Right now, me and several other of my friends who were accepted to FSU have decided to enroll elsewhere, at least unless there are major policy changes made.
Reason being, FSU is using ridiculously draconian academic software for their online curriculums. Honorlock and Zoom, just to name a few, are of major concern to me and other students. We're all seniors who were planning to attend FSU starting this year, but pretty much changed our mind after learning about their use of programs like Honorlock and Zoom.
I know Honorlock's already got a reputation as a shady remote proctoring service that's basically malware, but if you look into Zoom you'll find complaints of a significant number of security issues and privacy flaws as well. There's a whole list of things that make it worrisome, but some of the main things are 1) it tracks all your computer activity even when you’re not using it, 2) zoom enables professors to record the video conference footage of students without notifying them, and 3) it allows other websites access to your webcam without asking permission. Even if you uninstall it, the software basically overwrites your computer once its downloaded, so that it can still do all these things regardless of whether it’s installed or not. Zoom is a disaster in terms of cybersecurity and making it one of the only options for online class participation/communication is really terrible.
I know that the Covid-19 pandemic necessitates switching to online courses, but that's no excuse for implementing these downright authoritarian surveillance policies the school claims are merely to “prevent cheating".
The difference is that before this pandemic, online classes were up to the student so they knew what they were agreeing to -- you could still do classes and tests in person if you wanted. Currently, that's no longer an option.
And even if classes resume face-to-face for fall semester, what if there's another coronavirus outbreak in the winter? What if the school decides to move classes online again for flu season or something, since everyone will be used to the fully-virtual curriculum by then?
A lot of incoming freshmen have been learning about Zoom and the online proctoring services, and figured out that the level of control these websites possess over the students is straight out of 1984. The level of recording, tracking, and monitoring is downright dystopian and has no place in an otherwise incredible university. It’s an embarrassment.
I know a lot seniors, more than you’d think, who were accepted to major institutions this year — but have turned it down in favor of attending community colleges, which don’t use Orwellian computer software to watch & record students’ every move.
This pandemic has made it abundantly clear that in the event of fully-online classes, colleges will prioritize their reputation as a ‘superior university’ over the personal security and safety of its students. Personally, I will not be attending FSU, and neither will several of my friends. I’m disappointed in their decision to implement these policies — and while I’m fully aware that the programs aren’t mandatory and are used at individual professors’ discretion, it doesn’t change the fact that FSU allowing these kinds of measures being taken at all is backwards, and disrespectful to the entire student body. FSU was my dream school — but I simply can’t justify signing away my rights to attend. In doing so, I’d be sacrificing so many things. For those of you wondering what I mean, here’s an example of why Honorlock sucks.
Students can take the same online classes for cheaper at a community college without the intensive tracking.
The biggest advantage major universities have over community colleges is the strong student body, welcoming atmosphere and sense of community from attending a selective school. Basically, universities offer “the college experience” that CC’s don’t. But when you move partially or fully online, that advantage goes away when students are isolated at home learning from a computer 24/7.
Classes are online at both CC’s and major universities so there’s not much difference. The way I see it, I can pay tens of thousands a year to take online classes and be tracked incessantly. Or I can pay less than half of that price to take online classes at a CC that actually trusts its students. You are learning essentially the same thing from both, but what made FSU and similar places special was the in-person, on-campus experience. That’s gone for now, and I’ve got a feeling even when classes resume normally that mandatory online courses could easily be re-implemented in the event of another outbreak. Anything that remotely inconveniences the school could prompt them to switch to online classes again, since it’s fully integrated at this point and easier/cheaper to do.
Those of us choosing to enroll elsewhere are very upset, as none of us wanted this — we all dreamed of FSU for years. I’m posting here as a voice for incoming seniors who are hoping that FSU changes their policies regarding the use of invasive and untrustworthy academic services. It’s a difficult decision to make, but as concerns regarding surveillance and online privacy grow, students are realizing that it’s not worth it to sacrifice their safety for the sake of convenience.
If any of you are in touch with FSU’s president or campus administration, please tell them about us. We really do want to attend — so, so much. It’s an incredible school. But no school is incredible enough justify giving up our privacy rights and personal security.