Edit to clarify that I do not represent anyone in this matter. I am posting this because I am a concerned gamer.
I just wanted to send out a quick reminder that Hans im Gluck, the publishing company whose titles include “Carcassonne,” will be at GenCon in booth 1109. Feel free to drop by and RESPECTFULLY tell them what you think about their abuse of the legal system. (Recap, below, if you are not familiar with “Meeplegate.”)
I assume the people at their booth will not be owners, so I am emphasizing that your feedback should be RESPECTFUL. I plan on politely letting them know that I will not be buying any of their products due to their abusive behavior. If you agree that their behavior is sleazy and a threat to small publishes using common gaming terms, feel free to let them know, too!
Again…RESPECTFULLY. Their staff at the booth aren’t to blame.
MEEPLEGATE RECAP
Great deep dive, here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izDgyd2tDmY
Hans im Gluck (HIG) filed for a trademark for the word “meeple” as well as for a meeple image in both the EU. C-Mon noticed what was happening and filed an objection with 250 pages of evidence as to why trademark should not be granted. In short, C*Mon pointed out:
1) HUG did not invent the word, “Meeple.” It was invented by an enthusiast named Alison Hansel on Monday, November 27, 2000 (https://web.archive.org/web/20101130212607/http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/Unity_Games/message/2301 );
2) HIG’s game in question, Carcassonne, did not originally use the word “meeple” when it was first published. It used the word “followers.” HIG only changed their game AFTER the word “meeple” became popularized following Alison’s post.
3) It has become customary in the common language and practice of the trade to use the term “meeple” as well as the generic shape we all know as a “meeple.”
Because of C*Mon’s efforts, the EU only partially granted the mark. The EU protection does NOT cover toys and games. However, HIG then filed in German and was granted full trademark protection or the word “meeple.” (I have not found any records that discuss whether or not C*Mon filed an objection in the Germany case. If you have any, please DM me!)
HIG then wrote a scary cease-and-desist letter to a small two-person UK publisher team called “Cogito ergo Meeple.” HIG demanded that Cogito erg Meeple stop using the word “meeple” both in their company name as well as for their game which had just finished their crowdfunding stage called “Meeple, Inc.” The team changed not only the name of their game to “Tabletop Inc.” but also the name of their company from “Cogito ergo Meeple” to “Cotswold Games.”
In an effort to prevent HIG from gaining even more control over the term “meeple” in the U.S., a team has preemptively filed for copyright protection for “meeple” with the United States Patent and Trademark Office so that they can grant the world a free perpetual license to use the term. (See, https://boardgamewire.com/index.php/2024/06/14/the-word-meeple-is-being-trademarked-in-the-us-in-reaction-to-cease-and-desist-activity-from-carcassonne-publisher-hans-im-glueck/)
Hopefully, the USPTO will deny the mark which would be the best outcome. If they grant the mark, we must cross our fingers and hope the applicants live up to their stated purpose and grant the world a free perpetual license to use the mark in the U.S. I have no reason to doubt them.
Again, if you are worried about publishers abusing the system like this in order to stifle competition, especially for small shops that don’t have the resources to push back, drop by booth 1109 to tell them IN A RESPECTFUL MANNER, what you think of their practices.
BOYCOTT ISSUE
While I will not buy their games until they stop their abusive behavior, I completely understand that some people do not want to boycott because they are worried about how it will affect the designers who have hitched their wagons to HIG. I totally understand this concern. My observations are:
First, HIG has already attacked one small team of designers and will do it again if they want. Why should we prefer to protect designers affiliated with HIG over ones that are not? There may be a good number of HIG designers, but there are WAY more small teams around the would that have to live in fear of lawsuits from HIG and others like them if the market does not take a stand.
Second, arguing against a boycott is an argument for short term stability over long term change. In the long term, many more small publisher will benefit from a boycott.
Third, I would encourage all designers who have a contract with HIG to review their contracts for any “morality” clauses. If you have such a clause and it applies to HIG, I suggest you research the likely success you may have in activating the clause. The argument would be that what HIG has done violates the morality clause and, as such, means that they have breached the contract with you. While this will depend on the statutes and applicable case law in the jurisdiction that governs your contract (most likely Germany in the case of HIG), it's worth researching. Importantly, behavior can be legal yet still immoral. The typical remedy of such clauses is to allow the non-breaching side to get out of the contract. This is a long shot, but taking a few minutes to review your contract will get you a long way to see if you have a shot.
Fourth, if you are an HIG designer, do not renew your agreement with them if you can afford to find a different publisher when your current agreement expires.
Fifth, it would be a great idea for a large publisher to swoop in to help existing designers under HIG to do what I suggest above. Help review their contracts and see if they can leave HIG and join your team.