r/freemagic • • 3d ago

DRAMA Mtg should grow a pair and come up with an entire obese set. This is apparently what people want, so give it to them!

Post image
828 Upvotes

why stop at Harbinger of the seas. let’s reskin all the classics.

The interesting thing about harbinger of the seas is it still resembles the original, just fatter. this was genius. if you have any other ideas of crusty old cards that need a good revamp, feel free to share them so we can give mtg some more inspiration.

let’s make this happen everyone!


r/freemagic • • 3d ago

DRAMA I trained trained the fastest most accurate recognition model. Got rejected for "AI."

276 Upvotes

I’ve been a software engineer for 15 years, since long before the LLM hype. Over the last months I built a Magic card scanner around an idea I haven’t seen anyone else use: treat cards like faces.

Face recognition models are built to identify one specific face out of millions, in bad light, at odd angles, in a fraction of a second. So I took that kind of model and retrained it to recognize Magic cards instead. I trained it myself, on my own H100. There’s no API and no cloud service involved, and it isn’t somebody else’s model with my logo on it.

The result:

  • It identifies the exact printing, even for basic lands.

  • Lighting mostly stops mattering. A dim kitchen table or glare from a sleeve is fine.

  • It runs at around 50 cards per second. That’s theoretical, because nobody can flip cards that fast.

  • The phone’s gyroscope deskews the shot before recognition even starts.

That’s a fraction of the time every scanner app I’ve tried needs.

So why am I bragging? Because I’m pissed.

I asked the mods of one of the biggest MTG subreddits whether I could post a public beta invite. It’s a free app with no ads, and I have no financial interest. I got a no, and part of the reason was a “zero tolerance policy against AI.”

AI? This is computer vision. It’s the same category of tech as every card scanner you’ve ever used, just faster. It doesn’t generate art or text, and it replaces no artist. It looks at a card and tells you which card it is.

Somewhere along the way “AI” became a single word for “thing I don’t like,” and months of actual engineering get thrown out with the slop.

Can you feel me?

UPDATE:

Thanks guys for all your support. Wasn't expecting that the Post here on Freemagic would actually be released since it was initially blocked by Reddit for some Reason. We already had a great Discussion Yesterday in the Crosspost over here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TCG/comments/1xzo1kq/ And you really built me up there! Learned so many and regained a lot of faith in the Community.

I will answer every one of your comments, just at work currently.

The app btw:

https://app.mtgscan.org / https://testflight.apple.com/join/WFdFxdq2

To outline the toxicity and the tone used by so called moderators:
https://i.postimg.cc/9fX53YLV/image.png
https://i.postimg.cc/Cx3YWqWB/image.png

Update 2:

A talented Frontend Dev from the Community reached me a Hand and we cleared up some small things that led to the AI-Slopp-ish Look of the App. User wants to stay anonymous, tanks tho!!!

It's updated in Testflight. And new Video on https://app.mtgscan.org/

Because my DMs are full of Android Questions:
- It works on Android, same features, same performance etc. But i do not have a Google Store Account thats Approved yet. This can take up to a Week as far as i understood them. Then they want me to publish the Android Version to a Beta Store (like Testflight i guess) and there i need a certain number of Users over a certain time before i can publish the App on the normal Store... I am working on it!

Update 3:

I figured out a strategy to deliver a working Android Version to you guys Tomrrow! Stay tuned.

Also i am keeping Track of all your Feature Requests, Ideas, useful Feedback from every single one of you. I added a Page to organize it all and make it easily Trackable for you guys too:

https://app.mtgscan.org/roadmap

Thanks for Participating in the Beta :)


r/freemagic • • 3d ago

VIDEO You boys seen this? 1997 MTV x Magic

95 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 3d ago

NSFW For that one whale NSFW

Post image
173 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 3d ago

DRAMA Even the designers at Wizards realized how bad these characters were

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Culber and Stamets were clearly a top-down design that started with the suggestion "we need two men to kiss on-camera every other episode". They never really evolved beyond that as characters. Gray and Adira were also just there to check diversity boxes and made the show worse every minute they were on camera. Wise of the designers to only waste one card per pair instead of two.


r/freemagic • • 2d ago

ART What do you think?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Is this the classic art style you guys have been asking for?


r/freemagic • • 3d ago

DRAMA Apparently Wizards is now blocking anyone who criticizes their game, even if it wasn't spoken directly to them

Thumbnail
gallery
81 Upvotes

And for good measure, I checked if maybe this person said anything to Wizards, and nope!

Nothing.


r/freemagic • • 4d ago

GENERAL the main sub when you say you dont like UB 😬

Post image
289 Upvotes

sorry for being a long time fan who only likes magic cards 🤷‍♀️


r/freemagic • • 4d ago

DRAMA As someone who's been playing Magic since 1995, the new Harbinger of the Seas art is an absolute disgrace.

160 Upvotes

I've been playing Magic: The Gathering since 1995. Back when creatures looked like CREATURES, women looked like WOMEN, and you could tell what a card did just by looking at the art.

Now Wizards expects me to believe this new textless Harbinger of the Seas is a mermaid? I'm sorry, but since when did mermaids look like THAT?

I remember when Magic had artistic integrity. Now we're supposed to applaud this blatant pandering?

And don't even get me started on the fact that the card has NO TEXT. I've spent 31 years learning to read Magic cards, and now apparently that's offensive too.

Anyway my name is Joven, if you are in Providence, Rhode Island and are looking to play a game of standard, hit me up.

See you all at prerelease.


r/freemagic • • 4d ago

DRAMA Copium over 9000! “The merfolk need blubber to stay warm that why xir is obese”

Post image
165 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 4d ago

GENERAL 17 posts on this sub about the new Harbinger of the Seas full art

29 Upvotes

Seems like a lot huh


r/freemagic • • 4d ago

GENERAL Reconnaissance on a stick, but I don't know how to build a deck around it

Post image
11 Upvotes

Backstory first. One of favorite cards in magic's history is reconnaissance. I love how early you can get it out and can easily do attack triggers and not have issues. I put it in a few of my decks and have nothing but excitement when I play it.

For the current day. My friend asked me if I pulled nivea in my mystery booster box, and yes I did. He told me I should build it, but I told him why would I built a commander to just make an akroma token. He then told me to reread and I realized it was we're reconnaissance on a commander. I been scouting and looking for unique ways of building her to be a good bracket 3 deck, but I can't even think of something.

So do any of y'all have any ideas of how to build this commander in a unique way. I really want to build this deck for my love of reconnaissance.


r/freemagic • • 5d ago

FUNNY Whale tribal

Post image
230 Upvotes

Anyone else picking this up for their whale or sea monster tribal decks?


r/freemagic • • 5d ago

ART Flavorful?

Post image
38 Upvotes

did it capture the essence of mario?


r/freemagic • • 5d ago

DRAMA Triple Fixed Aragorn with AI

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 5d ago

NSFW For that one conquistador NSFW

Post image
99 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 5d ago

DRAMA From the depths of the Deep Fried Sea she comes

24 Upvotes

Wizards working with Burger King really left a mark on the merfolk.


r/freemagic • • 4d ago

DRAMA I was Shadowbanned

0 Upvotes

This is literally the only Leddit I use.

Why the hell was I shadowbanned?

u/Gunnarsonsnewbag2


r/freemagic • • 6d ago

SPOILERS Hambringer of the Seas

Post image
177 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 6d ago

FUNNY She's So Beautiful They Had to Turn Off Commenting

Post image
379 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 5d ago

GENERAL I made a chess clock life counter.

3 Upvotes

Apologies if this isn't allowed.

I've been working since mid-September on making a working life counter with a chess clock in it, and I'm looking for user feedback / suggestions from actual Magic players.

The idea is for it to be like any old life counter but with a chess clock w/ increments. I also implemented priority handling to keep people engaged, which I have yet to see any other MTG app do in a good way.

Unfortunately it's only available for Android, as Apple wants 99€ a year for me to publish anything there 💀💀. You can probably get it running on your own iOS device if you compile it yourself.

No ads. I don't make any money off of this, and I have no plans to monetize it. I just want to play a reasonably paced game, and of course if you don't like the chess clock you can disable it entirely to just have a normal life counter.

The reason I made this to begin with is because I've spent far too many hours stuck in games that dragged on for ages, and I'm too polite to scoop mid-game. :(

Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.kapsyloffer.rope

Github:

https://github.com/Kapsyloffer/ROPE

Lemme know if you think it sucks or nah 💪


r/freemagic • • 5d ago

GENERAL Random Legendary Creature

5 Upvotes

**Try it out here:
https://randcommander.netlify.app/

Once again, I’ve solved a problem that didn’t really exist and nobody but me will care about.

Skyfall has a button on the main page that will return a random Magic card. Using that I made a link that will return a random legendary creature that is more than one color.

Often I want to make a new deck, but don’t know which commander to choose so I will repeatedly load this page to keep getting random legendary creatures. I decided to take it a step further and make my own local HTML file that I can load up on the browser on my phone and click a button and do the same thing. There’s also a search box so you can tailor the search to whatever you want.


r/freemagic • • 6d ago

DRAMA Apparently you are not allowed to talk about this card on the other subreddits

Post image
244 Upvotes

r/freemagic • • 4d ago

ART Could Aragorn actually be ambidextrous?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Inb4: sincerely trying NOT trying to incite UB hate, nor discussions on skin colour.

Was looking to buy singles, and in considering some variants I noticed that in some art, Aragorn is wielding his sword in his left; some in his right hand. I’m curious as to how this came about: inconsistencies in artist briefs, mirroring of final art (for compositional reasons?) or just fuck-all draw whatever (which leads back to art direction?), or lack of a continuity department.

Or, could UB Aragorn be truly ambidextrous?

Disclaimer: I’m not a book reader (yet), but did searches and nothing seems to claim that Tolkien stated Aragorn was ambidextrous or otherwise. Only mention of left-handed wielding is film Aragorn in a scene at Helm’s Deep.

Personally, I wish UB sets/blocks came with their own official set of lore if they’re doing new takes on canonical aspects or character traits. Yet, I wonder, if ever published, that books, articles, etc would garner more hate (whether deserved or not) and could tank the set releases, especially if the variants are super or jarringly different.

Again, this isn’t bait, sincerely. Thanks in advance :)