I just finished watching Friday Night Lights for the first time, and I have some thoughts.
Overall, I loved the show, and for the most part liked the finale and how most characters’ arcs ended. I especially love what they did with Coach Taylor and Tammy. I think that was absolutely perfect.
My main issues were with three characters: Tim, Landry, and Luke.
With Tim, I think they were going for this happy ending where he ended up with his dream from the first season of owning some land in the country and Texas forever and everything. But to me it just felt sad.
When Tim said he didn’t want his brother to speak at his parole hearing, and they said he’d been keeping his head down and taking classes, I was really hoping they were going to show him having matured a lot in prison, and I was really hoping that him being sober for a long stretch of time was going to impact him more.
I thought this is where they were going when he didn’t want anything to do with his brother, and I was hoping he was going to resent his brother for not only enabling but actively encouraging his teenage alcoholism. I was really hoping that once he got out he was going to show that being sober had given him clarity and had lead to him realizing he could make something of his life and have some aspirations other than owning land, some sort of purpose or passion for something.
Instead he got out and immediately went back to being an alcoholic. It was just sad. There was no growth, other than him not wanting to commit crimes, but that was unnecessary because he hadn’t wanted to commit crimes in the first place and had tried to get his brother to stop initially. This would have made more sense if he really had been the one behind the chop chop idea, but he wasn’t, so it didn’t make much sense and left his storyline feeling pretty stagnant.
I also didn’t like what they did with Tyra and Tim being some kind of star crossed lovers or something. It felt very out of nowhere to me, especially since they’d already done the whole star crossed lovers thing between Tim and Lyla.
As an aside, I really hated that this also made it so that Tyra seemed like she’d had almost no growth as a character, either. She’d been off in Austin for a couple years but still seemed more or less the same, other than having different hair and now having nebulous political aspirations. I’d have loved to see her be a different, more mature person from her time away from Dylan.
But my biggest complaint ties in with my next point of contention: how they treated Landry.
If nothing else, I’d have much preferred a scene between Landry and Tyra. After everything that happened between them, I’d have loved for Tyra to apologize to Landry for how she’d treated him. Something. I’d also really have loved any sort of update with Landry, about how he’s doing at college, what he’s studying, what he’s been up to, how he’s liking living in the city. Anything! For as important of a character he was in the show, for them to bring him back only for him to have a short, one-sided conversation with Matt was crap.
And finally we have Luke. I don’t even know where to begin with Luke, but it feels like the writers actively hated Landry and Luke. Every chance they got they treated them badly.
My biggest complaint is that Luke not getting any college interest at all is nonsensical. It’d be one thing if they’d had two crappy seasons. It’d be another thing if nobody on the team was getting attention from recruiters. But for Vince to be getting all this college attention and Luke to get none legitimately doesn’t make sense.
It really does feel like the writers didn’t like his character. They wrote an entire storyline of how colleges only wanted Vince even though Luke was an incredible player. Luke in his two years playing for the Lions played halfback, fullback, wide receiver, defensive back, and quarterback. He excelled at every position except quarterback. He hit a guy so hard they did an investigation into it! He literally seemed like a better player than Smash or Tim. He was much more dynamic and integral to the team. For him to not get ANY attention makes zero sense.
Even apart from that, it really frustrates me how Coach Taylor treated Luke. Luke showed up every single time, no questions asked. He gave 110% for the team every single time, and not one time did Coach Taylor give him any sort of appreciation. But my biggest issue with it is that one of their first interactions, Coach Taylor told Luke that if he showed up and worked hard, he would do everything in his power to get Luke a scholarship. And then there was none of that. He didn’t do anything with Luke like he’d done with Smash. He moved heaven and earth to get Smash a scholarship. If he’d put in 1% of that same energy, Luke would have gotten something.
It’s frustrating too, because this could have been a perfect opportunity for them to show other paths to college/professional football, like being a walk-on somewhere, or playing at a junior college and then transferring. Instead they just had Luke give up and go join the Army. I hated it. His character deserved better. It feels like they were going with this weird “nice guys finish last” kind of message with both Landry and Luke. Yuck.