r/gamecollecting • u/[deleted] • Jan 09 '24
r/gamecollecting • u/MediumDogMedia • Mar 13 '22
Collection State of the Collection: Graded Final Fantasy
r/gamecollecting • u/[deleted] • Jun 27 '24
Discussion I see you with your Lego Marvel at Walmart and raise you this $300 copy of Pac-Man and the Ghostly Adventures 2 for the 360 that's been sitting at my Walmart for years
r/gamecollecting • u/Fit-Significance7516 • Feb 19 '23
Haul Make sure you are checking your local GameStops folks 😎
r/gamecollecting • u/[deleted] • Aug 22 '24
Discussion Limited Run Games sucks.
I do not appreciate what they do for the most part. Everything they make and it's aftermarket is just ridiculous. The only thing I recall purchasing from them was Scott Pilgrim Versus the World collectors. To be fair it is very high quality and neat. Probably one of my favorite things in my collection but hot dang does it create such an awful resale market. I never have the money for the stuff I want from them at the time that they are actually offering pre-orders. I don't even know how long it took for my collector's edition to arrive because it was months between ordering it and actually getting it. They make cool stuff sure but I feel like it's just unethical. Some part of me just feels like it's gross.
Does anyone else feel this way?
r/gamecollecting • u/KaleidoscopeNo5401 • Jun 08 '25
Haul Talked him down from $100 to $60. I couldn't be happier
r/gamecollecting • u/Shot_Background5682 • Dec 25 '22
Haul Parents got this for me for Christmas and I think it’s pretty cool. My first graded video game
r/gamecollecting • u/MindPrize1260 • Oct 18 '24
Collection Sealed silent hill from my collection
r/gamecollecting • u/taiomi • Feb 17 '22
Collection Debug PS1 £16.99 - Good Deal?
r/gamecollecting • u/Aldelia • Oct 02 '26
Collection Parents Moving, So Getting My Old Stuff
r/gamecollecting • u/Luvsvng • Oct 10 '26
Discussion Lowballed hard hard by retro game store in rhode island
Was buying a crtv off facebook marketplace to play some dreamcast at my partners house without having to bring my retro tink. the meet up was in front of a popular retro store so i decided to walk in.
Wanted to humor what a retro game store would offer me for these games.
Rudely slammed my games back on the counter after crunching numbers and said 180 for gunbird 2, silent scope, plasma sword, sonic adventure, jet grind radio. Then told me cannon spike and gigawing were too scratched when its just general use.
I knew i was gonna have a laugh but didnt expect 180
r/gamecollecting • u/Unlikely_Word_4142 • Aug 20 '25
Haul Did I just win the jackpot?
A friend of my cousin wanted to sell his collection to travel around Europe by bus. He wanted to sell his collection, and I could take everything for 250 euros. In addition to the items on the photo's, there were also a number of Game Boy games like Pokemon Blue and Gold.
Did I hit the jackpot?
r/gamecollecting • u/Independent_Home9746 • 16d ago
Discussion Hot take: actively buying and keeping sealed games without the intent to play them is stupid
What’s the point in buying anything sealed for example what’s the point in buying a vacuum cleaner if you’re not gonna open it you’re just wasting your money at that point unless you’re a reseller?? do you guys own any sealed games? What’s your reasoning for that?
r/gamecollecting • u/Aidenspeedcuber11 • Jun 11 '25
Collection What do yall think about my setup?
r/gamecollecting • u/GetTheGregGames • Jul 17 '23
Collection Still can't believe I have this. One of my favorite collection pieces!
r/gamecollecting • u/rdools • Sep 10 '23
Discussion What game should I add next to the collection?
r/gamecollecting • u/IDownvoteHauls • Sep 18 '20
Discussion Please downvote all 3D All Stars Posts to Keep Quality Posts at the Top
PSA
r/gamecollecting • u/BlueMikeStu • Jun 01 '26
Collection The Hell of Selling a Collection: How to navigate the paring your collection down headache free selling to retro stores.
As stated, I'm currently in the process of liquidating a games collection which I knew was valuable but wound up being... significantly worth more than my original, most wildly optimistic estimates. The problem I faced was that my collection is sufficiently large enough that I'm not exactly eager to eBay all 1300+ games in my collection as individual listings or deal with the headache of making that many individual sales and then packaging and shipping that many games. Even if I could theoretically get all of them sold relatively quickly, processing and mailing them out would not be.
So I started calling retro game shops in and around Toronto and being up front and asking some questions, and if you're thinking of selling your collection entirely or significantly paring it down, here's some helpful advice that you'll want to keep in mind.
If they won't offer an estimate over the phone or via email for a relatively valuable title claiming they need to see it in person, they are wasting your time.
I know this should be obvious, but anyone doing this wants you in the store with the game in hand so you'll feel more pressured to take their cash offer in person, even if it's a little less than what you want. The money is right there, after all. You can just let the game go and walk away with cash in hand. That's what they want.
If they're already trying to manipulate you at this stage, they're operating in bad faith as their first interaction with you. Just write them off, because there's more stores out there.
Do your research and evaluate your entire collection, not just the ones you THINK are valuable. Know what you have.
If you'd told me that my Xbox 360 copy of 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand without a manual was worth more than my CIB copy of Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn a year ago, I'd have laughed in your face, but that is the exact reality of the retro market today: Prices are crazy.
Additionally, you might not even think that some games you own are valuable just because you got them cheap and didn't really think much about them. That's the case with one game in my current collection that I'm selling.
Excluding variants and the like, Blood Will Tell, a PS2 game based on the Dororo manga, is the 8th most valuable game on the retro market for NTSC PS2 if complete in box. It is more valuable to collectors than well-known titles like Silent Hill 3, Xenosaga III, God Hand, Samurai Western, and in the same condition, and the difference isn't small: Sold at current price, I could buy a copy of any of those games and have enough to spare to throw a copy of Fatal Frame on top, and if I wanted to go the other way I could probably negotiate a copy of Haunting Ground with some extra cash for the trade.
Hell, in a million years I'd never have assumed Red Ninja: End of Honor was anywhere near the top 50 most valuable PS2 games of all time by today's market, and worth more than Raidou 2, Fatal Frame, or Shadow Hearts Covenant. I would have traded any of those for it in a heartbeat before I really checked my collection.
Check what you have.
Once you know what you have, be realistic about the price, but realize your own position.
While I said you should check Price Charting, do not expect to get the full value or anywhere near that if you're going to be selling your collection as a bulk deal. Whoever does buy them from you is taking on the liability and risk that some of the titles might not sell at all, or might drop in price before they sell them. If you want near market value, you need to sell them yourself, but that's something you're going to want to think about as well.
My buyer offered me 65% cash for my collection, and that's a fair trade in my books, because he's taking the cherries of the lot with the less appealing stuff. I very much doubt he'd be willing to give me that sort of sweetheart deal if I tried to keep God Hand, Blood Will Tell, and all my really expensive items to myself. Items like that are your bargaining power to get 65% cash for the Drakengard trilogy, Neir, and Bullet Witch. To get 65% cash for 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand.
Before calling any retro shop, check their online inventory to see what kind of margin they're expecting to make from your collection
When I called a store in Lindsay, Ontario, the guy on the other end of the phone offered me just $100CAD for God Hand. On the day I called, price charting had it sitting around $330. When he claimed it was maybe becauhe last sold one a while back, I kinda let it slide, but he then turned around and offered me $60 for my copy of Radiant Dawn CIB when he was selling an identical copy on his online store for $169.99.
If they try to tell you they have to take a 65% cut of the market value, they are lowballing you. Most of the games that are rare and expensive enough to be sold for over a hundred dollars generally can be moved pretty quickly if they really want them to. They can price it as a Buy It Now item at 10% below the fair market value on eBay, set a reserve at 75%, and it will generally be bought and paid for within five days at the most.
Besides, your the one with the product, not them. Without you, their profit is fucking zero dollars. Without them, you WILL find someone else willing to pay more. Don't let them take you for the bulk of the value and don't let them sob about their finances. If they're unable to make a profit off the current retro market, they are fucking something up drastically and it's not your issue to handle or your burden to share with them.
A 35% net profit margin is a fantastic deal for them. Most retailers have a 30-50% gross profit margin, but their net profit is closer to 4-6%. Them flipping one game is not going to be anywhere close to eliminating 25%+ of the total value as operating expenses.
Do not trust companies which offer to take and evaluate your collection for you.
This should be obvious, but until cash changes hands, you should have control over your collection, not them. If a single item is valuable enough to be worth hundreds of dollars, you have no reason to blindly trust another party to tell you how much they'll give you for it when they have it in hand and out of your control.
That's how you get told the games are barely worth anything, and then you might lose some items when they're being shipped back as they play the "he did it" game with the post office. If it's worth enough to worry about, it's worth enough to handle the transaction in person.
Don't let them convince you THEY don't need your collection or allow them to act like it
This one is a sore spot, and I'm going to specifically call out Power Up Gaming on this one, but this applies to many stores I've called in general: They are going to act like they're doing you a favor taking your collection, when it is very much the other way around if you've got a significant enough collection.
My collection kicks the shit out of their valuable stock on PS1, PS2, Wii, Xbox 360, etc. When you sort their items highest to lowest in those categories on their storefront, I have more of the titles they have listed there on hand, as 90% of those titles are listed as Out of Stock. They don't have them, they just have prices they'd want to sell them to anyone interested in them listed if they ever do get one.
When I emailed them a sample list, they were rude, condescending, and basically treated me like I was a weird alien creature for asking them to provide a quote for a hypothetical cash deal of 49 games that total over $4300 CAD. I don't know if they're just that arrogant or if they're only looking for easy marks to lowball, but anyone who tries to lowball you or tell you how much stock they're swimming in are all lying to you.
If they were really getting that much stock and selling it at the prices listed, they would be eager to take your collection for the quick 35% profit margin they'd get, because they flip their games so quick, right? I mean, if someone offered you a $10,000 item you could sell the next day for $6500, would you really dismiss them and not just thank them and pay them?
That said, you can only take this approach when your collection is fucking BIG enough to warrant this treatment. Don't throw your weight around if the bulk of your collection would be more economically viable as coaster sales and not vintage collectibles.
Conclusion: Be smart, be educated, and be aware of your negotiating power
About the only aside I can say of all this is that unless someone is willing to take your ENTIRE offering at a price you're happy with, if they request you divy it up into sales lots they can handle in batch purchases for cash flow reasons, make sure you don't front-load them with all the most expensive titles and spread everything out evenly.
I'm not going to be putting God Hand, Blood Will Tell, etc all in my first lot. I'm going to be showing them to my buyer to prove I have them, but he's going to have to eat his veggies and buy the lower-cost stuff as well if he wants them. If you get to the point where you've got none of the smoking hot items and crown jewels left and are just stuck with the $40-$60 stuff, you've lost your bargaining chips and might not ever move them, because they will take those a lot more readily when it comes with Rule of Rose in the box.
Be safe, be smart, and if you don't want to sell, more power to you.
r/gamecollecting • u/chicken69696 • May 23 '22