r/fnv • u/Randonaut0 • Sep 06 '23
r/fnv • u/futurehistorianjames • Oct 19 '25
Joshua Graham and My conversion to Catholicism
Played New Vegas in high school and of course all the DLCs. Anyway, Graham is my favorite character. His voice, arc, the way he held the scripture. Obsidian really did a great job. Incidentially, I was an agnostic in high school, but started reading the bible more and more. Eventually this lead me to identify as a Christian and then later in life becoming a full on Catholic. I have heard people say they had a moment of religious conversion playing this DLC and I tend to agree with them. I am sure this is not the first time this story has been talked about.
r/fnv • u/TheAnalystCurator321 • Feb 09 '25
Screenshot Why do so many fans actually believe this? Time and time again its been proven that Bethesda has nothing against New Vegas.
r/fnv • u/Immediate-Log8626 • Mar 15 '26
A new ending I found in honest hearts out
In my first playthroug I ended up in the cave led by Follows Chalk and met a former legate of the legion preparing weapons and with a vague christianity. what gave him the righthousness to lead this bunch of people? So I tried him, and he is the second most fun boss fight after Ulysses with a very high DT and dps with his pistol. So first time I gave up on it.
Tried it later on a powerful lategame save and found that unsatysfying non-ending.
today loaded the same save, closest to ending, got the totems, the map, got back, crushed hail marys and had a three way shootout with joshua and salt upon wounds.
in elite riot gear and old world blues upgrades I crushed them with an anti air cannon.
killed Joshua and Salt upon wounds after crushing the white legs.
He gets up twice and only third time he was finally dead. Thought he was essential in the ending for a second and it would proceed after salt upon wounds dying.
The new caananites loose their influence in the tribes. Joshuas painfuil flame finally came to peace at my hand. He does not burn anymore. Happy trails is no more. The white legs die out. Daniel lives on, a shadow.
I made sure they bury everyone properly.
No chest, no gear from Chalks or Daniel, or the scripture, a pleasant weight in the trash. Just the gear from the two tribe warlords.
Semi unique kinda bad ending
r/fnv • u/TheSyrupCompany • Sep 13 '24
Old World Blues sucks
There I said it. On my millionth playthrough, doing old world blues currently and yeah after the first time you hear the dialogue and stuff it loses its charm and it's just one massive chore and burn of resources.
The bonuses and items you get are amazing thus why I still do it. But oh my God who on earth thought it would be fun to do the school site tests 8 times over to complete the stinking quest?
Almost the entire DLC is just x-8 and x-13 on repeat lol
r/fnv • u/Unit3650andWilson • Feb 05 '26
About the TV finale? Spoiler
Did the Courier just not exist? I mean there were a few parts where it seemed like he was referenced but no evidence was shown (to me at least) that he really existed. I also thought the whole season was kinda filler and just designed to lead into the next season with the re-introduction of the Enclave for the 3rd time. They had so much to work with but I felt that they didn't really use any of it. Season was alright but I feel it didn't really do much of anything for the story except bring back the Enclave.
Overall 2/10 season for me, atleast Season 1 was much more memorable even if it did break a fuckton of lore.
r/fnv • u/Zacc0168 • Feb 03 '26
Discussion Mr.House plan makes no sense and he cannot be trusted.
after playing New Vegas so many times i thought everyone knew that mister house was being your standard evil businessman but apparently there are people who actually believe that he is the best chance not just for the Mojave but for humanity itself.
Not even bringing anything from the TV show its clear this mans plan is doomed to fail and it starts even before the bombs drop. this man calculated that the bombs would drop within 15 years and in that time what did he do.
did he move his resources to the Midwest to secure large arable land to feed his population of the future?
did he move to the rust belt states to save the valuable industrial equipment so he could "reignite the high technology sectors" and bring about his plans sending people to distant worlds?
No he went to Vegas, his little fortress in the middle of a desert with no means to feed a growing population and no industrial capacity at all. he portrays himself as this incredibly intelligent man but he's nothing but a tyrant who wants to play king in his little den of sin.
and i hear you say "he said the NCR would finance it because they are a society of customers". customers that had the lives of the friends and family members spent for nothing as MR house takes control of the dam. a society of customers that are growing more and more poorer thanks to brahmin barons, corrupt politicians and the brotherhood destroying their gold reserves making their money fiat and backed by nothing, causing hyper inflation and the return of the cap as a viable currency.
NCR civilians are not going to track across hundreds of miles to lose their money in Vegas to a man that made the sacrifices of their friends and family meaningless when they can't even afford to live or just to local casinos like the hub. he alienated his own customer base and expects them to still come because he is an old world ghost that still thinks he has a monopoly.
and to top it all off, his literal centuries of planning, his oh so incredible intelligence can be thwarted by one courier with a gun. people who hate his depiction in the tv show, saying they turned him into an idiot don't realise he always was. he is a narcissistic, self absorbed egoist that thinks he's gods gift to mankind and he is blowing smoke up your ass from the moment you meet him and he cannot be trusted.
r/fnv • u/Bobert_Ross113 • Sep 21 '23
Complaint I hate Dead Money and I haven't even finished it yet
The amount of times I've died is through the roof and I am about to rage quit the game. Probably a good thing since I've been addicted to the game for months now but it isn't even a fun challenging, just annoying. The ghost people ar so hard to kill and I never have enough ammo, even with a melee skill of 80 I die way too many times trying to get places because I can't have more than 2 Stimpaks at once most of the time. I would probably be a lot more invested in the story if I could focus on it rather than try not to rage at my millionth death. Anyway, it's all for the better since I'm chronically addicted to the game in the first place.
r/fnv • u/No_Quote600 • Jan 31 '23
Caesar and his long term goals are too intellectual for their own good so are underappreciated.
Caesar is a very intelligent man, and he has a very intricate plan for the future.
That plan is to take advantage of the wild opportunity he has in the Mojave with the NCR in the Mojave being largely untrained and conscripted. Then to modernize his military once he has Vegas safely in his grip, because a modernized military is the only way he would stand a chance against the trained forces of the NCR back in California.
Caesar only went the "Roman cosplayer" route because it was proven to be the easiest way to conquer the 86 tribes of uneducated morons he has so far. He says it himself that his perspective changed once he encountered the NCR, the people there are more educated, he would need a modernized military and belief system.
For anyone who cares to notice, Caesar doesn't even believe in most of the things he tells his men to believe in. He believes in modern weapons/medicine, so as soon as he announced to his Legion that they were modernizing, they would do it without question, because they worship him.
Caesar's long term goal is be in charge of a modernized nation while he hold on to all of the "roman cosplayer" parts that he personally finds beneficial to his society.
Like, imagine a modern day Roman Empire with guns and what not. That's what Caesar ultimately wants.
The NCR rangers are pretty much the only ones that legionnaires see as equal matches for them, and Chief Hanlon is ready to throw in the towel because even he knows NCR can't win long term in the mojave without a miracle (that miracle being the courier siding with them)
Now, common sense may tell us the guys with guns will obviously win, but consider this. It is proven that you are FAR less accurate with any firearm under duress, and the average NCR trooper is untrained, conscripted and isn't even carrying a full magazine. Now let's consider that the average NCR trooper is already nervous from the horror stories they hear about the Legion, and once they have Legionnaires who are faster and stronger than them charging from all sides, the NCR troopers brains go to mush and they are just as likely to shoot their own men as the enemy.
Even if the NCR troopers manage to come out on top against the machete/spear wielding front line, they still have centurions in the back with marksman rifles to deal with, and chances are they have already used up their 16 bullets, so they are doomed, since Legion troops are faster, stronger, and know how to fight in close quarters.
FNV devs may have made Caesar too intellectual for his own good.
r/fnv • u/ForkShoeSpoon • Jul 05 '23
Discussion Honest Hearts is deeply problematic... right?
I think it's largely been forgotten, but Honest Hearts sparked light controversy when it was released, justifiably so in my opinion. To give a very brief summary of my chief complaint: The story is a classic "White Savior" narrative about two White missionaries leading Indigenous coded "tribes," who fit the "Noble Savage" trope, who revere them as leaders and follow them in their war against a menacing outside force. Complaints about these tropes are at this point quite old, and saw a lot of attention in the 2010s, which is why I'm surprised I just don't see much discussion about them here. Looking through recent post history on the sub, I just don't see anybody mentioning how problematic this DLC is. Playing it made me deeply uncomfortable, so I wanted to share my thoughts and listen for any echos (or pushback) from the broader community, just to see if I'm alone here.
From the wiki, I know that Josh Sawyer has addressed some of the complaints about the dlc -- I have no idea if that list of quotes is comprehensive, but I recommend looking at them if you have any interest (positive or negative) in this post. And I deeply appreciate everything he has to say. In particular, responding to criticisms, he has made three points in the past that I think are important:
The White Legs, Sorrows, and Dead Horses were not intended to be Brown, and Daniel was not intended to be White. Sawyer has reiterated this frustration several times according to the wiki. The tribes of Zion were supposed to be multi-ethnic like everyone else in Fallout, but because of the limited space they had for skin textures, they had to be made ethnically homogeneous. Daniel (according to Sawyer) seems to have been racially switched late in development through a quirk of the Fallout engine (I'm not entirely sure I believe that Daniel's race was flipped by an engine bug -- it could have been a late-development design decision that Sawyer wasn't party to, it could have been a detail that was overlooked in implementation by whoever was implementing it because it wasn't considered important, etc.)
The pidgin language spoken by the tribes, mostly a mixture of German and Navajo, and English, was implemented largely to cut costs (they couldn't record every line twice, so they created an understandable pidgin language for the Zion tribes, rather than requiring the player character to get a translator or something along those lines). The tattoos and paintings were deliberately not based on any real Indigenous culture's designs -- the idea was that the tribes of Zion were not Indigenous people (Navajo or otherwise), but a multiethnic group with their own, new culture.
He acknowledges that the DLC's story cleaved a little too close to its source material (Lawrence of Arabia and The Mission), acknowledges that the tribals are not given enough agency in the story and look up to two "civilized" savior figures, and suggests it probably would have been a good idea to bring in Indigenous consultants from the American Southwest to make sure they weren't falling into negative tropes. (I bold this because I think it's an important lesson learned -- I don't think the DLC would have been released in the state it was if they had brought in consultants). He also acknowledges that the language and naming of characters probably should have been given a second pass.
I put these up front in the preface for three reasons -- first, to head off anyone complaining I'm just being crazy or oversensitive. Second, to acknowledge that the game was released in a format that was not in alignment with the developer's original vision, and that Sawyer has personally expressed some amount of regret over the project.
And third -- I don't think these explanations really address the underlying problem with the DLC, with the exception of maybe number 3, and that's why I want to make this post.
Here's my beef: Even if the game had the texture space to make all the tribes multi-ethnic, even if Daniel had been Asian, even if the language had been more fleshed out, this DLC would still be a classic white savior narrative, with the distinction that the "white saviors" aren't ethnically white and the "noble savages" aren't ethnically indigenous. The story, at its core, is about civilizing the savages -- there's a quest outright titled "The Civilized Man's Burden." That's pretty damn close to an outright wink at the colonial (and white supremacist) tone of the game's source material -- here are two noble, well intentioned missionaries, teaching the simple savages about the world, and the helpless little tribes revere the outsiders as messianic figures (again, not a new trope, and one that is deeply bound up with white supremacy).
And as for the "tribes" of Zion -- they are not indigenous-coded by their skin color. If they had been ethnically diverse, the game would have been better and more thematically consistent (a group of survivors forging new traditions by looking back at the old ways of Indigenous people of the Southwest, just the same as Caesar looking to Rome, the NCR looking to the US, the Khans, &c. -- Could have been some terrific factions!). But, as the narrative was written, the DLC would still be problematic -- the indigenous coding of the "tribes" comes from the very fact that they wear "tribal" tattoos, that they dress in few clothes, that they are described as ether "innocent" (as the Sorrows) or "savage" (as the White Legs), that they have descriptive or nature-based names like "Follows-Chalk" and "White-Bird" and "Salt-Upon-Wounds," that they have ceremonies using hallucinogens, that they have "taboos" and superstitions, syncretic religion which identifies the God of the missionaries with their traditional gods (syncretic religions of this type exist to this day, most notably Haitian voodoo, but there are many more!). Like, no matter the color of their skin textures -- these characters are obviously based on depictions of Indigenous people of North America. In my opinion, no amount of retexturing can make a bunch of Indigenous-coded folks being amazed by civilization and revering their "civilized" saviors not a racist depiction of Indigenous people -- again, this is a well established trope.
Even fundamentally exciting plot twists, like the excellent written story of the survivalist, ends with the revelation that the Sorrows' "tribal superstition" about the Father, the Mother, and the Son, is a story handed down to them in their childlike innocence from a "civilized" man. That's a cool reveal, but it makes the Indigenous-coded folks literally childlike -- they are literally descended from escaped children who were quietly guided by a benevolent Father figure protecting their innocence. Again, that's a cool plot twist, but the "innocent savage as a childlike being" thing is another old, really really troubling trope -- I wish all the interesting moments in this DLC weren't undercut by problematic things like this!
Again, I don't bring this up to drag any devs or anything so petty as that. The DLC was released in 2011 -- conversations about harmful tropes in media were not nearly so widespread. Obergefell v Hodges was still 4 years away, and this was a game with openly gay characters whose homosexuality wasn't their only personality trait. Ultimately, the game is pretty progressive, especially in the context of the time it was made.
I bring this up because I feel like now these tropes are in the public consciousness, and we've had about a decade-long public conversation about racism in media, and I thought people were more sensitive to problematic depictions in media now. Yet, when I see people talking about HH, I don't really see people bringing up just how problematic it is. I'm not saying "burn the witch, delete the DLC, how dare you how dare you" etc. etc. -- I'm just saying playing through this DLC made me deeply uncomfortable, and I don't think I'll ever revisit it. I'm just looking to see if anyone feels the same way, because I'm kind of surprised I don't see more discussion of it.
r/fnv • u/Team_Fortress_gaming • Dec 27 '25
“The bear” this, “The bull” that - I can’t BEAR this BULLshit anymore.
Ulysses is driving me insane because 80% of his dialogue is him saying random pseudointellectual nonsense with the words “bear” and “bull” thrown in there
“That package” “The long 15” “The bear” “The bull” “Courier 6”
r/fnv • u/Remarkable-Pin-8352 • Jan 17 '26
Watching this guy perform so admirably to the point he must've studied René Auberjonois' vocal mannerisms quite closely while reciting such awful *awful* dialogue is actually heartbreaking.
r/fnv • u/Dangerous_Builder516 • Apr 17 '26
Why is House bad?
Feels like a lot of the game implies that he's a tyrant and a dictator. But is that shown in any actions or significant dialogue?
Like I see the NCR being incompetant a number of ways throughout the game. The ants, the helios 1 situation, Chief Hanlon and more.
But with House it feels a lot thinner.
r/fnv • u/[deleted] • Aug 28 '24
Discussion (OPINION) "Essential npcs" in Bethesda game is bad ideal and here is why.
First thing I want to say, I just wanna share my ideal and opinion, I don’t criticize the game FO4 itself. I love the game, playing it and I think it can be better. I hope people in this sub get the opinion with open mind, friendly way.
1. Fallout New Vegas really allow you to kill 99% every npcs on the map even your companion, even quest npcs, if you kill a quest npc the game will clearly send you message that quest failed.
You can wipe out any settlements, even a whole faction from map, kill all three family in Strip, wipe out the Great Khan, wipe out the Boomer, you can ride the Fort and kill Caesar ( Legion Leader ) right from start game, you can set to self-destruct Brotherhood Bunker or just kill everyone in there, wipe out Followers of the Apocalypse, the King, the Power Ganger, all NCR, Legion on the map. There just very few npc that “essential” I don’t even remember, maybe just one or two, maybe Yes Man ?
+ There reason many people admire New Vegas over Fallout 4 even nowadays, not only for it has great story writing (which FO4 fail), but the gameplay, the freedoom of player. You can be a Savior of Wasteland, or just a psychopath roaming around. ( i'm not even NV fanboy )
2. People who say you can almost kill every npcs in Fallout 4 too. I mean what ? Even compare to FO3, FO4 have a lot immortal npcs.
First, the Minutemen: you can blow up the whole Institute and every man, women and children inside it. You can do much the same to Brotherhood, you can slaughter the RailRoad. But the Minutemen? Even when you want play evil, you join the Nuka World raider and clearly become worst enemy of Minutemen, you can’t just kill that guy Preston. So anyway Bethesda force you to play as nice guy.
Can you wipe out Diamond City ? Really ? Many essential npcs in there: Danny Sullivan, Doctor Sun, Ellie, Piper, Nick, … At least in FO3 you can nuke Megaton :)))
Can you wipe out Goodneighbor ? Of course Bethesda say no: MacCready, John Hancock, Daisy, there even few Drifter are essential I don’t know why.
The list go on the whole game there a lot essential npcs.
Finally, Marcy Long and yes maybe the most hate character in this game, she doesn’t involve in any quest, she just stand there annoying but for god damn sake Bethesda make her immortal.
3. People say make essential npc is necessary because there are many random event in the FO4 that make quest npc be killed without player knowledge and many quest failed.
+Solution: As i have seen many people say just make some important npc only be kill by player, the game can give a warning message if player try to kill important npc ( New Vegas did it as I said ). It’s not so hard for game devs, right ?
Question Why can’t you ask Caesar about the sexism?
You can ask Caesar a lot of questions about everything, but for some reason I don’t recall any option to interrogate why they implemented such harsh subjugation of women.
You don’t get to really grill Caesar on the slavery or crucifications either, but I think he likes those, thinks it makes them strong, that it’s an inevitability to separate the weak from the strong.
The thing about the sexism is, and I’m not inside the heart of Edward Sallow, but it just feels like it’s not him. Don’t think his heart would be in it. Not that he doesn’t have a little incel energy. I just think if a woman was clearly capable and intelligent he’d throw out a loser legionary for her. I mean he accepts a female courier, although that’s maybe unfair to cite since it’s kind of a plot convenience. My headcanon is that the sexism is more coming from Lanius and Caesar doesn’t really care one way or the other, not like he’s a good guy on the topic, it’s just that his heart isn’t in it personally.
I just wish you could have asked Caesar about it in the game. Has jsawyer ever answered a question about that?
If I have one criticism of the dialogue with Caesar, even though it’s great, it feels like one of the few places in the game where there are many obvious objections and questions you could ask and would be satisfying dialogue but the game doesn’t let you.
r/fnv • u/Warm_Albatross1335 • Sep 23 '24
fallout shelter was my 1st fallout game, ask me anything
r/fnv • u/GENERALmissile • Jan 29 '25
Screenshot I made the first shout count so he didn't get a second
r/fnv • u/LeonOfSkalitz • Feb 02 '26
Discussion I’m surprised you all are ok with how the canon courier 6 is established by the show. Spoiler
I remember when season 1 ended all the comments I would see were a variety of “oh man I hope they reference the courier and he is like a badass legend“
which is why now I am surprised so many people are ok with the fact that the canon courier seems like a complete useless bum that barely influenced new vegas and has clearly been forgotten by the population.
didn’t kill Caesar, maybe killed house, didn’t really stop the legion in places like Camp McCarran, Novac fell, didn’t kill the deathclaws in quarry junction.
at this point I am half expecting the show to reveal that canonically the courier died in goodsprings after being shot by Benny. which at this point would be better imo than being a bum loser ngl.
the vault dweller is canonically a legend, the chosen one is canonically legend, the lone wanderer is not referenced by name but we know they killed the enclave and finished project purity so they have to be a legend.
but I guess courier 6, well they were a failure, fuck them.