r/genesisvision • • Feb 27 '18

To my GVT folks

191 Upvotes

Despite the amazing progress and growth of the Genesis Vision platform / product of the last few months, the next few weeks will most likely be some of the most crucial times for GVT up to date.

As we all know, alpha launch on April 1st will be a big deal. This is the proof of concept, the MVP, before the next big milestone at the end of the year.

This will likely generate a lot of shilling and a lot of news. But also a lot of FUD. We need to be prepared for the influx of traffic on this page, telegram and all the social media platforms.

How we respond will be crucial to be seen as a legitimate product. Getting into arguments won't help. Think about it this way - which people convince you the most when you read about other projects? The ones that shill without arguing, only talk about mooning and curse out anyone who doesn't agree with them? Or is it people who put forth reasonable arguments and keep their cool?

If someone FUDs, that's fine. Ask for their reasoning. If they keep fuding without providing any meaningful and thoughtful counter-arguments, tell them you disagree and move on.

People don't like to be told what to do... so don't scream 'BUY GVT' everywhere, all day. Make your case intelligibly and tell them they should look into it, or not. Give them the option to NOT look into it, as it will pique their interest and show how confident you are, with or without them.

That's how I will try to deal with the increase scrutiny GVT will receive in the next few weeks and months. Feel free to follow my advice, or not.

Be confident in the product.

Edit: peak to pique


r/genesisvision • • Mar 08 '18

For the first time in history Genesis Vision is now in the top 100 on CoinMarketCap. Congratulations everyone!

Post image
173 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Mar 13 '18

GV platform screen♥️

Post image
155 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Mar 16 '18

FUD Slaying: A Guide on How to Force Binance to Touch Their Cold Wallets

148 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am writing today to slay some FUD and give better insight on how Binance secures our coins. This post is related to Genesis Vision Token (GVT), but it is relevant to many other ERC20 projects as well including OMG and VeChain.

A few days ago I saw a post on /r/cryptocurrency that I had an issue with:

https://np.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/83rdk4/beware_of_gvt_been_seeing_it_mentioned_a_lot/

The OP of this post was asserting that 35% of all GVT was owned by a single person. For any cryptocurrency project, centralization of coins is not viewed as a good thing. The primary concern of this is “What happens when that giant whale decides to dump?”

But he wasn’t the only one that was speculating that same wallet:

There were also posts related to VeChain and SingularDTV.

This particular wallet had been the source of FUD and hype for other projects as well, mainly because Etherscan never bothered to label it as a Binance wallet, and there was insufficient evidence to support that it did belong to Binance before today, even with their first GVT transaction coming from another wallet that held $2.9 Billion in other crypto. Thanks to the blockchain, there is now much stronger evidence to prove that this wallet does indeed belong to Binance. It is not a single mysterious whale hoarding coins. At first I thought this was going to be simple. I knew I owned more GVT than Binance had in their hot wallets so it should have been as easy as moving all my coins out and waiting for the cold wallet to refill the hot wallet. However, I ran into a few bumps along the way. In order to stay within the 100 BTC per day withdrawal limit, I had to split my withdrawals between 3 different days. Each day gave greater insight into how their hot wallet and cold storage method functioned.


The current wallets that are labeled on Etherscan are:

Binance Primary Hot Wallet

[Binance Secondary Hot Wallet #1] (https://etherscan.io/token/0x103c3A209da59d3E7C4A89307e66521e081CFDF0?a=0xd551234ae421e3bcba99a0da6d736074f22192ff)

Binance Secondary Hot Wallet #2

Binance also has some unlabeled cold wallets which include:

[Binance Primary Cold Wallet] (https://etherscan.io/token/0x103c3A209da59d3E7C4A89307e66521e081CFDF0?a=0xfe9e8709d3215310075d67e3ed32a380ccf451c8)

Binance Secondary Cold Wallet (The one in question) The keyword here is “unlabeled”. There may be more, but since my focus was on where GVT was being stored, I didn’t bother to track down others.


Withdrawal 1

I performed a withdrawal of 29000 GVT from Binance. Based on their wallet balance, this was going to severely drain their hot wallet, but I needed to get my coins off of the exchange anyway and was within my rights to do so.

I had waited over 6 hours for Binance to process my withdrawal, but nothing was happening. Were they going to shuffle their hot wallets around or would they touch their cold wallet?

Eventually my withdrawal was processed and their primary hot wallet was left with around 2900 GVT. A few hours after my withdrawal something unexpected happened. A swarm of deposits started flowing into Binance. Hundreds upon hundreds of transactions were flowing in at a mindboggling rate over the course of hours. Most of these transactions ranged between 8 and 70 GVT. All of this can be verified on the blockchain in the Binance Main Hot Wallet from March 13th.

Before I made my withdrawal there were around 8000 wallets that held GVT. After this there were less than 7000 wallets. Over 1000 deposits from varying addresses consecutively flowed into Binance in order to refill their hot wallet.

But this threw a wrench in my hypothesis. If Binance had this “wallet swarm” ready to refill their hot wallet when needed, then perhaps that cold wallet wasn’t theirs…

Withdrawal 2

The next day, I withdrew 31250 GVT. Soon after the withdrawal, the wallet began to refill again. This time a few hundred wallets were depositing between 7 and 10 GVT. It was strange but still interesting. After checking the number individual wallets holding GVT, I saw that it was down to 6630 and of those, only 6004 held an amount over 1 GVT. I also noticed that the number of “swarm wallets” was nearly depleted. Only a few remained and I was left wondering what would happen next.

Withdrawal 3

This was the last of my stash. I withdrew over 35,000 GVT to finally secure my coins and see what would happen when the smaller accounts were completely drained. My suspicion was proven correct.

With the swarm apparently depleted, Binance was forced to access their Cold Wallet for the first time in 42 days in order replenish their GVT reserves from the Secondary Cold Wallet in question. Over 550,000 GVT were moved from that wallet to their hot wallet, giving them more than enough GVT to fulfill my withdrawal request. The key here is that they moved the coins BEFORE they fulfilled my withdraw request. The timing was perfect. They saw my request, manually accessed their cold wallet and then processed my request. Previously they only used the swarm to refill their hot wallet after the request was completed. After that, they moved over 360,000 GVT from their primary hot wallet into their primary cold wallet (the one with billions of dollars in tokens). Overall, I was pleasantly surprised that things turned out the way they did. Part of me thought that they were simply going to refill from more swarm wallets that I may have been unaware of.


Of nearly 1550 transactions from March 13, 2018 and March 15, 2018, only 53 of those transactions after my first withdrawal were other withdrawals. Nearly 1500 transactions (Over 95%) into that wallet were deposits, and most of these depositing wallets each held around 0.04 ETH to facilitate transactions.

If you check the Binance Primary Hot Wallet blockchain prior to my first withdrawal you would only see a few GVT transactions per day. This event was unprecedented. I also noticed that a lot of these small wallets that emptied out their GVT held a few other coins as well. Most notably VeChain and OMG, along with some holding ZRX, Polymath and others.

The point to take away from this is that Binance secures your coins using more than a few large cold wallets. They also have a “Cold Wallet Swarm” where instead of 100,000 coins in a single wallet, they’ll have a few thousand wallets with varying numbers of coins, and each wallet can be ordered to deposit into the Binance hot wallet at a moment’s notice. Another thing to note is that the number of token holders for VeChain, OMG and other coins is not accurate since Binance themselves control thousands of those wallets. But then again, we don’t know how many people hold those coins solely on Binance either.


TL:DR

Binance apparently uses thousands of wallets to keep coins in semi-cold storage in addition to large cold wallets. They will not touch the large cold wallets unless there is low supply in hot wallets and depletion of these smaller wallets.

There is no GVT whale that owns 35% of the GVT supply. If your crypto appears to have a whale that has a crazy percentage of your project’s coins in one of these addresses, it is Binance.


r/genesisvision • • Jun 07 '18

Genesis Markets is OUT 🎉

Thumbnail
genesismarkets.io
128 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Dec 26 '18

It's Forex time!

Thumbnail
twitter.com
117 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Mar 12 '18

Why Genesis Vision (GVT) Should Be on Your Watch-List

115 Upvotes

In light of the recent shills regarding GVT, I thought it would be the perfect time to give some of you a quick look on what GVT is and why it has been getting so much attention as of late. As a disclaimer, I am invested in GVT and I would like to also point out that although I am fairly active on the GVT sub reddit, I have not shilled it whatsoever on /r crypto. I mention this because I know there will be those that say "oh great, another shill post/comment" and had I been trying to shill, I would be all over this sub spamming people about it. I will try to make this post as unbiased as possible. In return, I simply ask that any FUD, and shills as well, include some substance so that we may have a nice discussion.


What is Genesis Vision?

Genesis Vision, from the site, is "the first platform for the private trust management market, built on Blockchain technology and Smart Contracts". Simply put, they are creating an easy-to-use app where people who do not know how to invest their money can give it to someone who does on a trustless platform. Think of it like a trust-less brokerage firm that is backed by blockchain technology and smart contracts. From the white-paper, there are 3 types of people on the platform:

  • Managers: Management funds/traders are companies/individuals with a proven trading history, ready to acquire investors' money for management. The profit, received as a result of management of the total funds, is shared proportionally between the managers and investors. Managers receive a commission for management and a commission from the profit (success fee).

  • Investors: Investors do not trade in the market directly. Instead, investors transfer their funds to experienced traders who manage the funds for them. Investors get their shares from their managers’ profits.

  • Brokers: Brokers are companies that have the appropriate licenses to carry out brokerage activities. Through brokers, traders have access to trading financial instruments on exchange and over-the-counter markets.

The final GVT platform will have the forex, stock and crypto market all integrated onto one app. GVT's alpha release on April 1st will only include the forex market. Q4 of this year will then integrate crypto for their beta release. Finally, on their final product release, stocks will be added.


How is the platform trust-less?

First ask yourself this, why can people trust traditional brokers with their money? They can't. Who's not to say any given broker won't run away or make awful investments and lose your money? The only thing people like you and me can go off of when investing with any given broker is their track record - and that’s something that could be tampered with too. How long has this person/brokerage firm been in the market? How reliable are they? Stuff like this isn't going to be an issue on Genesis Vision. The time a person has been investing on the platform is all public on the blockchain. Every good investment and every bad investment will be publicly listed. Smart contracts will ensure that no manager can close shop and run with your money. At the end of the trading period, funds are released to the original investor and the manager is given a cut - all safely and securely using smart contracts. This completely eliminates the trust factor as everyone will simply base investments on a manager’s track record.


How does it work?

On the platform, each manager will have their own token. You invest into said manager by buying their token. The manager can then utilize the various markets available to invest and hopefully grow your money. Managers will have levels that are based on their ability to make consistent and reliable gains. The lowest level a manager can be is level 1 while the highest is 7. Your level basically determines how much money you can handle - the max level being able to handle roughly $1m. New people can apply to become a manager after they have developed a track record by trading a minimum of $1,000 over a given period of time.


How GVT is creating its own ecosystem.

To make it easier to understand how the platform will work, ask yourself how the current crypto market works. No matter how many trades you do or what coins you hold, the end goal is to have your portfolio be worth more satoshis/gwei than what you started with. You can either hold BTC, OR you can invest in various altcoins in hopes that it will grow faster than BTC. The reason people research low cap “undiscovered” cryptos is to hopefully catch a rocketship before it takes off. Times have since changed, but everything used to have to go through BTC. Buying alts? Exchange from BTC. Selling alts? Exchange to BTC. BTC falls, everyone falls. BTC grows, everyone grows (sometimes). Some alts will fall harder than BTC, and some won't. Some alts will grow faster than BTC and some won't. Because of BTC's dominance over the market, it is why many crypto veterans hold a big portion of their portfolio in BTC and why they often recommend it to others.

This is akin to how the GVT platform will work. GVT is BTC and the managers on the platform are the altcoins. You could either hold GVT or put it into a manager that will hopefully get you better returns. Much like how people right now look for “undervalued” and “undiscovered” altcoins, there will be talks and similar conversation about undiscovered managers with potential. Now remember, this is how it’s going to be for the intermediate to advanced people, but for newer or more busy people, GVT can become a fantastic tool for side-income.

The platform’s main goal is mass adoption. People like me and you would be more inclined to simply hold GVT since we’d be able to spot out good short, mid and long holds ourselves. Also, since as the platform grows, the coin itself will naturally grow with it. However, what GVT is aiming to do is build a platform similar to Robinhood. Just like how they made investing in stocks - and now cryptos - more appealing and easier to all audiences (especially younger ones), GVT is trying to do this but with a broker-like app instead. Also, keep in mind I’m just talking about crypto. The platform is going to utilize the forex market and the stock market as well.

The takeaway of all this is that because GVT will have its own platform where you can buy/sell GVT straight off of, down the line GVT could possibly part ways with Bitcoin and in a sense create its own ecosystem where GVT is the driving force of its own market.


Why invest with a manager?

So now, I’m again talking exclusively crypto (since I’m not the most knowledgeable on the forex/stock market), but why would any of us want to invest with a manager? Technical analysis and day-trading is an incredibly taboo subject on this subreddit, but that’s because people don’t understand that TA is a tool. It’s not a fact that it’s going to pan out exactly as it’s written and there are many different things to look at when doing technical analysis on a chart. Any investment in this market is speculation and TA is very useful with helping you make educated guesses for the short, mid and long term. With that said, there are some really good day-traders out there. I’m not sure how this subreddits sentiment is towards Philakone (an exclusive day trader on twitter/youtube/steemit), but the dude makes a good amount of consistent money on a daily basis, whether it be a bull or bear market, and keeps his followers up to date by the minute - for free. Imagine if he were to get on the GVT platform and instead of people trying to copy/paste or follow what he does on Twitter, they can just give him money on the GV platform and have him do the work? Down the line if he becomes a level 7 manager and as a result is given a cut of the $1m he is allowed to work with, the literal TON of money he’d be making would certainly appeal to others looking to do the same. They would no doubt have their eyes on GVT and from there, the platform’s growth would be exponential once more and more manager/brokers hop on.

I’m not saying that this is exactly how everything will turn out, but still imagine being able to make money in a bear market? And aside from that, there is the forex and stock market to utilize and if any of us ever become serious investors, it would important not to just diversify in crypto, but in different markets altogether and being familiar with GVT would greatly help. Again, this is purely talk on the potential of the platform so take it with a grain of salt and DYOR!


Some thoughts + moonboy talk

Okay this is going to be pure moon-talk since I know that’s what drives most of you. To start, the team is most familiar with the forex market - which has a LOT of money in it - and that is what they will be implementing first on their Alpha launch on April 1st. Crypto implementation in Q4 2018 on beta release and then stock implementation in Q1 2019 on the full release.

Remember that REAL adoption comes when people are using applications built on the blockchain without knowing - something GVT will be doing. Look at Steemit. It is the most active blockchain by far - beating out Ethereum AND Bitcoin ( http://blocktivity.info ). Why? Because it’s smooth and functions like a normal website, despite its use of blockchain technology. I’m not saying GVT will automatically shoot up to the top, but actual use is what will determine any crypto’s success and Genesis Vision is looking like a really solid candidate right now.

On top of this, GVT’s CBDO (Chief Business Development Officer) was the founder of tools4brokers ( http://www.t4b.com ) so they have someone on the team with experience with a successful and working product. I’m not going to take a deep-dive on the rest of the team, but I highly suggest checking out the roadmap and the team (all but a few have linkdin profiles).

Now for the money. First, do NOT be fooled about GVT’s USD price. The price is so high because its token supply is very limited. It is roughly 1/6th the supply of Bitcoin’s meaning we would just have to get to 1/6th of Bitcoin’s market cap (around $25b) in order for 1 GVT to equal 1 BTC. It’s a stretch, sure, but it’s more possible than you think. To put it plain and simple, the forex, stock and crypto market altogether amount to upwards of almost $100 trillion.

GVT is a $100m market cap crypto trying to disrupt a $100 trillion~ industry with an easy-to-use, innovative and game-changing app

  • .001% of this market = $1 billion market cap (1,000% gains from now)

  • .01% of this market = $10 billion market cap (10,000% gains from now)

  • .1% of this market = $100 billion market cap (100,000% gains from now)

Huge disclaimer that just because we could reach these numbers, does not necessarily mean we will, but I see no reason why can’t hit a billion or even 10 down the line.


Conclusion

That’s pretty much it from me. Genesis Vision is a project I, and many others, are extremely excited about. It has a lot going for itself and with such a low market cap, it’s definitely something to at least throw on your watch- list. Hopefully this post didn’t come off as too much of a shill (aside from the last portion) and instead opened some people up to why GVT isn’t just “another shitcoin”. If I missed anything, don't be afraid to chip in! And I’d also be more than happy to try and answer any questions some of you may have but I simply ask that you take a look at the white-paper ( https://genesis.vision/white-paper-eng.pdf ) first as it is very user-friendly and would answer some of your questions better than I could.


Links

Website: https://genesis.vision/

Whitepaper: https://genesis.vision/white-paper-eng.pdf


r/genesisvision • • Mar 27 '18

Can we stop for a second and acknowledge we have the best team in crypto?

110 Upvotes

Serious question, what other team in the crypto space, or any space for that matter, is ahead of their roadmap by 6 months?

Let's recap:

1- alpha version, delivered as promised

2- mobile apps, 6 months early

3- crypto trading, 6 months early

Oh, and they also had the time to add a new project to be delivered in May called Genesis Market, an exchange of exchanges.

They have the hardest working team in crypto. They don't achieve all these milestones by throwing money at them... no no no. In fact, they only raised a fraction of what they wanted during their ICO. They have a small team. But shit, they push code out everyday on github and deliver on EVERYTHING.

I have never been so impressed with a team before. Crypro and non-crypto alike. There's still a lot on their plate, but let's pause for a second and give them a round of applause. Well done team, well done.

Edit: trustworthiness, often lacking in the crypto space being full of scams, should be added to the list of attributes this team possesses. Thanks u/rocketleaguebr0


r/genesisvision • • Nov 01 '18

The wait is finally over! Investment programs are already waiting for their first investors.

102 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Apr 04 '18

Why Genesis Vision will FAIL

Thumbnail
medium.com
102 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Nov 02 '18

A sign that GVT is going to 94k

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Sep 20 '18

Partnership with Roboforex Ltd.

100 Upvotes

Please welcome the long-awaited addition to the list of our partners: an award-winning international broker Roboforex Ltd. https://blog.genesis.vision/genesis-vision-partners-up-with-roboforex-6530209b9916


r/genesisvision • • Apr 06 '18

Quantstamp : ‘GVToken’ Report

Thumbnail quantstamp.com
97 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Mar 07 '18

GVT announces partnership with Larson&Holz Brokerage

Thumbnail
twitter.com
97 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Nov 08 '18

Please welcome our newest outstanding partner! EXANTE is a broker for professionals and a one-stop shop for all kinds of derivatives. Learn more:

95 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Oct 10 '18

Genesis Vision announces its partnership with OKEx

94 Upvotes

And we are back to the good news! Genesis Vision managers will soon be able to trade on OKEx - the second largest crypto exchange in the world 🌎 Read more: https://blog.genesis.vision/genesis-vision-announces-its-partnership-with-okex-a37f9838b160


r/genesisvision • • Mar 04 '18

GVT $94k by 2021

Thumbnail
medium.com
94 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Nov 02 '18

Congratulations to Genesis team for actually providing a real product to the space that isn't just another network that supports other future "projects."

89 Upvotes

Cheers fellas, from Los Angeles. I'm not even one bit mad about the no-U.S. abilities right now. Actually it's more of a good thing because when it becomes a big thing all around the globe, the Americans will be jealous and want to participate as well(which actually would propel GVT acquisition as well). I don't think anyone has considered this yet. Great work!


r/genesisvision • • Mar 04 '18

Genesis Vision: FAQ

Thumbnail
medium.com
88 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Mar 08 '18

Lots of excitement but please...

87 Upvotes

Do not start posting moon, lambo, or other stuff. Don't ask how long it'll take to get to the top 50. We have to maintain civility in this sub and act like adults. These are exciting times but remember this project still has a ways to go. Let's try and keep this sub full post with a little more substance.

Edit: I know we asked the Mod to back off a little but maybe we can make suggestions like a weekly price discussion post that gets placed at the top and other posts like that to keep the rest of the sub clean?


r/genesisvision • • Mar 22 '18

FUD Slaying: Why “DYOR” is More Important Than YouTube Videos and Internet FUD

86 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am here to discuss the recent FUD presented by a relatively unknown YouTube reviewer. I intend to discuss his methodology and the actual points themselves.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=1hH5_FAEzyo

This is his YouTube video based on the document in question. He wrote the document. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XQlAGIDPjDoQNHtzEWGdbO9i8MUkc4lZFKYLTZzMpYU/edit

First, to get this out of the way, the reviewer has only been around on the social media scene for a short while. The views of his videos are only in the hundreds and his twitter was created a week ago. He is basically a "nobody" at this point. I don't mean that to be disparaging. He literally came out of nowhere. He is unproven and his methodology is inconsistent and extremely questionable.

With that said, just because he came out of nowhere doesn't mean he might not have a point, so let's look at his rating methodology to get a better idea of his process.

Oh and if you do not want to read all this, here is the TL:DR: The guy doesn't know what he is talking about. He doesn't has much idea of what he is doing when writing reviews. His research is lazy. I actually feel I wasted my time responding to this, but I am going to do it anyway.

When rating a project, he uses the following categories: MVP (minimum viable product), ease of research, team, roadmap, community (bonus), solving a problem, does it need blockchain, token use, red flags, competition, presentation, token vesting, demand/value, scarcity, customer service, best in field (bonus), active use, size of market, development (bonus)

These are pretty good things to look at, but he failed to look at GitHub contributions (or other source code related sites), so he can't really tell if a project is scammy or not. So, how well did he check this stuff out?


Rating the team:

When looking at his review of GVT, the only way to get an idea of this person's methodology is to look at his reviews of other projects. When rating the team there are basically two basic routes a person can take. You can analyze the team itself, or you can bundle the team and the advisors together and rate the project as a whole.

The reviewer is inconsistent in his reviews. In this category he bundles the entire team and advisors on some projects whereas he just looks solely at the team in other reviews.

His research is absolutely lazy. He gave Polymath a 0 rating for their team, but their website links to their company LinkedIn page and lists all 26 employees. It was not hard to find this. Even if it weren't on the site, a simple google search would have revealed who the team is. Polymath has a great team with some decent “stars” on it. It makes no sense to give them a 0. The reviewer doesn't know what he is doing.

Difficulty in finding the team deserves docking points in "ease of research", and it does not deserve giving the entire category a 0. The point of this category should be to evaluate the merits of the team members, which is something he does not do in most of his reviews.

He gave Selfkey a perfect score stating: "Team: 20 Points - Superstar team and advisors" This means he is bundling the team and advisors together. If so, any issues with advisors deserves docking points from that category, not docking at additional 20 points because of one advisor.

Looking at Selfkey, I don't know where the he gets the idea that they have a "superstar team". What does that even mean? I checked their profiles. Some of them only came onto the project recently and their LinkedIn pages are nothing to write home about. Some of them don't even have LinkedIn pages.

He gave the GVT team 13 points, but then docked 20 points because he didn't like Charlie Shrem.

Do you realize the ridiculousness of this? The GV team category effectively gets -7/20 points because the reviewer does not like Charlie Shrem. That is worse than giving the team 0/20. Charlie is only one advisor with no actual power over the GVT team's operations. He cannot execute any commands over the GV team or force them to do anything. The GV team can fire Charlie. Charlie cannot dismantle the GV team. That power balance is important. The rating makes no sense at all. Also, he docked the Changelly advisor because his company has bad customer service? Really? What does that have to do with his ability to advise the GV team on the things they need from him? Fact of the matter is his business is still running. The same cannot be said for advisors of other projects (more on that soon).

If you are going to rate the team and include the advisors, the value should be 3:1 or even 2:1. Even if you gave the advisors a score of 0, the category score should not be that low. GVT's advisors are absolutely amazing. To call them weak is ridiculous.

With regard to Nuls: "Asian team, isn’t on LinkedIn. No way to research." They get 0 points because they are Asian and don't use the sites you like to use? The language used allows that statement to be interpreted in a very negative way. There are non-Asians on that team as well. There is a way to research them. There are bios of each team member if you scroll over the pictures. You can then use that information to do more research on them. You are just too lazy.

Looking at The Key, their members are definitely not "all-stars". Their team is unknown and they have 3 relatively unknown advisors, only one of which has a LinkedIn page. Love him or hate him, Charlie Shrem is a crypto superstar compared to these people. Interestingly they are more of an "Asian team" than Nuls. That didn't seem to affect the score much though.

He gave the Bounty0x team a perfect score, but he obvious didn't bother to research every member of the team or their advisors with much effort. As an example, Terry Li is the Bounty0x solidity developer. If you check his LinkedIn page you will find a few serious red flags. He hasn't held a job for over a year. He has no visible programming experience. He has been a solidity developer for 10 months with no prior history or proof that he can program well. I cannot stress this enough: you do not want your solidity developer to be a programming newbie. This will spell disaster for your project.

When you look at their advisors there are some serious red flags as well. I picked two advisors to research and I found out that both of them have had their companies fail. One of them even declared themselves unsuccessful in a Facebook post. I don't want a project to be advised by people with a bunch of failed startups. Changelly having bad customer service pales in comparison to advisors whose project's failed. Bounty0x's advisor team is filled with failed entrepreneurs and members of their team lack experience in the jobs they are assigned. Also, their "Backend and Solidity engineer" has only been with the project for a month, and his blockchain programming experience is nonexistent. They do not deserve a perfect score in this category.

GVT has a team with years of programming experience, but more importantly, they have years of experience programming financial software. These are exactly the type of people you need on your team.

To the reviewer: Either bundle the advisors into the team rating or give them a separate category. Do not be inconsistent in this category. Do not bring a team's ethnicity into play as a factor for anything. Please do actual research on all the members, and please define what it means to be a "superstar". Please learn to navigate websites. Polymath's team is there. Your inconsistency and lack of research in this makes you appear incapable of judging a team. There is no clear methodology here. All your reviews are questionable because of this.


Roadmap:

He gave 0 points to GVT for their roadmap being hard to read. But the key point is this: They have a roadmap. There is no reason to give 0 points in this category. Not only that, the roadmap is decently detailed with many goals and objectives. The roadmap isn't some simple points on a line like Enigma's roadmap. Speaking of which...

He gave Enigma 0 points for not having a roadmap at all.... But they do have a roadmap. The guy didn't do his research.

https://en.decentral.news/2017/12/27/ico-analysis-enigma-catalyst-realm-crypto-trading-machines/

It can be found here.

MVP:

Having a minimum viable product be worth only 10 points is ludicrous. Any project that has an MVP basically utterly destroys a project that doesn't. More importantly, the reviewer didn't actually bother to use the MVP on what he reviews.

He gave Polymath 0 points for their demo, but gave GVT 10 points for theirs.

I am going to be blunt about this. GVT's demo is a non-functional interface demo. GVT's MVP comes on April 1. Polymath does not deserve a 0, and GVT does not (as of 3/21) deserve a 10. They both deserve a 5. He didn't bother to actually check out GVT's demo, which goes to show he doesn't actually research things properly.

He gave Enigma a 3 for an MVP not available to the public and Selfkey a 5 for an MVP not used by the public. Eh?

He gave the Authorship a 10 for their MVP but claims he cannot find any info about them. How is that supposed to work?

He gave Po.Et 0 points for their MVP because he couldn't find it.

Here you go buddy: https://github.com/poetapp/wordpress-plugin

It's right there. You just failed to find it. It isn't their fault your research is bad.

Ease of Research:

The reviewer either needs to dock points for research being difficult in their respective categories or dock research being difficult in this category. Do not "double dip" and dock points in both categories. This category is irrelevant since the reviewer already docks points in their respective categories. Also, this category is subjective because it is based on the reviewer's research skillset.


Community:

He uses coingecko's score or numbers from their telegram channel but there isn’t much evidence that he actually bothered to check out their communities much. Reeks of laziness and has nothing to do with the quality of a community. This really shouldn't even be a category if he is going to give points based on this. High telegram channel members has little meaning.

Solving a problem:

The reviewer’s inability to understand the problem that a project solves should not be held against it. Polymath is quite clear in the problem it solves.

He gives projects that solve problems of identifying people a 10, but gives projects that solve problems of identifying intellectual property a 3. That makes no sense. Those are both problems that need to be solved by the blockchain. The idea that he finds one more important than the other is clear bias.

Token Use:

The author does not understand the GV product. GV is platform agnostic, and more importantly GVT needs as little outside influence as possible. There is a very specific reason why GVT has to be used in place of ETH. ETH would technically be a middleman in this sense. GV's success is not meant the be tied to ETH's success or ETH token price manipulation. GV's success isn't even meant to be tied to crypto's success. GV is designed to succeed even if ETH or crypto fails.

GVT actually deserves a 10 in this category. GVT is needed to use the platform. Money is transferred using GVT. Profit is returned using GVT. Other services such as GV Markets will also function using GVT as gas. The utility of GVT is needed in all aspects of the platform. This gives the token great utility and investment value. If 1 Billion is invested through the GV platform, GV's market cap includes that 1 billion because the token is needed to transfer that 1 Billion around. This provides great incentive to invest in the platform and a great reason for the token price to grow in value. No other project that this much incentive or ways to bring value to their token as much as GVT. I am surprised the reviewer cannot see this.

GVT is also market agnostic. The entire crypto market can fail and GVT can still maintain value through profits brought in from the Forex and stock markets. This will make it extremely resilient over time.


Presentation:

The purpose of GVT is quite clear. It is broken down on the website and the presentation clearly explains why it is needed as all levels of trust management including the brokers, customers and managers. All that info is very clear on the front page of the site. 0/10? GVT presentation isn't the problem here. It seems the reviewer only watched the video which is just one part of the presentation. Everything is on the site and in the whitepaper, which the reviewer apparently didn't even fully read.

Token vesting:

He colors it yellow for GVT but green for other projects that also get 5 points... visual bias is apparent. He gave one project a 10 for an 18 month vesting period and a 6 to another project for the same period with little justification for such a disparity.

Supply/Scarcity:

GVT receives 3 points because 44M tokens were available during ICO but only sold about 4M. This makes him believe that they didn’t create much demand. “Everyone who wanted GVT got it.” The US and Singapore could not participate. Also, Bounty0x failed to reach their soft cap, but the reviewer didn’t dock any points for that. If everyone who wanted GVT got it then the marketcap wouldn’t be where it is today. What a terrible assumption he made.

Competition: He gave GV a 5/10, but his reasoning made little sense. “Covesting and coindash are used to trade cryptocurrencies while GVT is for cryptocurrency AND non-crypto trading. They will still compete for a portion of the same market. People will have only so much fiat to invest.” You do not use fiat to invest in Covesting or Coindash. Also, GV will allow people who are into stocks or forex to bring their money into crypto. No other coin is doing what GVT does. Covesting and coindash, arguably, are projects that try to compete against just one part of the entire GV platform. GVT is more than that and should have a higher score because there is basically no competition. There is competition for some of its features, but not for the platform as a whole. He gave Bounty0x a 20-point bonus for "Best in Field"... but they are the best because they have no competition. As a matter of fact, there is no reason for a 20 point "best in field category" when you already have a competition category worth 10 points.

He gave Funfair a 5/10 even though he states "No competition in FunFair’s niche"... That would automatically make it the best in its field if it has no competition as well.

Why does a project that has no competition effectively get 30 points (10/10 + 20), while another project with no competition get only 5 (5/10 + 0)? I will tell you why. It's because the author doesn't know what he is doing.

Guy's I am going to be honest. I am tired of doing this. You get my point. His reviews are an inconsistent and poorly researched mess. I've written around 8 pages worth of content covering this. If there is anything else you need me to compare, please write it in the comment section.


r/genesisvision • • Sep 11 '18

New Genesis Vision Platform Video.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
85 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Jun 01 '18

13 reasons why Genesis Markets is the best way to trade crypto

85 Upvotes

The game changer for crypto trading is coming soon! Check out our new article: "13 reasons why Genesis Markets is the best way to trade crypto": https://blog.genesis.vision/13-reasons-why-genesis-markets-is-the-best-way-to-trade-crypto-e1ac66994de0


r/genesisvision • • Mar 23 '18

Just2trade partners with GVT

Thumbnail
twitter.com
85 Upvotes

r/genesisvision • • Oct 23 '18

Genesis Vision managers will soon be able to trade on HuobiGlobal

81 Upvotes