r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 25 '14

This comment about hotel staff comping drinks is useful insight.

46 Upvotes

I have a friend who is currently a server for the Ritz. The $2,000 is correct and he generally uses it to comp drinks and food for customers. (This is a daily limit) He's pretty picky on who he uses it for, and it seems he rarely has to do it to make up for a mistake on the hotel's part. A good example: Word got around that one of the two men he was waiting on is a big business man and was staying at a neighboring hotel and were talking business by the pool over drinks. My friend comped their $600 (or something along those lines) tab and gave them amazing service. A few minutes later and they had a manager out planning out his yearly business meeting / convention thing he does every year. He now brings his company to the Ritz every year spending hundreds of thousands on banquets and whatnot.

~ Deathwagon

Though the transaction, service for potential business paid off in this specific instance, this is exactly the mechanics that can be exploited. "word got around" but the person never overtly said he was such a person, Either by eves dropping, assumption or another informal way they reasoned that this man was important. As a result they comped him free drinks.

I first learned about this mechanic accidentally. I used to play eve-on-line, I was waiting for a date in a hotel lobby, and talking to my friend on my phone. I had discussed moving 200 Mil out of my personal account and to move it into the corporate account to be used as a slush fund by the directorate to buy some bits of equipment for a new expansion. basically a few mods for ships because we were doing something and I was footing the expense.

I was drinking at the bar for about 15mins, met my date and we dined in the hotel itself, I was entertaining so splashing out part of the date so to speak. Steak dinner, a nice wine, and desert. it was about 200$ for the two of us.

I asked for the bill and the waiter said the manager comped the bill and he thanked us for our custom. I asked why? he said I should talk to the manager. Apparently they were short staffed and the barman was the manager and he had over heard my phone call. He didn't explicitly state that, I think he said something along the lines of "he appreciated a nice class of client and wished to encourage repeat business"

What's important to note, though accidental, I was dressed well, cleaned up, well shaven and such as one would normally prepare for a date. I had fulfilled enough parameters for his assumption to be believable.

I never lied, and he never openly said anything that I could correct, it was all down to his interpretation of events, an interpretation that can be articulated intentionally.


r/gamesandtheory • • Sep 17 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 1.

46 Upvotes

The ambiguity effect is a cognitive bias where decision making is affected by a lack of information, or "ambiguity".The effect implies that people tend to select options for which the probability of a favourable outcome is known, over an option for which the probability of a favourable outcome is unknown. even if the probability of the unknown option is more preferable.

This can be used to exploit games of chance, where you offer a person a choice. You don't need to have a Msc in game theory or even know what Nash equilibrium is. You just need to know a game well enough to ensure a profitable deviation.

Paper rock scissors, coin flipping and so on. Imagine how casinos play blackjack, the house always sits when it hits 17 points or more. there is a reason for this. though there is an element of chance, there is a set number of cards with a set number of outcomes in a deck and casinos have done enough research to ensure a profitable deviation and profitability. People still choose to play, they choose more cards they make the choices and yet the house always wins.

Anchoring or focalism is a cognitive bias that describes the common human tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information offered (the "anchor") when making decisions. During decision making, anchoring occurs when individuals use an initial piece of information to make subsequent judgements.

no matter how logical or reasonable someone is, they can only base their opinion their reasoning around what they know, if the initial piece of information they receive is incorrect they will build a stricture of logic and reason on a foundation of disinformation.

Games like cluedo, garrys mod (trouble in terrorist town/murder) where you have to figure out the puzzle using logic and reasoning can be totally undone by one person not playing properly, lying or not understanding the rules.

This can be exploited be devaluing a product or over valuing it depending on what is profitable for you. Equally you can devalue or over value your self or others social standing depending on context. The initial piece of information is always used comparatively.

Sometimes this can have the opposite effect as intended and that needs to be fully understood. For instance when your friend talks about this new friend that "you would love he is really funny" and you meet him with a high expectation of him to be funny,only to be disappointed and you then hold negative social opinion of your new acquaintance due to no fault of his own.

anchoring is also why it can be hard to change how your close long time friends perceive you.

Attentional bias is the tendency of our perception to be affected by our recurring thoughts. For example, people who frequently think about the clothes they wear, pay more attention to the clothes of others.

Knowing someone's interests, what they pay attention to, which isn't hard today with social media. you can shape a persona that is favourable to them, overtly showing interest in things they show interest in will attract their attention and respect.

People are more inclined to agree with people whose opinions appear on the surface to be similar to theirs, this is a major structure of society. its why we agree with our politicians even though we may dislike them in regards to issues on an international level. for instance a lot of people think David Cameron is a tool, but those same people will agree with him when he makes anti-putin remarks. because he is from the UK and closer to their interests then someone from Russia.

Equally if 2 of your friends fight, on an issue you know nothing about and have no pre-established opinion of, you will likely side with the friend who shares closer opinions and interests to yours as you have established in your mind that you think similarly and thus their opinion on this issue would likely be similar.

Exploiting this is good for climbing social ladders, getting promoted at work, learn and show interest overtly in the hobbies and interest of your superiors.

The availability heuristic is a mental short cut that relies on immediate examples that come to mind. The availability heuristic operates on the notion that if something can be recalled, it must be important. Subsequently, people tend to heavily weigh their judgements toward more recent information, making new opinions biased toward that latest news.

The media preys on this one, and they make serious cash flow from it. equally companies can rise and fall on this issue. Malaysia airlines is a perfect example. Nuclear energy is another one that receives a negative wrap on this, Nuclear energy works fine every day no issues but no one cares when things work as intended, but less than a handful of issues and the world never forgets. because the only notable thing anyone can think about nuclear energy is when it goes wrong.

This one can be exploited both negativity and positively, just like the media likes to remind us of the bad, reminding someone of the bad aspects of a 3rd party consistently will skew their perspective of that 3rd party. It will be unproductive to use words to perpetuate a favourable opinion of ones self, but if you can articulate a situation where others perpetuate it. it will increase your social capital, just don't be unrealistic as it can be self defeating if you don't live up to the persona you have designed. If you perpetuate the idea that you are awesome and never make mistakes yet are an incompetent shit, people will see through it fast and your time will be heavily wasted.

Recently over the last year I had fun perpetuating the idea that I was a horrible person, the bonus of this is once your persona graduates into a cult of personality in regards to negative public opinion, everything bad that occurs gets blamed on you, chaotic bad luck type events and peoples mistakes, not unlike hackers in the media or terrorists on the political table you become a scape goat and the blame perpetuates your persona. It can how ever snowball beyond your control. Kevin Mitnik ended up in prison because the idea of him as a bad guy was larger then who he really was, and it made people afraid. if you have 2hrs this goes into it

I'll hopefully have time to make more of these posts,I have a lot on my plate right now so I don't know how regular they will be.

As usual, questions and discussion encouraged.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 02 '16

Index of Cognitive biases poster.

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/gamesandtheory • • Jan 05 '15

Google Docs Compilation of Games and Theory Posts

27 Upvotes

I compiled a google docs of all the info ridik has posted. I did this so I could print it out and have a easy all in one place to store it instead of going to the specific thread every time I needed some refresher information.

GOOGLE DRIVE WITH THREE DOCUMENTS: https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0ByPZpf2huz7QVWJWTkpWTVNtVGM&usp=sharing

I figured I could post it here if anyone wants to look at it also.

In the folder contains three documents:

Cognitive Biases Document contains the compiled info from: All the cognitive bias posts 1-12 along with the info from the comments section posted.

Gambits Document Contains: http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2r76v5/games_and_theory_gambits_part_7_the_thirtysix/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2r71yt/games_and_theory_gambits_part_6_the_thirtysix/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2qb10b/games_and_theory_gambits_part_5_the_thirtysix/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2qacex/games_and_theory_gambits_part_4_the_thirtysix/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2q117s/games_and_theory_gambits_part_3_the_oldest_tricks/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2p8us4/games_and_theory_levels_tiers_and_gambits_an/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2opote/games_and_theory_levels_of_social_engineering/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2qrgd9/games_and_theory_gambits_a_recap/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2gu4t0/games_and_theory_high_concept_gambits_part_1/ http://www.reddit.com/r/SocialEngineering/comments/2qohhp/warning_seriously_long_post_gambits_what_are_they/

The Misc one has: http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2jv2z7/games_and_theory_gambling_statistics_and_hedging/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2kli2b/games_and_theory_social_psychology_1_special/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2l3me9/games_and_theory_social_psychology_2_propaganda/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2n4q1a/games_and_theory_the_pertinent_question_and_the/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gamesandtheory/comments/2nz5o2/comment_reply_to_uclasserrr_in_gt_pt_7_too_long/

There were a few posts that had the same info but also different info so I deleted anything that was similar but added the new stuff together. And some stuff is only found in comments and not in the actual opening. So I figured it would be easier for me to study if I had it all in one place so I wouldn't forget which comment of whichever thread I saw that particular info in.

Anyway, hope you guys find it useful and I will obviously be adding to it whenever new stuff comes out so I can keep studying. It's a very dense topic so I figure it is going to take a while to internalize and be able to practice everything I am learning so best of luck to all of us learning ya~!!

Comment if it does not work because this is my first time using Google drive in like 5-6 years so I forgot how to use some of the features correctly. And the UI is different from what I remember.


r/gamesandtheory • • Sep 19 '14

Games and Theory: High Concept Gambits Part 1.

24 Upvotes

I was going to do a new Games and Theory on cognitive biases tonight, But I just squared away a lot of IRL work so I wanted to treat myself to something a little more fun to discuss. I thought it would also be fitting as to highlight the direction in which the foundational material can be applicable, so people have an idea what some end game material might look like, and allude to the direction this sub could take.

A gambit is similar to a method/script (which we frown on here) but instead of a ridged scripted series of events it more resembles an over arching strategy. Initially a gambit referred to a chess opening in which a player, more often White, sacrifices material, usually a pawn, with the hope of achieving a resulting advantageous position.

In social engineering a Gambit is is the articulation of a series of events which by design leave the social engineer in a similarly advantageous position. Gold digging, as in an attractive male/female manipulating the affections of an affluent person with the explicit goal of financial gains could be considered a Gambit, as the details are left to the "aggressor" but the over arching goal remains the same. Thus allowing it to be adapted to a variety of situations. The name of the gambit can sometimes be rather abstract of vaguely referential, it isn't always the case that the goals or engineering behind the gambit can be surmised by its name.

The First Gambit, is something I adapted from a TV trope, I felt leaving the name to reference that would be fitting.

"The key to strategy... Is not to choose a path to victory, but to choose so that all paths lead to a victory." ~ Cavilo, The Vor Game

A Xanatos Gambit is a plan whose multiple foreseen outcomes all benefit its creator. It's a win-win situation for whoever plots it. At its most basic, the Xanatos Gambit assumes two possible outcomes for the one manipulated, success or failure. The plan is designed in such a way that either outcome will ultimately further the plotter's goals.

In the simplest form, imagine you are challenged to a task, for which the success of which benefits you in some way, to ensure a favourable outcome in either a win/lose scenario you place a bet against yourself. You will either win the bet or the challenge either of which is now a favourable outcome for you.

Another scenario would be to articulate a confrontation between 2 rivals or adversaries, no matter who wins or loses, you benefit. Again though these are very simple win lose scenarios in which the lose possibility is augmented.

To truly benefit from a Xanatos gambit we must become adept at understanding and visualizing both "Game Tree" and "Extensive-form game"

I believe I have already touched on game theory, where as Game Tree is an extension of that. A game tree is a directed graph whose nodes are positions in a game and whose edges are moves. The complete game tree for a game is the game tree starting at the initial position and containing all possible moves from each position. As I referenced tic tac toe in my initial Games and Theory post, its simplicity is always a great example of the thought processes involved with out an overly distracting game, I find it fitting that it is used to explain game tree in this image sourced from the wiki

If we imagine in a social context, not all probable choices a person might make, but all possible ones, then exclude ones beyond their means, beyond their ability, ones that won't effect the out come of the gambit in play and so on, refining along the way, making sure to ignore our own emotional biases. We can accurately define the Potential actions of a target involved in our gambit. An important part is we do not need to follow the flow chart or tree past unfavourable decision points as the depth of which is often unnecessary complex to our goals or reasoning, we just need to account that it is unfavourable, then amend the potential to favourable. When we have done that we should have something called a...

An extensive-form game is a specification of a game in game theory, allowing (as the name suggests) explicit representation of a number of important aspects, like the sequencing of players' possible moves, their choices at every decision point, the (possibly imperfect) information each player has about the other player's moves when he makes a decision, and his payoffs for all possible game outcomes. Extensive-form games also allow representation of incomplete information in the form of chance events encoded as "moves by nature".

When we fully grasp cognitive biases, logical fallacies, Have full in depth information on a target (thanks social media), Learn their motivations and so on, it can be quite simple to plot out decision points and create a Game Tree for them. However that can be unnecessarily complex, adjusting your gambit for individual cases and working on one person at a time is also a slow task. The effort for pay off can be exponentially unrewarding, though for learning's sake its best to start small. If we incorporate exit gates as detailed in this post...

An Exit gate is an intentional phrase, instance, action or environment that removes undesirables. These are commonly used by 419ers, those Nigerian e-mail scammers. They deliberately make e-mails sound very unrealistic thus excluding the chance of someone who is intelligent, aware or sensible would reply, people the scam would be unlikely to work on. By doing this they ensure a specific target demographic, people more likely to fall for a scam.

...we Can articulate a standing passive situation, where by unfitting people are filtered out of the gambit by exit gates, and people who fit-in are separated from them for what ever beneficial reasons. The series of events can run passively with out much work almost being self regulatory.

"While the individual man is an insoluble puzzle, in the aggregate he becomes a mathematical certainty. You can, for example, never foretell what any one man will do, but you can say with precision what an average number will be up to. Individuals vary, but percentages remain constant." ~William Winwood Reade

  • The Ridik Ulass Gambit [no wiki for this one {shut your face its not conceited I can name it what ever I like I came up with it}]

Similar to the Xanatos gambit where by all possible potential out comes are accounted for and expected. However rather than playing to win, This gambit employs the idea that its better to play to not lose and we concede a draw as a favourable probability. This is best utilized when you already hold favourable ground or a position.

Playing to draw rather than win, not only ensures a draw, It also makes your actions unpredictable and your motives uncertain. The goals and desires of someone aiming to win as they will likely pursue the goal to win to the limit of their resolve can be clear and apparent, even exploitable after all it is our desires and emotions that so often betray us. Not unlike a rat in a maze pursuing a piece of cheese, taking an elaborate engineered path in pursuit of their goals, the physical maze being a metaphor for a branch in the game tree of the series of events you have designed.

"A strange game. The only winning move is not to play. How about a nice game of chess?" ~Joshua, wargames, 1983

In the end the Ridik Ulass Gambit is not unlike political filibustering, best used as a stall for time to either test your opponents resolve and commitment, or search for leverage or an opening to gain more favourable ground, it in itself can even be used as a meta-exit gate in testing the resolve for potential allies or associates.

As always discussion encouraged and opinions wanted, its very late here and writing this much on reddit is hard to stay on topic so I may have to update this or fix structure


r/gamesandtheory • • Dec 02 '14

Q&A : "Using social engineering when applying to college?"

23 Upvotes

There was a post in /r/socialengineering here asking how to use social engineering productively when applying to college. I stated here that I social engineered a scholarship for a 1 year masters, didn't even need an undergraduate qualification. So here is the post.

I debated for about 3 hours how to write and do this, as I didn't commit any fraud my real identity is all over this. I also have all the resources and information I used. the e-mails and everything. The issue is even if I blacked out names and e-mails, the grammar, phrasing and syntax would be very telling. So having everything, is not the ability to reveal everything. I really want to, but if this came back on me It could cause drama. This is also the reason I am posting this to this smaller sub, rather than /r/socialengineering. The details, and time's are going to be obfuscated in this telling, in the end the details don't matter. The hows and whys are more important than the whats.

So, here we go.


  • The prologue

OK Firstly to begin, I have to make the case that though I acquired the course entirely due to social engineering. I have the ability to consume and internalize vast amounts of knowledge very very quickly, Its related to my field of work, where I will be contracted to work in an area in which I have zero previous experience, It isn't quick, I may spend upto 6 months learning enough information to be equatable to a MSc in information.

One thing that is notable to know is.

  1. In school we learn from teachers

  2. In college we learn from professors, to become a teacher you go through this processes.

  3. Professors, Learn from research and development

In school and even college we can learn a lot of information we don't need, it is possible to straight bunny hop and go straight to research and development. Most of what you may be doing in social engineering would be equatable to this. Professors often go to conferences and talk with other professors, specialists and notable professionals. There is often talks and speeches at these conferences, published papers and so on. Everything is available online.

Find topic, find convention, raid resources well done you are now able to hold conversation with people who are the top of their field.

For Instance who wants to know about cybernetics, cool right? Though I didn't look at that site to hard, it may be better to look up the 2013 site, as I believe they are still receiving papers. look for 2013 award winners if you want to be lazy. Congratulations you are now an expert in a cutting edge field. even if you don't internalize or retain the info you can still use it to hold an interesting conversation, so the social engineering applications are endless.

  • The Beginning.

I good few years ago, my hat was a few shades darker than it is now, I learned a few tricks along the way. Most notable I learned a Zero Day. A zero-day is an attack that exploits a previously unknown vulnerability in a computer application or operating system, one that developers have not had time to address and patch. It is called a "zero-day" because the programmer has had zero days to fix the flaw. They are generally unknown to the developers and can't be patched or addressed until its use becomes apparent and its workings understood. I could avoid this by not talking about it.

Zero days are worth a bit of money, to the developer, to the government, to nefarious types.I made a post explaining zero-days here a while back...

I work in the field so let me explain, it is common practice to make exploits and vulnerabilities common and public knowledge, because when they are not people don't know about them and can't fix or defend against them.

An unknown exploit or vulnerability is called a zeroday, as in there is no defense against it because it is entirely unknown. Imagine this issue is only with one brand of pacemakers, people would make sure as hell if they needed a pace maker it wouldn't be that brand, and thus that brand would fix the now known issue, which previously even they didn't know existed.

An unknown bug/exploit or issue, a zero day for a large company like Microsoft or Google or what have you, is worth good money, they often pay hackers and cyber computer experts alike to divulge the zero day, because once these companies know about it they can fix it. equally governments and criminal organizations alike Love zero days. stuxnet which has been confirmed to be an NSA designed virus, had 20 zerodays, and the Russian mafia which loves its cyber crime has been known to pay upto 100,000$ for zeroday exploits.

Imagine you knew a way to break into cars, a way that no one else knew, and though it may only work with some cars a specific brand or a specific model or even cars made between a certain year bracket, those cars are 100% guaranteed to open up and give you everything you want.

what do you do?

  1. use it yourself lord it up and have all these cars you want, however illegal

  2. sell it to a criminal organization, they will steal many cars but you won't commit the crime yourself and you will make some cash.

  3. sell it to the government, they have unknown uses for it, but productive and positive ones are probably non existent.

  4. sell it to the relevant company and inform them. Though some companies have refused to pay people after the fact, and even though they say they pay they have claimed it to be black mail. also while were talking about cars, what if the cost to fix the issue is too expensive and they try to bury the issue? Sony didn't admit getting hacked until many weeks after the fact back in 2011, keeping hush is a profitable business.

  5. make it public, everyone now knows and individuals can have their cars fixed on an individual basis, the manufactures hand is now forced and they will be obliged to do something about the issue, and though the criminals now know about the issue there is no longer a 100% guarantee it will work where ever they try, and trying it everywhere is too costly and inefficient to put into practice. you don't make any money but gain reputation which will help you get a job.

So here I am with this knowledge, and I'm thinking Option 4 (yeah I know kind of boring but I want to be paid and that seems most legit) but I don't even have an under grad in computer science.

some randomer rings up a company or makes an e-mail saying they know a zero-day and they want to be paid for what they know. I can't tell them anything encase they figure it out themselves, so I sound like or am basically black mailing them. I need some credibility, I need a bit of paper that says I know a thing.

But its the middle of January, and college and shit doesn't start until September. do I weight 8 months and do nothing, meanwhile they might figure it out and I end up with nothing? fuck that jazz I'm a master of my own destiny. So I dig around and see what I find.

A post grad cert, diploma, Msc and PhD in the area, they start soon, and instead of being over 1,2,3,4 years progressively they are over 1 year apart from the PhD which is 2 years, they are compressed, no summer break, or spring break...sounds good, time not progressing is time standing still, time lost. Only one issue, they are all scholarships only, my assumption was they would be doused in nepotism, provably professors choice candidates. I only need a piece of paper so fuck 2 years on the PhD I got better things to do, may as well go for that MSc a year is a year right? may as well get the best damn bit of paper I can.

  • Game time.

I have work to do, this course starts soon, and though I am pre-prepped for the content, I don't know anyone, I don't have a single "In" I need some perspective. Let the doxxing begin.

I dox everyone and everything, professors, students, staff, security, looking for anything or anyone I know. Nothing turns up, Everything I gather is public information, publicly available just FYI. , I go so far as everyone within 1 degree of separation of anyone of interest. still nothing, but its information, and information is never really nothing.

I get names and faces from the staff page of the university, I am now familiar with the leadership structure. I focus on them.

I'm there reading the thesis and every published bit of information by people in charge of the course. Getting to know and understand them, their perspectives and fields of knowledge.

There are 2 notable people "Belmont" in charge of the course, and who joins it as well as teaching it and his boss "Karl" the department head. Though Karl isn't involved in the bits and pieces of the course, he is "Belmont" boss, and association with "Karl" will give be a perceived bonus to social status with "Belmont".

I go over "Karl" thesis, I read it, I don't lie, I make sure when I address Karl I bring up genuine points I liked and appreciated from it, making sure to throw in a conflict or 2 that I can disagree with and show I actually read it, but also I can back down from his response and show some humility, it will feed his ego and he will associate me with positive feeling.

I e-mail "Karl" I discuss his thesis and some of his work history and express how I am excited he is teaching this course. I also know he worked in a company in which my exploit pertains, so we shoot the shit back and forth for a bit. He tells me he isn't teaching the course, I express my disappointment and he forwards my initial e-mail onto "Belmont" so now instead of me chucking my lot in with the randoms, its coming, approved from a socially superior source, someone respectable and notable. If it was a temp thing, faking the header on the e-mail would suffice but I needed the real deal here.

"Belmont" gets back to me saying he got the e-mail saying that I was greenlit and I just needed an interview because of the lack of formal education on the matter, basically to see if I knew what I said I knew.

The conversation was pretty easy, because I was discussing a zero-day that I have a legit reason not to talk about in detail, I could side step any question if I had to, and just infer that speaking about it too much might incriminate me in some way. I didn't have to and by the time the conversation was over I was in.

A year later I was done, did the min amount of work to get by and turned up every other day. got paid to take the course and got my piece of paper at the end. I only turned up as much as I did because of the awesome ethnic food place across the street.


r/gamesandtheory • • Sep 21 '14

Fake Persona Generator; Generate fake names, DOB, ADDRESS, User name, PW, Phone number and usable E-mail.

22 Upvotes

This stuff is useful for filling out websites and creating alt accounts when you need random and chaotic information that is less connected to who you actually are. Or information in quantity for numerous said alt accounts.

I would use this sort of information in superficial areas where meta data has little relevance to what you are doing. when You need more detailed data, usurping an established (real) identity can help with photographic and more detailed information. Also as real people generate new information all the time it helps if your persona gets Doxxed or you need to simulate real life activity.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 19 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 9

21 Upvotes

OK Hopefully I can knock out a few of these today and tomorrow, need to make up for a lack of posting over the last week and a bit. I'm free tonight and should be on IRC while writing these, and my plans for tomorrow evening have been cancelled, so I'll try knock out a few cognitive biases posts and maybe some propaganda posts as well. There is an area in propaganda I am really trying to push towards called "thought terminating Clichés" but I need to lay foundation first.


The hostile media effect, originally deemed the hostile media phenomenon and sometimes called hostile media perception, is a perceptual theory of mass communication that refers to the finding that people with strong biases toward an issue (partisans) perceive media coverage as biased against their opinions, regardless of the reality. Proponents of the hostile media effect argue that this finding cannot be attributed to the presence of bias in the news reports, since partisans from opposing sides of an issue perceive the same coverage differently.

This is connected to the Argument from fallacy which states that analysing an argument and inferring that, since it contains a fallacy, its conclusion must be false. It is also connected to the Framing effect, Focusing effect, belief revision, Backfire effect, Choice-supportive bias and Confirmation bias and also some related to Ad hominem logical fallacy. It's cause is closely related to cognitive dissonance where by if someone finds something that contradicts something they they know they find trouble accepting the new information. Thus they have to either create a reason to refuse the new knowledge or change their beliefs. This can make people very uncomfortable and they would rather discredit the source of information and ignore it then accept it.

This can be used either aggressively or defensively, you can point out its going on with someone if you want them to accept the new information presented, even fallacious information. Undermine some ones argument intentionally this itself would be ad hominem and an argument from fallacy as you would state that their point of view is only existing because of the initial hostile media effect, and by proxy they are being bias and unreasonable and if they are wrong that the other view point must be correct.

Conversely you could place an ad hominem attack on the source of information,to discredit it and refuse to accept the points conveyed and suggest that anyone who does is ill informed. "fox news is right wing, if you agree with them you must be right wing" , "The daily mail is a shitty newspaper that never cites its sources don't believe everything they say, unless you are a fool"

For instance, 2 friends of equal social standing, you know them equally as long. one male and one female. The female informs you the male has raped her, you not knowing if this is true or not, only having 1 persons word to go on, may not believe her. However when the male denies it, you are now incapable of separating your new knowledge from your perception of him thus lowering his his social standing, and lowering the weight of his words. Despite his lack of apparent guilt in a situation of one persons word against another, if they were originally on equal footing, the person who speaks first will have the upper hand. If however he pre-emptied the situation either honestly or disingenuously and told you first she had stolen from him, or something else that may damage her character and social standing as per your perception. Her rape claim and his subsequent denial might be perceived differently, it could be rationalized in your head as her trying to retaliate and escape responsibility. Yet over the course of these events no evidence has been presented from either party it has remained one persons word against another.

We can see this often In say a high profile court case, where the public has decided that someone is guilty with out knowing the evidence of the case, and often being observably upset when they out come they have decided, based on no information or incorrect information doesn't come. OJ simpson is still today seen by many as a murderer who escaped justice, He was a prominent actor before his case in 1994 but hasn't exactly been back into the public eye for anything positive in nearly 20 years. People thought he was guilty, he was found innocent, thus the source of the information must be wrong.. the court itself. "If the result contradicts what I think I know, then the source itself must be wrong". I use OJ simpson as there is many similar more topical and politically weighted instances, but the nature of those instances themselves hold an in escapable bias. I feel the objective nature of the point I am trying to make Might be lost if I made such a reference.

The "hot-hand fallacy" is the fallacious belief that a person who has experienced success with a random event has a greater chance of further success in additional attempts. The concept has been applied to gambling and sports, such as basketball. While a previous success at a skill-based athletic task, such as making a shot in basketball, can change the psychological behaviour and subsequent success rate of a player,

This is related to the Clustering illusion and I have covered the psychology behind it more than a few times. The gamblers fallacy and discussions about it in gambling and statistics.

This can be abused by either encouraging someone to continue their streak much to their folly, or building a false streak to begin with. Coin flips, dice rolls, poker and so on, letting someone win and convince them they are on a streak before proposing a deal or an agreement and they will convince themselves that this is part of their streak and that it is continuing and will be associated with something beneficial.

Discounting is the tendency for people to have a stronger preference for more immediate payoffs relative to later payoffs. Hyperbolic discounting leads to choices that are inconsistent over time – people make choices today that their future selves would prefer not to have made, despite using the same reasoning. Also known as current moment bias, present-bias, and related to Dynamic inconsistency

Want to change your life ...tomorrow and then tomorrow comes and you change your mind? want to lose weight but you can start after new years? staying up till 4am playing games or binging on Netflix but you have to get up early tomorrow? Now you know why...that's right its a cognitive bias.

Its easy enough to convince someone to give up something that has a long term benefit, for something that is a short term gain. Shit there is a thought terminating Cliché for it "a bird in the hand is worth 2 in the bush" as I said Thought terminating Clichés are something I'll likely cover in the propaganda/social psychology series. They are generic Clichéd phrases that everyone accepts to be true and generally are so platonic they don't offer enough substance to even be contradicted so they are hard to argue with. In short they prevent discussion and terminate thought.

"Identifiable victim effect" refers to the tendency of individuals to offer greater aid when a specific, identifiable person ("victim") is observed under hardship, as compared to a large, vaguely defined group with the same need. The effect is also observed when subjects administer punishment rather than reward. Participants in a study were more likely to mete out punishment, even at their own expense, when they were punishing specific, identifiable individuals ("perpetrators").

This has been also covered extensively and is associated with Attentional bias, Availability heuristic, Availability cascade and very specifically related to the Base rate fallacy.

This is often used by politics to push self defeating laws on the population as people are often very willing to incur an expense in defense of the victims. Overly zealous internet restrictions in pursuit of the perpetrators of child pornography is a perfect for instance.

The tendency for people to place a disproportionately high value on objects that they partially assembled themselves, such as furniture from IKEA, regardless of the quality of the end result.

The Truth is that this bias extends beyond objects, projects, ideas, companies or even structures. Ribbon cutting ceremonies even, can give someone enough of a sense of involvement or give them pride and stake in the success of what ever something may be.

If you were ever asked to help someone fix their computer only to be turned around to later in time to be blamed for its faults. you can resolve an incident like that by having someone solve the issue themselves and showing them how. same with fixing cars or any such tasks, having some ones pride invested in the work can elevate the perception of the quality of the work.

This can be highly beneficial at work, even if you are a an independent consultant asking someone of authority their opinion, offering them 2 options even if one option is total shit so they will chose what you are going to or already have done, can invest their pride in your success and create a small among of cognitive dissonance if you were to fail.

Vector marketing, pyramid schemes and such exploit this effect as people take pride in the organizations success because they are involved directly in it, in its recruiting, building and expansions. I would also say kick starter projects and early level games where people are alpha and beta testing would also be susceptible.

As per usual, comments and discussion encouraged.


Pending editing and layout changes.


r/gamesandtheory • • Sep 17 '14

Welcome new users and introductions.

21 Upvotes

Hey everyone I'm ridik_ulass founder of this sub, I recently stepped down as moderator of /r/realsocialengineering due to mod abuse as you can read...

This sub has custom css, if there is any issues or complaints Please inform me. we also have a custom snoo(reddit alien) up the top left thanks to /u/Fingebimus. There are some clear outlined rules in the sidebar but all content including memes are welcome.

I'm not sure how fast the sub will grow but some of the early users may as well get to know each other, so drop by and introduce yourself.

We have user flairs to define your skill/knowledge level as well to make use of. If people post exceptional OC they will get custom flairs.

A subreddit is only as good as its content and its users, and the users provide the content so tell your friends and spread the good word x-posts to and from other subs are welcome just make sure to reference where you got them.

I have no issues linking other subs in the sidebar but only if the linking is mutual. If you run a sub and want us to link you in the side bar just PM me.

Any other questions or ideas about the sub are not only welcomed but encouraged so please express yourself.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 02 '14

Games and Theory: Social psychology 2. Propaganda.

20 Upvotes

Games and Theory: Social psychology 2. Propaganda.

This is a continuation of the content and theme in the previous Social Psychology post. In said post, I mentioned such logical fallacies as "Ad hominem" and "straw man", I mentioned how it was possible even with the best of intentions to get caught up in the politics of the discussion rather then the content of it. Due to the insipid and potentially accidental nature of some of the fallacies I felt them best discussed seperately.This post will detail Intentional Propaganda, actions which by design can manipulate and control public opinion.

A number of techniques based in social psychological research are used to generate propaganda. Many of these same techniques can be found under logical fallacies, since propagandists use arguments that, while sometimes convincing, are not necessarily valid. Information dissemination strategies only become propaganda strategies when coupled with propagandistic messages. Identifying these messages is a necessary prerequisite to study the methods by which those messages are spread.

I will highlight, but quickly skip over points covered in other posts.


A phrase that has come to mean attacking one's opponent, as opposed to attacking their arguments. This was covered in Social Psychology part 1.

This argument approach uses tireless repetition of an idea. An idea, especially a simple slogan, that is repeated enough times, may begin to be taken as the truth. This approach works best when media sources are limited or controlled by the propagator.

This benefits from Attentional bias as well as the Availability heuristic and the Availability cascade covered in the first and second games and theory posts among many other cognitive biases.

Appeals to authority cite prominent figures to support a position, idea, argument, or course of action. I touched on this in the 4th games and theory post when I quoted "Sun Tzu from The Art of War" I made the point that it can be easy to not only quote someone of note out of context and phrase it that they support their argument, but you could even make things up as it would be unlikely that any one person is fully familiar with every thing stated by any person living or dead. The common meme "Don't believe everything you read on the internet" ~Abraham Lincoln holds true.

Fallacious examples of using the appeal include any appeal to authority used in the context of logical reasoning, and appealing to the position of an authority or authorities to dismiss evidence, as, while authorities can be correct in judgments related to their area of expertise more often than lay persons, they can still come to the wrong judgments through error, bias, dishonesty, or falling prey to group think. Thus, the appeal to authority is not a generally reliable argument for establishing facts.

So even if the Quote is real, the context is accurate and the author is an authority on the topic concerned, it still does not mean the quote should hold weight in the context of discussion.

An appeal to fear (also called argumentum ad metum or argumentum in terrorem) is a fallacy in which a person attempts to create support for an idea by using deception and propaganda in attempts to increase fear and prejudice toward a competitor.

This benefits from the appeal to emotion, the conjunction fallacy and in the case of people who are already afraid or have plausible how ever improbable sense of fear the Confirmation bias as the fear mongering appeals to their beliefs. In the case of a previously standing fear, how ever improbable or irrational, like I stated in the 2nd games and theory post this will also benefit from the Availability Cascade, the Availability Heuristic and the Attentional Bias

  • Appeal to prejudice

Using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition. This is very much like the Appeal to fear, but benefits from knowing your audience. it works in many the same ways

Bandwagon and "inevitable-victory" appeals attempt to persuade the target audience to join in and take the course of action that "everyone else is taking." I already discussed this in the 2nd games and theory post. As the Bandwagon Effect and benefits from the Availability Cascade, and the Availability Heuristic

The repeated articulation of a complex of events that justify subsequent action. The descriptions of these events have elements of truth, and the "big lie" generalizations merge and eventually supplant the public's accurate perception of the underlying events. After World War I the German Stab in the back explanation of the cause of their defeat became a justification for Nazi re-militarization and revanchist aggression.

The expression was coined by Adolf Hitler, when he dictated his 1925 book Mein Kampf,about the use of a lie so "colossal" that no one would believe that someone "could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously." Hitler asserted the technique was used by Jews to unfairly blame Germany's loss in World War I on German Army officer Erich Ludendorff.

This benefits from the Belief bias and having pulled it off personally I can speak full well to its effect, not only does it enforce your agenda but it makes opponents look like lunatics and lose all social standing simply by opposing or questioning it. I would argue that the "big lie" insulated NSA spying before the snowden leaks, in that people who previously claimed government spying was going on were treated as crazy, and that the claims alone were enough for an individual to lose social standing.

Presenting only two choices, with the product or idea being propagated as the better choice. "You're either with us, or against us"

This was covered in games and theory part 4, under False dilemma

Richard Crossman, the British Deputy Director of Psychological Warfare Division for the Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force during the Second World War said "In propaganda truth pays... It is a complete delusion to think of the brilliant propagandist as being a professional liar. The brilliant propagandist is the man who tells the truth, or that selection of the truth which is requisite for his purpose, and tells it in such a way that the recipient does not think he is receiving any propaganda... [...] The art of propaganda is not telling lies, but rather selecting the truth you require and giving it mixed up with some truths the audience wants to hear."

This is nearly identical to the Texas sharp shooter fallacy I pointed out in the previous social psychology post. Though I feel the above paragraph sums up the continued sentiment I try to convey with social engineering, articulating a selective truth, can hold one less exposed to counter points and having to maintain a web of lies.

All vertebrates, including humans, respond to classical conditioning. That is, if object A is always present when object B is present and object B causes a physical reaction (e.g., disgust, pleasure) then we will when presented with object A when object B is not present, we will experience the same feelings.

I'll talk more about this in another thread, but I'm not sure it has the right context here, enough to say That while I don't social engineer people within my inner circle, and I do not advocate redpill philosophy. It is possible with a consenting partner to involve classical conditioning in your relationship, mentally associate feelings of pleasure with an appropriate action, phrase or command. It is even possible, and reasonable easy to have your partner cum or orgasm on command with out physical stimulation. Again, a conversation for another thread.

In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

People desire to be consistent. Suppose a pollster finds that a certain group of people hates his candidate for senator but loves actor A. They use actor A's endorsement of their candidate to change people's minds because people cannot tolerate inconsistency. They are forced to either to dislike the actor or like the candidate.

This was covered briefly under the Choice-supportive bias, in games and theory part 3.

The "'plain folks'" or "common man" approach attempts to convince the audience that the propagandist's positions reflect the common sense of the people. It is designed to win the confidence of the audience by communicating in the common manner and style of the target audience. Propagandists use ordinary language and mannerisms (and clothe their message in face-to-face and audiovisual communications) in attempting to identify their point of view with that of the average person. A common example of this type of propaganda is a political figure, usually running for a placement, in a backyard or shop doing daily routine things. This image appeals to the common person. With the plain folks device, the propagandist can win the confidence of persons who resent or distrust foreign sounding, intellectual speech, words, or mannerisms." For example, a politician speaking to a Southern United States crowd might incorporate words such as "Y'all" and other colloquialisms to create a perception of belonging.

Not really much about this one, its just another form of pandering to a specific demographic, in this case a rather large or "common" one.

A cult of personality arises when an individual uses mass media to create an idealized and heroic public image, often through unquestioning flattery and praise. The hero personality then advocates the positions that the propagandist desires to promote. For example, modern propagandists hire popular personalities to promote their ideas and/or products.

I really enjoy this one, and have discussed it in the past, if you can articulate one I'd recommend it, its just so much fun. Everything you do no matter what or how eccentric can and will be excused on your behalf because of the nature of the cult. This one can snowball if not managed properly as I discussed before I built a cult of being evil and a horrible person, I became a scape goat for every ones failings almost like the devil anything bad that happened in that community were blamed on me. The corresponding version would be Vladimir Putin, before his annexation of the Crimea and the new Russian anti-gay laws, he was loved by reddit with images like this, this and this floating around. As with most well constructed cults of personalities they almost become meme's in which people who are not in on the construct start contributing usually as a joke. The most interesting man in the world character from dos equis is a perfect example.

Making individuals from the opposing nation, from a different ethnic group, or those who support the opposing viewpoint appear to be subhuman (e.g., the Vietnam War-era term "gooks" for National Front for the Liberation of South Vietnam aka Vietcong, or “VC”, soldiers), worthless, or immoral, through suggestion or false accusations. Dehumanizing is also a termed used synonymously with demonizing, the latter usually serves as an aspect of the former.

The Demonizing the enemy, Demonization of the enemy or Dehumanization of the enemy is a state propaganda technique which promotes an idea about the enemy being threatening evil aggressor with only destructive objectives. Demonization is the oldest propaganda technique aimed to inspire hatred toward the enemy necessary to hurt them more easily, to preserve and mobilize allies and demoralize the enemy.

In my above discussed Cult of Personality, this demonizing by my enemies of, me, fed into my cult of personality because the brand image I was going for , was destructive, evil and aggressive Their attempts to demonize me were conducive to my own goals. Unlike reality where being generally evil is frowned upon, many people online like to be trolls, destructive, aggressive and generally unpleasant towards others. Being the bad guys isn't such an inherently bad faux pas. It also allowed me to exploit aspects of the glass castle gambit, where by being every ones enemy, in a "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" scenario I became the friend of anyone who felt slighted, crossed or wronged.

  • Dictat

This technique hopes to simplify the decision making process by using images and words to tell the audience exactly what actions to take, eliminating any other possible choices. Authority figures can be used to give the order, overlapping it with the Appeal to authority technique, but not necessarily. The Uncle Sam "I want you" image is an example of this technique.

There is not much to really say about this, it is just a case of telling people do to a thing. Obviously the amount of social and political capital that the person doing the telling has comes into play, but there isn't much depth to this at all.

The creation or deletion of information from public records, in the purpose of making a false record of an event or the actions of a person or organization, including outright forgery of photographs, motion pictures, broadcasts, and sound recordings as well as printed documents.

Disinformation is intentionally false or inaccurate information that is spread deliberately. It is an act of deception and false statements to convince someone of untruth. Disinformation should not be confused with misinformation, information that is unintentionally false.

Again in regards to my previously discussed Cult of Personality, Disinformation created on the behalf of my adversaries only served as propaganda for my own ends and goals. Information and disinformation if created or released should be fully thought out in a game tree as to its potential cause and effects.


As per usual editing and layout changes pending, questions and discussion encouraged.



r/gamesandtheory • • Oct 28 '14

Games and Theory: Social psychology 1. [Special Topical Post]

20 Upvotes

Hello everyone, Today I decided to do something different. I feel community observation in a neutral capacity will be educational in regards to the topic I wish to address. Considering the emotional nature of participants on both sides of the argument, as well as, intentional trolling, bare faced social engineering and the occasional zealot, I think much can be learned. so what might be this inflammatory topic be?

Well, recently it has come to my attention and likely yours too the whole "Gamer Gate" debacle. It is an emotionally charged subject to say the least, that has in my opinion developed into a fully fledged propaganda war on both sides. Each side trying to change public perception of both itself and the opposing side. Social engineering, whether intentionally or not, is being used aggressively as well as defensively by both sides in order to maintain ground in the hearts and minds of the public opinion.

Even now, as I write this, I re-type every sentence in an effort to remove my own personal bias and try to present an objective and neutral language. This I might say is tedious and exhausting, I honestly expect in my finished post that my personal bias be clearly observable and my efforts to be a exercise in futility. Considering my experience and knowledge of the factors in play, and the likely hood that I am better defended than most against such biases, I think this serves to highlight the gravity and weight of the conflict.

So with that out of the way lets get on with this...


Self-licensing is a term used in social psychology and marketing to describe the subconscious phenomenon whereby increased confidence and security in one’s self-image or self-concept tends to make that individual worry less about the consequences of subsequent immoral behaviour and, therefore, more likely to make immoral choices and act immorally.

This is best understood in the term's "The ends justify the means" or "The path to hell is paved with good intentions" where by, as long as you believe you are doing good, it is often common practice to in fact do bad and ignore any feelings of guilt. No army has ever marched to war with the intent to kill for the sake of fun, people always think their cause is more just and right than that of the cause of their enemy. As I stated with the Endowment effect in my last cognitive biases post, where people ascribe more value to things, simply because its their thing... this includes "Ideas" and as referenced in my first cognitive biases post, Anchoring is the common human tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information offered when making decisions. stacked with the previously referenced backfire effect, where people react to dis-confirming evidence by strengthening their beliefs. It becomes clear how easy it can be to get sucked into a mess like this.

Adding in the fact that internet arguments and discussions are hardly even moderated or organized and if you were to as a neutral party call one side a foul, you can easily be painted with the same brush as the opposition and disregarded on principal.

Without oversight logical fallacies founded in cognitive biases can seep into the collective thought structure unhindered, evening having supportive members ostracized for bringing attention to them as it can be seen as undermining the support of that specific side.

Notable Logical fallacies we are seeing are..

ad hominem, is a form of criticism directed at something about the person one is criticizing, rather than something independent of that person. When used inappropriately, it is a fallacy in which a claim or argument is dismissed on the basis of some irrelevant fact or supposition about the author or the person being criticized. Ad hominem reasoning is not always fallacious, for example, when it relates to the credibility of statements of fact or when used in certain kinds of moral and practical reasoning.

Ad hominem is the core of why we are seeing a lot of character attacks on both sides of the gamer gate fiasco, slander, people digging up dirt and so on. As stated it isn't always fallacious, specifically when the augment is based around a specific individuals character to begin with.

A straw man is a common type of argument and is an informal fallacy based on the misrepresentation of an opponent's argument. To be successful, a straw man argument requires that the audience be ignorant or uninformed of the original argument.

I expect many people to be familiar with this one, considering the unofficial borders between internet groups, Straw man argument's can be especially effective on the internet. Mainly due to the fact that misinformation can be easily spread. Which members are of which various groups is not information of record...essentially anyone can say anything about anything. One person does or says something inappropriate or stupid and it can be easier to argue and win against that one person, and declare victory over the group and argument entirely, rather then address the issue properly.

A false dilemma is a type of informal fallacy that involves a situation in which only limited alternatives are considered, when in fact there is at least one additional option. The opposite of this fallacy is argument to moderation.

The most notable use of the false dilemma is when an argument becomes emotional, and parties involved become competitive. It creates an "Us against Them" mentality where for one side to be right the other inevitability has to be wrong and vice versa. It lends to a style of arguing that rather than trying to prove ones self right, it becomes about proving the other wrong as the thought process becomes that if they are wrong and lose, I am by proxy right and victorious. This lends motivation to the ad hominem character attacks.

Appeal to emotion is a logical fallacy which uses the manipulation of the recipient's emotions, rather than valid logic, to win an argument. The appeal to emotion fallacy uses emotions as the basis of an argument's position without factual evidence that logically supports the major ideas endorsed by the elicitor of the argument. Also, this kind of thinking may be evident in one who lets emotions and/or other subjective considerations influence one's reasoning process.

I don't think that one needs further explaining.

Tu quoque, Latin for "you, too" or the appeal to hypocrisy is an informal logical fallacy that intends to discredit the opponent's position by asserting the opponent's failure to act consistently in accordance with that position. It attempts to show that a criticism or objection applies equally to the person making it. This attempts to dismiss opponent's position based on criticism of the opponent's inconsistency and not the position presented.

This is understood with the phrase "let he who is without sin cast the first stone", which posits that unless everyone is free from guilt that one should not be held accountable. This is often used by people in positions of authority or benefit when they might fail to remember that theres is a position of responsibility, I see it commonly in moderators or admin who forget that they are in an official position where by they are representing more than themselves, but in an effort to escape responsibility believe they should be held to the same standard as everyone else. when in fact they are the ones enforcing the rules and if they behaved as everyone did their position would be one of hypocrisy rather than responsibility.

The genetic fallacy, is a fallacy of irrelevance where a conclusion is suggested based solely on something or someone's origin rather than its current meaning or context. This overlooks any difference to be found in the present situation, typically transferring the positive or negative esteem from the earlier context.

This is often used in conjunction with ad hominem, where by the character of the opposition is attacked and discredited and then it is declared that because of the Characteristics highlighted that ones opinion and information is tainted and holds no value.

The people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country. ~ Hermann Göring, Nuremberg War Crimes Trials (18 April 1946)

This quote illustrates my point perfectly, not only is goring suggesting attacking some ones character to make his point irrelevant, but I have had that quote itself dismissed when I bring it up, simply because Göring was a nazi, as if that retracts from the weight of his words.

The Texas sharpshooter fallacy is an informal fallacy which is committed when differences in data are ignored, but similarities are stressed. From this reasoning a false conclusion is inferred. This fallacy is the philosophical/rhetorical application of the multiple comparisons problem and apophenia. It is related to the clustering illusion, which refers to the tendency in human cognition to interpret patterns where none actually exist.

This can be stretched to encompass people who, when addressing several counterpoints, made against them, they ignore the points that contradict their argument, ones that they can't respond to, while making a clear and concise attempt to deal with points they can address . Their retort seems legitimate and respectable as they have side stepped any points they were unable to deal with, cherry picking the best responses to seem like they have an answer for every question, but maybe not the time to deal with everything.

Pending Editing and layout.


r/gamesandtheory • • Oct 20 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 6.

20 Upvotes

Sorry I haven't contributed one of these in a while, I'm still here just been a bit too busy recently. Also the Games and Theory posts haven't been doing too well recently vote wise. The whole point of me writing them is for you the readers, so if you want to see different content or a change in direction let me know, with out input I can't do anything.

Now, on with this.


The denomination effect is a cognitive bias relating to currency, whereby people are less likely to spend larger bills than their equivalent value in smaller bills.

By itself it is unremarkable. However in conjunction with

Collectively they create what I have called the

As named after a folk story of the same name. This can be used to exploit further gains in either wealth, assets, time and commitment or even social capital. I have already explained the Ben Franklin effect as well as the gamblers fallacy but not the other two, I will explain them all before going on to explain how this gambit works.

The gamblers fallacy is the mistaken belief that if something happens more frequently than normal during some period, then it will happen less frequently in the future.

The Ben Franklin effect is when person who has done or completed a favour for someone is more likely to do another favour for that person than they would be if they had received a favour from that person.

Loss aversion and the sunk cost fallacy or Escalation of commitment, has been used to describe the phenomenon where people justify increased investment in a decision, based on the cumulative prior investment, despite new evidence suggesting that the cost of continuing the decision outweighs the expected benefit.

A quick explanation would be if someone buys a cheap car because they are on a budget, and ends up sinking more money into repairs than the cost of a decent car. However instead of getting a new car, they are convinced that after the initial repairs they won't have any future issues, and they reaffirm this state of mind after each repair processes often spending more then several cars worth of money on repairs of their shitty banger, and their car still remains in poor condition.

Using the domination effect, it is possible to drip feed money out of a source to the point of no return where they become very invested in an event or situation, specific to the denomination effect this can occur during social games involving gambling, if you are playing for small amounts breaking notes down into coins will make people more likely to part with them and make riskier bets.

But as I said this can be applied to many other situations, often more valuable than money, like time and energy in a company start-up getting people to work or invest in a lost cause because they have already invested time and energy, similar to pyramid schemes vector marketing work this way, but rather then people investing money they invest time and energy, something that is not illegal which still make the people at the top a lot of money. This is a point I am continually trying to make, there is ways to get what you want, directly or indirectly in social engineering, ways that are legal where as many laws deal specifically with money and wealth, social contacts, peoples time and energy and other resources can be much more valuable and regulated in no way at all, much of which can be translated into money if needs be, but money is a means to an ends and should never be an end goal, as it is a distraction.

Distinction bias, a concept of decision theory, is the tendency to view two options as more distinctive when evaluating them simultaneously than when evaluating them separately. This is very similar to The decoy effect which was the last point I covered in my previous post, between that and the wiki Link I don't think I need to explain this one.

A hot-cold empathy gap is a cognitive bias in which a person underestimates the influences of visceral drives, and instead attributes behaviour primarily to other, non-visceral factors. The crux of this idea is that human understanding is "state dependent". For example, when one is angry, it is difficult to understand what it is like for one to be happy, and vice versa

This is easily explained as "emotional people make emotional decisions" and it can be seen a lot in politics when politicians and the media try to play on our heart strings, fear, rage, anger to either distract or drive people. I mention negative emotions as they are much easier to cultivate and manipulate There is a benefit to this as an emotional person, to non emotional people will seem irrational and unreasonable because it can be hard to empathise with someone in an emotional state.

I experimented with this more than a few times, by being an unreasonable dick to someone in a group, but not others, instead being overly nice to the others in the group, the target began to associate with negative emotions and hated me, but in the eyes of the others in their group they seemed irrational and emotional as they were in a leadership position this in turn undermined their leadership and brought it under question, allowing me to defend the guy who was attacking me, appear reasonable and in contrast to the target, and separately in contrast to what has been said about me appear to be a humble and rational person suitable for the leadership role. Doing this in conjunction with gas-lighting this is a gambit called the innocent whistler

Gas-lighting or gas-lighting is a form of mental abuse in which false information is presented with the intent of making victims doubt their own memory, perception, and sanity. Instances may range simply from the denial by an abuser that previous abusive incidents ever occurred, up to the staging of bizarre events by the abuser with the intention of disorienting the victim.

In it's basic form this would be when someone tells you to calm down when you are calm, to the point of aggravation. sometimes used by shitty moderators who aggravate situation and then use the newly aggravated user as a reason to justify harsher action, like a ban even though it was their initial intent to actively encourage frustration and aggravation. Some times the unintentional side-effect of elaborate well constructed pranks, which cause a target to question their perception of reality and incorrectly address cognitive dissonance in their new perception.

  • The Innocent Whistler Gambit

The Innocent Whistler Gambit is when you use Gas-lighting in a public social context to undermine someone in a leadership position who has no authority over you. With the intention of making them appear irrational and weak in order to have him replaced by an inside man. While appearing publicly to support them and their organization using their apparent irrational hate of you to expedite the gas-lighting effect.

I once used the pretence of a prank, to include people in a gas lighting event, where like an "evil genius" in a clichéd manner I revealed my goals and intent to someone[the target], all my social engineering, various manipulations and machinations and my as yet un-accomplished end game goals.I referenced this when explaining the belief bias in my 3rd games and theory post.

What happened after the target went public with the information, he tried to appeal to people on a one on one level private messaging people, these people were in on the "prank" and responded with messages like "It's too late ridiks won" or "There is nothing you can do, just accept it" it must have been a surreal "invasion of the body snatchers" moment for him, when in fact everyone was just in on a prank.

This can be used to great effect with the "Glass Castle Gambit" as mentioned in the 4th games and theory post.

In behavioural economics, the endowment effect (also known as divestiture aversion) is the hypothesis that people ascribe more value to things merely because they own them. This is illustrated by the observation that people will tend to pay more to retain something they own than to obtain something owned by someone else—even when there is no cause for attachment, or even if the item was only obtained minutes ago.

Console gamers, Mac users, shit even nationalistic patriots I'm looking at you -.- just because you have it doesn't mean its better.

This can be used in the stone soup gambit in that you can actually give someone something related to the venture, before encouraging them to invest into the larger venture, and they will attribute value to the item and by association the venture itself.

You can also use it with the backfire effect, where you give someone something, and try ask for it back your desire giving it value and then you submitting to allowing the person to keep said item thus increasing its perceived value.

This is also effected by the Choice-supportive bias and later the Confirmation bias after people have decided they are committed. To this effect you can actually involve someone and get them to commit to an investment by giving them something rather than taking something from them initially, people being inherently less sceptical to receive free thing then they have to commit nothing in return. A perfect example is a gambling website or event that gives you an initial amount to spend or gamble.

The amount of cognitive biases exploited by on-line gambling especially in the situation where they give you money in advance to gamble will require its own post, which I might do next, as it will make referencing what I'm talking about easier.


As usual questions and Input welcome and encouraged, I'll also be tidying this up so if it looks like crap for a bit don't be afraid to say as I might have missed something.


r/gamesandtheory • • Feb 16 '15

I'm still around, Caught up heavily with IRL. heres something to check out in the mean time.

19 Upvotes

r/gamesandtheory • • Dec 22 '14

Games and Theory: Gambits Part 3. [The Oldest Tricks In The Book]

19 Upvotes

Games and Theory: Gambits Part 3. [The Oldest Tricks In The Book]

"The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting." ~ Sun Tzu

A lot of people nay say the UN/NATO when Russia started getting "rowdy" saying sanctions do nothing. As it is Russians economy is collapsing they may be forced into war in a reactionary measure, but that would give the sedate west the excuse to start a war, one they can afford. Currently Russia is bleeding wealth, they may not be even able to afford a war if this maintains.

This is the world in which we live, words are weapons, propaganda and espionage are the super weapons in this age of information. You can't go to war with out the support of your nations people. But that support can be coerced with information and propaganda, or even the right excuse/opportunity.

Where do we stand, we manipulators of information when words and ideas can destroy nations?

Many of you may have heard the expression "the oldest trick in the book" but most of you likely don't know that its an actual list, rather than a generic expression. Many of them are so simplistic they could hardly be called a gambit. However some of them definitely are. I hope to discuss all of them, regardless of relevance, simply to cover the content.

A lot of the oldest tricks in the book are used in terms of combat or war so I will explain them in that context when applicable then translate them into social engineering.


  • [Backup Bluff]

Frequently People find themselves going up against an opponent which outnumbers them or otherwise has a tactical advantage. When they know that in this instance, they don't have enough of a chance in a straight-up fight, so they try to gain an advantage by out-thinking their opponent.

One way of doing this try to make the enemy think that the enemy is outnumbered or surrounded, by pretending that there are people on your side which in fact do not exist. The most basic way to do this is to lie to the enemy. For example, the Social Engineer might say "I have agents in your organization" when they are in fact all alone.

I once used security exploits to find out privileged information that only organization members should have access to, I then eluded to an organizational member, that I had internal organizational support, citing the information as evidence. leveraging the bandwagon effect to garner support.

I could use the security exploits to verify the credibility of the new contact and use that contact to leverage others within the organization. Also leverage other contacts with the initially exploited information.

From a position of no information, to a position of some, to a position of a contact and then a tree of contacts, then separate trees of contacts, it is very possible to take over an organization, using their very cooperation with you as leverage for extortion and coercion. "do as I say or I'll have it known you worked with me, you may not want to lose your job, but if you don't do as I say you will....don't worry my reach is far, If you work for me I'll keep you safe"..."you know I have other contacts and agents and haven't lost anyone else yet?" this exploits the ambiguity effect, working with you becomes the known outcome, the sure thing, yet lack of cooperation becomes ambiguous. Using the backup bluff in conjunction with the Bandwagon Technique is called the bandwagon bluff gambit

  • [Bandwagon Technique] : Everybody is doing it. You should do it too.

In other words, everybody is buying our product, so you should buy it too. Sometimes uses statistics to back up the claim with numbers. A form of Appeal To Popularity. If a commercial tells you, "No wonder six million customers purchased our product last year," they're resorting to the Bandwagon Technique. Same for ads that boast of their product being "number 1"

"Eat shit, billions of flies cannot be wrong." ~ proverb

The bandwagon Technique is a simple action based gambit, exploiting the bandwagon effect cognitive bias and the "Appeal To Popularity" logical fallacy.

  • [Briar Patching]

A deliberate use of Reverse Psychology in order to get a desired result. A Social Engineer begs and pleads someone not to take a certain course of action — do anything, anything at all, but that! Terror, fear, hysterics, every scenery-chomping trick is pulled out to make that person think that this is the worst possible thing he could do to the Social Engineer. And thinking that, he does it.

  • The reverse of this is the [False mentor]

When in a position of authority, but not absolute authority over someone, you infer concern for their position, "I like you, trying to look out for you, but when the bosses find out they are gonna fuck you, so what don't you want to happen" with this gambit you can find out someone's least favorable outcome in a situation, and stick them with it. Not much is gained by the Social Engineer other than spiteful retaliation possibly for some previous slight or indifference. This is done by major Rawls to detective mcnulty in the TV show "the wire", mc nulty spends a season riding a boat policing a river.

  • Crying Wolf

You know the story. A little shepherd boy cries wolf to get people to come running, because he's bored. They fall for it. He does it again. They fall for it again. Then, an actual wolf comes along, and the little boy screams his little lungs out but this time nobody comes, since they think he's just playing that stupid prank again. Moral of the story: nobody believes a liar, even when he's telling the truth. This can be taken two ways: "Don't be a liar" or "Don't assume liars are always lying."

Russ borough House, a private art gallery among other things, was robbed in 1986 by Martin Cahill (nicknamed "The General") He went up by the place the same time every night, and set off the alarms in advance for a prolonged period, until the Security Staff got tired of checking the place each time and finding nothing, gave up and turned the system off. once they did this he then robbed the place proper, with out issue.

  • Defensive Feint Trap

An opponent lures their enemy into a trap by either feigning retreat or weakness. Once the attacker has moved into position, or spent most of their energy/ammo attacking, the defender turns the tables by going all out.

This can be hard to pull off if you have any sort of notable reputation, people may treat you with an err of suspicion or "If your attack is going well, you have walked into an ambush." ~Murphy's Rules of Combat, mentality.

Between intentionally losing a conversation to ensure someone's belief that they are right, Or appearing to pull out activity in an organization to lull an opponent into a false sense of security, this can be employed at any level. Sometimes you can force someone to either over extend themselves or reveal their intentions, conviction or resolve. This can be used as a part of a xanatos gambit to bait a desired response.

  • Divide and Conquer

"Siamese fighting fish - fascinating creatures. Brave, but on the whole, stupid. Yes, they're stupid. Except for the occasional one, such as we have here, who lets the other two fight. While he waits. Waits until the survivor is so exhausted that he cannot defend himself, and then like SPECTRE... he strikes!" ~ Ernst Stavro Blofeld, From Russia with Love

This also can be used as part of the xanatos gambit or the ridik ulass gambit where you can set up exit gates and Defensive Feint's such that a condition for your involvement with an opponent is that they quarry with any other potential opponents along the way, but by the time they get to dealing with you, they are exhausted, ill equipped, lacking social capital or personal resources. The very act of meeting you is a pyrrhic victory in such an instance while opponents quarry, I may instigate various bandwagon bluff gambit's against each potential opponents Organization, using information gathered to to make any venture that much more attritious and escalating and playing them off each other. applying "leadership fatigue" internally and an "The Innocent Whistler Gambit" externally.

By the time a strong enough opponent reaches me, they have been internally groomed. The most useful members of their organization have been ear marked for indoctrination by way of "Artificial Divergence" allowing me to instigate a perfect **"The glass castle gambit"**which in conclusion would be a "Involuntary Syndicate Gambit". which would all be part of a greater "Xanatos or ridik ulass Gambit". This can be passive, and require no work or maintenance. you do not need to target a specific group or organization, and simply rely on the fact that once one, which ever one becomes strong enough to challenge your position, they will naturally be weakened by the processes of exclusion you have set up. If you do not utterly destroy them, you can knock them back to a fresh start position with a motivation and vendetta and farm them essentially for anything useful. Resources, assets, wealth, people, information and so on.

  • Engineered Heroics

"I'm a professional beach bully. I pretend to steal your girl, you punch me, I go down, she swoons, you slip me 50 bucks." ~ Beach Bully, Futurama

So, there's someone that you need to impress. Maybe it's a pretty girl that you'd like to date, or maybe it's someone that you need on your side. What's the best way to get their attention? Why, a bit of Engineered Heroics, of course. Basically, this gambit is for when a Social engineer sets up a situation that seems like a spontaneous feat of derring-do, but is actually a deliberately concocted circumstance. Usually involves the use of a friend as an aggressor, though this runs the risk of an actual aggressor showing up.

That is basically the jist, but you can engineer any attribute, athletics, intelligence and so on simply by having a response ready for a designed situation or articulated event. Also you can Co-opt strangers under the guise of an elaborate practical joke.

In regards to the "bandwagon bluff gambit" you can engineer knowledge or authority by colluding with someone's superiors and have information planted with the intended target in advance, where you can know things before they do, and make it appear to them that they may already be under suspicion or "out of the loop" if their enemy has better lines of information then our internal organization, They may feel they are on the wrong side.

  • [Honey Trap]

This is also a term for a grifters' Blackmail scam wherein a sexy woman approaches a wealthy married man and gets him into a compromising position (preferably in bed, though in some cases just a passionate embrace will do), while her partner-in-crime secretly takes pictures. Then the pictures are sent to the man with a demand for money; no money, and the wife gets sent copies of everything. This is the classic form; there are plenty of variations, but they all rely on using sex as bait to get someone to do something unwise, then making them regret it. This can also be done with an Closet Gay if it would ruin his career, he's married, or lives in a time or place where homosexuality is illegal.

Also the name of special computers made to appear as a desirable targets (typically governments or large corporations); used by cyber-crime investigators for trapping playful hackers and crackers to learn their techniques.

I have discussed this in passing a few times. so I won't go into it here.

  • [I Never Said It Was Poison]

The usual response to a perp Saying Too Much. The perp, while maintaining his innocence, reveals information he could not possibly have known if he were innocent, usually the specific details, of a murder. It can take the form of a Suspiciously Specific Denial. For full dramatic effect, the interrogator does not immediately point out this discrepancy, but continues the interview, often saving the kicker to the very end, as a sort of And Another Thing... epilog. Even more dramatically, the interrogator may insist it wasn't poison and then probe the perp's reaction to this lie.

Once when I represented myself in a legal situation, The opposition presented receipts as part of proof of expense in a claim they were making. These receipts were dated before the issue under contention. Showing that they had made their plans in before they had encountered me, and decided after the fact to to try and burden me with the expense of the action.

Due to rules of submission of evidence in this situation, they waited until the last possible moment, Hoping I wouldn't attend to it. I quite literally got to say "and one more thing.." while presenting copies of the information in triplicate. The nature of the time stamps proved intent, malice over incompetence and I financially benefited from the inconvenience. In short pay attention to the details, they could cause you or your opponent to slip up, and a key to a good lie is brevity.

  • [Look Behind You]

Its a Cliché quite literally one of the oldest tricks in the book. but it works. Once I was approached by a unarmed mugger in a reasonably busy area, I didn't make a face and and said "are you serious? there is literally some police right behind you" when he turned to look I sucker punched him. I'm not a big guy, so I'm not above fighting dirty, victory by any means is still victory.

  • [Nasty Party]

"Explain to me why it is more noble to kill ten thousand men in battle than a dozen at dinner." ~Tywin Lannister, A Song of Ice and Fire

in the context of the trick, A person or group of people are invited to a social gathering — a party, banquet, or any other form of get-together. However, it's just an excuse to get them all together and kill them. Not unlike a certain wedding some of you may know of, from a popular TV show.

In social engineering it is basically luring someone into a favorable ground or situation under false, friendly pretenses. Invited to a Dinner date that turns into a invitation to a pyramid scheme? or some vector marketing deal, or worse yet some Cult of some sort...this would be one of those. In a one on one situation it can be an easily evaded situation.

If however you end up in a group situation, where the group is pushing an agenda, there can be some bandwagon effects in play.Though pyramid schemes and vector marketing or cults can be desperate and uninformed making applications of these effects weak in comparison to a greater backfire effect.as a result of discomfort.

It could also be extended to define inviting someone into a game, online chat-room or other social remote gathering where sympathetic, supportive or cooperative agents lay.

  • [Spanish Prisoner]

A Con Man identifies a potential mark—someone with wealth and native. The con man convinces the mark that he serves a dethroned princess who is being held prisoner in, say, Spain. If the mark can come up with just a few hundred dollars, then a guard can be bribed and the princess can flee to the US (where the mark lives) in eternal gratitude.

The mark can easily part with a few hundred, and so, though he is wary, he falls far enough for the con man's smooth line. A week goes by. Two. The mark has come to understand that he's been tricked, but before that last spark of hope can die, the con man reappears with a letter from Her Highness. She is free and in France. Now she needs a few thousand dollars for her final passage by sea, and the mark gladly shells it out.

This is basically the premise for those Nigerian e-mail scams, which wouldn't exist if people didn't fall for them. As I have established in other posts, they are intentionally incredulous in an attempt to deter any people sound of mind and inherently suspicious. Their goal is to act as an exit gate to filter out a chance of response from everyone but the most foolish. Meaning work and energy can be put into defrauding an actual likely candidate for the ruse.

People are very suspicious of this one, mainly because of the common nature of the $!( Nigerian e-mails. I use this personally, to proxy myself, I'll feign a position in relation to myself, a supporting role or assistant position, someone who maybe a trustee to myself. Then say feign interest to he right parties in betraying myself, if they believe the persona, I will ask for a show of trust, an action or an overt expression or statement that can be observed. To them it is a simple act that ventures nothing but a sign of cooperation.

However in conjunction with the bandwagon bluff gambit I can predict the actions of someone of note, and make it appear that they are in full cooperation with me. "you don't think I have cooperative agents? well I'll show you Mr. X will say "xyz" at 22:00 tomorrow, how else can I know that?" The bonus of this is that I can then coordinate release of false information to Mr X or whoever my opponent is, and Throw blame and insinuate that uncooperative members are in fact the ones in cooperation with me. undermining people who are against me, and working to promote those who work with me. While my opponents leadership will be working against me, it will appear they are working for me, furthering my support from recently acquired agents and cementing my authority with them. If they think their leadership is inept or working for me, they have little option but to cooperate as they lack alternate Options.

  • [Tricking the Shapeshifter]

"You know the trick. The clever mortal convinces the stupid djinni to squeeze inside a bottle then stoppers him up and refuses to let him out unless he grants three wishes, etc., etc." ~ Bartimaeus, The Golem's Eye

This is simply a case of coercing someone of pride and ego to act in a manner to display their skill, when the very display is either an act that will defeat them or puts them in a position that could defeat them.

This is especially effective against other hackers or social engineers who may act outside the confines of what is legal and incriminate themselves in a display of hubris. Equally you could goad a mod/admin/authority figure into banning you or abusing their power, allowing you to highlight the abuse of power, potentially having them removed from the position or undermining the authority of the collective staff/authority base. Basically they remove one bad leader or refuse and taint their leadership.

  • [Wounded Gazelle Gambit]

Using self-inflicted injuries, real or fake, to deceive others and manipulate them into doing what you want. Often used to frame a third party, this strategy is particularly effective for, and often used by, women, due to societal prohibitions against hurting women.

This one is pretty instrumental in the whole social justice warrior movement garnering the support of sympathetic white knights. I would argue that it is used an involuntary capacity where people take it for granted and the act of portraying it is purely habitual. Though there definitely is some people portraying it maliciously with intent, and benefiting from it. [Tricking the Shapeshifter] can work well in this situation if you can garner a position of trust and respect with the "wounded Gazelle" you can document their agenda and intent, present it publicly and highlight their real character.

  • [You Just Told Me]

Similar to I Never Said It Was Poison , however unlike that you must have an assumption, a modicum of information or an amount of suspicion, and intimate knowledge of the target, Usually you can elude to internal knowledge, but rather than coerce cooperation from the target, you elude to the idea that you are working secretly with him. That what ever secret is being kept that you know and that it is OK to discuss it with you.

Social engineers, hackers and other somewhat egotistical people can be prone to bragging, they may now brag to you because you are unknown, but if you know the information they know, they are dying to talk about it, and may make an assumption so they can share based on a tiny bit of information you have. I have made this mistake in a non serious context myself

I have personally seen first hand people reveal classified information with an unauthorized person, just because they thought that person already knew such information, and they were desperate with someone to discuss it with.


For the sake of continuity "High concept gambits", and "Levels, Tiers, and Gambits an explanation and comparison." are to be considered 1 and 2 in the gambits series.

As per usual, pending editing/layout and structural edits. Questions, comments and discussion encouraged.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 18 '14

"links that will show you what Google knows about your* Google account" [content x-post /r/technology]

19 Upvotes

The website was not nice to look at or read so I'm just compiling the content into text. When I say "your*" the truth is you can use anyone's google/gmail account provided you have access to it or its logged on at the time. This can be used to gather information on someone which can allow you to approach them in a more optimised manner.

Find out how Google sees you. Google attempts to create a basic profile of you, your age, gender, interests. They use this data to serve you relevant ads. You can review how Google sees you here:

  • https://www.google.com/ads/preferences/

  • Find out your location history. If you use Android, your mobile device may be sending your location as well as velocity data to Google. You can see your entire location history and export it here:

  • https://maps.google.com/locationhistory

  • Find out your entire Google Search history. Google saves every single search you have ever done. On top of that, they record every Google ad you have clicked on. This log is available to you here:

  • https://history.google.com

  • Find out every device that has accessed your Google account. If you worry that someone else might be using your account, you can find a list of all devices that have accessed your Google account, their IP address and approximate location here:

  • https://security.google.com/settings/security/activity

  • Find out all the apps and extensions that are accessing your Google data. This is a list of all the apps that have any type of access to your data. You can see the exact type of permissions granted to the app and revoke access to your data here:

  • https://security.google.com/settings/security/permissions

  • Export all of your data out of Google. Google let’s you export all your data: bookmarks, emails, contacts, drive files, profile info, your youtube videos, photos and more here:

  • https://www.google.com/takeout

This information can be used for instance in something like this where you design targeted adds for Facebook or Google plus, in such a specific manner that only your targeted person sees them. Sure you can do it as a prank, shit do it as a prank as practice, but what if you were to target a CEO of a company or a useful social contact of some sort? using the ad to lay ground work in some manner. seeing an ad on Google or Facebook would give what ever your up to an associate err of legitimacy.


r/gamesandtheory • • Oct 04 '14

We have chat, Encrypted, Anonymous, IRC set-up on the 2600.net IRC servers.

19 Upvotes

OK, I set it up to be overly secure essentially as an exit gate in and of it's self, in that people too lazy or other wise incapable or unwilling to follow the rules will likely not follow the instructions required to connect.

Equally the accommodating nature of the 2600.net network as well as the anonymity and encryption features, and the fact that the 2600.net server doesn't store logs should provide several layers of redundancy as a precautionary defence against either incompetence or malice.

Any questions, as usual are not only welcome but encouraged.

  • RULES

  1. Firstly we are guests, it is their home treat staff and other channel users with respect.

  2. Do not discuss or take part in any illegal action that may jeopardize the subreddit or the 2600.net server. apart from that you are responsible for your own actions.

  3. Be respectful of each other.

  4. No malicious attempts at social engineering other members of the community. This extents to ALL the IRC server users.

  5. No poaching/recruiting users for off site forums that use a VIP pay wall donation system.

  6. IRC 2600.net server rules

  7. Remember your actions and words have consequences that reach beyond the law, for instance upsetting some skids causing them to d-dos the IRC server effecting everyone.

  8. Rules may be subject to change in extreme instances.

  9. not mandatory, consider this a request/suggestion but I'd prefer people use their reddit names on IRC as I feel this will make communication easier and create a modicum of accountability.


  • How To Use Chat.

  • First you will need Tor which can be acquired here

  • Install and open the Tor browser

  • Then go to this URL this will green light your new IP for access to the server.

  • Then go to this URL this is a webchat IRC client that will go straight to the channel. the channel is #gametheory

  • Channel admins are me @Ridik_ulass (me) and @Polly (bot)

  • if you have a dedicated IRC client, you can connect by normal means, but the server has no Cloaks, Vhosts or masks so IP obfuscation is up to you.


You may also want to register your nick to do so...

  • make sure you are using the nick you want to register /nick "new nick" to change it

  • type /msg nickserv register "password" "email"

  • if you want to use a fake e-mail go here just make sure to remember your PW.

  • every time you come on-line you will have to identify (logon essentially) your nick to do this type /msg nickserv identify "password"

  • If people register their reddit names, and use them, then PM me confirming, I will voice them to signify to other users that I have personally confirmed that the IRC user and reddit user of the same name are the same person.

I think that should be it.


r/gamesandtheory • • Apr 03 '15

Beginner's intro/primer on body language.

18 Upvotes

Today we will begin our summary of body language, mostly for beginners, different types, different meanings, etc. I’m going to start with a quick introduction on why it’s an important set of things to know and how reading what you see effectively can give you a very real insight to someone’s thoughts, and can give an upper hand in many cases. Body language can vary from culture to culture, so be mindful of that. This will be mostly be based on American culture and body language, and I’m sure much of it will be relevant elsewhere as well. The ability to read those around you can serve to be anywhere from a useful tool to judge how a conversation is going, all the way up to saving your life because you notice something “off” and avoid danger. Lying tends to have visible representation in body language as well, so you could end up being a human lie detector if you wanted. Important generalization: Most body language will fall into the categories “open” or “closed.” Open body language usually leaves the vulnerable areas on the body open and relaxed, meaning that the arms will be at ease, or making expansive gestures and so on. Closed body language is protective, often the solar plexus/chest area will be blocked by crossed arms. Another common one is hunching forward while seated, showing uncertainty and lack of confidence, almost like hiding. Basically, if you see something but don’t know what it means, you can try to see how relaxed or protective somebody is to help guide you. Don’t assume that you know what exactly is going on, just use it to make an an educated guess. I still recommend looking into it further after the fact, but in a pinch at least an educated guess is better than absolutely nothing. We’ll be getting into more specifics very soon, follow along and stay tuned. You won’t regret it, trust me. Enjoy!


r/gamesandtheory • • Dec 31 '14

Political Engineering - Condorcet's Paradox

17 Upvotes

Hello /r/gamesandtheory,

Typically, this forum is a space for the discussion of high-level social engineering. With the mods’ permission, I would like to talk about something different: political engineering. Despite its name, this is not necessarily on the large scale of governments. After all, man is a political animal.

Although traditionally an academic subject, game theory in political science has uncovered exploitable flaws in even basic political systems. I present Condorcet’s Paradox, where the outcome of a basic decision-making/voting method can be manipulated/determined by whoever sets the agenda. This exploit is powerful because 1) the decision-making system feels intuitive, 2) the decision-making system can be applied to varied situations, and 3) the exploit works at all scales (and works best at large scales).

The basic and reasonable decision-making system is: if a democratic vote results in a tie, everyone lists their preferences and compares the results one by one, eliminating the losing option at each round.

Example: Three friends, Anne, Beth, and Charlie, are deciding between eating apple, banana, or chocolate pie. Anne likes 1) apple, 2) banana, and 3) chocolate. Beth likes 1) banana, 2) chocolate, and 3) apple. Charlie likes 1) chocolate, 2) banana, and 3) apple. Two out of three people prefer banana to chocolate, two out of three people prefer banana to apple, and two out of three people prefer chocolate to apple.

Let’s resolve this system of pie-based preferences through a simple majority vote. We first compare the options of apple and banana, and the winning option gets to go against chocolate. Two out of three people prefer banana to apple, so banana wins that round. At the second and final round, we compare banana to chocolate. Two out of three people prefer banana to chocolate, so banana wins round two as well. Option banana has won against all other options, so choosing banana pie is the democratic thing for the group to do.

The above example showed three friends choosing between three options. There are 216 potential combinations of preferences between the three friends, and a clear winner is evident in 204 of those cases, leaving 12 cases of gridlock, where no winner wins a sufficient majority.

Gridlock example: Anne prefers 1) apple, 2) banana, and 3) chocolate. Beth prefers 1) banana, 2) chocolate, and 3) apple. Charlie prefers 1) chocolate, 2) apple, and 3) banana. In the previous example, banana beat chocolate and apple, and chocolate beat apple. In that system, banana was the clear victor. Here, though, 2/3 of the people prefer apple over banana, 2/3 of the people prefer banana over chocolate, and 2/3 of the people prefer chocolate over apple. No option is more supported than any other.

In this gridlock, whoever controls the agenda of voting rounds determines the outcome. First examine the agenda where apple and banana face off in round one and the winning option goes against chocolate in round two. Here, apple wins over banana in round one since 2/3 of the people prefer apple over banana. In the second round, chocolate wins over apple since 2/3 of the people prefer it over chocolate. For this agenda, banana is chosen as the result of this democratic decision process. However, examine the agenda where apple and chocolate face off in round one and the winning option goes against banana. Here, chocolate wins the first round and banana wins the second round, making banana the democratic option. There is also an agenda that makes apple win, too. If Beth was in charge of agenda-setting, she should choose the first agenda as it would guarantee that her most favored pie, banana pie, would be chosen.

Thanks to rigorous game theory analysis, we know that any similar situation with preference gridlock is exploitable through agenda-setting. If you are in the above gridlocked situation and you can decide how to set the agenda of discussion, you can guarantee that the vote will go your way. These cases may seem artificial and limited, but as I said earlier, they scale up. With three participants and three options, gridlock only affects 5.6% of cases. But with hundreds of participants and options, the rate of gridlock rises to around 40% of cases. Even complicated situations can fall prey to this highly exploitable gridlock. Additionally, this kind of decision-making mechanism is flexible. The above examples were over the relatively silly issue of pie choices, but this kind of gridlock also affected Congressional decisions in the Revenue Acts of 1932 and 1938 (John C. Blydenburgh, “The Closed Rule and the Paradox of Voting,” Journal of Politics 33 (1971): 57-71) as well as the Tax Reform Act of 1986. Exploitable gridlock is the natural product of evaluating options with simple majority votes, and it is why congressmen and other major decision makers vie for the position of agenda-setter.

I am happy to discuss this and related topics in the comments. If there is sufficient interest, I may write another article on political engineering.

(Much of this was adapted from material presented in the lectures of Professor Kenneth A. Shepsle, professor at Harvard University and author of Analyzing Politics.)


r/gamesandtheory • • Dec 24 '14

Games and Theory: Gambits Part 4. [The Thirty-Six Stratagems 1/6]

17 Upvotes

Games and Theory: Gambits Part 4. [The Thirty-Six Stratagems 1/6]

The thirty-six stratagems, used both in real warfare and by "corporate warriors", attributed to Sun Tsu (of The Art of War fame), though he probably never came up with such a list (especially since the names of several strategies reference events from long after his death). That said, quite a lot of these are either included in The Art of War or immediately deducible from it.


  • Stratagems When Commanding Superiority:

  • 瞒天过海 Deceive the heavens and cross the ocean: Mask your real goals with a fake goal until your aims are achieved; the enemy will be so annoyed with the constant false alarms that they will ignore you once you make your real move. (This rule is also used as a Chinese aphorism for "to pull the wool over someone's eyes".)

This "stratagem" is the premise for the Ridik Ulass gambit as when you play to win your goals are apparent, however if you play for a stalemate, your goals and intentions become obscure and obfuscated. You can't be baited, extorted, threatened or coerced it also becomes difficult to reason or compromise with you and predict your actions.

In its more simple form you could appeal to a sense of "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" and work towards what is an apparent ends, when your real ends is defeating the person you are cooperating with. The alternate enemy could be an extension of your self or a figmental apparition, articulated by allies and proxies. Once in a position of trust and responsibility you are then poised for betrayal.

  • 围魏救赵 Besiege Wei to rescue Zhao: Avoid a head-on battle with a strong enemy, and instead strike at his weakness (for example, a weaker ally) elsewhere. The name came from Qi forcing Wei's army to retreat from laying siege to Zhao's capital by laying siege to Wei's capital in 354-353BC.

The little bighorn strategy as referenced in "The Social Network" is a perfect application of this "stratagem"

In "The Social Network" they reference that one college already has a social network and that is unwilling to naturally use Facebook. Rather than target this college directly, they decide to put Facebook out in every college in a 50 mile radius. After a time the members of the college switch over from their established social network to Facebook as they hear about the neighbouring colleges using it.

I always say "everyone within 1 degree of separation" from a target is worth researching, when doing target analysis. Anyone of these people could provide a useful "in" with the target, and though some might consider them innocent bystanders and their privacy important, we can't know what may or may not be relevant, until we know the information. What is and is not pertinent to the situation can only be deemed as such after the fact of knowing it. As much as I am an advocate of peoples privacy, this is the nature of information. Equally it would appear to be a sign of the times, that most government security agencies have come to the very same conclusion.

  • 借刀杀人 Kill With a Borrowed Knife: Cause damage to the enemy by getting a third party to do the deed or causing an Enemy Civil War.

Scapegoat, fall guy, chump, mark, patsy and so on. We have all heard the terms.

This Stratagem can be implemented in 4 ways, aggressively to attack, or defensively to parry. and on 2 ways stemming from those alternate goals.

Aggressively you have the obvious and traditional Kill With a Borrowed Knife: straight up convince/coerce someone else to do your dirty work for you. Escapes you from accountability and allows you established access to some ones inner circle. Simple enough.

The alternate aggressive strategy is the slow knife penetrates the shield This is a variation of the paranoia gambit, where rather than actually having someone else do the work, you elude to the idea instead. Sowing seeds of paranoia. The innocent whistler gambit is based on this thought process. After a time the target becomes unstable and like a self fulfilling prophecy eventually someone betrays him. If you have been saying he was unstable since he was actually stable, people believe you see things that they did not, and this generates faith in you like some sort of prophet, when in fact rather than predicting the future, you designed it.

The process of "predicting" events by your design, is integral to the "fictitious man gambit", and can be insured by the "xanatos gambit" or "ridik ulass gambit". provided they have been properly mastered, predicting an inevitable series of events by your design is simplistic. which will all contribute to your cult of personality.

  • 以逸待劳 Substitute Leisure for Labour: Have your troops well-prepared for battle, in the same time that the enemy is rushing to fight against you, ideally resulting in their exhausted troops running into your fresh soldiers on the terms of your choosing.

Hannibal barca, famously used this tactic during the Second Punic War (218 to 201 BC) when he, as night set in, sent scouts to disturb and rouse a Roman army from slumber, while Hannibal's troops rested well, the Romans perused, with out sleep, brooking rivers and marching a notable distance to Hannibal's troops. By the time of the engagement Hannibal's troops were well fed and well rested, while the romans were weary, tired, physically exhausted and rather hungry. The victory was absolute.

Interestingly, Hannibal was defeated in the Battle of Zama by Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus using a Besiege Wei to rescue Zhao: Stratagem. While Hannibal held most of Italy for many years, Scipio moved south to attack Hannibal's homeland, forcing Hannibal to return and address the issue, on Scipio's terms.

In social engineering gambits like "leadership fatigue" and "the Innocent whistler" are derived from this stratagem, also The ridik ulass gambit benefits from indefinitely maintaining a tiresome and arduous atmosphere around ones opponents.

  • 趁火打劫 Loot a Burning House: The best time to attack an opponent is when they have their own problems to deal with. Though he who loots a burning house should be careful lest he become trapped inside.

As discussed in Besiege Wei to rescue Zhao: everyone with in 1 degree of separation can be used against a target if one desires. The threat to one is these "free agents" can be chaotic and unpredictable, unless we can dedicate as much research into them as we have our target, which can consume chronological resources beyond diminishing returns and the worth of the venture, essentially it may not be worth the time.

Family, friends, relationships, work, hobbies and interests and the people contained can be incited into causing drama and dismay in a targets life. A distraction of which can obscure and distract from more important goings on. Again this stratagem lends to the "leadership fatigue" and "the Innocent whistler" gambits.

  • 声东击西 Clamor in the East, Attack in the West: Get the enemy to focus his forces elsewhere, and then attack a position that would be weakly defended.

Sometimes, an enemies forces are already rallied somewhere as per Besiege Wei to rescue Zhao: but it is possible to engineer the rallied forces to a point, either through leaks, misinformation triplicity or traditional duplicity.

Similar to the Fictitious man gambit, The Odious man gambit, where one builds a reputation of ill repute. instead of positive, This can encourage aggression from people, mainly because good or bad, everyone self justifies their own actions, and sees them selves as the hero to their own story. If they see you as a villain they will directly peruse you.

I have an adept ability to deflect, parry or dodge most if not all social attacks, so when an Opponent is busy attacking me, they may leave other resources unattended or vulnerable to exploit or attack or even sheer neglect. Unlike the innocent whistler gambit, The Odious man gambit is more overt, using your aggression itself to encourage a response and as a distraction. Maybe while corporative agents usurp your opponents authority from with in. Declaring his action's emotional, personal and petty.

I have slummed this gambit, by just being a two faced jerk, insulting and mistreating someone when people aren't around and being nice and reasonable when others are there to bear witness. The acquired disdain for me, seems to an observer unreasonable, and undermines the targets decision making which undermines their very position.


r/gamesandtheory • • Oct 29 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 7. + An Important Warning about the Dark Triad. [Important post please all read]

17 Upvotes

This was Originally going to be a normal Cognitive biases post, I have been reminded a lot lately how the very nature of what we do can be self deprecating and have wanted to discuss the Dark Triad. I have also wanted to warn the beginners of the craft about potential dangers before we got too far into this to look back.

I sadly don't have many social engineers who are on the level that I can talk to about some of the more philosophical and ethical qualities of what we do. That is to say I have one, and I wouldn't regard her opinion on such things with very much weight, it is enough to say I consider her a monster and a psychopath. With that being said she is fully aware of who she is and what she does, and that is more than most. In fact I asked her once about an ethical question I had an issue with, her reply was "If you are asking me you are looking for a very specific answer" we both knew full well what that meant.


In experimental science, experimenter's bias, also known as research bias, is a subjective bias towards a result expected by the human experimenter. For example, it occurs when scientists unconsciously affect subjects in experiments.

This one doesn't really help social engineers, but it is important to be aware of, as when your experience with social engineering becomes intuitive and natural something you won't need to think about, it can be probable to unconsciously influence people, and possible that in doing so you may unconsciously influence people in a way you expect them to behave.

You expect someone to be trouble, so you unconsciously influence them into causing trouble, you expect someone to make a mistake so you unconsciously influence them into making a mistake and so on. Your thoughts, your assumptions become a sordid self fulfilling prophecy.

This is usually supported by the bias blind spot and the Confirmation bias.

As I have been making overtly clear, its possible to convince many people of anything, for any reason and if enough people belive that thing it then becomes true, this is the nature of society. Money, justice, honour, respect, religion are all Ideas that we collectively agree are true, Truth itself is just an idea and what we do is in essence a psychological slight of hand, bringing attention to desirable truths and removing attention from undesirable truths forwarding our agenda with our lies or misrepresentation is the ideal we strive for. This however can effect us, equally. This where the Dark Triad comes in.

The simple sense of power that comes with unconsciously influencing peoples ideas, opinions and choices, having them and their personalities utterly remodel by you as you see fit, for your own ends and means can be self depreciating. it is why I don't teach people under 18 any more. Having personally seen first hand the effects of social engineering on the users ego and personality as they learn and adapt to the new information and perspective, and subsequently stop learning. Even after a time thinking they know more or are more experienced, due to the hubris of youth. Dismissing the very information they originally sought to learn, the very information that could keep them defended against a negative shift in personality.


The dark triad is a group of three personality traits: narcissism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy. The use of the term "dark" reflects the perception that these traits have interpersonally aversive qualities.

Considering the nature of social engineering, we as a community have a knack for attracting people whose personalities lean heavily in these areas as it is, a perspective shift as a result of practising ones abilities can be devastating coupled with any of these already standing personality traits.


Narcissism is characterised by grandiosity, pride, egotism, and a lack of empathy

  • Grandiosity refers to an unrealistic sense of superiority—a sustained view of oneself as better than others that causes the narcissist to view others with disdain or as inferior—as well as to a sense of uniqueness: the belief that few others have anything in common with oneself and that one can only be understood by a few or very special people.

When having the ability to influence people, when you can see the root cause of their choices and the cause and effect system in place that has led them to the principals and ideals that they hold dear, knowing that you can change this simply because you want to. it can clearly lead to a false sense of superiority. No matter how smart someone is, they can fall victim to various cognitive biases simply because they are unaware of them. when you see smart and intelligent people, people you respect be as easily influenced by obvious ploys in the media or marketing, as normal average people it can be hard not to lose a modicum of respect for these people. When these obvious ploys are beneath your own level of skill, and you think how easily you could influence your friends and family, those around you, you very quickly feel superior to those people around you.

I have by my own choice, decided that social engineering people with in 1 degree of separation from me, is unethical Never the less, I have had issues in my life, between family and friends that I could have easily solved with social engineering, Though I belive that I may have solved that issue itself, I would have lost respect for the people on the receiving end. It would likely have either equally or greatly damaged the relationships that have been established.

I would advocate that rules and principals for social engineers are important to maintain perspective, as in the short term in an emotional situation the easiest solution might seem the best, but have as yet un apparent long term effects.

  • Pride is an inwardly directed emotion that carries two common meanings. With a negative connotation, pride refers to an inflated sense of one's personal status or accomplishments, often used synonymously with hubris.

If your social engineering results in great feats, either by your hand or the hand of someone you have tasked, it can be easy to take pride in your accomplishment. It can even motivate you to be more productive and active some times you can lose sight of your actions and pursue only the accomplishments. The more you think of yourself and the less you think of others can lead to some distorted understanding of what is ethical. Many of you, myself included have questionable ethics to begin with, we are not always bound to rules and laws but more so what we think is right or wrong, which can be fine, but if what we think changes, so too does our ethics and what we once thought was wrong suddenly becomes OK.

  • Egotism is the drive to maintain and enhance favourable views of oneself, and generally features an inflated opinion of one's personal features and importance. It often includes intellectual, physical, social and other over estimations.

Either by maintaining those favourable views by actions, like pursuing social engineering goals, or by social engineering the views themselves to alter the observers perspective. Egotism is something we actively practise by intent, it can become habitual in nature. You yourself can lose perspective do something often enough and you get used to it, it becomes second nature almost. It can be nice to have others think highly of us so the habit can almost become an addiction. If we over estimate ourselves and our abilities, becoming conceited it may in and of itself neuter our abilities and become self depreciating.

I see this a lot in social engineering, people thinking they are too good or above everyone else even other social engineers, often better social engineers, because the best ones always see everything as an opportunity to learn, while egotistical social engineers think no one has anything to teach them and they know more than everyone else.

Empathy is the capacity to share or recognise emotions experienced by another sentient or fictional being. One may need to have a certain amount of empathy before being able to experience accurate sympathy or compassion.

we need to recognise emotions in order to understand a situation and interprete it, especially if we want to benefit from it. it can be hard to empathise with people when they are being as apparent to us, emotional or irrational. A lot of what I teach about cognitive biases in fact encourage us to remain emotionally neutral and rational.

I recently referenced Appeal to emotion in social psychology games and theory post and empathy gap in my cognitive biases part 6 post. in both instances I advocated an emotionless and rational response and perspective.

When I care to, which is more often than not, I rationalise and reason everything by my self. I do this to avoid undesired external input. Nearly every choice I make, is understood to be the best choice, not necessarily the best choice for me, but rather the best choice for everyone concerned, that I care about in the context of the choice. In essence I plot games trees in everything I do. asking questions about every topic like, do I care, is it worth it, do I care to invest that much energy, is the result worth the in put.... and so on.

I personally find it difficult to empathise with other people when making a choice, because I think unequivocally think that the choice I have reasoned is the best one, and I usually know other people have not given the choice as much thought. it can be very difficult to empathise with someone when you think they are being irrational or unreasonable. sometimes I can forget that many choices don't matter, after I have decided that it does matter while plotting my game tree. so while I think people are being irrational, unreasonable and emotional, I am being overly rational, stubborn and cold.


Machiavellianism is characterised by manipulation and exploitation of others; a cynical disregard for morality, and a focus on self-interest and deception.

  • Psychological manipulation is a type of social influence that aims to change the perception or behaviour of others through underhanded, deceptive, or even abusive tactics. By advancing the interests of the manipulator, often at another's expense, such methods could be considered exploitative, abusive, devious, and deceptive.

Social influence is not necessarily negative. For example, doctors can try to persuade patients to change unhealthy habits. Social influence is generally perceived to be harmless when it respects the right of the influenced to accept or reject and is not unduly coercive. Depending on the context and motivations, social influence may constitute underhanded manipulation.

This is pretty clear, I think we all know why we are here and I don't need to go into to much more about this. The issue becomes that, when our ability to reason right from wrong becomes compromised, when we think less of others and more of ourselves, when we think that because of that we are more right than others, and we think that we have more of a right than others, to power, wealth or authority we might justify in our minds actions we previously deemed unacceptable.

  • Exploitation is the use of someone or something in an unjust or cruel manner, or generally as a means to one's ends.Most often, the word exploitation is used to refer to economic exploitation; that is, the act of using another person as a means to one's profit, particularly using their labour without offering or providing them fair compensation.

Though it sounds it, exploitation isn't inherent to what we do, we might exploit bugs in the human condition but we don't inherently exploit people. Often what we can do is highlight a mutually beneficial perspective that has not been previously apparent to an individual, if it is not as beneficial as other non cooperative possibilities, we may be able to sure up the balance in a compromising of some sort.

Equally, as I have discussed Proxies are people entirely unaware that they are part of your plots or schemes, or even that there are plots and schemes in place. these people are being unquestionably exploited, even if your machinations aren't detrimental to them individually, they are essentially working for you, unknowingly and with out compensation.

Morality is the differentiation of intentions, decisions, and actions between those that are "good" (or right) and those that are "bad"

As I have explained already in this thread, as we think less of others and more highly of ourselves we can disregard others interpretation of morality as naive, foolish and childish. When we think highly of ourselves, even think that we are more powerful and have authority over others simply because of our abilities we can deem ourselves excluded from the rules of morality. Not unlike Self-licensing as I described in the other thread on social psychology, it stems from a deluded sense of entitlement.

  • Self-interest generally refers to a focus on the needs or desires (interests) of the self.

This again stems from an inflated sense of self worth, which in turn prioritises personal goals and desires above that of people around you. either from a sense of entitlement or from the notion that you can do better because you understand things differently, or maybe a simple sense of the "weak are meat for the strong to eat" and you take what you can because no one will be looking out for your interests. I try to include philosophy of some sort in what I teach here, there is no right answer that I know of, but in my opinion like everything else knowledge is the best defence.

  • Deception beguilement, deceit, bluff, mystification and subterfuge are acts to propagate beliefs of things that are not true, or not the whole truth (as in half-truths or omission). Deception can involve dissimulation,propaganda, and sleight of hand, as well as distraction, camouflage, or concealment. There is also self-deception, as in bad faith.

Deception is a major relational transgression that often leads to feelings of betrayal and distrust between relational partners. Deception violates relational rules and is considered to be a negative violation of expectations. Most people expect friends, relational partners, and even strangers to be truthful most of the time. If people expected most conversations to be untruthful, talking and communicating with others would require distraction and misdirection to acquire reliable information. A significant amount of deception occurs between romantic and relational partners.

Again like many things in this thread, this is something we intentionally practise we seek it out and knowledge associated with it, with the full intention of using it. we practise it regularly, regularly enough to make a habit out of it. The habit forming nature of social engineering with many of these negative characteristics is exactly why we need to be weary and why falling into the Dark Triad can be so very easy and so very dangerous. It can become an inescapable self perpetuating trap from which you may never recover.


Psychopathy is characterised by enduring antisocial behaviour, impulsivity, selfishness, callousness, and remorselessness.

  • Anti-social behaviour are actions that harm or lack consideration for the well-being of others. Anti-social behaviour is labelled as such when it is deemed contrary to prevailing norms for social conduct.

Your very reading of this post means you already question the norms of social conduct, a lot of which is social habit handed down from generation to generation. we question it, the what and why's of it, how it works and what can we gain from it. Often the study of which leads us to understand and perceive the irrational and unquestioned nature of some social rules. Tradition I believe is a word that sums much of it up.

Working against the social norms is common in what we do, Try to explain social engineering to an average person, even friend or family and you will be met with inherent distrust.

It is my belief that contradicting social norms isn't inherently bad and shouldn't be deemed anti social, but my personal belief that social norms should be questioned could be itself a sign that even I have fallen victim to the dark triad?

  • Impulsivity is a multi factorial construct that involves a tendency to act on a whim, displaying behaviour characterised by little or no forethought, reflection, or consideration of the consequences. Impulsive actions are typically "poorly conceived, prematurely expressed, unduly risky, or inappropriate to the situation that often result in undesirable consequences," which imperil long-term goals and strategies for success.

This is our saving grace, I think its the only thing I mentioned so far, that is not only not inherent to social engineering, but very much opposed to it. We should all endeavour to act with forethought, reflection, consideration of consequences and deny impulsive actions entirely.

  • Selfishness is being concerned, sometimes excessively or exclusively, for oneself or one's own advantage, pleasure, or welfare, regardless of others.

Pride, egotism, morality, self interest I have gone over this enough.

Remorse is an emotional expression of personal regret felt by a person after they have committed an act which they deem to be shameful, hurtful, or violent. Remorse is closely allied to guilt and self-directed resentment. When a person regrets an earlier action or failure to act, it may be because of remorse or in response to various other consequences, including being punished for the act or omission.

A person who is incapable of feeling remorse is often labelled with antisocial personality disorder. In general, a person needs to be unable to feel fear, as well as remorse, in order to develop psychopathic traits.


Pending editing and layout changes.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 01 '16

Cognitive biases can lead to systematic deviations from a standard of rationality or good judgement, and can be exploited. [ All Original Content To Date]

16 Upvotes

r/gamesandtheory • • Dec 08 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 11

16 Upvotes

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 11

Ok here we go, back to the irregular scheduled viewing.


Insensitivity to sample size is a cognitive bias that occurs when people judge the probability of obtaining a sample statistic without respect to the sample size. For example, in one study subjects assigned the same probability to the likelihood of obtaining a mean height of above six feet [183 cm] in samples of 10, 100, and 1,000 men. In other words, variation is more likely in smaller samples, but people may not expect this.

Like many cognitive biases we are coming to understand they can be used to frame information in a specific light as an offensive way to change some ones perspective or defensively they can be used to highlight potential biases and agendas in some ones argument and undermine their argument and themselves equally.

We see this often in marketing and advertising you may often see in say a "make-up" advertisement where the sample size is a unusual non-round number. like "results from testing on 93 women" why not 100? why not 75 or 50 another one is 4/5 dentists approve of X product considering many dentists get free supplies from toothbrush and toothpaste manufacturers the numbers are already under question, so why not some larger sample size of dentists I'd be more inclined to believe 40 professionals than 4. This is all symptomatic of the framing effect. here -> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_effect_(psychology) because of brackets in the URL I can't embed it.

The term sunk cost fallacy has been used to describe the phenomenon where people justify increased investment in a decision, based on the cumulative prior investment, despite new evidence suggesting that the cost, starting today, of continuing the decision outweighs the expected benefit. Such investment may include money, time, or even — in the case of military strategy — human lives. The phenomenon and the sentiment underlying it are reflected in such proverbial images as "Throwing good money after bad", "In for a dime, in for a dollar", or "In for a penny, in for a pound".

I have described this a few times when discussing the sunk cost fallacy in relation to gambling, I also described it during my discussion of the "stone soup gambit" where by you get someone to commit slight amounts of either time, money or energy to a project and drip feed them results until they are committed to the projects overall success. It has been discussed in depth so we will move on.

The less-is-better effect is a type of preference reversal that occurs when the lesser or smaller alternative of a proposition is preferred when evaluated separately, but not evaluated together.Another paradigm that incorporates this effect is Occam's razor, which is referred to as simplifying a situation as much as possible to avoid confusion and annoyance.

  • seven ounces of ice cream overflowing in a small cup was preferred over eight ounces of ice cream in a much larger cup

  • a dinnerware set with 24 intact pieces was preferred over a dinnerware set of 31 pieces with a few broken pieces

  • a smaller dictionary was preferred over a larger dictionary with a torn cover

  • participants perceived people giving away a $45 scarf as more generous than those who gave a cheap $55 coat.

This is a product of the contrast effect and the framing effect as linked above. It can be used to alter peoples decision making ability in either direction depending on the social engineers choice at the time, the flexibility providing alternative potentials and is very accommodating for Xanatos Speed Chess a derivative of the xanatos gambit.

While the Xanatos Gambit stipulates that one should plan and prepare for every possible significant outcome in a series of events, encouraging the planning and use of game trees. Xanatos Speed Chess is orientated towards constant tweaking and maintenance of ones plans, Personally I prefer the Xanatos gambit itself because if set right it requires less work and I can dedicate my time and energy to other objectives. Xanatos Speed Chess speed chess is perfect for newer Social engineers or when dealing with an adept opponent by proxy.

"This is how Vetinari thinks. [...] Plans can break down. You cannot plan the future. Only presumptuous fools plan. The wise man steers." ~ Cosmo Lavish, Making Money

The main thing involved with Xanatos Speed Chess is the need for full knowledge of all effecting factors as well as the attention and consistency for regular constant input, Practice at this, understanding and learning of the involved factors, becoming accustom to the very nature of manipulating social dynamics will teach and train you to be Abel to practice it in your head. Preparing you to eventually be Abel to plot a successful Xanatos Gambit as detailed here in Games and Theory: High Concept Gambits Part 1.

The mere-exposure effect is a psychological phenomenon by which people tend to develop a preference for things merely because they are familiar with them. In social psychology, this effect is sometimes called the familiarity principle. The effect has been demonstrated with many kinds of things, including words, Chinese characters, paintings, pictures of faces,geometric figures, and sounds. In studies of interpersonal attraction, the more often a person is seen by someone, the more pleasing and likeable that person appears to be.

This is effected by the usual suspects , Ambiguity effect, Attentional bias, Availability heuristic and Availability cascade but if it becomes effected by the Backfire effect it can have the opposing effect. This effects favoritism and trust a lot. Reddit itself is a perfect example of this, the rise and fall of memes and subs as they gain popularity then counter-culture which dislikes them gains popularity in its place and the meme becomes a source of disdain.

If we were to exploit the Argument from authority fallacy in conjunction with this, in that say a company from a position of authority and respect like Google, were to advertise some fictional person, product or company they would gain reputation in a persons mind by proxy of their trust for Google. This can be done with highly targeted Google adds and suddenly in the mind of your target, your fictional company has the social standing and reputation required to be considered for a cooroprative venture.

I once used a similar method to bombard the VP of a technology company I was hired to pentest. This company was a military contractor and worked on DARPA projects as you might imagine the highest security. Yet by convincing the VP I was the CEO of a reputable company wishing to design software for their product, they released to me, with out meeting me or any finincial exchange some prototype hardware, one of only a handful of models they had in exsistance. Obviously there are more details in which I had to account for the various forms of vetting that I am bound by Non-Disclousure Agreement to not go into.However what I am trying to infer and have been for a while is, with social engineering you can get Anything, even things money can not get you.


r/gamesandtheory • • Nov 20 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 10

16 Upvotes

Consider this will be in the same sitting as Part 9 I have nothing of substance or merit to say in the intro.


The illusion of control is the tendency for people to overestimate their ability to control events; for example, it occurs when someone feels a sense of control over outcomes that they demonstrably do not influence.It is thought to influence gambling behavior and belief in the paranormal. Along with illusory superiority and optimism bias, the illusion of control is one of the positive illusions.

Positive illusions are unrealistically favorable attitudes that people have towards themselves or to people that are close to them. Positive illusions are a form of self-deception or self-enhancement that feel good, maintain self-esteem or stave off discomfort at least in the short term.

The Illusion of control can be associated with conceited personalities. If you notice someone discuss events or anecdotes that they were not involved in or were merely in the presence of it when it occurred as "we" rather than naming a specific individual in some cases this may be not intentionally disingenuous but an actual held belief. National accomplishments, personal preference sport teams or even online communities, you may hear someone referring to when one sports team beats another as "we kicked ass last night" or someone who frequents 4chan but no a specific raid as saying "yeah, we totally screwed with that poll" combined with Choice-supportive bias and Illusory truth effect after time even if they were originally disingenuous they can come to believe their version of events.

At times, people attempt to gain control by transferring responsibility to more capable or “luckier” others to act for them. By forfeiting direct control, it is perceived to be a valid way of maximizing outcomes. This illusion of control by proxy is a significant theoretical extension of the traditional illusion of control model. Rather than contest someone for a position of authority, say a promotion or an elected position due to the Ambiguity effect, someone who wants the position might not go for it and instead convince them selves that they are "letting" someone else go for it because they will either do better or carry out the persons intentions anyway and the person can avoid responsibility and work.

This can be exploited much the same way as the IKEA effect. By feeding into some ones illusion of control you can allow them to get complacent and socially and emotionally invested in the outcome of a project. so much so that they may even take full responsibility of it if and when it goes pear shaped. Due to them having re-written their own perception of reality and history due to the illusory truth they will honestly believe and be fully convinced that any possible mistakes or actions were and are their responsibility.

This is especially true of people with large egos, including social engineers who themselves have a strong sense of control of the people around them. I have seen a few amateur social engineers and hackers fully accept and believe that they are wholly responsible for a series of illegal events when they were merely a scape goat. However after a certain point they have convinced themselves that they are fully responsible and trying to remove them from that position can result in the back fire effect. When more often than not police want to close cases and everyone involved is in agreement, there is not enough interest in the truth for it ever to make it to the light of day.

I'll cover this again in social psychology. But its always important to know that memories don't remember incidents, but rather the last time you remember an incident. that means Opinions, cognitive biases can re-write a memory each time it is recalled, the events re-written. If you control the cognitive biases, use attentional bias to bring up events over and over, you can re-write some ones memories, This is why I made a post about the dark triad because the same can happen to you and it would be negative. memories and perceptions of such effect some ones personality so given enough time, you can actually change some ones entire personality you can even change your own personality, intentionally for the positive.

After explaining a lot about social engineering to someone, after I explained how it is possible to indirectly convince someone to do something through proxies I hinted at but avoided specifically spelling it out, that I was responsible for making them do something that they did, before I met them, simply as a proof of theory. After a time, about a month, they became fully accepting that I had in fact made them do something indirectly, with out their knowing.

Citations regarding my statement on the operation of memory...

  1. citation

  2. citation .pdf

Illusory correlation is the phenomenon of perceiving a relationship between variables (typically people, events, or behaviors) even when no such relationship exists. A common example of this phenomenon would be when people form false associations between membership in a statistical minority group and rare (typically negative) behaviors as variables that are novel or salient tend to capture the attention. This is one way stereotypes form and endure. Hamilton & Rose found that stereotypes can lead people to expect certain groups and traits to fit together, and then to overestimate the frequency with which these correlations actually occur.

Thanks to Attentional bias, Availability heuristic and Confirmation bias racism or even just stereotyping can be self reinforcing. The obvious truth is that correlation does not denote causation. This can be used both aggressively and defensively whether you want to confirm someone of an opinion or dissuade them from it.

The other thing is that Though correlation does not denote causation, it doesn't disprove it either. Though, the phrase "correlation does not denote causation" can be used as a thought terminating Cliché which is something I still have to go over I thought I'd bring attention to it. a converse Thought terminating Cliché is "well its the exception that proves the rule"... Personally I think that phrase is a fucking joke and makes no sense, I can't help but find it hilarious how many people just accept what is being said when its said because of that phrase. I think for the most part the "proves the rule" part is an acceptance of someone else opinion so some see it as a cognitive compromise. an "I'll accept this defeat here and now if you accept my opinion on the whole" its a phrase that actually got me to ask about thought terminating Clichés, because its so common, so unquestioned and makes so little sense, yet seems to be taken fully for granted.

Like many of these cognitive biases, simply pointing them out can undermine some ones point of view and you can then accuse them of being unreasonable and irrational. equally if the needs be you can encourage them and allow them to flourish with in some ones perspective.

The impact bias, a form of which is the durability bias, in affective forecasting, is the tendency for people to overestimate the length or the intensity of future feeling states.

A mix of Empathy gap and the Ambiguity effect , When predicting how an experience will impact us emotionally, events which have not been experienced are particularly difficult. Also often when making a prediction of the impact of an event people focus solely on the event in question. This ignores the fact that with the passage of time, other events will occur that influence happiness.

On its own this bias is not very substantial but it can be used in conjunction with other cognitive biases like the Illusion of control, Gambler's fallacy or the ambiguity effect. in that people will be unlikely to accurately understand the emotional effect of the result of their actions. In conjunction with the Hyperbolic discounting it can be dangerous as it will allow people to rationalize a emotionally dangerous satisfying short term action over the long term implications....like cheating on a partner. In the wrong hands, it could be exploited to encourage such and action, then exploiting the ambiguity effect someone could then be exposed to extortion. such as a honeypot scam

As per use by espionage agencies.

Information bias is a type of cognitive bias, and involves e.g. distorted evaluation of information. An example of information bias is believing that the more information that can be acquired to make a decision, the better, even if that extra information is irrelevant for the decision.

We see this a lot with anecdotal evidence where a person thinks quantity is more important than quality. As well as encouraging, discouraging and making note and undermining this bias to what ever your ends might be. The bias itself can be used to busy and distract someone citing the thought terminating Cliché "better have it and not need it, than to need it and not have it" as an excuse to sanction results.

Conversely and even used in legal defense, where by the opposition has to go through submitted information to form counter points in advance, you can present someone with a needle in a haystack, haystack included. If anyone suggests that someone you might be overdoing it, you can cite "better to have it and not need it, than need it and not have it...


r/gamesandtheory • • Sep 17 '14

Games and Theory: Cognitive biases Part 2.

16 Upvotes

A Little Prologue this time.

Hopefully given time I can not only cover most of the standard cognitive biases but also in-depth explanations of logical fallacies and other common bugs in the human condition that can be exploited. I will call these "games and Theory" posts so if they become consistent and regular they can be dug up by people looking for past content.

Last post LINK:// Part 1.

Now on to the meat of this post. As per the last post I will be initially covering Decision-making, belief, and behavioral cogitative biases.

The truth effect, the illusory truth effect or the illusion-of-truth effect is the tendency to believe information to be correct because we are exposed to it more times.

This stems from the social issue that we are told a lot of information we assume to be true from birth, don't touch that that's hot, that's dangerous and so on. We rarely or often just can't verify information first hand, like the Eiffel tower is in Paris sure but have you personally verified that to be true? So often take peoples word for it. The more people the more likely it is to be true.

Many of you might have heard the "fact" people swallow 6 or so spiders a year in their sleep. This is a perfect example of not only the Cognitive bias but social engineering. as the Snapple company published a number of incorrect facts on their lids it has been debated that they published these incorrect facts intentionally as a social experiment in suggestibility.

This is very closely tied to Availability heuristic as mentioned last time where people tend to believe things that are more prominent in their memories, in conjunction with Attentional bias where peoples perception can be affected by recurring thoughts we can see why the "fact" about swallowing spiders perpetuated so deeply into society compared to the other incorrect facts.

Peoples natural fear of spiders, which is very common, means this is an attentional bias, they think about it a lot, bring it up when the opportunity is available, The shocking nature of the "fact" means it sticks in peoples minds causing an Availability heuristic meaning more people say it, and more people think about it which means it must be true right? Causing an Availability cascade.

It can be very hard to reason someone out of a position they never reasoned themselves into. When many cognitive biases such as this burden someone with an idea, it can sometimes cause Cognitive dissonance for them to change their belief. In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values. People don't want to experience Stress or discomfort leading to willful ignorance where someone would rather ignore the new correct information then be confronted and find that their beliefs are wrong. It steaks heavily in pride, someone would rather believe them selves right then confirm they have always been wrong about something. The longer their belief has been the more willful they will be about protecting these beliefs. It can get to the point they will actively try to convince others of what they believe because of the other cognitive biases and their unconscious understanding of them. If they believe what they believe because everyone else did, the more people who believe it the more true it must be. After a time a lie, an idea, a belief can become self perpetuating. In this instance I won't point out what parts of society might be a home to a self perpetuating lie but I'm sure you can observe them for yourselves.

This can simply be exploited by reminding someone about something, either positive or negative depending on your goals. Though if you are reminding them about something positive about you it won't have as strong an effect.

When people react to dis-confirming evidence by strengthening their beliefs. People display this bias when they gather or remember information selectively, or when they interpret it in a biased way. The effect is stronger for emotionally charged issues and for deeply entrenched beliefs.

The effect is also stronger for emotionally charged people, As I noted in my last post I spent the last year developing a negative cult of personality which itself became self perpetuating as I received blame for everything bad that happened and strengthened the idea that I was an awful person. When you piss someone off, fuck with them and burden the comfort of their life, they may become angry, emotionally charged. The confirmation bias was in the end my undoing. As I couldn't rationally explain my point of view or escape blame for wholly awful acts that were not by my hand, nor by my design.

In an instance where someone has a bad reputation, it will be harder obviously to believe them. Faced with a man who is a registered sex offender and a woman claiming rape, even with no evidence on the table even the most logical and reasonable jury/judge would be bias against the registered sex offender. This sadly exposes people with a History that they have moved on from to things like blackmail and extortion. On top of the established freedom of information in the USA in regards to sex offenders, I have heard stories of ethically questionable women using these resources as a shopping list for potential targets for blackmail and extortion.

As stated in the last post the Ambiguity effect The ambiguity effect is a cognitive bias where decision making is affected by a lack of information. Not being sure of the outcome from the potential response to the refusal of payment would be a heavier weight than knowing sure, say the threat being that of death. Due to this, this kind of extortion can lead to suicide, as other cognitive bias drive home the sense of peril. Constantly thinking what could, what might happen if the aggressor made such a claim, the uncertainty of the outcome the unknown possibilities being burdened with life changing bad past experiences and the possibility that this might happen again. If one were in that situation it would be very hard to have a rational response.

This can be exploited by feigning interest in removing someone from a belief position you have put them in. Losing the argument will have the added effect of them being abel to remember winning. if you have high political or social capital it will stand to their defence next time. "ridik is smart and he couldn't find a flaw with my argument so it must be true" I once used this when I created a senario where people discovered a fake persona I had articulated them to find, I denied that that persona was my real identity, but I did it badly and had no back up evidence to say that was the case, thus they thought i was lying and themselfs clever for seeing past my lies, as I had a reputation as a liar and trickster they thought themselfs espicially celever for seeing past my lie.

The bandwagon effect is a phenomenon whereby the rate of uptake of beliefs, ideas, fads and trends increases the more that they have already been adopted by others. This is increased by other cognitive biases as we are quickly learning everything is. But the how and why of it has been mostly explained through my explanation of the other cognitive biases.

The bandwagon effect is your cut and dry social peer pressure, if someone on the bandwagon is someone you like or hold favor for you may also incur an attentional bias and if your friends are also participating in the fad or what have you. Availability cascade and Availability heuristic will also be present.

A lot of what I'm pointing out highlights why a group of social engineers can be so very powerful, they increase in ability exponentially when their numbers grow additively.

Both a logical fallacy and a cognitive bias this one. Base rate fallacy, also called base rate neglect or base rate bias, is an error in thinking. If presented with related base rate information (i.e. generic, general information) and specific information (information only pertaining to a certain case), the mind tends to ignore the former and focus on the latter. This is what the base rate fallacy refers to.

"One death is a tragedy; one million is a statistic." ~Joseph Stalin

Joey Stalin's famous words, sum this one up perfectly I don't think I have heard an average person give one fat shit about the death statistics in my country, murder, car accidents, household accidents what ever no one really cares. But one blond haired blue eyed little girl gets the bad news and it makes international news and suddenly why isn't anyone doing anything about it? I personally hold a certain amount of contempt for the slacktivism people who make a point about giving a shit about the next big thing to care about, anyone remember kony?

This can and is exploited by the media every day, find a story that appeals to the heart strings of a demographic and start playing the worlds smallest violin.

I often say, what is being said doesn't often matter, but why its being said and I can't help but find an agenda behind when ever one tragedy, one death or one instance is made out to seem more important than another of statistically equal relevance. People trying to use emotion to conjure a reaction always have an agenda. This conversation between hermann goring and Gustave Gilbert during the Nuremberg War Crimes Trials in 1946 I find always conveys my sentiment.

Göring: Why, of course, the people don't want war. Why would some poor slob on a farm want to risk his life in a war when the best that he can get out of it is to come back to his farm in one piece? Naturally, the common people don't want war; neither in Russia nor in England nor in America, nor for that matter in Germany. That is understood. But, after all, it is the leaders of the country who determine the policy and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along, whether it is a democracy or a fascist dictatorship or a Parliament or a Communist dictatorship.

Gilbert: There is one difference. In a democracy, the people have some say in the matter through their elected representatives, and in the United States only Congress can declare wars.

Göring: Oh, that is all well and good, but, voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country.

As usual, questions and discussion encouraged.

:pending structural edits:


r/gamesandtheory • • Apr 05 '15

Body Language of Liars and Hiders

15 Upvotes

This post is an extension of my previous one, which covered "truthers". You can find it here. We’ve all dealt with them and most of us have been them at one or more points in our life. Everybody lies and everybody has things that they try to keep under wraps, but knowing when and why someone lies as well as being able to back up claims revealing their lies can be crucial in many settings.

I mentioned this in another post but I’ll rehash because it’s relevant: Detail is key. Liars often describe every little detail including heavily irrelevant ones, I can only assume that it’s due to trying too hard to make it seem real. Keep that in mind when you lie as well as when dealing with a liar, useful on both sides of the force. Additionally, if you remember the eye accessing cues of truthers, they would look in leftward directions when recalling actual information. On the other hand, the rightward glances are often creative, meaning they utilize imagination instead of memory. The one cue that could be confusing for you is downward-right which signals both constructed and remembered feelings. The rightward glance with no angle signals auditory construction and upward right signals visual imagination.

Hands are another good indicator of a person's mental state, feelings and intentions. If someone is fiddling with things constantly often they're nervous, which can mean a lot of things. They could be lying or hiding something but never jump to conclusions based on just that, always have multiple layers of verification. This can be anything from social phobia to an indicator of a build up to supicious/criminal activity. When you take it and look at other indicators, though, things often become clearer. Another thing, palms facing down while talking tends to indicate dishonesty or evasiveness. Combined with facial expression these can be powerful insight into another person's mind. Eyebrows tense and pulled down usually signifies some kind of distress where as relaxed and slightly elevated eyebrows indicate confidence/relaxation. This combined with widened eyes can signify awareness of surroundings.

Enjoy and be mindful of ambiguous body language.