After playing FFX through 10 times over the last 25 years, I still feel like Square made a huge mistake passing on a Braska/Jecht/Auron prequel. I replay FFX for the incredible story and boss fights, but the standard combat does get repetitive after a while. On the flip side, FFX-2’s battle system is wildly addictive, but I’ve only replayed it once in 15+ years because the story is so bad and full of dress-up Barbie doll fluff.
If they had taken that exact ATB job engine and applied it to a prequel, we would've gotten the best of both worlds:
No fluff, keep the combat: Strip away the playing-dress-up aesthetic. Just make it mid-battle stance shifting (Jecht swapping between brawler/tank, Auron with samurai/counter stances, Braska doing summoner/black-white magic).
Solves the 3-man party issue: The biggest complaint about a prequel is "only 3 party members gets boring." Giving those 3 guys hot-swappable jobs in FFX-2's fast-paced system fixes that completely.
Temporary guest party members: You could easily slot in temporary 4th members for specific story arcs—young Cid with Al Bhed machina, Kinoc back when he was actually a legit warrior monk, or even a teenage Seymour at Baaj Temple.
The tragic ending is the point: Everyone says "we already know how it ends," but knowing Jecht becomes Sin and Braska dies gives the whole journey that heavy, unavoidable weight you see in movie prequels or historical tragedies like Titanic —knowing the tragic destination actually makes the character bonds hit way harder. Controlling Jecht in his Final Aeon form for the last fight would be insane.
FFX-2’s gameplay was way too good to be wasted on a campy Barbie simulator. A dark, tragic trek through Spira with that exact combat system would've been an absolute classic.
What do you guys think?
Edit: clearly you guys don't know much beyond the basics of the basics of Braska's pilgrimage. The backstory and plan between Brasksa / Auron / Jecht had significant depth to it. Some of this is covered in the Ultemania and not explained well in the game.