r/genderqueerstraight • u/Glum_Caterpillar_345 • 2d ago
Venting Awkward convo I got myself into, left me feeling invalidated about my identity
So, this happened under a post talking about gooners that take over fandoms. I did feel weird about this person saying that every anime femboy were caricatures, however, I do know that many popular animes and mangas with femboys can have problematic tropes like the “trap” trope which is very transphobic; so I trusted their word on it as I’ve never actually watched these animes myself (even if I recognize the names of some femboy characters). Also, the way I’ve seen some authors portray their ‘femboy’ characters as “girlfriends” for their mcs while engaging in a kind of “sissyfication” kink makes their characters feel like a poorly thought-out, goonerish caricature of transfems, which is what that person was talking about. I decided to bring up my own past experiences with edge lords and right-wingers on sites like Twitter that like or identify as femboys but are also extremely bigoted, misogynistic, and transmisogynistic; and I mentioned how us regular GNC people are have been trying to not let guys that act like this affect our community and image.
However, the whole conversation just makes me realize I shouldn’t have commented in the first place, because this seems like the kind of person who doesn’t believe in the existence of any man that would want to dress feminine/crossdress and still identify as a man. The use of quotation marks over “GNC” made me feel worried that they don’t see it as a real label. I’m a GNC woman who aligns more with masculinity; but it still feels so invalidating. It feels like someone saying that only women can genuinely be feminine and men can genuinely be masculine. Or maybe I’m interpreting their comment wrong? I feel so confused and kind of down right now.
I feel like an idiot for inserting myself into a conversation when I most likely barely understood the issue they were intending to address.