r/foucault • • Feb 18 '23

Help with Foucault

0 Upvotes

Currently attempting to write an essay on "Foucaults Hypothesis: from the critique Juridico-discursive concept of power to the analytics of government," by Thomas Lemke at university level, im struggling because I'm not versed at this as it's an outside module. We have to focus on a specific section, and I'm thinking of focusing on "3.1 government as conduct" would anyone be able to help clarify some strengths and weaknesses of this section, and some thing I could talk about or argue. Thanks. Help is much appreciated.


r/foucault • • 14d ago

History of sexuality as a beginner

0 Upvotes

I am thinking about reading history of sexuality. I am an engineering major and I haven't read such things ever. I want to read about sex in the way that I imagine Foucault writes about it (from the memes lol). Is it a very heavy series of books? Can I read Vol1 and read the rest later? Can I read it a s a beginner? Will I (at all) learn about pornography and how it relates to sexual desire? I mean this in a specific way: I understand porn was different back then. Maybe even non existent, I don't really know. But can the information of the book be used to analyze the use of pornography and how it relates to sexual desire? Or do I need a psychoanalysis or psychology book for this?

And most importantly: Would a 300 page introduction to Foucault make my life easier or would I just waste my time. I see in the contents of this 300page book that sexuality is not mentioned.

Contents

Abbreviations of Foucault's works

Editor's preface

Why Foucault?

Key concepts

Archaeology

Genealogy

Care of the self

Foucault's detour A

fter Foucault

Further reading

References

Index


r/foucault • • Jan 13 '23

Foucaults enemies

0 Upvotes

I’m a libertarian in most of my thinking on economics and culture at large. It is not hard to see thus why I have profound respect for Foucaults idea and explanation. Foucault is extremely disliked by conservatists and Marxism alike. The latter might have not forgiven him for leaving in the 60s since he disliked their overarching narrative, their liking of the Soviet Union and their antisemitism. The conservatist arguments are much harder to parse apart since almost everything they are complaining about (like too much “scientism” around COVID, and lack of free speech) is EXACTLY those subjects that was much dearest to Foucault (I am refering to biopower and parrhesia). Where does this utter disdain for Foucault among conservatists come from? From Roger Scruton? From Stephen “I got most things wrong” Hicks?


r/foucault • • Dec 10 '24

The Guy Sorman accusations

Thumbnail
aljazeera.com
1 Upvotes

I was sent this article by a conservative friend of mine. Obviously i don’t think it impacts the value of his philosophy but it sounds pretty bad.

https://centremichelfoucault.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Communiqué-Foucault_English-rev-2.pdf

This article claims journalists investigated this and found it to be false but the articles are in a foreign language.

Does anyone have any information on this? Thanks


r/foucault • • Dec 10 '24

Foucault on standardization of time

2 Upvotes

I vaguely remember a text by Foucault where he discussed about how time was standardized into neat 24 hours as a means of control. Or am I mistaken? Does anyone have any recommendations about standardization of time from the works of Foucault? I would greatly appreciate it!


r/foucault • • Feb 04 '20

Artaud Quote about Madness

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/foucault • • Jul 25 '26

Where to Begin with Foucault's Birth?

3 Upvotes

Dans le grondement qui nous ébranle aujourd'hui, il faut peut-être reconnaître la naissance d'un monde où l'on saura que le sujet n'est pas un, mais scindé, non pas souverain, mais dépendant, non pas origine absolue, mais fonction sans cesse modifiable. - «La naissance d'un monde» (entretien avec J.-M. Palmier), Le Monde, supplément : Le Monde des livres, no 7558, 3 mai 1969, p. VIII.

Fast approaches the 100th anniversary of Foucault’s birth into the 'socially conservative, upper-middle-class,' intellectual-medical milieu of Portiers, which begs the question…

Where to begin with birth?¹ The womb? That maiden milieu which gestates an irruption?² The dispositive matrices and clusters of juridico-political force which configure the conditions of emergence of an object as knowledge and its problematic contemplation as an instrument of reflection and analysis?³

Should we paradoxically begin with the post-natal void which forms as the birthed object is able to be conceived as such, that which both sketches natality's historical formation and portends more natality to come? Or perhaps we must perpetually part from the placental sac’s mutable sphericity, as it sustains our floating and then facilitates our falling, all while remaining residual and even marginal, thus mirroring our increasingly terminal, dividual existence.

"[...] a political marginalism in which the individual has value only as a marginal unit, destined to live, to work, to produce, to consume, or to die."- «The Political Technology of Individuals», Vermont, October 1982; in Dits et écrits, texte n° 364 (vol. IV).

Perchance conception and not gestation should be the point of departure, as is only natural?⁴ Corte ist die Stadt der Empfängniß Napoleon’s: wie ich ausgerechnet habe.” – Nietzsche [BVN-1886,734]

Or maybe neither, since Foucault pluralizes the word and denies it a singular: there are only naissances: technico-institutional, dispersed, dated, machined.¹⁷ And where he does fix a birthday, he fixes it while telling us, in the same paragraph, that the fixing is unjust.¹⁸

Next we come to the nativity, itself a long and painful process, which can be found in book titles (Birth of the Clinic), course titles (Birth of Biopolitics), subtitles (Birth of the Prison), lecture titles (Birth of Social Medicine), chapter titles (Birth of the Asylum)… and which can be bifurcated into non-discursive institutional births (e.g. police and prisons being birthed hand in hand),⁵ and analytico-discursive births such as population, security, politico-economic knowledges, human species and milieu,⁶ prison, normation, delinquent and discipline; or Foucault’s own coinings and novel uses, such as bio-politics in Brazil’s Naissance de la médecine sociale and biopower in the College of France course Sécurité, Territoire, Population⁷, etc.⁸

To the bifurcation a third class must be added, and it is the one the corpus performs rather than states: the six births Foucault narrates aloud and then withdraws in his own hand, on the same page, in the same hour.¹⁹

Among these births and emergences, some are spoken and retracted in writing; some are written and never spoken; some reach us only as a translator’s restitution, into French, of a language Foucault never wrote.¹⁶ A genealogy of naissance in Foucault must first genealogise the archive in which the word is printed.

We then have the events of escape, the lines of flight which construct Foucault’s disconfigured, anti-strategic an-archeology of counter-conduct.⁹ One might state that the 'final' yet interminable flight, signalled already in History of Madness, is ethics: the relation with and government of self and other. Other flights include the pleb¹⁰ and the aforementioned truth-telling itself, along with abortive escape attempts such as bio-poetics¹. If the criminal has replaced the offender, and if he must confess not simply what he has done but what he is, then can truth-telling be anything other than "the splinter, the wound, the line of flight, the breach in the entire penal system?"¹.

« Cette autre question de la véridiction du sujet est à la fois l'épine, l'écharde, la plaie, la ligne de fuite, la brèche de tout le système pénal. » - Mal faire, dire vrai, p. 275.

Ligne de fuite, predominately Deleuze’s phrase, is in some ways advanced as a correction of Foucault (see: Desir et Plaisir) rather than a gloss upon him,²¹ which is interesting, since the single occurrence of la ligne de fuite in the received French of the corpus names not a conventional escape mechanism; it's worth repeating that the very confessional apparatus²² which characterizes pastoral power is also tied to the solitary mention by Foucault of this Deleuze-Guattarian expression. Foucault’s own lexicon for the same field runs to a dozen terms, and when he was offered five well-built words for it he took the ugliest: counter-conduct, on stated grounds.²³

And to the four registers of conceptual fate: coined-and-kept, coined-and-stillborn, weighed-and-refused-aloud, used-and-publicly-repudiated, a fifth must be added: les seuils, the words Foucault takes from the archive rather than coining.²⁴ A threshold cannot be stillborn; it was never his to bear. The aveu is a seuil; biopoétique is not. The distinction is what separates a Herkunft from an Entstehung in his own vocabulary.

Finally, we have birth rate (control and stimulation) as an instrument of punitive society, governmentality and pastoral power (immaculate birth, and rebirth as baptism/penance),¹² along with their counter-strategies, explosive energies and illegalisms in relation to the self and others, among them refusal to beget;¹³ i.e. we must continue to counter, via conduct and attitude, this “coupling [of] statistical knowledge [with] knowledge of the individual — […] (at the moment of the birth of the clinic)…” which continues acceleratingly to this day via Palantir et al.

As already hinted, the birth rate is not one monolithic object. Within a single course it is governed three ways: commanded by a regulatory apparatus, stimulated below the threshold of perception, and, in the disciplinary register, not governed at all.²⁰ As birth rates fall in all but weak labor-division zones, we might suppose that this is the new planned model now that brute population size increasingly loses its supreme value vis-à-vis politico-economic-military potentia.

Apart from the biopolitical context, birth also protagonizes Foucault’s unfinished fourth tome on sexuality: birth as an instrument of the pastorate – via marriage and other sexual-social mandates of self-implicating surveillance from womb to tomb – is doubled by birth as its object: the original immaculate birth, maintained through virginity, and the sacramental seconde naissance, which the genealogy dissolves in the very gesture with which it dissolves the Ursprung;²⁵ the womb entered by law and liturgy before the child has seen the day;²⁶ and the two machines of natal truth: the king who flees the secret of his birth and the emperor who has it painted on his ceiling.²⁷ Across the final courses this alèthurgie migrates from birth-truth to bios-truth, until the last form of truth-telling is defined against nativity altogether.²⁸

As Foucault signals, birth is always displaced, and the birth we seek is not a mythical bursting forth, but a synthesis of practices, debt/guilt-relations, scientific thresholds, attitudes, networks, etc which gave subtle birth to a knowledge formation, be it money, governmentality, bio-power, prisons, police, etc.¹⁴

« Ce n'est pas une origine qui est à chercher, mais une naissance toujours déplacée. Ce qui apparaît dans l'histoire est toujours né d'autre chose que lui-même. » - Leçons sur la volonté de savoir, leçon du 16 décembre 1970, p. 27.

Perpetually displaced, and also perpetually reversed. The element that appears last comes to cover the elements that preceded it, so that the order of appearance and the order of explanation run against one another.²⁹ Perhaps this is why no birth-title in the corpus is a history of the thing it names.

It is also why the centenary is such an enigma. A discourse whose apparition has long been watched over is honoured into disarmament;³⁰ and the last book withholds every one of the words with which we would describe this one.³¹

The anti-strategic crux, amongst predictive language models, predictive algorithmic control, etc., is singular support of uncanny resistance: multivalent, non-algorithmic anomalies¹⁵ inventing and being invented by ‘other’ space-times.

In tardo-modernity, as neo-panoptic Civil Society allows less and less to escape, it’s clearer each day how what are now called anomalies are manufactured at the margin by the tightening of the mesh, and are immediately re-capitalised as profit;³² beyond transgression and anti-confinement, freedom itself can, and perhaps must, be the correlate of an apparatus rather than its outside, just as truth-telling, bio-creative self-relation and avowal are simultaneously apparatuses of capture and agencies of flight.

What survives is the self-styling singularity that rises without explanation and, on the other side of the same coin, the paraskeuē: an equipment for the unforeseen event, for speaking frankly despite the danger, and for kynically defacing the coin via living truth as fleshy (fragile and exposed) sphere-dwellers.

Note:

To use Foucault’s unfolding of birth to diagnose what we are at this present moment: our biopolitical and pastoral vectorization among dispositifs, as dispotifs, within dispositifs.

We remain confessing animals, we continue to pine for an epiphanic rebirth without habitual and self-reflective transmutation, we are more accustomed than ever to seek external direction of our conscience and consciousness, ever in the same pre-Kantian state of infantilized tutelage; we hope restlessly for eternal Being, everlastingness of soul, indelible social memory, thereby siphoning off energy from life projects of irrepeatable becoming and tenuous construction of social memory via the social weave.

Pastoral power’s vectorization needs to be diagrammed, our lack of political-popular potentiation, our self-implicating social-medial and bio/psyscho/neuma-political enmeshing of late modernity, our never-ending self-imposed distractions and notifications, our self-chosen dependence of technico-prosthetic artifices.


r/foucault • • Oct 19 '25

introduction to the history of sexuality (vol ii)

1 Upvotes

has anyone ever read Foucault's History of Sexuality (vol ii)? can you give me pointers on where to start and how?

especially the three sections on it's introduction? i actually have a workshop I have to attend on it and would love if I could discuss it with someone beforehand!


r/foucault • • Jun 18 '24

how to understand that 'the disciplines should be regarded as a sort of counter-law' ?

1 Upvotes

I am reading the Panopticism part of discipline and punish now; I'm confused about Foucault's consideration of disciplines as counter-law. my current understanding is that Disciplines do not violate laws but can sometimes undermine law. but how? Maybe my understanding is wrong, I hope someone can correct me and give some detailed explanations.


r/foucault • • Apr 25 '26

Foucault was a nonce

0 Upvotes

Michel Foucault made specific arguments advocating for pederasty, particularly in post-1968 writings, interviews, and activism, framing it as a form of romantic love and resistance against state power. These views drew heavily from his critiques of age-of-consent laws and modern sexual norms.

Foucault celebrated classical pederasty - adult men with adolescent boys - as the purest form of male love, superior to egalitarian homosexuality. He referenced French law post-1791 Revolution, where sodomy was legal from age 13, and praised André Gide's similar stance, urging its revival to abolish moral boundaries alongside S&M subcultures.

He dismissed prosecutions of adult-child encounters as overblown "bucolic pleasures" turned into scandals by judicial, medical, and theoretical machinery. He argued these trivial acts revealed petty biopower mechanisms, not inherent harm, and signed petitions like the 1977 French Petition for Penal Reform to decriminalize non-violent sex with minors

https://thecritic.co.uk/issues/april-2021/michel-foucault-the-prophet-of-pederasty/


r/foucault • • May 04 '21

Why is Foucault so associated with (left) activism when his idea of truth is so nihilistic?

7 Upvotes

This might be a noob question, but I can't really understand why he is so politicized and polarizing.

I can of course see that his way of thinking about truth connected to power relations is useful for people who wants power, but why is it so one-sided? It is both strange that the right doesn't embrace his ideas as the fact the left doesn't feel that the nihilism undermines their conviction.

From my understanding of Foucault it would be more reasonable if he became popular among an elite of influensers, but an elite motivated by egoism and not justice, social or otherwise.

Or is the development a result of the idea that truth must be forced upon the majority to be true? So that the nature of power relations dictate what kind of truth are possible.

That would explain the collectivist aspect, but the right can be just as collectivistic as the left, so why hasn't nationalist or conservative Christians embraced his ideas of power relations? Are they at the losing end of the power relations maybe? Or is it connected to the intrinsic value systems of the groups?


r/foucault • • May 14 '22

A video critiquing Jordan Peterson's analysis of French Philosopher Michel Foucault

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/foucault • • Aug 24 '22

Is there some validity in saying that Foucault's works are more so creative as opposed to something purely academic?

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!
In reading Foucault's work, I have felt that creative liberty was taken in his published work. I don't say this as a critique but rather as an emphasis on the subjectivity of truth and how post-modernism challenges how we engage with academia.

I read Foucault as a subjective interpreter of society and history.... would you agree with this characterisation? Looking forward to hearing your responses... thanks. :)


r/foucault • • Dec 17 '25

Has anyone heard of/any thoughts on the theory of the "bicameral mind"?

7 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of talk recently about this theory that essentially claims that ancient people may not have understood consciousness in the way that we do and so experienced many of their thoughts and inspirations as outside voices that they may have attributed to various deities.

From what I've read, it seems like its at least seen as a respectable theory, though obviously not really provable and plenty of folks are critical of it.

How would a concept like this effect the kind of genealogies of concepts that Foucault worked on? And in a broader post-modernist context, is it possible to further explain these phenomena, not through biological processes like the two parts of the mind becoming more integrated, but instead by the effects of our concepts and how they change the reality we experience? In other words, that a new conception of consciousness gave rise to a new experience of consciousness.

Curious to hear any and all thoughts on that intersection. At the very least, it's an interesting idea.


r/foucault • • Feb 06 '24

human sexuality

4 Upvotes

283 KB JPG is reading THE HISTORY OF HUMAN SEXUALITY worth it in the modern age? is any of it still relevant? all of it? some of it?


r/foucault • • Dec 26 '25

Foucault and Nietzsche

20 Upvotes

Does anyone else have the feeling that Foucault could have been significantly more useful as an author (albeit less impactful maybe) had he grounded his cultural analysis in Marx rather than Nietzsche? He keeps indicating that disciplinary dispositifs and the episteme of modernity arise from economic demands of utility (which brings him a bit closer to historical materialism) but then resorts back to his transhistorical, Nietzschean idea of "pouvoir" which seems to hold him back from drawing up practical possibilities of resistance against the hierarchies he describes.


r/foucault • • Jul 12 '25

Biopolitics & Biopower

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/foucault • • Apr 17 '26

What is your opinion on the show “Euphoria” in the perspective of Foucault’s philosophy?

5 Upvotes

Hi,

I don’t know if some of you are familiar with this (very) popular TV show.

The aim is not to express our love or hate for the show but to go beyond that.

I will be interested to know if it made you reflect on some ideas from Foucault.

Of course the themes there will be sexuality and freedom amongst other ones.

Thanks


r/foucault • • Nov 23 '24

How factual are the conclusions/premises of the works of Michel Foucault such as “Discipline and Punish” and “History of Sexuality” (despite his flawed methodology)? How accurate are the descriptions of individual events?

5 Upvotes

I’m currently reading “Discipline and Punish” and am quite enjoying it. It seems like r/AskHistorians likes Foucault and acknowledge his ideas of power and admits they have had an impact on academic history as much as on philosophy and sociology but think his methodology was flawed in that he was selective in his sources and overgeneralized. But how accurate are his conclusions/premises and descriptions of individual events? I asked this on r/AskHistorians and it got 15 upvotes but no answer.


r/foucault • • Apr 17 '17

Hello,

1 Upvotes

I suggest buying the audio books for an introduction...,sitting back and just thinking about his ideas as in a lecture was very helpful for me.....there are only a couple of audiobooks tho and none of his lecture work has been audioiezed


r/foucault • • Jun 30 '25

Biopower explanation

2 Upvotes

Hey I'm new to Foucault's philosophical takes and interpretation of power. I've been looking into bio power for an argument within debate could some one give a relatively beginner level explanation of what bio power is and its relation to society? Thank you!


r/foucault • • May 24 '25

Article: "Why Marxists Need Foucault"; Foucault helps Marxist understand how ideology works today - linking identity struggles with class domination.

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Read the (guest-)article here, and find us on Instagram here, to keep up with our little magazine.


r/foucault • • Mar 29 '21

French philosopher Michel Foucault 'sexually abused boys in Tunisia': report

Thumbnail
english.alaraby.co.uk
28 Upvotes

r/foucault • • Apr 04 '21

I translated one of Foucault’s sources

10 Upvotes

A passage in volume one of the History of Sexuality (it’s page 31 of the Penguin Classics edition, and I believe most editions are the same) has been the subject of some controversy, since some have interpreted it as promoting sexual relations with minors. Without wanting to make my own opinion on this explicit, in researching the matter I realised his source was in French, and couldn’t find an English edition, so I translated it myself (to a very amateur standard; do not take this as a particularly good translation). Here it is if you care for that sort of thing.

https://sarcanor.substack.com/p/medico-legal-report-regarding-the


r/foucault • • Dec 16 '23

As scientific methodologies take over the domain of philosophical inquiry into the human condition, individuals are left with limited capacity to conceive of themselves beyond the confines of psychological and psychiatric classifications.

Thumbnail
unexaminedglitch.com
3 Upvotes