r/gamemusic • u/Unit076 • 15d ago
News Nobuo Uematsu Warns 'Hollywood-Style Scores' Are Making Game Music Sound Too Similar
From the latest print Famitsu interview. Do you agree with Uematsu and Hitoshi Sakimoto's assessments? While something NieR definitely deserves all the praises, I do think the constant need for orchestral tracks could lessen the "feel" of a particular franchise's soundscape. The most obvious one is Monster Hunter IMO; current ones still lack those percussives and drums (and sometimes electronic or other experimental elements) even if Wilds have made a lackluster attempt to reverse course on this.
Just compare Alatreon's pre-5th gen and Iceborne themes. Also take time to listen to Frontier's.
Uematsu recalled how musical expectations quickly changed as the industry moved beyond the SNES and into the PlayStation era. Composers capable of producing ‘film-like’ music were becoming increasingly sought after in the fifth console generation. “You couldn’t survive if you can’t make robust and substantial music,” he said. “Moreover, the whole gaming industry was aiming for the scale of Hollywood movies.”
“When you’re thinking of orchestral music with intensity, it’s easy to end up with something that sounds like a Hollywood-style score. In that sense, it has become increasingly difficult to differentiate a work just through its overall feel alone,” explained Uematsu.
Regarding that change of trends, Eternal Anima‘s main composer, Hitoshi Sakimoto of Final Fantasy XII and Tactics Ogre‘s fame, chimed in, “Perhaps it’s because film scores are practically the only source for new orchestral music, I think,”
