor didn't seem very pleased with that response. We had to be pretty blunt to make them drop the subject of a geneticist, and I found out later that we were still referred to a specialist to rule out my disability in my baby (I don't mind this so much). I just feel like there was an implication that we should not try to have more children or that we had made a mistake in having this one. The entire interaction put a sour taste in our mouths, but maybe it's some kind of standard practice for disabled parents that we just aren't aware of? I would appreciate some insight for anyone who might know more than I do. Editing to add that there was and is no concern that my child is affected. Both conditions can be ruled out via physical exam. My spouse's is more visible, while mine would have to be checked for in a medical setting, but it is possible to diagnose without genetic testing. The general concensus seems to be that I overreacted, especially in my use of the word eugenics to refer to this situation. Apologies. My main issue was with what I perceived as appropriate interest in us seeking genetic counseling for the future and a lack of willingness to drop the subject after I explained that I am already aware of the facts about our conditions and how they are inherited.


r/genetics • • Mar 11 '26

Why does everyone hate eugenics/gene editing embryos? I'm an uneducated idiot on this topic, please help me.

0 Upvotes

So google isn't any help, and AI is slop.

I'll be honest, i don't know anything about this subject apart from the dictionary definition and a few other things. But recently all over the internet everyone is hating on it and I just don't understand why.

As far as my very limited knowledge goes, if before my baby is born I can make sure that my child doesn't have any defects/birth disorders or aren't born with anything that will be debilitating or make their life harder, why wouldn't I want to do it? If i can make sure my child is born normal, why shouldn't I? If there's an opportunity to make sure that my baby is born with perfect health and no defects, why shouldn't I take that opportunity and instead just hope for the best? No, ofcourse im gonna do it and make sure my baby is born perfect and healthy and without any defects.

Again, i don't know much about what this even is, but not doing it, with my limited knowledge, kinda feels like being ill, not taking medicine and just hoping for the best and that it will go away. I certainly don't know anything about what the whole "turned pregnancy into a subscription" stuff is either.

Someone please educate me.


r/genetics • • May 20 '24

Question If two females had a baby, would it make the baby’s gender definitely female

0 Upvotes

So like I know it’s not possible, but say that theoretically two biological females had a baby together. With the XX chromosome thing, would it be impossible to have a male baby or is that different?


r/genetics • • Apr 17 '24

Question If intelligence is hereditary, why is it wrong to say that there are group differences when it comes to intelligence?

1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I am black

It seems to me that the consensus is that intelligence is heritable. I understand that we are not 100% sure as to how intelligence works and how to measure it (IQ is probably not a good measure).

But, even with these limitations, we know it’s hereditary.

If that’s the case, how is there no correlation between intelligence and belonging to a certain human group (ethnic, racial, linguistic, national origin, or whatever)?

It seems to me that it has to be true by definition. Why would it be wrong to say that people from group X are, on average, less intelligent than people from group Y? We do this with many other features with no issue.

Are there principled/ scientific reasons for being skeptical about group differences when it comes to intelligence or is the skepticism mainly motivated by the political implications (racist people using such things to justify some harmful nonsense)?

Note: Groups don’t have to be racial groups. You can ignore U.S’s dumb white/ black distinction for this purpose. We also don’t have to precisely define what constitute the groups (we are not expected do that with other features, for instance—say, height). I’m just interested in group level differences (at some level), given that it’s heritable.


r/genetics • • Mar 06 '25

Discussion What’s the big deal with companies owning genetic information?

0 Upvotes

Genuinely, I don’t think it matters all that much. Our DNA does not determine political leanings; it does not determine which products we will want to buy. It barely codes for the phenotypes that actually show up. Most of what and who we are is shaped by the environments we are raised in and heavily interact with. I did 23andMe years ago, and people are freaking out about privacy for these test kits as if they could do anything with that information.

Maybe I’m stupid, but what could possibly be the effect of someone having access to your genetic code? The only thing I could think of is that it could encourage racism based on trace ancestry, but that seems kind of far-fetched. For example, that an apparent white person who has 2% African ancestry would experience newfound prejudice simply because a DNA testing company knows that they have 2% African ancestry just seems a bit far fetched.


r/genetics • • May 14 '20

If you cross a heterozygous tall plant with a short plant, what is the expected phenotypic frequency of short offspring?

0 Upvotes

r/genetics • • 9d ago

What do you call a variant that's worse than a heterozygous deletion of the same gene? We proposed a name: PEAK variants

0 Upvotes

"Dominant-negative" often gets used as shorthand for "worse than a heterozygous deletion." But it's a mechanistic claim (the mutant product interferes with the wild-type one), and gain-of-function or neomorphic variants can produce the same pattern.

We propose a mechanism-agnostic label based purely on clinical severity:

PEAK = phenotype-exceeding-(mono)allelic-knockout. A variant whose associated phenotype exceeds that of heterozygous loss-of-function in the same gene. Example: the recurrent DNAJC5 variants would be PEAK-missense / PEAK-indel.

Paper: https://www.cell.com/trends/genetics/fulltext/S0168-9525(26)00244-1


r/genetics • • Nov 26 '25

How much green fluorescent cells are in this plate?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I don’t know if I’m counting them correctly..


r/genetics • • Feb 18 '24

Question If race and ethnicity is a social construct, then how does 23andMe work?

0 Upvotes

I learned in an anthropology class last quarter about how race is a social construct, arbitrary boundaries created by us, rather than a real biological distinction that we can point to. So there’s no way to tell what “race” someone would be just by looking at their DNA. And I think I understood is pretty well. But I asked my professor at the time how 23 and Me works, and I’m pretty sure she answered me, but I Lowkey forgot her answer. Anyone know the answer?


r/genetics • • Jul 07 '26

HELP WITH HW QUESTION

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

i’m super confused as i keep getting B or C yet that’s not an option choice!! any help would be super super appreciated


r/genetics • • Sep 03 '25

Why are Russians so distant from northern europeans genetically?

1 Upvotes

Russians and northeast europeans (Balts, poles and ukrainians) are genetically distant from northwest europeans such as Swedes and Norwegians. It is also difficult to model the ancestry of Russians on genetic tools, unlike most other Europeans. Why is this?


r/genetics • • Jan 01 '26

Can a trauma be the origin of a genetic mutation??

1 Upvotes

There is a genetic disease that appeared about 200 years ago in one of my ancestors, and my parents (not geneticians lol) strongly believe that, somehow, it was caused by the shock/traumatism because of a murder that happened in the family literally 300 years ago (so 100 years before the mutation). I'm very skeptic about that story, obviously, because how would that even be possible? I don't know a lot about genetics (which is my main raison for asking here, I could be wrong), but I'd find it really hard to believe that the traumatism of having a relative killed could change your actual DNA? Maybe it could change the epression of the genes by epigenetics or something, but that wouldn't transfer to the next generation, would it?

They argument is that "psychology can have extreme and unexpected effects on the body", which is true as far as I know, but I don't think it can interfer with genetics, though...

And even if that whole story was true, how would it be the most plausible theory explaining the mutation in the first place?


r/genetics • • Sep 06 '26

Meta IQ and genetics

0 Upvotes

So based on the research, IQ is 50-70% genetic, with the remaining being something that can be controlled by nurture and the environment (nutrition, education, reading books, healthy and supportive social environment)

The genetic component of IQ sets the upper limit of what can be achieved, but beyond that, no amount of hard work and effort is going to yield results, IQ wise. Meaning that one cannot DO anything to increase one's IQ beyond what is genetically predetermined.

Assuming that a person has access to decent quality of resources (school/college, food, access to a library/money to buy and read books), the IQ a person has generally is strongly correlated to their ability to work on certain types of tasks. For example, the work that Physicists and scientists like Einstein do, Mathematicians like Terence Tao do, doctors who discover and invent new drugs do, economists who advise heads of state do, requires a higher level of IQ than say an accountant does, a web developer does, a lawyer does, a teacher does.

I don't mean to demean any profession here.

And society, as is the reality of it in 2026, rewards people who can successfully work on the former types of tasks much higher than people working on the latter types of tasks, for the majority of cases.

So does society reward people disproportionately for things like IQ which are, for the most part, out of their control?


r/genetics • • Nov 13 '22

Question Was my kid switched at birth or am I just bad at Punnett squares???

0 Upvotes

I have BB hair, her father has Bb hair. I thought her hair would darken from blonde to brown but she's 8 now and still blonde.

There is a 0% chance that he is not the father.

Please tell me 8th grade science oversimplified the way genetics work. Could this be an epigenetic thing? Like is her "brown hair" gene just switched off or something? Are there other genes that can control hair color? I am panicking because I'm concerned she was switched at birth???


r/genetics • • Sep 14 '26

23andMe’s bankruptcy made me realise genetic data behaves very differently from normal customer data

0 Upvotes

I made a documentary tracing 23andMe’s rise, breach, bankruptcy and what happens to genetic data when the company holding it changes hands.

What I found most interesting wasn't really the ancestry-test story. It was the strange nature of the asset itself. Genetic data doesn't only say something about the person who submitted it. Through relatives and shared DNA, one person's data can reveal information about people who never submitted anything.

I tried to separate what actually happened from some of the more sensational claims around the bankruptcy, but this sub obviously knows the genetics better than I do.

What do you think people misunderstand most about the value, and the actual privacy risk, of a database like 23andMe's?

I made the documentary here if anyone wants the full argument:

https://youtu.be/IWwz9ykUQFw


r/genetics • • Oct 13 '25

Is there a proof that European Jews are half Judean specifically?

1 Upvotes

An argument I often read online is the following: "All Jews are more related to each other than the host countries they lived in"

And I have been studying the genetics of different Jews for awhile and I realized this is a lie. Basically Jews are related to each other based on "ingroup", ie, Persian Jews are more related to each other than to Persian non-Jews, but a Persian Jew is much closer to a Persian non-jew than an Ashkenazi, you can see that Yemeni Jews are basically Peninsular arab, and Ethiopian Jews are just Ethipian, so this argument is strange, why do some websites online claim that Jews are more related to each other than their continents or countries?, I don't know if I'm using the calculator wrong but I don't see relationship between different groups (Ashkenaz and Sephardici do seem to be related, but I think both groups had a common origin from what I have been analyzing: Italy and Greece).

Now the topic I want to discuss is another argument that to me sounds a bit far fetched and strange, but someone who might have researched deeper would know. A common idea is that Ashkenazi Jews are basically "Exiles from Judea who married Italian women and then had minor Eastern European and Germanics in minor scale". I think people say this because the autosomal composition of Ashkenazi plus the Y DNA and mtDNA

However, I find a flaw with this logic.

I noticed that in different models, the Southern European component is, indeed, Italic, but they also have Anatolian and Levantine. It's true that Judeans are Levantine, but the thing is, and while I don't discard the option that maybe some of the pharisees who converted Europeans back in Ancient Rome mixed with them (just like the early Judean Christians tbh), I think that their genetic aportation to modern European Jews might be minimal and not "half of their DNA" as some people suggest.

Why do I think this?

Simple, the Italians who would give European Jews the Anatolian DNA isare thesouthern ones, not the northern ones. So it's extremely likely that they mixed with Southern Italians. Southern Italians also have, by default Levantine DNA. So if a Judean married a Southern Italian woman, their component of the child wouldn't be "50% European and 50% Judean/Levantine", the result would be like 70-80% West Asian. But they barely show up to be 40% more or less, which I assume the "50%" could have not been due the Eastern and Germanic DNA, however even with this small account, the Levantine should be MUCH higher if they came from a male line judean predominantly. For example, if a Palestinian Christian man (who typically are almost completely Levantine) marries a Southern Italian woman, their children wouldn't be "50% West Asian and 50% European" if you break down their DNA, the result would break down into a very high amount of West Asian and a minority of European. So I really suspect that European Jews (specifically Ashkenazi ones) might have Italian in both sides, they do have more levantine shift than Italians, but it depends on the region, I have senoticed that the amount of west asian varies drastically in Italiann South, they are a more heterogeneous population, but these "factors" are always there.

The key problem: The reason why people assume the Judean hypothesis is because they show up J haplogroup, but this haplogroup is present in Southern Italy and the BAlkans, because as I said, they already have an ancient west asian DNA from both the levant and anatolia. So is this idea believed here? What do you know about this?

I find htis peculiar because, when you analyze Jewish populations many don't have Levantine, and the ones with most Levantine seem to be specifically the Sephardic Jews (of the Talmudic kind (I use this word to make distinction with Karaites)), which yeah, syrians are levatine so it makes sense.


r/genetics • • Aug 28 '24

am i more likely going to have boys than girls?

0 Upvotes

my boyfriend(m22) just found out that his mother is pregnant with her 5th boy. out of all 5 of him and his siblings, he has 1 older sister and 3 younger brothers, and then the soon to be 4th younger brother (they started super young). i, however, am the oldest between my sister and i.

my question purely out of curiosity is, when we decide down the line to get married and have children, will we be more likely to have boys or girls? i know that it’s technically 50/50 but it seems like based on their amount of times having boys it’s a little more than 50/50.

to add: his paternal grandmother had more boys and my paternal grandmother also had more boys (not sure if this information is entirely relevant).

edit: completely forgot to mention that i am a female (22)


r/genetics • • Jul 12 '25

What's the legacy of the human genome project in your mind? your specific field?

0 Upvotes

(Edit: Wow that internet has never made me cry before by being mean to me. We can check that off the list now. I am geninuenly curious. I am an interested outsider (a person, not an AI bot) who did some bioinformatics research 10 years ago in my undergrad and haven't been in the field since. I didn't mean to espouse a view here or make an argument. I really am just curious. This Hobbs-Cohen approach seems incredible. I was hoping for more stories like that. I guess I being young took a lot of things for granted which really are remarkable developments. If I had just said GWAS didn't lead to satisfying conclusions would everyone still be so mad? I have also been told that HGP led directly to NGS. I thought NGS was a separate development. That explains a lot of the response to me. Finally I think I forgot that science is always building on itself and that every exciting thing that's come out in genetics/genomics since 2000 owes a debt to what came before - i.e. HGP)

25 years after Bill Clinton announced the first draft of the human genome in a joint press conference with Tony Blair, Francis Collins and Craig Venter, the legacy of the Human Genome project has been uncertain. In some ways it was an incredible, unequivocal success. In others it was a failure that didn’t meet many of its less grandiose claims let alone any of the grandest ones. What is your opinion based on your own work and experience?

There is one extremely compelling success story highlighted in an article in the Scientific American published in October 2010 titled, “Revolution Postponed”. It presciently highlights the work of Hobbs and Cohen in their clever research of PCSK9.

They write, “The Hobbs-Cohen approach focuses on extreme cases of disease, assuming that rare gene variants that strongly perturb biology account for the extremity and will stand out starkly. They also pick and choose which genes to examine in those people, based on a knowledge of biology. And, they sequence specific candidate genes, looking for subtle but functionally dramatic variations between people, rather than using SNP associations, which can indicate the genetic neighborhood of a disease-related gene but often not the gene itself”.

The article then notes that “PCSK9 is a ‘top-10 target’ of virtually every pharmaceutical company now.” In 2025, there are now three drugs on the market to lower LDL cholesterol based on their findings.

In my field of interest I’m curious if we can look at people with the worst manifestations of mental illness, check key biomarkers and other factors and related genes to try to pinpoint some of its underpinnings in the same way. What challenges about mental illness make this harder to do that the study of heart disease and cholesterol. Do any make it easier?

Are there similar things you could do in your research area? Are there already lots of other success stories like this that I haven’t heard of?


r/genetics • • Dec 27 '25

Is the Reddit sub “23andme” mostly about ancestry and not genetics, SNP’s etc.?

0 Upvotes

I just casually glanced over there and seems like most people are just interested in ancestry info.

Is this the place where people discuss actual medical genetics from 23 and me?

Like many people, I used a couple of other companies to decipher my 23 and me data, one of them had a lot of info, 20 pages of genes.


r/genetics • • Apr 29 '24

Question Recently discovered that there was inbreeding in my wife's family. Possible link to wife's learning disability?

0 Upvotes

I recently discovered that my wife's great grandmother had an arranged marriage with a cousin. So, it was my wife's mom's mom's mom that married and had children with her cousin, back around the turn of the century. My wife has severe dyslexia (but no intellectual deficits) and her mom we suspect may also be dyslexic as well as have an intellectual deficiency. Her mom can barely read, consistently pronounces very common words incorrectly, even after being corrected and shown how to pronounce them. My wife's mom also shows strong signs of intellectual deficits. My wife's mom's mom also showed some signs of intellectual deficits, but did not seem to be dyslexic.

As some examples, my wife's mom thought that MLK had been president of the US. She thought Hawaii was a different country, until we pointed out that it isn't. She asked a British family member in England what their plans were for Thanksgiving. She thought New Mexico was the country of Mexico, rather than a US state. It goes on and on. She lacks general knowledge to quite a large degree. She fails to grasp a lot of concepts that most everyone else can. She didn't even know the word 'sophisticated' when I used it in a sentence.

She grew up in a town in this country and had plenty of exposure to other people and pop culture. She also graduated from high school. Whether any of this stuff could be attributed to dyslexia or some other learning disability, my question is this:

Could a case of inbreeding (with a cousin) a couple generations prior be responsible for these challenges my wife and her mother face?


r/genetics • • Feb 12 '26

Are Humans Genetic Pool weakening with technology?

1 Upvotes

This is NOT a eugenics question, please dont devolve the conversation/answer with any of that. With technology advancing, individuals who couldn't or wouldn't have kids, now have the opportunity to. Does that weaken the overall genetic pool? I'm not familiar with Genetics, recessive/dominant genes, etc..

Compare this to 2,000-10,000 years ago when survival of the fittest played a more crucial part of human development.


r/genetics • • Aug 01 '25

How much of me is passed on through my siblings children?

0 Upvotes

I have no children but my 2 brothers and sister have 10 in total. I tried to ask ChatGPT but it really did not know the answer ( 250% ! )

https://chatgpt.com/share/688c6f4e-6e48-800f-8213-0987a2adbbd8


r/genetics • • Sep 10 '22

Question Is being tall usually related with professional athleticism?

1 Upvotes

Most athletes regardless of the sport are usually very tall. I know they haven’t figured out where athleticism comes from but do you think height and sports ability are often related?


r/genetics • • Jun 13 '24

Can the expansion of the human genome plausibly be the cause of rising cancer rates?

5 Upvotes

This might actually be a silly question, but I was thinking about how cancer rates are going up globally, and read an article that cited 2/3 of cancer being attributed to genetics rather than environmental factors.

Since the population has exploded over the past century, the human genome has evolved and expanded, right? Living organisms tend to develop cancer if they live long enough- could a similar mechanism be the cause of increasing cancer at the population level?

Again might be dumb and silly but I’m a lay person and I’m curious