r/gamefly • • 29d ago

Disingenuous bait

0 Upvotes

Kinda bummed. I figured I’ve give GameFly a try as I’d never used it before and noticed they had a deal on a game I was curious about. So I signed up for the free trial and figured if the game ships fast and seems hassle free to receive and send games I’d sign up after trial. Also, if I liked the game I rented I wanted to buy it and it was listed at 27.99 so I was very excited. Then I noticed the day it got delivered(or perhaps the following day) the “Keep it” price bumped up to 34.99. Seems pretty dishonest to have an offer like that knowing it will entice people to try a product and then jack it up as soon as they do. My game came within just a couple days and I really appreciate that but tbh I think the fact the price changed like that has shifted my mind to not continue a subscription. Why do companies always have to mislead and try to weasel every dime?😤

Just had to rant about it.


r/gamefly • • Jul 05 '26

Just heard a gamefly ad while in the shower and it's terrible

1 Upvotes

Normally I skip ads but was in the shower so I heard the entire ad that was the length of my shower. It was so bad and obviously a.i. I used to love gamefly but there's no way they'll last much longer. The intro to the ad pretty much acknowledged it with their intro, gamefly: yes we're still here. Like if you have to remind ppl you exist, you're just in hospice. Has anyone else heard this ad and what are your thoughts?


r/gamefly • • Jan 13 '25

GAMEFLY GAMEFLY GAMEFLY GAMEFLY NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

GAMEFLY


r/gamefly • • Sep 20 '26

Gamefly is stupid.

Post image
0 Upvotes

We recently moved and one of my kids wanted to try out Gamefly to rent a PS5 game and apparently because a previous renter had gamefly, they closed their account.... Wonder how business is going to go for them when Playstation stops making disk....


r/gamefly • • Jun 20 '26

Gamefly conspiracy theory: support lies to you

1 Upvotes

I live one state over from the shipping distribution center that's in Pittsburgh, and I live in my state's capital, so usps is fairly consistent and around. Google maps says it would take 5 hours to just flat out drive there.

Anyways all that to say is that I usually drop my games in the mail Monday morning and they're usually received Wednesday. Then they ship out the next one and it takes 2, sometimes 3 days to arrive.

Monday before last(11 ish days ago) I sent in the previous game. On Wednesday I get the email that my next title shipped. Great, I'll see it Friday or Saturday(a week ago). Nothing arrives.

Support tells me needs to be a week delay and they'll do something for me. SO Wednesday(3 days ago) I contact them and the day after, just this Thursday, they send out a second copy.

Today, I received both in the mail. Like man, what are the chances the game they shipped out Wednesday week and a half ago arrives same day as the one they shipped two days ago? I'm not a conspiracy theorist but man half of me believes they didn't ship anything Wednesday 11 days ago

UPDATE: it took me a while because I was busy with work, but I finally got around to playing and returning saros, and guess what, it's delayed! I swear to baby Jesus, it's usually 2 days(Monday to Wednesday) for they to receive it, as I live in delaware(center in Pennsylvania). Conspiracy theory is that they have flagged my account! It is now Friday and no receipt from gamefly. I would guess usps did it's job and it's sitting somewhere in their warehouse unscanned. I think if they don't fix it with a system or someth, maybe usps tracking, I think I'm out. Moot point anyways maybe, with the disc-apocalypse in 2028


r/gamefly • • Aug 28 '26

Gamefly won’t ship me third game on 3 game plan

1 Upvotes

I was shipped a game on Monday the 17th which never arrived and on Wednesday the 19th on a two game plan. I didn’t receive any games last week which was disappointing given I’m in NJ and I usually get them in 3-4 days to play over the weekend.

On Monday the 24th I got the game from the 19th. I didn’t like the game much and got tired of it after a playing a few hours so I mailed it back and did a self return for it that night. On Tuesday the 25th I got no game on the mail so I reported the game from the 17th lost and it changed to being investigated. Then since one game got lost and was being investigated, I upgraded my plan to the three games to get two games this week while I Gamefly sorts out what happens with the lost game. I had two empty game spots on the 25th after the upgrade, one from my self return and one from my plan upgrade, then Gamefly spent one on a new game from my Q and the other resending me the same game that got lost which still didn’t arrive today 27th. So at the end of the 25th, I had no games at home, 2 just shipped. So where did my third game go?

I decided to contact support around noon on the 26th after seeing no changes to my account on the morning to try to get a game shipped in the afternoon, my only chance to get third game by Saturday, otherwise I wasted one slot a whole week. I got a cookie cutter response that next game ships in 24-48 hours based on availability and deliver in 2-5 days. Meanwhile my account is still messed up and not showing 3 active slots.

Availability? My Q has 8 games. 24-48 hours from what? I self returned the one of the games on Monday, 24-48 hours later means game ships on Wednesday, otherwise self returned is not cutting my “turnaround time in half!” as it took 2-3 days for automatic scans to get the next title shipped most of the times. Third slot is brand new so it should not have to wait 24-48 hours. The only remaining slot is the game that got lost which makes no sense to add a 24-48 hours delay to resend it after Gamefly shipped it who knows where. They have the scans, tell me when and where it last scanned. All the investigation did was add it as lost to my account and resend me the game. If the game was resent as a replacement, why is the same game taking two of my slots? I am being punished for the mail’s mistake. There is no valid reason third game did not ship on Tuesday or Wednesday and still didn’t ship today Thursday, even after I contacted support to ask where is my third game and was ghosted.

Most of the time Gamefly had done a decent job even with shipping delays here and there but this week Gamefly totally dropped the ball. My account is borked and support won’t fix it and I now spent two weeks plus of rental slot on a game that I can go and buy new right now to keep for $20 and my membership is supposed to renew in 2 weeks at $35/month for a 3 game plan I get two games at a time from? Unreal.


r/gamefly • • Sep 22 '26

Nice work, GameFly

Post image
4 Upvotes

It would have been nice if I actually got the game I’ve been waiting a month for first though.


r/gamefly • • Oct 17 '26

Now that Sony is officially discontinuing discs, guess how long til Gamefly leaves the business?

6 Upvotes

I've used the service for a decade or so and have had zero issues with it, aside from the occasional slow shipment. It will be a sad day when they stop doing business but it seems inevitable at this point.

I'd guess they will announce their final year around the time PS6 gets announced but what do I know.


r/gamefly • • 15d ago

Getting the new Xbox instead of PlayStation

3 Upvotes

I’ve been playing the PlayStation since I was 7 on the PS3. Now I’m 27 and still play on the PlayStation with the PS5. I just found out about GameFly January 2025 and I love it. I’m on social security disability because of my schizophrenia and game all day. Ever since they decided to end physical games I knew I would get the new Xbox instead of PS6 because of GameFly. Anyone else doing the same?


r/gamefly • • Jul 15 '26

Why can't I keep the game that I have out?

Post image
7 Upvotes

In the picture I posted i have Persona 5 Tactica currently out why dont i have the option to keep it?


r/gamefly • • Oct 26 '23

Gamefly

Post image
1 Upvotes

Sometimes I really think if Gamefly shipped any games or they just put it as shipped and not ship just so to delay the shipment and get monthly subscription worth for them.


r/gamefly • • Jan 14 '25

Weird and slow shipping the standard?

1 Upvotes

I see a lot of praise for GF in online reviews. I've been using them a few months, and wonder if my experience is different or abnormal. Some, less than half, games arrive in 5-6 days. I'm in Florida, getting them from PA. First class mail from there typically takes 4-5 days. MOST games take 10-18 days to arrive, and can take as long to be checked in when I send them back. The Fast Scan happens right away so I know my mailman isn't keeping it (and he's great in general) and they'll 'send' another one right away, which again I likely won't get for a long time. I have 3 out at once currently.
Most recently it had been well over 2 weeks since one was shipped so I reported it, they said they'd send a replacement. 5 days later the replacement AND the original arrived together.
It is also very common for me to receive a game shipped 8 days after another one before it. I've had 3 send on the same day and gotten them weeks apart. This last one looked like both were actually shipped at the same time after I reported it. If it wasn't for all the other positivity I see, I'd think they had major issues in the shipping/receiving area. I don't have issues with any other mail and send to/from PA plenty using first class.
I just imagine a big shipping pile and receiving pile that they pick from randomly rather than any chronological order, but is my experience non-standard? No idea why it would be, it's all running through the same system.


r/gamefly • • Aug 25 '26

Advice on GameFly?

1 Upvotes

Planning on preordering a game that seems to have a unique case with GameFly. Anyone got any experience with how good or bad GameFly is?


r/gamefly • • Jul 29 '26

Anyone know if The Sinking City 2 is getting a GameFly release?

1 Upvotes

The release is right around the corner (August 18) and I'm super hyped to try it out, but I'm trying to figure out if it'll be available to rent.

Appreciate any insight if someone's spotted a listing somewhere!


r/gamefly • • Apr 17 '25

GameFly is so bad

2 Upvotes

I decided I was going to try it out. Game said it shipped out on Monday and I was expecting to get it on Wednesday. Mind you I order a ton of stuff online and everything that ships usually gets here within 1-3 business days. Mailman came today and still nothing. The one thing that bothers me is your renting games and you have to send them back all for a monthly subscription. So if I am using this service to sit in limbo for 5 days then it’s just not worth it. What a weird company. Seems like a scam if I’m being honest.


r/gamefly • • Jun 01 '24

#Gamefly is a rip off and a cheat. All they do is still steal money from you!

2 Upvotes

r/gamefly • • Oct 18 '26

Anyone Else Preorder Ace Combat From GF?

2 Upvotes

Preordered and received no code for AC0. Their response was simply that they have no codes. wth?? Anyone else?


r/gamefly • • Jul 16 '26

GameFly queue prawn

Post image
3 Upvotes

Not sure why I felt compelled to share this. Upgraded back to the 4 disc plan and my queue is looking particularly sexy today 🔥


r/gamefly • • Apr 29 '26

Switch 2 upgrades

3 Upvotes

Has anyone rented a switch game and bought the upgrade for switch 2 on the Nintendo store?

I am new to switch and game fly so I not sure if that would work or hurt my system.


r/gamefly • • Feb 06 '25

Paying too much money monthly for an inferior service compared to way back when.🤦🏾‍♂️

4 Upvotes

I've been a longtime subscriber of GameFly for years now, since either 2005 or 2006 at least, and for the longest time now, I've had nothing but good things to always say about the service. It was even more so the case since it has since been the only way to actually rent physical games to this day. But nowadays, it's been harder and harder trying to really keep this up with all the glaring issues that have been built up during these last few years.

Whether it be the removal of helpful features on its mobile app like sending you notifications of games being shipped to you are are returned back to them, or something as simple as showing you right from the get go what game has the highest availability rate is making it more infuriating with time now. Nowadays you have to actively add the games over to your Game Q in order to see what the rate is for the game's availability (which for the majority of titles for me has been either low or very low).

With how much more expensive the service has been, especially for the standard two game plan, meaning without the whole GameLock thing they've been advertising lately but charges EXTRA for for some reason, the least they could've done is at least have more games readily available to rent instead of it being a first come first serve basis. And mind you I GET one of the things that made it so liked was the fact that you get to keep your games for as long as you like before you send them back, but with how things are in this economy and how expensive games are nowadays, there has to be more done to make sure we don't end up feeling like we're just GIVING our money away to GameFly in exchange for not getting any games shipped to us BECAUSE of the constantly low availability.

It also doesn't help that when you DO actually get some games shipped to you, they take an absurdly long time to be shipped over to your home. I've had plenty of instances when either one of or both of my games almost half a month or almost a whole month to actually be shipped here even though one of the shipment centers is one that's closest to my hometown in Tennessee. Back then, it never had that much of an issue, typically taking as much as two to three days at the most for most games with high availability or the seemingly rare "NOW" availability, but even with the former, it's been more and more longer to the point where even my patience was tested a lot at times. Again, it also gets more infuriating when you continue to remind yourself that you're paying nearly thirty bucks a month for this...

I really want to continue liking this service to this day even while stuff like Xbox Game Pass exists but when the overall experience has been getting much worse these days, I really hate to consider ending my near twenty year long membership with the service if they don't try to fix these issues and try to get the site back to where it was in their glory years.


r/gamefly • • 17d ago

Did anyone’s Ocarina of Time ship yet?

4 Upvotes

Surprised to see mine has not shipped, as usually they send it a couple days before release date.


r/gamefly • • 24d ago

Mafia for ps4

4 Upvotes

Where did you go?


r/gamefly • • 4d ago

How is the service today?

4 Upvotes

Haven't used GF in years. Thinking about putting on the budget plan ($13?/month) since I have a huge backlog and my PS+ is expiring. The biggest gain would be the ability to choose what I want to play.

Thnx.


r/gamefly • • Jun 21 '26

Hows gamefly

4 Upvotes

Considering trying gamefly out i heard about them as a kid but being an adult and seeing this 30 day free trial makes me even more tempted to see what it's about. This 007 is what I want to try.


r/gamefly • • 15d ago

Time to go

15 Upvotes

Well after being with gamefly for 16 years i think our time together is coming to an end. Returns are taking 4-6 weeks and new games are taking 2-3 weeks. Zelda will be my last game rental.