Every once in a while, the subject of queer representation pops up in FE circles. "Ike's sexuality" this, "Kyza's gender" that. But out of all the discussions in regards to queer characters, one topics tends to become a footnote: non-binary characters. It's well known at this point that FE has dabbled in making characters outside the gender binary, albeit few, but the nature of them is never really discussed. What's up with these characters, anyway? Since it's pride month, I see no bettee time to look into them than now. So uhhh happy pride y'all!
Limstella (Fire Emblem: The Blazing Blade)
Fire Emblem's first non-binary character appeared in The Blazing Blade. A morph made to serve Nergal, Limstella is a recurring character throughout the story. Their role is to collect quintessence for their master and do his bidding, lacking any emotion or free will. While Limstella was documented as being "genderless" since the game's release, it didn't get much attention until Limstella got a card in Fire Emblem Cipher, which had them lacking a gender marker. Until this point, Limstella was largely perceived as feminine by the western fanbase, and understandably so. Their design is feminine at first glance (at least their in-game portrait is), they use the female sage sprite in battle, and they are referred to as "Lady Limstella" once in the main story (simply "Limstella-sama in Japanese, which is not gendered. The localizers likely assumed Limstella was female and used "Lady".) Limstella wouldn't officially be recognized in localization as non-binary until their debut in Fire Emblem Heroes, where they are strictly referred to with they/them pronouns (and even voiced by a non-binary VA.)
Bramimond (Fire Emblem: The Blazing Blade)
Our second non-binary character...is also in Blazing Blade! Two for one deal right there. Bramimond is one of the Eight Legends that fought in The Scouring. He used the tome Apocalypse, which he guarded after the war. Sadly, his devotion to dark magic caused him to lose his humanity, becoming little more than an empty husk that mirrors those around him. He has no emotions, memories, or even gender anymore.
"Bramimond has no self. He... She... It... Yes, it is a mirror that reflects the person addressing it. It projects no personality of its own. There are as many Bramimonds as there are people facing him. ...Bramimond, do you remember me?" -Athos, Chapter 27E/29H
Not much else to say about Bramimond in regards to gender identity. Notably, he is the only non-binary character in FE (so far) to not be referred to as they/them, but rather he/him. Obviously, pronouns =/= gender, but it's an interesting thing to note here.
After Bramimond, Fire Emblem would not have another non-binary character for 19 years.
"But wait, what about Kyza? They are non-binary in FEH!"
Ah yes, Kyza. Kyza is a whole can of worms on their own. But to keep things brief: Kyza is not non-binary. At least, not in the original Japanese. Kyza being non-binary is strictly an invention of the English localization for FEH, almost definitely to accommodate the messy topic of their gender identity. Because of this, I am not including Kyza in this post. Maybe I'll make a seperate post for them, since there is a lot to unpack.
Now, back to the topic at hand.
Arval (Fire Emblem: Three Hopes)
Arval is a mysterious being with no memories of their past who saves the life of Shez and lives rent free in their head. Arval and Shez both share a goal of beating Byleth, the Ashen Demon. Eventually, it is revealed that Arval was a being created by Epimenides to house his soul so he could live on to kill Sothis.
Arval is consistently referred to with they/them pronouns throughout the game and has no gender. Kinda. Storywise, Arval could technically be considered a man, seeing how they are modeled off of and a vessel for Epimenides. Gameplay wise, Arval is mechanically the gender opposite of the one you chose for Shez. Yes, it is strange. But despite this, Arval isn't any less non-binary on their own.
There's a Pattern Here...
So what can be said about these characters? Well, they all share something in common: They are not human. Limstella is a morph, Bramimond is no longer a person, and Arval is an Agarthan tube baby. These characters are all non-binary...but only because they functionally lack gender. It is not part of their identities. And these are our only non-binary characters in the series as of 2024.
A common criticism of non-binary representation in media is how a solid chunk of them are inhuman. Aliens, shapeshifters, you name it. Fire Emblem follows suit. Granted, two characters were made before non-binary identities became more commonly known, but the point still stands. So...does this make Fire Emblem's non-binary representation bad?
No, actually. While it is a commonly criticized trend with non-binary characters, what makes "good" and "bad" representation is entirely subjective (deliberately offensive portrayals excluded). How one relates to characters can vary. Like, for some non-binary folks, characters being inhuman is relatable. Everyone expresses and experiences their identity in different ways. I'm trying to think of a better way to phrase this point but I'm typing this whole thing out at 1 am.
While it would be nice to one day have a character who consciously does not adhere to the gender binary, what we have now isn't bad at all. It's great that we can have queer characters featured in series, and I hope it doesn't stop.
Happy pride y'all. Again.